Phenomenological research into life and work for people with invisible chronic illness has revealed many examples of stigmatization. In trying to make sense of one particular case, the available literature on stigma is helpful yet unsatisfying, especially when considering life and work for those with unseen illness. The article presents a review of the stigma literature followed by the presentation of a taxonomy of potential determinants and detriments of stigma for those with invisible chronic illness. It would seem that stigmatization is influenced by numerous issues: knowledge of the diagnosis, moral judgments, and incorrect knowledge held about the disease as distinct from an absence of or incomplete knowledge. The proposed taxonomy is suggested to have been helpful in explaining one person's poignant comments and is advocated for use in the analysis and interpretation of future stories of those with invisible illness.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlbrechtG. L.WalkerV., and LevyJ.1982. Social distance from the stigmatized: A test of two theories. Social Science and Medicine16:1319–27.
2.
AndersonS. J.1982. Sarcoidosis: A multisystem disease. American Journal of Nursing82:1566–69.
3.
AsherR.1995. Malingering. In Health and Disease: A Reader, edited by DaveyB.GrayA., and SealeC., 157–60. Buckingham, UK: Open University Press. (Original work published 1972)
4.
BarrittL.BeekmanT.BleekerH., and MulderijK.1984. Analyzing phenomenological descriptions. Phenomenology and Pedagogy2(1): 1–17.
5.
BattyeL.1974. The Chatterley syndrome. In The handicapped person in the community, edited by BoswellD. M. and WingroveJ. M., 93–9. London: Tavistock Publications in Association with the Open University Press.
6.
BeckerH. S.1963. Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of deviance.New York: Free Press.
7.
BergerP. L., and LuckmannT.1966. The social construction of reality: A treatise in the sociology of knowledge.London: Allen Lane.
8.
BlakeL. S.1993. It's not in my head. Canadian Nurse89, 29–32.
9.
BlaxterM.1976. The meaning of disability: A sociological study of impairment.London: Heinemann.
10.
CacioppeR.1988. AIDS in the workplace: A frightening disease poses delicate questions for employers. Human Resource Management in Australia26:52–67.
11.
ChristensenC. A.1992. Deviant, disabled or different: The politics of labelling. Australian Disability Review3:5–12.
12.
ConantS.1990. Living with chronic fatigue: New strategies for coping with and conquering CFS.Dallas, TX: Taylor.
13.
DonoghueP. J., and SiegelM. E.1992. Sick and tired of feeling sick and tired: Living with invisible chronic illness.New York: Norton.
14.
EriksonK. T.1964. Notes on the sociology of deviance. In The other side: Perspectives on deviance, edited BeckerH. S., 9–21. New York: Free Press.
15.
FabregaH. J.1981a. The scientific usefulness of the idea of illness. In Concepts of health and disease: Interdisciplinary perspectives, edited CaplanA. L.EngelhardtH.T.J., and McCartneyJ. J., 131–42. London: Addison-Wesley.
16.
FabregaH. J.1981b. Concepts of disease: Logical features and social implications. In Concepts of health and disease: Interdisciplinary perspectives, edited CaplanA. L.EngelhardtH.T.J., and McCartneyJ. J., 485–92. London: Addison-Wesley.
17.
FalvoD. R.AllenH., and MakiD. R.1982. Psychosocial aspects of invisible disability. Rehabilitation Literature43:2–6.
18.
FinermanR., and BennettL. A.1995. Overview: Guilt, blame and shame in sickness. Social Science and Medicine40:1–3.
19.
ForgasJ. P.1985. Interpersonal behaviour: The psychology of social interaction.Sydney: Pergamon.
20.
FoucaultM.1961. Madness and civilization.London: Tavistock.
21.
FoucaultM.1977. Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison.New York: Vintage.
22.
FreedmanJ. L., and DoobA. N.1968. Deviancy: The psychology of being different.New York: Academic Press.
23.
GalballyR.1988, November-December. Technology and disability—The promise and the reality. ACROD Newsletter, pp. 7–12.
24.
GethingL.1984. Cumberland's strategy for changing attitudes towards disabled people. Australian Disability Review1:44–52.
25.
GoffmanE.1961. Asylums: Essays on the social situation of mental patients and other inmates.Ringwood, Australia: Penguin.
26.
