Abstract
This article investigates two aspects of corporate involvement in public education: commercialization of public schools and use of private companies to deliver instructional services or to manage schools. The extent of private investment in education and arguments for and against these activities are reviewed. Also explored are value conflicts among supporters and critics of such corporate involvement and implications of recent developments in this arena for the future of public education.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.American Federation of Teachers. 1994 . The Private Management of Public Schools: An Analysis of the EAI Experience in Baltimore. Washington, DC : AFT.
2.
Badie R.
1994 . “In the School Business, Who Profits?” The Orlando Sentinel , (August 28): G1 .
3.
Bennis W.
1990 . Why Leaders Can't Lead: The Unconscious Conspiracy Continues. San Francisco : Jossey-Bass Publishers.
4.
Bierlein L.
, and
Mulholland L.
1994 . Charter School Update: Expansion of a Viable Reform Initiative. Tempe, AZ : Morrison Institute for Public Policy.
5.
Bills M.
1994 . “The Fear of the Unknown,” Education Week , (June 22): 42 .
6.1994 . “Boards Urged to Contract for Operation of Schools,” Education Week , (May 11): 4 .
7.
Brodinsky B.
1993 . “How ‘New’ Will the ‘New’ Whittle American School Be? A Case Study in Privatization,” Phi Delta Kappan , 74 : 540 –547 .
8.1994 . “Business,” Education Week , (September 28): 11 .
9.
Chapman S.
1992 . “Study Says Schools Net Savings in Contracts with Private Firms,” The Chicago Tribune , (June 11): 25 .
10.
Chubb J. E.
, and
Moe T. M.
1990 . Politics, Markets, and America's Schools. Washington, DC : Brookings Institute.
11.
Deener B.
1994 . “Edison Project Raises Schools’ Hopes, Concerns,” The Dallas Morning News , (September 4): 1H .
12.1994 . “Disney Says Florida School Will Be Model for the Next Century,” Education Week , (June 22): 16 .
13.1994 . “Disney Subsidiary Plans a School,” School Board News , (June 7): 1 .
14.
Doyle D. P.
1994 . “The Role of Private Sector Management in Public Education Phi Delta Kappan , 76 : 128 –135 .
15.1994 . “EAI Overstates Student Progress in Its Schools,” School Board News , (June 21): 7 .
16.1994 . “Edison Project Expands Negotiations,” School Board News , (August 16): 7 .
17.1994 . “Education, Inc.: Perspectives on Private Management of Public Schools,” Education Week , (June 22): 41 –46 .
18.
Elam S. M.
,
Rose L. C.
, and
Gallup A. M.
1994 . “The 26th Annual Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup Poll of the Public's Attitudes toward the Public Schools,” Phi Delta Kappan , 76 : 41 –56 .
19.1993 . “Entrepreneurial Schools: Caveat Emptor,” School Board News , (November 9): 2 .
20.
Frerking B.
1994 . “Teachers Union Going All Out against School Privatization,” The Plain Dealer , Cleveland, OH, (June 24): 5A .
21.
Golle J. T.
1994 . “You Must Take Care of Your Customer,” Education Week , (June 22): 44 –45 .
22.
Green R.
1994 a. “EAI Faces Lawsuit by Investors; Stock Values, Officers’ Compensation Contested,” The Hartford Courant , (July 8): E4 .
23.
Green R.
1994 b. “Teachers’ Union Sues over EAI,” The Hartford Courant , (August 2): A1 .
24.
Greenberg B. S.
, and
Brand J. E.
1993 /1994. “Channel One: But What about the Advertising?” Educational Leadership , 51 (4 ): 56 –58 .
25.
Harp L.
1994 . “Schools Turning to Sponsors to Add to Coffers,” Education Week , (September 21): 1 , 8.
26.1994 . “Hartford Plan,” School Board News (Fast Report), (October 11): 1 , 7.
27.1991 . “Here Comes ‘McSchool,’” The American School Board Journal , 178 (9 ): 30 –31 .
28.
Hoff D.
1994 . “States Must Create Policies for Private Management,” Education Daily , (October 18): 1 , 3.
29.
Houston P. D.
1994 . “Making Watches or Making Music,” Phi Delta Kappan , 76 : 133 –135 .
30.
Huemer J.
1992 . “Education Opens Its Doors,” Venture Capital Journal , (April): 24 –27 .
31.
Jensen J.
1993 . “Ad-Supported Radio Rolls into the Nation's High Schools,” Advertising Age , 64 (31 ): 22 .
32.
Kozol J.
