The public is currently being bombarded with a growing number of hospital report cards revealing hospital-specific outcome data. The original intent of these report cards was to provide information to the public to enable them to make a more educated choice in selecting health care services and to stimulate provider activities to improve outcomes of care. Serious issues have been raised about the accuracy, validity, meaningfulness, and interpretability of these reports, which has affected both provider and consumer response. With public image and financial implications on the line, hospitals need to be aware of these reports and take the necessary steps to improve outcomes of care.
Schneider E, Epstein A. Use of public performance reports: a survey of patients undergoing cardiac surgery. JAMA. 1998;279: 1638-1642.
2.
Naylor C. Public profiling of clinical performance. JAMA. 2002; 87:1323-1325.
3.
Jauhar S. When doctors slam the door. Available at: NYtimes.com. Accessed March 24, 2003.
4.
McGinley L. Merit pay for top hospitals. The Wall Street Journal. May 27, 2003:D1, D2.
5.
Freudenheim M. Quality goals in incentives for hospitals. Available at: NYtimes.com. Accessed June 26, 2002.
6.
Jaspen B. Insurer will pay more for better care: Blue Cross starts with incentives for hospitals. Chicago Tribune [online]. April 27, 2003.
7.
Morrissey J. Quality initiative gets serious. Modern Healthcare. December 22-29, 2003:28-29.
8.
Becker C. Time to pay for quality. Modern Healthcare. June 30, 2003:6, 7,16.
9.
Hofer T, Hayward R, Greenfield S, et al.The unreliability of individual physician report cards for assessing the costs and quality of care of a chronic disease. JAMA. 281:2098-2105.
10.
Health Care Report Cards: Too Soon for a Passing Grade. White Paper. Oak Brook, Ill: University HealthSystem Consortium;2003.
11.
Krumholz H, Rathmore S, Chen J, et al.Evaluation of a consumer-oriented internet health care report card: the risk of quality ratings based on mortality data. JAMA. 2002;87:1277-1287.
12.
Rosenstein A. Provider profiling: promises and pitfalls. Manag Care Med. 1995;2:10-14; 33-35.
13.
Marshall M, Shekelle P, Leatherman S, et al.The public release of performance data: what do we expect to gain?JAMA. 2000; 283:1866-1874.
14.
Hibbard J, Stockard J, Tusler M. Does publicizing hospital performance stimulate quality improvement efforts. Health Aff. 2003;22:71-84.
15.
Shaller D, Sofaer S, Findlay S, et al.Consumers and quality-driven health care: a call to action. Health Aff2003;22:95-101.
16.
Mehrotra A, Bodenheimer T, Dudley A. Employers efforts to measure and improve hospital quality: determinants of success. Health Aff2003;22:60-70.
17.
Scalise D. Stars for sale. H&HN. August 2003;28-29.
18.
McCormick D, Himmelstein D, Woolhandler S, et al.Relationship between low quality-of-care scores and HMOs subsequent public disclosure of quality-of-care scores. JAMA. 2002;288: 1484-1490.
19.
Tu J, Cameron C. Impact of an acute myocardial infarction report card in Ontario, Canada. Int J Qual Health Care. 2003;15: 131-137.
20.
Rainwater J, Romano P, Antonius D. The California Hospital Outcomes Project: how useful is California's report card for quality improvement. Jt Comm J Qual Improv. 1998;24:31-39.
21.
Consumer confusion. Special report. H&HN. April 2003;28-40.
22.
Quality ratings have almost no influence on consumers. Choices of hospitals, health plans and physicians. Harris Interactive Health Care News. 2002;2:1-2.
23.
Consumers and Health Care: Boomers at the Gate. VHA Research Series 2003. Irving, Tex: VHI, Inc;2003.
24.
How safe is your hospital. Consumer Reports. January 2003;12-18.
25.
Conn J. HealthGrades finds consumers look at hospital quality. Modern Physician [e-Newsletter]. January 26, 2004.
26.
Studies conclude consumers more likely to assess health web sites as credible based on design, rather than on critical disclosure information. E-Health Business. November 3, 2002.
27.
Poll: reputation is top indicator of hospital quality. Modern Physician MP Stat. August 17, 2003.
28.
Forster S. Most consumers ignore health ratings. The Wall Street Journal Online. October 11, 2002.
29.
Versel N. PacifiCare publishes hospital quality data for 2 million enrollees. Available at: Modernphysician.com. Accessed March 3, 2003.
30.
Solucient Top 100 hospitals. Modern Healthcare. Special supplement. September 30, 2002.
31.
100 top hospital addendum. Modern Healthcare. April 14, 2003; 31-33.
