Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 1993-05
Toward a Cross-Cultural Theory of Aboriginal Crime: a Comparative Study of the Problem of Aboriginal Overrepresentation in the Criminal Justice Systems of Canada and Australia
This article provides a theoretical starting point for the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime. The authors contend that any attempt to develop such a theory has to proceed on three fronts: (a) through offering a cross-cultural explanation of the problem of aboriginal overrepresentation; (b) through undertaking comparative research aimed at accounting for aboriginal offending patterns that often lie outside the official picture of overrepresentation; and (c) through developing a primarily societal-based (as opposed to individualist) cross-cultural theory of aboriginal criminality that is able to account for identified cross-national patterns of aboriginal overrepresentation and aboriginal offending. As a takeoff point for this series of interconnected and overlapping comparative research efforts, the authors undertake an examination of the state of research and theory about the causes of aboriginal overrepresentation in the criminal justice systems of Canada and Australia. In order to explain the similar patterns of overrepresentation found among aboriginal peoples in Canada, Australia, and other countries, the authors identify and synthesize a number of different cross-cultural theories of crime recently developed by comparative criminologists that can be used in working toward the development of a more encompassing cross-cultural theory of aboriginal crime.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alberta Government . (1991). Justice on trial: Report of the Task Force on the Criminal Justice System and Its Impact on Indian and Mdtis People: Vol. 1. Main report. Edmonton, Alberta, Canada: Attorney General of Alberta.
2.
Amnesty International . (1993). Australia: A criminal justice system weighted against aboriginal people. Sydney, Australia: Author.
3.
Atkinson, J. (Ed.). (1990). Beyond violence: Finding the dream. Aboriginal and Islander Sub-Program, National Domestic Violence Education Program. Canberra, Australia: Office of the Status of Women.
4.
Australian Institute of Criminology . (1988). Crime digest. Canberra, Australia: Author.
5.
Australian Law Reform Commission . (1986). The recognition of Aboriginal customary laws (Report No. 31). Canberra, Australia: Australian Government Printing Services.
6.
Bartlett, R. (1993). The Mabo decision. Sydney, Australia: Butterworths.
7.
Beirne, P. (1983a). Cultural relativism and comparative criminology. Contemporary Crises, 7, 371-391.
8.
Beirne, P. (1983b). Generalization and its discontents: The comparative study of crime. In I. Barak-Glantz & E. Johnson (Eds.), Comparative criminology (pp. 19-38). Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE Publications.
9.
Beirne, P. , & Messerschmidt, J. (1991). Criminology. New York, NY: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
10.
Bell, D. , & Napurrula Nelson, T. (1989). Speaking about rape is everyone's business. Women's Studies International Forum, 12(4), 403-415.
11.
Bennett, R. (1991a). Development and crime: A cross-national, time-series analysis of competing models. The Sociological Quarterly, 32, 343-363.
12.
Bennett, R. (1991b). Routine activities: A cross-national assessment of a criminological perspective. Social Forces, 70, 147-163.
13.
Bennett, R. , & Basiotis, P. P. (1991). Structural correlates of juvenile property crime: A cross-national, time series analysis. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 28, 262-287.
14.
Bennett, R. , & Lynch, J. P. (1990). Does a difference make a difference? Comparing cross-national crime indicators. Criminology, 28, 153-182.
15.
Berger, T. (1991). A long and terrible shadow: White values, native rights in the Americas, 1492-1992. Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada: Douglas & McIntyre.
16.
Bienvenue, R. (1983). Comparative colonial systems: The case of Canadian Indians and Australian Aborigines. Australian-Canadian Studies: An Interdisciplinary Social Science Review, 1, 30-43.
17.
Bienvenue, R. , & Latif, A. H. (1974). Arrests, disposition and recidivism: A comparison of Indians and whites. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 16, 105-116.
18.
Biles, D. , & McDonald, D. (Eds.). (1992). Deaths in custody Australia 1980-1989. Canberra, Australia: Australian Institute of Criminology.
19.
Biles, D. , McDonald, D., & Fleming, J. (1990). Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal deaths in custody. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 23(1) 15-23.
20.
Boldt, E. , Hursh, L., Johnson, S., & Taylor, W. (1983). Presentence reports and the incarceration of natives. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 25, 269-276.
21.
Boldt, M. (1993). Surviving as Indians: The challenge of self-government. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: University of Toronto Press.
22.
Bourgeault, R. , Broad, D., Brown, L., & Foster, L. (Eds.). (1992). 1492-1992: Five centuries of imperialism and resistance. Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada: Fernwood Publishing.
23.
Braithwaite, J. (1979). Inequality, crime and public policy. London, England: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
24.
Braithwaite, J. (1989). Crime, shame and reintegration. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
25.
