Background: Educators are often viewed as emotional laborers who must be attuned to the emotional challenges of their profession and adept at managing their feelings, while a few studies that pay attention on the emotional labor strategies for special education teachers in China.
Objective: The study aimed to understand the current situation of emotional labor strategies of special education teachers in China, to examine the relationship between different emotional labor strategies and job burnout, as well as the moderating effect of psychological capital.
Methods: We applied Emotional Labor strategies, Job-burnout, and Psychological Capital to investigate 349 special education teachers teaching students with developmental disabilities. Hierarchical regression analysis was conducted to explore the moderating role of psychological capital in the relationship between special education teachers’ emotional labor strategies and job burnout.
Results: We found the three emotional labor strategies applied by special education teachers were natural acting, deep acting and surface acting from high to low. The emotional labor strategies of special education teachers were negatively correlated with their job burnout. Besides, psychological capital played a moderating role in the relationship of teachers’ deep acting and job burnout, and the association of teachers’ nature acting and job burnout.
Conclusions: Special education teachers would use emotional labor strategies to deal with complex emotional events in their work, and it's related to their burnout. Strengthening psychological capital training for special education teachers is an important strategy to reducing their job-burnout as well.
HopmanJClarkT. Finding a way: what crisis reveals about Teachers’ emotional wellbeing and its importance for education. Educ Sci2023; 13: 1141.
2.
TianGYuH. Segmentation, stratification and classification of teachers’ emotional labor strategies. Glob Educ Perspect2021; 50: 93–102.
3.
NwokoJCEmetoTIAduliEOM,et al.A systematic review of the factors that influence Teachers’ occupational wellbeing. Int J Environ Res Public Health2023; 20: 6070.
4.
HargreavesA. Emotional geographies of teaching. Teach Coll Rec2001; 103: 1056–1080.
5.
JeonHDiamondLMcCartneyC,et al.Early childhood special education teachers’ job burnout and psychological stress. Early Educ Dev2022; 33: 1364–1382.
6.
KinmanGWraySStrangeC. Emotional labour, burnout and job satisfaction in UK teachers: the role of workplace social support. Educ Psychol2011; 31: 843.
7.
MorrisJAFeldmanDC. The dimensions, antecedents, and consequences of emotional labor. Acad Manag Rev1996; 21: 986.
8.
LyndonSRawatPSPawarD. Is emotional labour a positive experience for teachers? A qualitative study. Int J Educ Manag2021; 35: 532–548.
9.
YinHLeeJCKZhangZ,et al.Exploring the relationship among teachers’ emotional intelligence, emotional labor strategies and teaching satisfaction. Teach Educ2013; 35: 137–145.
10.
SilbaughMWBarkerDBArghodeV. Emotional labor, emotional intelligence, and burnout among school principals: testing a mediational model. Leadersh and Policy Sch2023; 22: 73–86.
11.
GhyasiMGurbuzN. Emotional labor and emotional capital: an interpretive phenomenological analysis of teachers of English. PLoS One2023; 18: 1–21.
12.
WangHZhangS. Meta-analysis of the relationship between emotional labor strategy and job satisfaction. Prog Psychol Sci2018; 26: 599–613.
13.
SchutzPALeeM. Teacher emotion, emotional labor and teacher identity. Utr Stud Lang Commun2014; 27: 169–186.
14.
WalshGYangZDahlingJ, et al.Effects of service employees’ negative personality traits on emotional labour and job satisfaction: evidence from two countries. Manage Decis2020; 58: 1035–1052.
15.
AshforthBEHumphreyRH. Emotional labour in service roles: the influence of identity. Acad Manage Rev1993; 18: 88–115.
16.
HuYMiaoPCaoX. The relationship between emotional labor strategies, mental health and job satisfaction among primary teachers. J Yuzhang Normal Univ2015; 1: 111–113.
17.
TianXZhouHChenD. A survey on emotional labor of special education teachers. Chinese J Spec Educ2009; 8: 50–56.
18.
XiongZ. The effect of emotional labor on job satisfaction of special education teachers. Shanghai: East China Normal University, 2019.
19.
ZhengCGuoL. A meta-analysis of the relationship between teacher’s emotional intelligence and burnout—–based on researches in the 21st century. Teach Educ Res2018; 30: 114–121.
20.
ReddyLA. School-wide educator evaluation for improving school capacity and student achievement in high-poverty schools: year 1 of the school system improvement project. J Educ Psychol Consult2015; 25: 90–108.
21.
QiuJHeWWangF,et al.Psychological factors influencing job burnout of special education teachers: a comparative study based on strength analysis. Chinese J Spec Educ2022; 5: 88–96.
22.
FuWTangWXueE, et al.The mediation effect of self-esteem on job-burnout and self-efficacy of special education teachers in western China. Int J Dev Disabi2021; 67: 273–282.
23.
ZhaoYHuangZ. On the strategies for special education school teachers’ job burnout from the perspective of positive psychological characters. Chinese J Spec Educ2017; 5: 15–18.
24.
LiGTsangKK. Does accountability aggravate the risk of teacher burnout?Evidence from the Chinese Educ System. Beha Sci2023; 13: 772.
25.
YangL. A study on the relationship between emotional labor, occupational identity and job burnout of primary and secondary school teachers. Nanjing: Nanjing Normal University, 2014.
26.
LiuDJiaoRWangH,et al.The relationship between preschool teachers’ emotional labor strategies and burnout: an application of latent profile analysis. Psychol Dev Educ2018; 34: 742–749.
27.
XuYLiuQ. Mediate role of emotion work strategies between teaching efficacy and teachers’ job burnout. J Hubei Normal Univ (Nat Sci)2011; 31: 30–34.
28.
