“Instigating Women” and Initiation in Postmodern Male Identity: Women Mentoring Men in Michael Dorris's Short Fiction

Abstract

Two short stories from Working Men by the American fiction writer Michael Dorris enact romantic heterosexual relationships in which a woman becomes the mentor who helps carry a man stuck in delayed adolescence into initiated manhood. Dorris's stories update and make accessible the mythical and magical elements that Robert Bly has described in his Iron John as being able to renew a man stuck in his boyhood woundedness. Where Bly discusses the female mentor for men in terms of “meeting the god woman” and the wild woman guarding a sacred pond, Dorris fleshes out his female guides in the form of what Bly calls “instigating wom[en],” contemporary women who possess a certain wisdom. These women play a life-transforming role in establishing a more mature, differentiated identity in men.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alcorn

M. W.

, & Bracher

(1985). Literature, psychoanalysis: New directions for reader response theory. Publications of the Modern Language Association, 100, 342–352.

Bly

(1990). Iron John. New York: Vintage.

Bonetti

(1988). An interview with Louise Erdrich and Michael Dorris. Missouri Review, 11, 79–99.

Dorris

(1987). A yellow raft in blue water. New York: Warner Books.

Dorris

(1993). Earnest money. In Working Men (pp. 16–39). New York: Warner Books.

Dorris

(1993). Oui. In Working Men (pp. 188–214). New York: Warner Books.

Dorris

, & Erdrich

(1991). The crown of Columbus. New York: HarperCollins.

Eprile

(1993, October 17). We are what we do. New York Times, Section 7, 12.

Gergen

(1991). The saturated self: Dilemmas of identity in contemporary life. New York: Basic Books.

10.

Hillman

(1975). Why “archetypal” psychology? In Loose Ends (pp. 138–145). Dallas: Spring.

11.

Hillman

(1977). Re-visioning psychology. New York: Harper and Row.

12.

Larsen

C. A.

(1993, October 17). Hard to be a guy. Washington Post, Section 10, 6.

13.

Miller

(1974). The new polytheism: Rebirth of the gods and goddesses. New York: Harper and Row.

14.

Miller

(1981). Christs: Meditations on archetypal images in Christian theology. New York: Seabury Press.

15.

Moore

(1996). The re-enchantment of everyday life. New York: HarperCollins.

16.

Morris

(1992). First persons plural in contemporary feminist fiction. Tulsa Studies in Women's Literature 11, 11–29.

17.

Owens

(1987). Acts of recovery: The American Indian novel in the '80s. Western American Literature 1, 53–57.

18.

Rayson

(1991). Shifting identities in the work of Louise Erdrich and Michael Dorris. Studies in Native American Literatures, 4, 27–37.

19.

Wood

M. R.

, & Zurcher

L. A.

Jr. (1983). The development of the postmodern self. New York: Greenwood.