1992 . “Whittle and the Privateers,” The Nation , (September 21): 272 , 274, 276–278.
33.
Kuby R.
1993 . “Whittling the School Day Away,” Education Week , (December 1): 40 .
34.
Lieberman M.
1989 . Privatization and Educational Choice. New York : St. Martin's Press.
35.1994 . “Maryland Says EAI Violated Special Education Rules,” Education Daily , (July 11): 1 , 3.
36.
McLaughlin J.
1992 . “Schooling for Profit: Capitalism's New Frontier,” Educational Horizons , 71 : 23 –30 .
37.
McLaughlin J.
1994 . “Privatization Trend Likely to Continue,” School Board News , (June 7): 4 –5 .
38.1993 . “Media Business’ Whittle Said to Shrink Its School Project,” The New York Times , (July 30): D1 .
39.1994 . “More on Private Management of Schools,” OI A Info Memo , Organization of Institutional Affiliates, American Educational Research Association , (February): 9 –10 .
40.1994 . “NEA Puts Money behind Preserving Public Education,” Education Daily , (July 8): 1 –2 .
41.1993 . “New Music Radio Channel-Including Advertising-Making Debut in Schools,” Education Week , (September 8): 15 .
42.
O'Leary J.
, and
Beales J. R.
1993 . “Education, Inc.,” Education Week , (December 15): 34 .
43.
Olson L.
1992 . “New Approaches Blurring the Line between Public and Private Schools,” Education Week , (October 7): 1 , 18 .
44.
Osborne D.
, and
Gaebler T.
1992 . Reinventing Government-How the Entrepreneurial Spirit Is Transforming the Public Sector. Reading, MA : Addison-Wesley.
45.1993 . “Private Firm Will Run Minneapolis Schools,” School Board News , (November 23): 1 , 6 .
46.1994 . “Privatization Update,” School Board News , (June 7): 4 .
47.
Rank H.
1993 /1994. “Channel One: Asking the Wrong Questions,” Educational Leadership , 51 (4 ): 52 –55 .
48.
Richardson J.
1994 . “Contracts Put Superintendents to Performance lest,” Education Week , (September 14): 1 , 12 .
49.
Rist M. C.
1989 . “Mass Marketers Have a Sweet Deal for You, But There Are Strings Attached,” The American School Board Journal , 176 (9 ): 20 –25 , 39.
50.
Rist M. C.
1991 . “Whittling Away at Public Education,” The Executive Educator , 13 (9 ): 22 –28 .
51.
Sanchez C.
1994 . “Entrepreneur Wants to Run Public Schools for Profit,” Morning Editor, National Public Radio , (October 3).
52.
Sanger E.
1994 . “Whittling Down to … Nothing,” Newsday , (September 26): C02 .
53.
Schmidt B. C.
1994 . “A Very Different Kind of School,” Education Week , (June 22): 42 –43 .
54.
Schmidt P.
1994 a. “Privatization Proposal Deleted from D.C. Agenda,” Education Week , (March 16): 5 .
55.
Schmidt P.
1994 b. “Private Enterprise,” Education Week , (May 25): 27 –30 .
56.
Schmidt P.
1994 c. “Baltimore's Amprey Backs Off Plan to Increase E.A.I. Role,” Education Week , (June 22): 14 –15 .
57.
Schmidt P.
1994 d. “E.A.I. Faulted on Special-Ed. Compliance in Baltimore Schools,” Education Week , (August 3): 19 .
58.
Shanker A.
1994 . “There Is No Free Lunch,” Education Week , (June 22): 43 .
59.
Sizer T.
1992 . “Edison Project Will Deserve Gratitude for Putting Focus on Public Education,” Sun Sentinel (FL), (August 12): 6F .
60.
Stewart J. B.
1994 . “Grand Illusion,” The New Yorker , (October 31): 64 –82 .
61.
Stover D.
1994 . “More Districts Explore ‘Privatizing’ Schools,” School Board News , (February 1): 1 , 4 .
62.1994 . “Take My Schools Please,” OI A Info Memo , Organization of Institutional Affiliates, American Educational Research Association , (January): 10 –14 .
63.1994 . “Three More School Boards Agree to Establish Edison Schools,” School Board News , (July 5): 5 .
64.
Tyack D.
1982 . Managers of Virtue: Public School Leadership in America. New York : Basic Books.
65.
Walsh M.
1994 . “Questions about Finances Put Edison Project at Crossroads,” Education Week , (August 3): 18 –19 .
66.1994 . “Whittle's Collapse Means Uncertainty for Edison,” School Board News , (November 8): 1 , 8 .