This study made use of Hersey and Blanchard's concept of situational leadership to investigate the relationship between teacher job satisfaction and the leadership behaviors of “telling,” “selling,” “participating,” and “delegating.” Questionnaires were mailed to a sample of 520 teachers, stratified by gender and school type. Three hundred and thirty-nine usable responses were returned (65 percent) and analyzed by correlation and analysis of variance procedures.
About 42 percent of the respondents were either “very dissatisfied” or “dissatisfied.” Teachers were least satisfied with the financial aspects of teaching and most satisfied with their co-workers. There were no differences in satisfaction by teacher gender, principal gender, experience, or school type.
Additionally, job satisfaction was not significantly related to leadership style. Suggestions for further research speak to the need to take into account the “consideration” aspect of leadership style and to measure job satisfaction in specific task areas such as curriculum development, faculty evaluation, staff development, and instructional organization.
Policy implications of the findings were discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BlaseJ. J.1984a. “A Data-Based Model of How Teachers Cope with Stress,”Journal of Educational Administration, 22(2): 173–191; 1984b. “School Principals and Teacher Stress: A Qualitative Analysis,” National Forum of Educational Administration and Supervision, 1(1): 35–43; 1984c. “Teacher Coping and School Principal Behaviors,” Contemporary Education, 56(1): 21–25.
2.
BlaseJ., DedrickC., and StratheM.1986. “Leadership Behavior of School Principals in Relation to Teacher Stress, Satisfaction, and Performance,”Journal of Humanistic Education and Development, 24(4): 159–171.
3.
BlochA. M.1978. “Combat Neurosis in Inner-City Schools,”American Journal of Psychiatry, 135(1): 1189–1192.
4.
BordieriJ. E., ReagleD. Y., and CokerC. C.1988. “Job Satisfaction and Leadership Style of Rehabilitation Facility Personnel,”Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin, 32(2): 149–160.
5.
BrodskyC. M.1977. “Long Term Work Stress in Teachers and Prison Guards,”Journal of Occupational Medicine, 19(2): 133–138.
6.
CameronG. J.1985. “The Effects of Clinical and Traditional Supervision Methods on the Satisfaction Levels of Higher and Lower-Order Teacher Needs,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 45(8): 2321A.
7.
Carnegie Forum on Education and the Economy.1986. A Nation Prepared: Teachers for the 21st Century, Hyattsville, MD.
8.
ChapmanP.1983. “The Relationship between the Teacher's Perception of the Principal's Leadership Behavior and the Teacher's Perceived Level of Occupational Stress,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 44(4): 924A.
9.
ChungK.1970. “Teacher Centered Management Style of Public School Principals and Job Satisfaction of Teachers,” paper presented at The Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Minneapolis, April.
10.
CichonD. J., and KoffR. H.1980. “Stress and Teaching,”NASSP Bulletin, 64(434): 25–29.
11.
CoatesJ. T., and ThorensenC. E.1976. “Teacher Anxiety: A Review with Recommendations,”Review of Educational Research, 46(21): 159–184.
12.
CookK. E.1983. “The Relationship between Teacher Perceptions of Supervisory Behavioral Style and Perceived Teacher Burnout,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 44(4): 925A.
13.
GreenblattR. B.1983. “School Management Systems and Teacher Effectiveness,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 44(2): 340A.
14.
HallB. W., and DelosC.1987. “Teachers at Risk: A Profile of the Teacher Predisposed to Quit,”Florida Journal of Educational Research, 29(1): 55–72.
15.
HalpinA. W.1966. Theory and Research in Administration, New York: MacMillan.
16.
HanesR. C.1962. “A Study of Leadership Behavior and Its Effects upon the Morale and Attitudes of Teachers in Selected Secondary Schools,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 23(18): 3702A.
17.
HellerH. W., and ClayR. J.1991. “Predictors of Teaching Effectiveness: The Efficacy of Admission, Retention, and Certification Standards to Predict the Teaching Success of Graduates from a Teacher Education Program.” Manuscript presented for publication.
18.
HerseyP., and BlanchardK. H.1977. Management of Organizational Behavior: Utilizing Human Resources, 3rd edition, Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
19.
HerseyP., and BlanchardK. H.1983. Situational Leadership Resource Guide, San Diego: University Associates, Inc.
20.
HerseyP., and BlanchardK. H.1988. Management of Organization Behavior: Utilizing Human Resources, 5th edition, Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall.
21.