Braithwaite, J. (1992, April/May). Los Angeles and the pathologies of criminal justice. Criminology Australia, pp. 2-5.
26.
Broadhurst, R. G. (1987). Imprisonment of the Aborigines in Western Australia, 1957-1985. In K. M. Hazlehurst (Ed.), Ivory scales: Black Australia and the law (pp. 153-189). Sydney, Australia: University of New South Wales Press.
27.
Broadhurst, R. G. , & Maller, R. A. (1990). White man's magic makes black deaths in custody disappear. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 25, 279-289.
28.
Brogden, M. (1990). Law and criminal labels: The case of the French Metis in western Canada. Journal of Human Justice, 1, 13-32.
29.
Cooper, D. (1993, August). Current delinquency in Chile: Urban, rural and indigenous delinquency. Paper presented at the 11th International Congress of Criminology, Budapest, Hungary.
30.
Cowlishaw, G. (1987). Policing the races. Unpublished manuscript. Mitchell College of Advanced Education, Sydney, Australia.
31.
Cunneen, C. , & Robb, T. (1987). Criminal justice in north-west New South Wales. Sydney, Australia: NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research.
32.
Daniels, D. (1986). The coming crises in the aboriginal rights movement: From colonialism to neo-colonialism to renaissance. Native Studies Review, 2, 97-116.
33.
Dyck, N. (Ed.). (1985). Indigenous peoples and the nation-state: Fourth World politics in Canada, Australia and Norway. Saint John's, Newfoundland, Canada: Memorial University, Institute of Social and Economic Research.
34.
Edmunds, M. (1987). They get heaps: A study of attitudes in Roebourne Western Australia. Canberra, Australia: Aboriginal Studies Press.
35.
Edmunds, M. (1990). Doing business: Socialisation, social relations and social control in Aboriginal society (Discussion Paper). Canberra, Australia: Royal Commission Into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody.
36.
Eggleston, E. (1976). Fear, favour or affection: Aborigines and the criminal law in Victoria, South Australia and Western Australia. Canberra, Australia: Australian National University Press.
37.
Fisher, R. (1980). The impact of European settlement on the indigenous peoples of Australia, New Zealand, and British Columbia: Some comparative dimensions. Canadian Ethnic Studies, 12, 1-14.
38.
Foley, M. (1984). Aborigines and the police. In P. Hanks & B. Keon-Cohen (Eds.), Aborigines and the law (pp. 160-190). Sydney, Australia: George Allen & Unwin.
39.
Gale, F. , Bailey-Harris, R., & Wundersitz, J. (1990). Aboriginal youth and the criminal justice system. Melbourne, Australia: Cambridge University Press.
40.
Grabosky, P. , Scandia, A., Hazelhurst, K., & Wilson, P. (1988). Aboriginal deaths in custody. Trends and issues in crime and criminal justice (No. 12). Canberra, Australia: Australian Institute of Criminology.
41.
Graham, D. (1989). Dying inside. Sydney, Australia: Allen & Unwin.
42.
Green, D. (1993). The contextual nature of American Indian criminality. American Indian Culture and Research Journal, 17, 99-119.
43.
Griffiths, C. , & Verdun-Jones, S. N. (1994). Aboriginal peoples and the criminal justice system. In C. Griffiths & S. N. Verdun-Jones (Eds.), Canadian criminal justice (2nd ed., pp. 633-668). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Harcourt, Brace and Company.
44.
Griffiths, C. , Yerbury, C., & Weaver, L. (1989). Victimization of Canada's Natives: The consequences of socio-cultural deprivation. In E. Fattah (Ed.), The plight of victims in modern society (pp. 118-138). New York, NY: St. Martin's Press.
45.
Groves, W. B. , & Newman, G. (1989). Against general theory in comparative criminology. International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice, 13, 23-29.
46.
Hagan, J. (1974). Criminal justice and native people: A study of incarceration in a Canadian province. Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology Special Issue, pp. 220-236.
47.
Hagan, J. (1975a). Parameters of criminal prosecution: An application of path analysis to a problem of criminal justice. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 65, 536-544.
48.
Hagan, J. (1975b). The social and legal construction of criminal justice: A study of the pre-sentencing process. Social Problems, 22, 620-637.
49.
Hagan, J. (1977). Criminal justice in rural and northern communities: A study of the bureaucratization of justice. Social Forces, 55, 597-612.
50.
Hanks, P. , & Keon-Cohen, B. (Eds.). (1984). Aborigines and the law: Essays in memory of Elizabeth Eggleston. Sydney, Australia: George Allen & Unwin.
51.
Hartnagel, T. (1987). Correlates of human behavior. In R. Lindon (Ed.), Criminology: A Canadian perspective (pp. 91-126). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Butterworths.
52.