GoffmanE.1963. Stigma: Notes on the management of spoiled identity.New Jersey: Penguin.
27.
GoffmanE.1974a. Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of experience.Ringwood, Australia: Penguin.
28.
GoffmanE.1974b. Stigma and social identity. In The handicapped person in the community, edited by BoswellD. M. and WingroveJ. M., 79–91. London: Tavistock.
29.
GoldinC. S.1994. Stigmatization and AIDS: Critical issues in public health. Social Science and Medicine39:1359–66.
30.
Good News Bible.1976. Old Testament. New York: American Bible Society.
31.
GouldD.1985. The medical mafia: How doctors serve and fail their customers.London: Sphere.
HarréR.ClarkD., and De CarloN.1985. Motives and mechanisms: An introduction to the psychology of action.London: Methuen.
34.
HelmanC. G.1990. Culture, health and illness: An introduction for health professionals.2d ed.Oxford, UK: Butterworth Heinemann.
35.
IllichI.1975. Medical nemesis: The expropriation of health.London: Marion Boyars.
36.
JacobyA.1994. Felt versus enacted stigma: A concept revisited. Social Science and Medicine38:269–74.
37.
JourardS. M.1971. The transparent self.New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.
38.
JunorC. L.1985. Disabilities, employers and employees: Some issues. Australian Journal of Social Issues20:295–307.
39.
KantorA.1991. Coping with the invisibly disabled. Business and Health9:81–4.
40.
KelleyS.D.M., and TedderN. E.1993. Serving persons with both psychiatric and vision disabilities in psychosocial rehabilitation. Psychosocial Rehabilitation Journal16:101–11.
41.
KeseyK.1962/1973. One flew over the cuckoo's nest: The text. In One flew over the cuckoo's nest: Text and criticism, edited by PrattJ. C., 1–311. New York: Penguin.
42.
KleinmanA.1988. The illness narratives.New York: Basic Books.
43.
KlineP.1984. Psychology and Freudian theory: An introduction.London: Methuen.
44.
KroenkeK.1991. Chronic fatigue syndrome: Is it real?Postgraduate Medicine89: 49–50, 53.
45.
LambertV. A., and LambertC. E.1979. The impact of physical illness: And related mental health concepts.Englewood, NJ: Prentice Hall.
46.
LeonardV. W.1989. A Heideggerian phenomenologic perspective on the concept of the person. Advances in Nursing Science11(4): 40–55.
47.
LeonardD.HockingB., and LeggattM.1989. Schizophrenia and work rehabilitation. Journal of Occupational Health and Safety, Australia and New Zealand, 5:441–44.
48.
MankoffM.1971. Societal reaction and career deviance: A critical analysis. Sociological Quarterly12:214–18.
49.
ManuP.1992. Chronic fatigue: Practical guidelines for the primary care setting. Consultant32:71–4.
50.
MarshallG.1994. The concise Oxford dictionary of sociology.Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
51.
MilburnC.1996, Autumn. Employing people with mental illness. Perspectives, pp. 33–35.
52.
MillerJ. F.1992. Energy deficits in chronically ill persons with arthritis: Fatigue. In Coping with chronic illness: Overcoming powerlessness, edited MillerJ. F., 196–221. Philadelphia: F. A. Davis.
53.
MorrisJ.1995. Pride against prejudice: “Lives not worth living.” In Health and disease: A reader, edited DaveyB.GrayA., and SealeC., 107–10. Buckingham, UK: Open University Press.
54.
NavranF. J., and ZibulaP.1991. Managing the disabled employee. Transportation and Distribution32:47–9.
55.
NettletonS.1995. The sociology of health and illness.Cambridge, UK: Polity.
56.
NijhofG.1995. Parkinson's disease as a problem of shame in public appearance. Sociology of Health & Illness17:193–205.
57.
NothdurftJ., and AstorH.1986. Laughing in the dark—Anti-discrimination law and physical disability in New South Wales. Journal of Industrial Relations28:336–52.
58.
OldhamM., and KleinerB. H.1990. Understanding the nature and use of defence mechanisms in organisational life. Journal of Managerial Psychology5:i–iv.
59.
ParsonsonB. S.1989. Psychological effects of chronic illness and disability. In Psychology for the Health Sciences, edited by KingN. and RemenyiA., 211–20. Melbourne, Australia: Thomas Nelson Australia.