KaganD. M.1989. “Inquiry Mode, Occupational Stress, and Preferred Leadership Style among American Elementary School Teachers,”The Journal of Social Psychology, 129(3): 297–305.
22.
KnoopR.1981. “The Leadership Styles of Principals and Teachers’ Job Satisfaction, Satisfaction with Supervision and Participation in Decision Making,” paper presented at The Meeting of the Canadian Association for the Study of Educational Administration, Halifax, Nova Scotia. (Eric Document Reproduction Service No. ED 218 754)
23.
LiebermanA.1969. “The Effects of Principal Leadership on Teacher Morale and Style in the Classroom,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 30(10): 4727A.
24.
LittM. D., and TurkD. C.1986. “Sources of Stress and Dissatisfaction in Experienced High School Teachers,”The Journal of Educational Research, 78(3): 178–185.
MadduxC. D., HendersonD., and DarbyC.1982. “A Survey of Texas Public School Teachers.” Unpublished paper. (ERIC Documentation Service No. ED 212 559)
27.
MagillW. R.1976. “Organizational Stress and Charismatic, Rational-Legal, and Traditional Leadership among School Principals,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 37(11): 6877A.
28.
MazurP. J., and LynchM. D.1989. “Differential Impact of Administrative, Organizational, and Personality Factors on Teacher Burnout,”Teaching and Teacher Education, 5(4): 337–353.
29.
MetzP. K.1980. “An Exploratory Study of Professional Burnout and Renewal among Educators,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 40(8): 4308A–4309A.
30.
MoraccoJ., DanfordD., and D'ArienzoR. V.1982. “The Factorial Validity of the Teacher Occupational Stress Factor Questionnaire,”Educational and Psychological Measurement, 42(1): 275–283.
31.
NeedleR. H., GriffinT., and SvedsenR.1981. “Occupational Stress: Coping and Health Problems of Teachers,”The Journal of School Health, 51(3): 175–181.
32.
NgugiN. N. N.1984. “The Relationship between Mississippi Public Senior High School Principals’ Perceptions of Their Actual Supervisory Behaviors and Teachers’ Perceptions of Actual and Preferred Principals Supervisory Behaviors,” unpublished doctoral dissertation, Mississippi State University: Oxford.
33.
Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services.1987. “An Annotated Bibliography on Attrition. Information on Personnel Demand and Supply,”Reston, VA: National Clearinghouse for Professions in Special Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 307 735)
34.
PletcherP.1987. “An Annotated Bibliography of Current Literature Dealing with Teacher Stress and Burnout.” (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 289 843)
35.
RichardsonG., and SistrunkW. E.1988. “The Relationship between Secondary Teachers’ Perceived Levels of Burnout and Their Perceptions of Their Principals’ Supervisory Behaviors,” paper presented at The Meeting of the Mid-South Educational Research Association, Louisville, KY. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED 302 925)
36.
RichardsonG., and SistrunkW. E.1989 (update). “The Relationship between Secondary Teachers’ Perceived Levels of Burnout and their Perceptions of their Principals’ Supervisory Behaviors,” paper presented at The Meeting of the Mid-South Educational Research Association, Little Rock, AR. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED 312 763)
37.
RichardsonG., and SistrunkW. E.1990. “Supervision, Burnout, and Evaluation of Instruction,” paper presented at The Meeting of the Mid-South Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED 326 527)
38.
RobertsK. E.1983. “An Analysis of the Relationship of Principals’ Leadership Style to Teacher Stress and Job Related Outcome,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 44(7): 2002A.
39.
SpeedN. E.1979. Decision Involvement and Job Satisfaction in Middle and Junior High Schools that Individualize Instruction (Tech. Rep. No. 561). Madison: Wisconsin Research and Development Center for Individualizing Schooling.
40.
TaylorD. M.1986. “Perceptions of Teachers in Small, Isolated Alaskan Schools Regarding Supervision Received Compared to Supervision Preferred.” Unpublished Doctoral Dissertation, University of Montana. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. 325 384)
41.
ThierbachG. L.1980. “Decision Involvement and Job Satisfaction in Middle and Junior High Schools,”Dissertation Abstracts International, 41(9): 3827A.
42.
TishlerA. G., and ErnestB.1989. “Career Dissatisfaction among Alabama Teachers: A Follow-Up,” paper presented at The Annual Meeting of the Mid-South Educational Research Association, Little Rock, AR. (ERIC Reproduction Service No. ED 314 407)
43.
WebbB.1990. “Situational Leadership: The Key is Knowing When to Do What,”Executive Educator, 12(1): 29–30.