Havemann, P. (1988). The indigenization of social control in Canada. In B. Morse & G. Woodman (Eds.), Indigenous law and the state (pp. 71-100). Dordrecht, Netherlands: Foris Publications.
53.
Havemann, P. (1989). Law, state, and Canada's indigenous people: Pacification by coercion and consent. In T. Caputo, M. Kennedy, C. Reasons, and A. Brannigan (Eds.), Law and society: A critical perspective (pp. 54-72). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
54.
Havemann, P. , Crouse, K., Foster, L., & Matonovich, R. (1984). Law and order for Canada's indigenous people: A review of recent research literature relating to the operation of the criminal justice system and Canada's indigenous people. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Solicitor General of Canada.
55.
Hazlehurst, K. (Ed.). (1987). Ivory scales: Black Australia and the law. Kensington, England: New South Wales University Press.
56.
Hazlehurst, K. M. (1993). Political expression and ethnicity: Statecraft and mobilization in the Maori world. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
57.
Hazlehurst, K. , & Dunn, A. T. (1988). Aboriginal criminal justice. Trends and issues in crime and criminal justice (No. 13). Canberra, Australia: Australian Institute of Criminology.
58.
Heiland, H.-G. , & Shelley, L. L. (1992). Civilization, modernization and the development of crime and control. In H. Heiland, L. Shelley, & H. Katoh (Eds.), Crime and control in comparative perspectives (pp. 1-19). Berlin, Germany: SAGE Publications.
59.
Heiland, H.-G. , Shelley, L. I., & Katoh, H. (1992). Crime and control in comparative perspectives. Berlin, Germany: SAGE Publications.
60.
Hocking, B. (1988). Colonial laws and indigenous peoples. In B. Hocking (Ed.), International law and Aboriginal human rights (pp. 3-18). Sydney, Australia: Law Book Company.
61.
Independent Commission on International Humanitarian Issues . (1987). Indigenous peoples: A global quest for justice. London, England: Zed Books.
62.
La Prairie, C. (1984a). Native juveniles in court: Some preliminary observations. In T. Fleming & L. Visano (Eds.), Deviant designations: Crime, law and deviance in Canada (pp. 337-350). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Butterworths.
63.
La Prairie, C. (1984b). Selected criminal justice and socio-demographic data on native women. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 26, 161-169.
64.
La Prairie, C. (1987). Native women and crime: A theoretical model. Canadian Journal of Native Studies, 7, 121-137.
65.
La Prairie, C. (1990). The role of sentencing in the over-representation of aboriginal people in correctional institutions. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 32, 429-440.
66.
La Prairie, C. (1991). Justice for the Cree: Communities, crime and order. The Grand Council of the Crees, Quebec, Canada: Cree Regional Authority.
67.
La Prairie, C. (1992). Aboriginal crime and justice: Explaining the present, exploring the future. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 34, 281-298.
68.
La Prairie, C. , & Griffiths, C. T. (1982). Native Indian delinquency and the juvenile court: A review of recent findings. Canadian Legal Aid Bulletin, 5, 39-46.
69.
Langton, M. (1983). After the tent embassy. Woollahra, New South Wales: Valadon.
70.
Law Reform Commission of Canada . (1991). Report on aboriginal peoples and criminal justice: Equality, respect and the search for justice. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Author.
71.
Lincoln, R. , & Wilson, P. (1994). Aboriginal offending: Patterns and causes. In D. Chapell & P. R. Wilson (Eds.), The Australian criminal justice system: The mid 1990s (4th ed., pp. 61-86). Sydney Australia: Butterworths.
72.
Mambo and Others v. State of Queensland . (1992). Australian Law Report, Vol. 107, pp. 1-170.
73.
Manitoba Government . (1991). Report of the Aboriginal Justice Inquiry of Manitoba: Vol. 1. The justice system and aboriginal people. Vol. 2. The deaths of Helen Betty Osborne and John Joseph Harper. Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada: Queen's Printer.
74.
Marenin, O. (1992). Explaining patterns of crime in the Native villages of Alaska. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 34, 339-368.
75.
May, P. A. (1982). Contemporary crime and the American Indian: A survey and analysis of the literature. Plains Anthropologist, 27, 225-238.
76.
McCorquodale, J. (1987). Aborigines and the law: A digest. Canberra, Australia: Aboriginal Studies Press.
77.
McMichael, P. (1990). Incorporating comparison within a world-historical perspective: An alternative comparative method. American Sociological Review, 55, 385-397.
78.
McNamara, L. (1992a). The Aboriginal Justice Inquiry of Manitoba: A fresh approach to the "problem" of overrepresentation in the criminal justice system. Manitoba Law Journal, 21, 49-79.
79.
