From Sunnyvale to Flatbush: The Conflict between School Reform and Teachers’ Job Protection Rights

Abstract

Nobility is defined by the demands it makes upon us—by obligations, not by rights.

Jose Ortega y Gasset

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bernard v. Avoyelles Parish School Board, 640 So.2d 321 (La. App., 1994).

Board of Education of Sunnyvale Elementary School District v. Commission on Professional Competence, 162 Cal. Rptr. 590 (Cal. Ct. App., 1980).

Bridges

E. M.

1988. “Coping with Incompetent Teachers,” in Urban, Social, and Educational Issues, Golubchick

L. H.

, and Persky

, eds., Garden City Park, NY: Avery Publishing Group, pp. 158–161.

Clune

W. H.

1993. “Systematic Educational Policy: A Conceptual Framework,” in Designing Coherent Educational Policy: Improving the System, Fuhrman

S. H.

, ed., San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, pp. 125–140.

Condon

1993. “Arrest Leaves Questions, but No Answers,” Hartford (Connecticut) Courant, (March, 28): b1.

Cortines

C, and Stancik

E. F.

1994. Final Report of the Joint Commission of the Chancellor and the Special Commissioner for the Prevention of Child Sexual Abuse, New York, NY: City Board of Education.

Dillon

1994. “Teachers and Tenure: Rights v. Discipline. New York Times, (June 28): Section A, p. 1.

Erin

1994. “Student Reports Affair 14 Years Later,” Baton Rouge Advocate, (September 24).

Finch

, and Nagel

T. W.

1984. “Collective Bargaining in the Public Schools: Reassessing Labor Policy in an Era of Reform,” Wisconsin Law Review, pp. 1573–1670.

10.

Fossey

, and Merseth

1992. Anchorage School District. Harvard Graduate School of Education, teaching case.

11.

Frahm

1994. “Teacher's Dismissal Is a Test for All: Ridgefield Case Highlights Process under Tenure Law,” Hartford Courant, (July 31): A1.

12.

Goldberg

1994. “They're Outta Here; Legislature OKs Bill to Remove Bad Teachers,” Newsday, (July 2).

13.

Howe

P. J.

1993. “Weld Puts Lukewarm Pen to Education Reform Bill,” Boston Globe, Metro/Regional sec., (June 19): 10.

14.

Johnson

S. M.

1978. The Case of Edna Wiley. Harvard Graduate School of Education, teaching case (typewritten).

15.

Kerchner

C. T.

, and Koppich

J. E.

1993. A Union of Professionals: Labor Relations and Educational Reform. New York: Teachers College Press.

16.

Maxcy

S. J.

, and Maxcy

D. O.

1993. Educational Reform in Louisiana. International Journal of Educational Reform, 2: 236–241.

17.

Mumane

, Singer

, Willett

, Kemple

, and Olsen

1992. Who Will Teach? Policies That Matter, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

18.

Myers

1994. “Ninety-Nine Percent of Teachers Pass Evaluations, Baton Rouge Advocate, (August 22).

19.

Nisbet

1974. The Sociology of Emile Durkheim, New York: Oxford University Press.

20.

Refroe v. Green, 626 P.2d 1068 (Alaska 1980).

21.

Schmidt

1994. “Philadelphia Leaders Join Call for Overhaul of Schools,” Education Week, p. 3.

22.

Shanker

1992. “The Crisis in Education and the Limits of the Traditional Model of Schooling,” in Restructuring the Schools: Problems and Prospects, Lane

J. J.

, and Epps

E. G.

, eds., Berkeley, CA: McCutchan, pp. 3–14.

23.

Timar

, and Kirp

1988. Managing Educational Excellence, Philadelphia: Falmer Press.

24.

Wilson

S. F.

1992. Reinventing the Schools: A Radical Plan for Boston, Boston: Pioneer Institute.