Over the years, occupations and workplaces have become more gender neutral as female participation in the workforce has risen. However, few studies have reported how the gender composition of the workplace affects occupational stress.
Objective
This study aims to evaluate the relationship between gender composition and occupational stress among Japanese public servants.
Methods
This cross-sectional study, conducted in 2019, included 18,486 public servants from City A, Japan, using data from the Brief Job Stress Questionnaire (BJSQ). After exclusions, 16,444 participants were analyzed based on their BJSQ scores. Workplaces were categorized according to their gender compositions: female- or male-dominated, and gender-neutral. Multivariable logistic regression was used to estimate the odds ratios (OR) for the effect of gender composition on mental health, after adjusting for demographic and occupational factors.
Results
Among females, high job stressors were associated with both female- and male-dominated workplaces, and high stress responses were associated with male-dominated workplaces. Among males, high job stressors and high stress responses were associated with both female- and male-dominated workplaces.
Conclusions
Female-dominated workplaces were associated with high occupational stress. In contrast, male-dominated workplaces were associated with low occupational stress. Understanding the differences in occupational stress due to gender composition may play an important role in creating a more equitable and effective work environment.
Campos-GarcíaIÁngel Zúñiga-VicenteJ. The gender diversity–performance linkage at the board of directors and the workforce levels: testing two competing curvilinear models. Gend Manag2022 Oct 20; 38: 373–393.
2.
FernandoGDJainSSTripathyA. This cloud has a silver lining: gender diversity, managerial ability, and firm performance. J Bus Res2020 Sep 1; 117: 484–496.
LukanJBolligerLPauwelsNS, et al.Work environment risk factors causing day-to-day stress in occupational settings: a systematic review. BMC Public Health2022 Feb 5; 22: 240.
van der MolenHFNieuwenhuijsenKFrings-DresenMHW,et al.Work-related psychosocial risk factors for stress-related mental disorders: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open2020 Jul 5; 10: e034849.
8.
ElwérSJohanssonKHammarströmA. Workplace gender composition and psychological distress: the importance of the psychosocial work environment. BMC Public Health2014 Mar; 14: 241.
9.
KronbergAKGerlachAGanglM. Promoting men and women to management: putting the glass escalator paradox in the establishment context. Soc Sci Res2024 May 1; 120: 103003.
10.
MarshallALHalvorsenAJKearnsL, et al.Disparities in salary and work-life integration in internal medicine program directors are associated with gender and partner employment Status. Am J Med2021 Feb; 134: 285–291.e1.
11.
KanterRM. Men and women of the corporation. New York: Basic Books, 1977.
12.
RosanderMHetlandJEinarsenSV. Workplace bullying and mental health problems in balanced and gender-dominated workplaces. Work Stress2023 Jul 3; 37: 325–344.
13.
JusterRPDe TorreMBKerrP, et al.Sex differences and gender diversity in stress responses and allostatic load among workers and LGBT people. Curr Psychiatry Rep2019 Nov; 21: 110.
14.
RepchuckRYoungM. The combined impact of workplace and occupational gender composition on Workers’ mental health and employment consequences. Sociol Q2023; 64: 1–26.
15.
GonäsLWikmanAVaezM, et al.Gender segregation of occupations and sustainable employment: a prospective population-based cohort study. Scand J Public Health2019 May; 47: 348–356.
16.
BryngelsonABacchus HertzmanJFritzellJ. The relationship between gender segregation in the workplace and long-term sickness absence in Sweden. Scand J Public Health2011 Aug; 39: 618–626.
17.
JonssonRLidwallUHolmgrenK. Does unbalanced gender composition in the workplace influence the association between psychosocial working conditions and sickness absence?Work Read Mass2013 Jan; 46: 59–66.
18.
KawakamiNTsutsumiA. The Stress Check Program: a new national policy for monitoring and screening psychosocial stress in the workplace in Japan. J Occup Health2016; 58: 1–6.
19.
HurrellJJMcLaneyMA. Exposure to job stress: a new psychometric instrument. Scand J Work Environ Health1988; 14: 27–28.
20.
KarasekRBrissonCKawakamiN, et al.The Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ): an instrument for internationally comparative assessments of psychosocial job characteristics. J Occup Health Psychol1998 Oct; 3: 322–355.
21.
WatanabeKImamuraKEguchiH, et al.Usage of the Brief Job Stress Questionnaire: a systematic review of a comprehensive job stress questionnaire in Japan from 2003 to 2021. Int J Environ Res Public Health2023 Jan; 20: 1814.
22.
LidwallU. Gender composition in occupations and branches and medically certified sick leave: a prospective population study. Int Arch Occup Environ Health2021; 94: 1659–1670.
23.
HaukenesIHammarströmA. Workplace gender composition and sickness absence: a register-based study from Sweden. Scand J Public Health2023 Jun; 52: 14034948231176108.
24.
CharlottaM. Flexible time–but is the time owned? Family friendly and family unfriendly work arrangements, occupational gender composition and wages: a test of the mother-friendly job hypothesis in Sweden. Community Work Fam2021; 24: 291–314.
25.
WaldenströmKHärenstamA. Does the job demand-control model correspond to externally assessed demands and control for both women and men?Scand J Public Health2008; 36: 242–249.
26.
WatanabeY. The structure of multiple male role models: four domains characterizing traditional and new concepts. Jpn Psychol Rev2017; 60: 117–139. (in Japanese).
27.
CheungHGoldbergCBKonradAM, et al.A meta-analytic review of gender composition influencing employees’ work outcomes: implications for human resource development. Hum Resour Dev Int2020; 23: 491–518.
28.
AckerJ. Hierarchies, jobs, bodies: a theory of gendered organizations. Gend Soc1990; 4: 139–158.
AungNTewogbolaP. The impact of emotional labor on the health in the workplace: a narrative review of literature from 2013–2018. AIMS Public Health2019; 6: 268–275.
32.
NybergAMagnusson HansonLLLeineweberC, et al.Occupational gender composition and mild to severe depression in a Swedish cohort: the impact of psychosocial work factors. Scand J Public Health2018 May; 46: 425–432.
33.
ElwérSHarrysonLBolinM,et al.Patterns of gender equality at workplaces and psychological distress. PloS One2013; 8: e53246.
34.
MilnerAKingTLaMontagneAD, et al.Men’s work, women’s work, and mental health: a longitudinal investigation of the relationship between the gender composition of occupations and mental health. Soc Sci Med2018 May; 204: 16–22.
35.
ChenJLinTF. Gender composition and team performance: evidence from a randomized experiment. Appl Econ Lett2024 Mar; 31: 349–353.
36.
SigurðardóttirSAspelundTGuðmundsdóttirDG, et al.Mental health and sociodemographic characteristics among Icelanders: data from a cross-sectional study in Iceland. BMC Psychiatry2023 Jan 12; 23: 30.
37.
NybergALeineweberCMagnusson HansonL. Gender differences in psychosocial work factors, work-personal life interface, and well-being among Swedish managers and non-managers. Int Arch Occup Environ Health2015 Nov; 88: 1149–1164.
38.
BourgeaultIParkJKohenD, et al.A gendered analysis of work, stress, and mental health among professional and non-professional workers. Prof2021 Nov; 11: e4029.