McNamara, L. (1992b). Aboriginal peoples, the administration of justice and the autonomy agenda: An assessment of the status of criminal justice reform in Canada with reference to the prairie region. Unpublished LLM thesis, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba.
80.
McNamara, L. (1992c). Autonomy-based solutions and criminal justice reform: A comparison of the recommendations of the Australian Royal Commission Into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody and the Aboriginal Justice Inquiry of Manitoba. Aboriginal Law Bulletin, 54, 4-7.
81.
Merry, S. (1991). Law and colonialism. Law and Society Review, 25, 889-922.
82.
National Aboriginal and Islander Legal Services Secretariat . (1989). An interesting and informative chat is not what I had in mind. Aboriginal Law Bulletin, 36, 12-14.
83.
Neuman, W. L. , & Berger, R. J. (1988). Competing perspectives on cross-national crime: An evaluation of theory and evidence. Sociological Quarterly, 29, 281-313.
84.
Nova Scotia Government . (1988). Royal Commission of Inquiry Into the Donald Marshall jr. Prosecution. Sydney, Australia, and Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada: Queen's Printer.
85.
Parker, D. (1987). The administration of justice and its penal consequences. In K. M. Hazlehurst (Ed.). Ivory scales: Black Australia and the law (pp. 136-152). Sydney, Australia: University of New South Wales Press.
86.
Read, P. (1988). A hundred years war. Canberra, Australia: Australian National University Press.
87.
Rees, N. (1982). Police interrogation of Aborigines. In J. Basten, M. Richardson, C. Ronalds, & G. Zdenkowski (Eds.), The criminal injustice system (pp. 36-61). Sydney, Australia: Australian Legal Workers Group and Legal Service Bulletin.
88.
Rosenfeld, R. , & Messner, S. (1991). The social sources of homicide in different types of societies. Sociological Forum, 6, 51-70.
89.
Royal Commission Into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody . (1991). Royal Commission Into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody: National report. Canberra, Australia: Australian Government Publishing Service.
90.
Sackett, L. (1990). Aboriginal violence: Responding to the Tatz view. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 26, 68-70.
91.
Sackett, L. (1993). The panopticon re-visited: The RCIADIC. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 28(3), 230-246.
92.
Schneider, H. J. (1992). Life in a societal no-man's land: Aboriginal crime in central Australia. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 36, 5-19.
93.
Smandych, R. , & Linden, R. (in press). Co-existing forms of Native and private justice: An historical study of the Canadian west. Justice and Reform.
94.
Tatz, C. (1990). Aboriginal violence: A return to pessimism. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 25, 245-260.
95.
Taylor, K. W. (1982). Multiple association analysis of race and plea negotiation: The Wynne and Hartnagel data. Canadian Journal of Sociology, 7, 391-401.
96.
Tickner, R. (1992). Government response to the final report of the RCIADIC. Aboriginal and Islander Health Worker Journal, pp. 16-19.
97.
Walker, J. (1987). Prison cells with revolving doors: A judicial or societal problem? In K. M. Hazlehurst (Ed.), Ivory scales: Black Australia and the law (pp. 106-117). Sydney, Australia: University of New South Wales Press.
98.
Waller, L. (1984). Elizabeth Eggleston, Aborigines, and the law. In P. Hanks & B. Keon-Cohen (Eds.), Aborigines and the law: Essays in memory of Elizabeth Eggleston (pp. 304-309). Sydney, Australia: George Allen & Unwin.
99.
West, G. (1989). Towards a global criminal justice problematic. Journal of Human Justice, 1, 99-112.
100.
Wilson, P. R. (1982). Black death white hands. Sydney, Australia: George Allen & Unwin.
101.
Wilson, P. , & Lincoln, R. (1991, November). Black death and white commissions: The politics of investigating Aboriginal deaths in and outside custody. Paper presented at the annual meetings of the American Society of Criminology, San Francisco, CA.
102.
Wotherspoon, T. , & Satzewich, V. (1993). First nations: Race, class, and gender relations. Scarborough, Ontario, Canada: Nelson Canada.
103.
Wright, R. (1992). Stolen continents: The "New World" through Indian eyes. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Penguin.
104.
Wundersitz, J. , Bailey-Harris, R., & Gale, F. (1990). Aboriginal youth and juvenile justice in South Australia. Aboriginal Law Bulletin, 44, 12-14.
105.
Wynne, D. , & Hartnagel, T. F. (1975). Race and plea negotiation: An analysis of some Canadian data. Canadian Journal of Sociology, 1, 147-155.
106.
Yerbury, C. , & Griffiths, C. T. (1991). Minorities, crime, and the law. In M. Jackson & C. Griffiths (Eds.), Canadian criminology: Perspectives on crime and criminality (pp. 315-346). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
107.
York, G. (1990). The dispossessed: Native life and death in Canada. Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Little, Brown.
