Deconsolidation of Public-Safety Agencies Providing Police and Fire Services

Abstract

In recent years, a growing number of communities have consolidated their police and fire agencies into a single “public-service” agency. Consolidation has appealed to communities seeking to achieve efficiency and cost-effectiveness, but resistance has arisen from organized labor and firefighters. Some communities have even begun to abandon the model. Exploring the reasons for disbanding can help cities considering the public-safety model determine whether it is right for them. Such analysis can also help cities that have already adopted the model understand what may cause it to falter. In this work, we analyze six case studies of public-safety agencies, chosen for their diversity in geography, date of consolidation and deconsolidation, form of consolidation, and other community characteristics. We explore their reasons for consolidation and deconsolidation in the context of broader police organizational research, particularly that regarding organizational theory, change, and performance. We place our findings in the context of structural contingency and institutional theories of organization, finding both to explain many of the reasons these organizations consolidated but later deconsolidated.

Keywords

police fire consolidation public safety

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alamogordo (New Mexico) City Commission. (2013, 2 26). Meeting agenda. Retrieved from http://ci.alamogordo.nm.us/Assets/COA+Document/City+Clerk/Agenda/February+26$!2c+2013+Agenda+Book.pdf

Ayres

L. D.

(1957). Integration of police and fire services: Advantages and disadvantages. Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology, and Police Science, 47, 490–496. Retrieved from http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4525&context=jclc

Baker

(1999a, 1 20). West Jordan may split up police, fire. Deseret News. Retrieved from http://www.deseretnews.com/article/675131/West-Jordan-may-split-up-police-fire.html

Baker

(1999b, 2 11). W. Jordan to split its public safety department. Deseret News. Retrieved from http://www.deseretnews.com/article/679662/W-Jordan-to-split-its-public-safety-department.html

Barbati

(2011a, 4 8). Trujillo retiring: Alamogordo Department of Public Safety director will leave his post July 1. Alamogordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/ci_17798667

Barbati

(2011b, 7 9). Wallis sees challenges as new ADPS director. Alamogordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/ci_18448861#

Barbati

(2012a, 8 25). Officers at Alamogordo Department of Public Safety allege superiors asked them to change accident report information. Alamogordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/tablehome/ci_21402757/officers-at-alamogordo-department-public-safety-allege-superiors

Barbati

(2012b, 8 31). Interim city manager, assistant city manager to take over ADPS. Alamagordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/ci_21448290/interim-city-manager-assistant-city-manager-take-over#

Barbati

(2012c, 9 26). Alamogordo won’t release Department of Public Safety study. Alamogordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/ci_21640356/alamogordo-wont-release-department-public-safety-study

10.

Barbati

(2013, 3 7). At GOP event, ADPS chief discusses new department tweaks. Alamogordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/ci_22744553/at-gop-event-adps-chief-discusses-new-department

11.

Barnett

J. L.

Sheckells

C. L.

Peterson

Tydings

E. M.

(2014, 12). 2012 Census of Governments: Finance—state and local government summary report. U.S. Census Bureau, Economy-Wide Statistics Briefs: Public Sector. Retrieved from http://www2.census.gov/govs/local/summary_report.pdf

12.

Bear

(2013a, 2 22). ADPS may split in two. Alamogordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/ci_22651904/adps-may-split-two

13.

Bear

(2013b, 4 9). Alamogordo city commission OK’s splitting public safety department. Alamogordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/ci_22992376/alamogordo-city-commission-oks-splitting-public-safety-department

14.

Bear

(2013c, 7 29). Fire training important for ‘team chemistry.’ Alamogordo Daily News. Retrieved from http://archive.alamogordonews.com/ci_23756258/fire-training-important-team-chemistry

15.

Berkshire Advisors, Inc. (2012, 9). Alamogordo, New Mexico: Management review of the Department of Public Safety. Bay Village, OH. Retrieved from http://extras.mnginteractive.com/live/media/site561/2012/1016/20121016_055156_DPS_Study.pdf

16.

Berenbaum

(1977). Municipal public safety: A guide for the implementation of consolidated police-fire services. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.

17.

Bernitt

R. O.

(1962). A study of the attitudes held by police and fire chiefs and city managers toward the integration of police and fire services (Unpublished master’s thesis ). Michigan State University College of Business and Public Service, Lansing.

18.

Burruss

G. W.

Giblin

M. J.

(2014, 4). Modeling isomorphism on policing innovation: The role of institutional pressures in adopting community-oriented policing. Crime & Delinquency, 60, 331–355.

19.

Burruss

G. W.

Giblin

M. J.

Schafer

J. A.

(2010, 2). Threatened globally, acting locally: Modeling law enforcement homeland security practices. Justice Quarterly, 27, 77–101.

20.

Chermak

Scheer

Wilson

J. M.

(2014, 6). Police consolidation in the news. Police Quarterly, 17, 150–175.

21.

City of Alamogordo (New Mexico). (2007). History of Alamogordo. Retrieved from http://ci.alamogordo.nm.us/Government/coahistory.htm

22.