60.
PhilipC. E.1993. Dilemmas of disclosure to patients and colleagues when a therapist faces life-threatening illness. Health and Social Work18:13–9.
61.
RaphaelB.1986. When disaster strikes: a handbook for the caring professions.Sydney: Hutchinson.
62.
RaynerM.1992. Disability and discrimination. Australian Disability Review2:31–40.
63.
RegisterC.1987. Living with chronic illness: Days of patience and passion.New York: Free Press.
Safilios-RothschildC.1970. The sociology and social psychology of disability and rehabilitation.New York: Random House.
67.
SaylorC.1990. Stigma. In Chronic illness: Impact and intervention, edited LubkinI. M., 65–85. Boston: Jones and Bartlett.
68.
ScamblerG.1984. Perceiving and coping with stigmatizing illness. In The experience of illness, edited by FitzpatrickR.HintonJ.NewmanS.ScamblerG., and ThompsonJ., 203–26. London: Tavistock.
69.
ScottR. A.1974. The construction of conceptions of stigma by professional experts. In The handicapped person in the community, edited by BoswellD. M. and WingroveJ. M., 108–21. London: Tavistock.
70.
ShepherdC., and LeesH.1992. ME: Is it a genuine disease?Health-Visitor65:165–67.
71.
SmallN.1995. Living with HIV and AIDS. In Health and disease: A reader edited by DaveyB.GrayA., and SealeC., 100–6. Buckingham, UK: Open University Press.
72.
SontagS.1977. Illness as metaphor.New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
73.
SontagS.1988. AIDS and its metaphors.Ringwood, Australia: Penguin.
74.
StoneR.A.1994. AIDS in the workplace: An executive update. Academy of Management Executive8:52–64.
75.
StoneS.D.1995. The myth of bodily perfection. Disability & Society10:413–24.
76.
SusmanJ.1994. Disability, stigma and deviance. Social Science and Medicine38:15–22.
77.
Swanson-KauffmanK., and SchonwaldE.1988. Phenomenology. In Paths to knowledge: Innovative research methods for nursing, edited by SarterB., 97–105. New York: National League for Nursing.
78.
SzaszT. S.1970. The manufacture of madness.Bungay, UK: Granada.
79.
SzaszT.1980. Sex: Facts, frauds and follies.Oxford, UK: Basil Blackwell.
80.
SzaszS.1991. Living with it: Why you don't have to be healthy to be happy.Buffalo, NY: Prometheus.
81.
TurnerB. S.1987. Medical power and social knowledge.London: Sage Ltd.
82.
van ManenM.1990. Researching lived experience: Human science for an action sensitive pedagogy.Ontario, Canada: University of Western Ontario.
83.
VickersM.1995. Chronic illness: An organisational perspective long overdue. Policy Organisation and Society10:116–40.
84.
VickersM. H.1997a. Life at work with invisible chronic illness: The unseen, unspoken, unrecognized organisational dilemma of disclosure. Journal of Workplace Learning: Employee Counselling Today9(7): 240–52.
85.
VickersM.H.1997b. Life and work with “invisible” chronic illness (ICI): Authentic stories of a passage through trauma—A Heideggerian, hermeneutical, phenomenological, multiple-case, exploratory analysis. Ph.D. thesis, University of Western Sydney.
86.
VickersM. H.1998. Life at work with “invisible” chronic illness (ICI): A passage of trauma—Turbulent, random, poignant. Administrative Theory and Praxis20(2): 196–210.
87.
VickersM. H.1999. Sick organizations,” “rabid managerialism”: Work-life narratives from people with “invisible” chronic illness. Public Voices4:59–82.
88.
VickersM. H. In press. The “invisibly” chronically ill as unexamined organizational fringe-dwellers: Voices of ambiguity, confusion and uncertainty. In Marginality, edited by HodsonR.Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
89.
WangC.1992. Culture, meaning and disability: Injury prevention campaigns and the production of stigma. Social Science and Medicine35:1093–102.
90.
WilmotW. W.1975. Dyadic communication.2nd ed.New York: Random House.
91.
YelinE.1986. The myth of malingering: Why individuals withdraw from work in the presence of illness. Milbank Quarterly64:622–49.