XieSWuDLiH. The relationship between Chinese teachers’ emotional labor, teaching efficacy, and young children’s social-emotional development and learning. Sustain2022; 14: 2205.
29.
TazeemASMohammadNKZolinR,et al.Psychological empowerment and employee attitudinal outcomes: the pivotal role of psychological capital. Manag Res Review2019; 42: 797–817.
30.
KeJSunJLiY. Psychological capital: Chinese indigenous scale’s development and its validity comparison with the western scale. Acta Psychol Sin2009; 41: 875–888.
31.
QasimMIrshadMMajeedM,et al.Examining impact of islamic work ethic on task performance: mediating effect of psychological capital and a moderating role of ethical leadership: JBE. J Bus Ethics2022; 180: 283–295.
32.
XiaF. Research on the influence of psychological capital on teachers’ job burnout—-based on a survey of 528 on-the-job teachers. Jiangxi Soc Sci2017; 37: 250–256.
33.
WangMZhangMC. On the relationship between special education teacher’s psychological capital and job burnout. Chinese J Spec Educ2015; 9: 49–57.
34.
DemeroutiENachreinerFBakkerAB,et al.The job demands-resources model of burnout. J Appl Psychol2001; 86: 499–512.
35.
WangJPanW. Reflection on the development of special education teachers’ professional psychological quality from the perspective of psychological capital. J Mod Spec Educ2016; 16: 45–49.
36.
MaoJPMoTY. Relationship among psychological capital, emotional labor strategies and job burnout of primary and secondary school teachers. Teacher Educ Res2014; 26: 22–28+35.
37.
HeC. Research on the relationship between emotional labor strategy, psychological capital and job burnout of junior high school teachers. Doctor dissertation. Changsha: Hunan Normal University. 2015.
38.
YinW. Psychological capital moderates the effect of emotional labor strategies on job burnout in college teachers. Soc Beha Pers2023; 51: 1–8.
LiRFuW. Research on the realistic dilemma, cognitive basis and practical strategy of inclusive education: from the perspective of otherness theory. J Educ2023; 19: 132–142.
41.
YinH. The effect of teachers’ emotional labour on teaching satisfaction: moderation of emotional intelligence. Teach Teach2015; 21: 789–810.
42.
Tung-JuWLian-YiWJia-YingG,et al.Social support and well-being of Chinese special education teachers—an emotional labor perspective. Int J Environ Res Public Health2020; 17: 6884.
43.
FuWPanQZhangC,et al.Influencing factors of Chinese special education teacher turnover intention: understanding the roles of subject well-being, social support, and work engagement. Int J Dev Disabil2022; 68: 342–353.
44.
KerrMMBrownEL. Preventing school failure for teachers, revisited: special educators explore their emotional labor. Prevent School Fail2016; 60: 143.
DiefendorffJMCroyleMHGosserandRH. The dimensionality and antecedents of emotional labor strategies. J Vocat Behav2005; 66: 339–357.
47.
ZhouH. The effect of emotional labor strategies on turnover intention of primary school special education teachers: the mediating role of emotional burnout. J Hangzhou Normal Univ Nat Sci Ed)2021; 6: 584–590.
48.
McDonaldRPHoMR. Principles and practice in reporting structural equation analyses. Psychol Meth2002; 7: 64–82.
49.
NäringGBriëtMBrouwersA. Beyond demand-control: emotional labour and symptoms of burnouts in teachers. Work Stress2006; 20: 303e315.
50.
ChenYWeiYZhangA, et al.The relationship between perceived organizational support and job burnout of special education teachers: the mediating role of professional mission and the moderating role of professional title. J Chin Spec Educ2023; 30: 90–96.
51.
WangSHeQSunY, et al.Research on the current situation and influencing factors of emotional labor of special education teachers. Educ Observ2022; 11: 120–124.
52.
KerrMMBrownEL. Preventing school failure for teachers, revisited: special educators explore their emotional labor. Prevent School Fail: Altern Educ Child Youth2016; 60: 143–151.
53.
WuMMaoJJingQ. Study on the influence of emotional intelligence on turnover intention of special education teachers: based on the chain mediating effect of emotional labor and emotional exhaustion. Chinese J Spec Educ2023; 8: 76–84.
54.
ValentiMBrownELHornerCG, et al.Pathways to working alliances: special educators’ emotional labor and relationships with students with emotional and behavioral disorders. Teach Coll Rec2019; 121: 1–24.
55.
YangYGeX. Needs, problems and suggestions for special education teacher training in northern guangdong. J Mod Spec Educ2016; 4: 48–52.
56.
KariouAKoutsimaniPMontgomeryA,et al.Emotional labor and burnout among teachers: a systematic review. Int J Environ Res Pub Health2021; 18: 12760.
57.
YinHHuangSChenG. The relationships between teachers’ emotional labor and their burnout and satisfaction: a meta-analytic review. Educ Res Rev2019; 11: 100283.
58.
QiYWuXHuB. Classification of teachers’ job requirements – based on the impact of job burnout and job engagement. Educ Res2016; 37: 119–126.
59.
NäringGVlerickPVan de VenB. Emotion work and emotional exhaustion in teachers: the job and individual perspective. Educ Stud2012; 38: 63–72.
60.
KayaÇAltınkurtY. Role of psychological and structural empowerment in the relationship between teachers’ psychological capital and their levels of burnout. Egit Bilim2018; 43: 63–78.
61.
BrotheridgeCMGrandeyAA. Emotional labor and burnout: comparing two perspectives of “people work”. J Vocat Behav2002; 60: 17–39.
62.
CareySSuttonA. Early childhood teachers’ emotional labour: the role of job and personal resources in protecting well-being. Teach Teach Educ2024: 148: 1–13.
63.
WangJRenH. A review of teachers’ psychological capital research. Educ Guide2018; 36: 22–27.