City of Durham (North Carolina). (2014). Durham history at a glance. Retrieved from http://www.durham-nc.com/about/overview-facts-history/history_glance.php

23.

City of Eugene (Oregon) Fire Department. (n.d.). History. Retrieved from http://www.eugene-or.gov/index.aspx?nid=271

24.

City of Eugene (Oregon) Police Department. (n.d.). Eugene police historical perspective. Retrieved from http://www.eugene-or.gov/index.aspx?nid=660

25.

Coe

Rosch

(1987, 9). Benefits and barriers to police-fire consolidation: A case study. Journal of Police Science and Administration, 15, 216–225.

26.

Crank

J. P.

Alexander

(1990, 3). Opposition to public safety: An assessment of issues confronting directors of public safety departments. Journal of Police Science and Administration, 17, 55–65.

27.

Crank

J. P.

Langworthy

(1992, Summer). An institutional perspective of policing. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 83, 338–363.

28.

Crank

Langworthy

(1996). Fragmented centralization and the organization of the police. Policing and Society: An International Journal of Research and Policy, 6, 213–229.

29.

Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport. (2014). Fast facts. Retrieved from http://www.dfwairport.com/visitor/P1_009559.php

30.

Darroch

Mazzerolle

(2013, 3). Intelligence-led policing: A comparative analysis of organizational factors influencing innovation uptake. Police Quarterly, 16, 3–37.

31.

Donaldson

(1995). American anti-management theories of organization: A critique of paradigm proliferation. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

32.

Eitle

(2005, 3). The influence of mandatory arrest policies, police organizational characteristics, and situational variables on the probability of arrest in domestic violence cases. Crime & Delinquency, 51, 573–597.

33.

Eitle

D’Alessio

S. J.

Stolzenberg

(2014, 6). The effect of organizational and environmental factors on police misconduct. Police Quarterly, 17, 103–126.

34.

Eitle

Monahan

(2009, 9). Revisiting the racial threat thesis: The role of police organizational characteristics in predicting rate-specific drug-arrest rates. Justice Quarterly, 26, 528–561.

35.

Evans

(2000, 11 6). My view: Cooperating, not consolidating, best way to combine services. Deseret News. Retrieved from http://www.deseretnews.com/article/795112/Cooperating-not-consolidating-best-way-to-combine-services.html

36.

Farr

Daniel

E. D.

(1988). Police and fire consolidation: Pros and cons. Chicago, IL: International Protection of Assets Consultants.

37.

Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2013). Uniform crime reports. Retrieved from http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/ucr

38.

Giblin

M. J.

(2006). Structural elaboration and institutional isomorphism: The case of crime analysis units. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 29, 643–664.

39.

Gustafson

(2013, 11). Diversity in municipal police agencies: A national examination of minority hiring and promotion. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies and Management, 56, 719–736.

40.

Haynes

M. R.

Giblin

M. J.

(2014, 3). Homeland security risk and preparedness in police agencies: The insignificance of actual risk factors. Police Quarterly, 17, 30–53.

41.

House

(2013, 10 23). U.S. cities still reeling from Great Recession. Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2013/10/23/u-s-cities-still-reeling-from-great-recession/

42.

International Association of Fire Fighters and International Association of Fire Chiefs. (n.d.). Police and fire consolidation: An ineffective use of resources. Retrieved from http://www.iaff.org/09News/PDFs/PSOSystems.pdf

43.

Katz

Kahn

R. L.

(1966). The social psychology of organizations. New York, NY: Wiley.

44.

King

R. D.

(2007, 3). The context of minority group threat: Race, institutions, and complying with hate crime law. Law & Society Review, 41, 189–224.

45.

King

W. R.

(2014, 8). Organizational failure and the disbanding of local police agencies. Crime & Delinquency, 60, 667–692.

46.

Kohl

Johnson

P. C.

Schlacter

Dutcher

(1997). Public safety in Meridian Township: A 25 year analysis. Meridian Township, MI: Department of Public Safety.

47.

Lawrence

P. R.

Lorsch

J. W.

(1967). Organization and environment. Boston, MA: Harvard University.

48.

Lynch

R. G.

Lord

(1979). Public safety programs: Consolidating police and fire services. Popular Government, 45, 1–8, 33.

49.

Marenin

Copus

(1991). Policing rural Alaska: The village public safety officer program. American Journal of Police, 10, 1–26.

50.

Maguire

E. R.

(2003). Organizational structure in American police agencies: Context, complexity, and control. Albany: State University of New York Press.

51.

Maguire

E. R.

Uchida

C. D.

Hassell

K. D.

(2015, 2). Problem-oriented policing in Colorado Springs: A content analysis of 753 cases. Crime & Delinquency, 61, 71–95.

52.

Mata

V. R.

(2010, 3). The contribution of police and fire consolidation to the homeland security mission (Unpublished master’s thesis). Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA.

53.

Matarese

Chelst

Fisher-Stewart

Pearsall

(2007, 5). Public safety concept in the post 9/11 world. Public Management, 89, 14–17.

54.

Melekian

(2012). Policing in the new economy: A new report on the emerging trends from the office of community oriented policing services. Police Chief, 79, 6–19. Retrieved from http://www.policechiefmagazine.org/magazine/index.cfm?fuseaction=display_arch&article_id=2576&issue_id=12012

55.

Meridian Charter Township (Michigan). (2011). White paper on the feasibility of altering EMS, fire and police service delivery. Retrieved from http://www.meridian.mi.us/vertical/sites/%7B1800D46E-0900-43BD-B3FA-10A5660870B1%7D/uploads/White_Paper_-_EMS_Fire_and_Police_Service_Delivery.PDF

56.

Meyer

J. W.

Rowan

(1977, 9). Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology, 83, 340–363.

57.

Michigan Townships Association. (2013). Township structure. Retrieved from http://www.michigantownships.org/twpstructure.asp

58.

Miller

(2013, 2). The institutionalization of racial profiling policy: An examination of antiprofiling policy adoption among large law enforcement agencies. Crime & Delinquency, 59(1), 32–58.

59.

Morabito

M. S.

(2007, 12). Horizons of context: Understanding the police decision to arrest people with mental illness. Psychiatric Services, 58, 1582–1587.

60.

Morabito

M. S.

(2008, 8). The adoption of police innovation: The role of the political environment. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 31, 466–484.

61.

Morabito

M. S.

(2010, 10). Understanding community policing as an innovation: Patterns of adoption. Crime & Delinquency, 56, 564–587.

62.

H. W.

(1970). The new era of public safety. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.

63.

Morley

B. S.

Hadley

J. M.

(2013). Public safety consolidation: Does it make sense? FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin. Retrieved from https://leb.fbi.gov/2013/april/perspective-public-safety-consolidation-does-it-make-sense

64.

Robbins

W. C.

Jr. (1975, 6). The costs of police-fire consolidation: A case study of Durham, North Carolina (Unpublished master’s thesis). Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA.

65.

Obadal

(1998, 1). Planning for deconsolidation of a Department of Public Safety. Retrieved from http://www.usfa.fema.gov/pdf/efop/efo28042.pdf

66.

Office of Community Oriented Policing Services. (2011). The impact of the economic downturn on American policing agencies. Washington, DC. Retrieved from http://www.cops.usdoj.gov/files/RIC/Publications/e101113406_Economic%20Impact.pdf

67.

Paoline

E. A.

Sloan

J. J.

(2003). Variability in the organizational structure of contemporary campus law enforcement agencies: A national-level analysis. Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management, 26, 612–639.

68.

Police Executive Research Forum. (2010, 12). Is the economic downturn fundamentally changing how we police? Washington, DC. Retrieved from http://www.policeforum.org/library/critical-issues-in-policing-series/Econdownturnaffectpolicing12.10.pdf

69.

Police Executive Research Forum. (2013, 2). Policing and the economic downturn: striving for efficiency is the new normal. Washington, DC. Retrieved from http://policeforum.org/library/critical-issues-in-policing-series/Economic_Downturn.pdf

70.

Thompson

J. D.

(1967). Organizations in action. New York, NY: McGraw Hill.

71.

U.S. Census Bureau. (1993). 1990 Census of population and housing, population and housing unit counts, United States. Retrieved from http://www.census.gov/prod/cen1990/cph2/cph-2-1-1.pdf

72.

U.S. Census Bureau. (2014). State and county quick facts. Retrieved from http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/

73.

Wall

N. L.

(1961, 8). A survey of public safety integration: Just as controversial as ever, police, fire integration has some new adherents and continued strong opposition. Public Management, 43, 170–175.

74.

West Jordan (Utah) Fire Department. (2014). History. Retrieved from http://www.ci.west-jordan.ut.us/Fire.aspx?pgID=3.9.1.1

75.

Wilson

J. M.

(2006). Community policing in America. New York, NY: Routledge.

76.

Wilson

J. M.

Dalton

Scheer

Grammich

C. A.

(2010). Police recruitment and retention for the new millennium: The state of knowledge. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corporation. Retrieved from http://www.rand.org/pubs/monographs/MG959.html

77.

Wilson

J. M.

Grammich

(2012). Police consolidation, regionalization, and shared services: Options, considerations, and lessons from research and practice. Washington, DC: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, BOLO 1. Retrieved from http://a-capp.msu.edu/sites/default/files/files/PEDSConsolBOLO.pdf

78.

Wilson

J. M.

Hollis

Grammich

(In Press). A census and administrative examination of consolidated public safety departments in the United States. Washington, DC: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services.

79.

Wilson

J. M.

Weiss

Grammich

(In Press). Public safety consolidation: A multiple case-study assessment of implementation and outcome. Washington, DC: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services.

80.

Zucker

L. G.

(1987). Institutional theories of organization. Annual Review of Sociology, 13, 443–464.