Severe icing on the space shuttle Challenger's launch pad should have halted the launch on the morning of January 28, 1986. One Rockwell International manager told his subordinates to be sure NASA knew that Rockwell thought a launch was not safe. When the Rockwell subordinates spoke directly to NASA managers, however, they used politeness strategies like those enumerated by Penelope Brown and Stephen Levinson to blur the directness of the Rockwell manager's message. The NASA managers interpreted the politeness of the Rockwell subordinates as meaning it was safe to launch. The Rockwell subordinates did not mean it that way, but the Challenger was launched.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anson, Chris
, and L. Lee Forsberg. “Moving Beyond the Academic Community.”Written Communication7 (1990): 200-231.
2.
Argyris, Chris
. “Skilled Incompetence.”Harvard Business Review64.5 (1986): 74-79.
3.
Arnold, Vanessa Dean
, and John C. Malley. “Communication: The Missing Link in the Challenger Disaster.”Bulletin of the Association for Business Communication51.4 (1988): 12-14.
4.
Barkman, Patricia R.et al.“Interpersonal Skills: An Essential Component in the Editing Class.”Teaching Technical Editing. Ed. Carolyn Rude. Lubbock, TX: Association of Teachers of Technical Writing, 1985. 109-128.
5.
Bethke, Frederick J.“Advice to Novice Technical Writers: A Veteran Speaks.”The Technical Writing Teacher11 (1984): 157-159.
6.
Broadhead, Glenn J
, and Richard C. Freed. The Variables of Composition: Process and Product in a Business Setting. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1986.
7.
Brown, Penelope
, and Stephen C. Levinson. Politeness: Some Universals in Language Usage. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987.
8.
Cherry, Roger D.“Politeness in Written Persuasion.”Journal of Pragmatics12 (1988): 63-81.
9.
Doheny-Farina, Stephen
. “A Case Study Approach Using Conflict among Collaborators.”The Technical Writing Teacher15 (1988): 73-77.
10.
Fisher, James
. “Politicians, NASA Rushed Countdown toward Operational Shuttle.”Orlando Sentinel 27 Apr. 1986: A-15.
11.
Fisher, James
, and Tom Scherberger. “ `Safety First' Lost in Maze of NASA Management Ills.”Orlando Sentinel 8 May 1986: A-1+.
12.
Fitzgerald, A. Ernest
. The Pentagonists: An Insider's View of Waste, Mismanagement, and Fraud in Defense Spending. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1989.
Glazer, Myron Peretz
, and Penina Migdal Glazer. The Whistleblowers: Exposing Corruption in Government and Industry. New York: Basic Books, 1989.
15.
Gouran, Dennis S.
, Randy Y. Hirokawa, and Amy E. Martz. “A Critical Analysis of Factors Related to Decisional Processes Involved in the Challenger Disaster.”Central States Speech Journal37.3 (1986): 119-135.
16.
Guinn, Dorothy M.“Sleuthing, Diplomacy, Scheduling, and Budgeting for Technical Writing.”The Technical Writing Teacher13 (1986): 13-17.
17.
Hagge, John
, and Charles Kostelnick. “Linguistic Politeness in Professional Prose.”Written Communication6 (1989): 312-339.
18.
Harrison, Teresa
. “Framework for the Study of Writing in Organizational Contexts.”Written Communication4 (1987): 3-23.
19.
Jackall, Robert
. Moral Mazes: The World of Corporate Managers. New York: Oxford University Press, 1988.
20.
Kantor, Rosabeth Moss
. “Power Failure in Management Circuits.”Harvard Business Review57.4 (1979): 65-75.
21.
Leusner, Jim
, and Dan Tracy. “ `A Bit of Russian Roulette': Radio Talk on Jan. 28 Was No Go.”Orlando Sentinel 16 May 1986: A-1+.
22.
Lewis, Richard S.Challenger: The Final Voyage. New York: Columbia University Press, 1988.
23.
Limaye, Mohan R.
, and Roger D. Cherry. “Pragmatics, `Situated' Language, and Business Communication.”JBTC1.1 (1987): 68-88.
24.
Lipson, Carol
. “A Social View of Technical Writing.”JBTC2.1 (1988): 7-20.
25.
McConnell, Malcolm
. Challenger: A Major Malfunction. Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1987.
26.
Moore, Patrick
. “Using Case Studies to Teach Courtesy Strategies.”The Technical Writing Teacher17 (1990): 8-25.
27.
Nader, Ralph
, Peter J. Petkas, and Kate Blackwell, eds. Whistle Blowing: The Report of the Conference on Professional Responsibility. Washington, 30 Jan. 1971. New York: Grossman, 1972.
28.
Odell, Lee
, and Dixie Goswami. Writing in Nonacademic Settings. New York: Guilford, 1985.
29.
Pace, Roger C.“Technical Communication, Group Differentiation, and the Decision to Launch the Space Shuttle Challenger.”Journal of Technical Writing and Communication18.3 (1988): 207-220.
30.
Reidy, Chris
. “Panel Backs Fletcher for Top Job at NASA.”Orlando Sentinel 1 May 1986: A-8.
31.
Riley, Kathryn
. “Conversational Implicature and Unstated Meaning in Professional Communication.”The Technical Writing Teacher15 (1988): 94-104.
32.
Riley, Kathryn
. “Speech Act Theory and Degrees of Directness in Professional Writing.”The Technical Writing Teacher15 (1988): 1-29.
33.
Rowland, Robert C.“The Relationship between the Public and the Technical Spheres of Argument: A Case Study of the Challenger Seven Disaster.”Central States Speech Journal37.3 (1986): 136-146.
34.
Seeger, Matthew W.“The Challenger Tragedy and Search for Legitimacy.”Central States Speech Journal37.3 (1986): 147-157.
35.
Smart, Tim
. “Roots of Disaster Traceable to 70's.”Orlando Sentinel 27 Apr. 1986: A1+.
36.
Tracy, Dan
, and Jim Leusner. “Shuttle Workers Say They Are Afraid to Talk about Challenger.”Orlando Sentinel 10 Feb. 1986: A-4.
37.
Trento, Joseph
. Prescription for Disaster. New York: Crown, 1987.
38.
United States. Congress. House of Representatives Committee on Science and Technology
. Hearings.99th Cong., 2nd sess. 2 vols. Washington: GPO, 1986.
39.
United States. Congress. House of Representatives Committee on Science and Technology
. Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident. Report of the Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident. Vol. 1. Washington: The Commission, 1986. 5 vols.
40.
Wartzman, Rick
. “Chain Reaction: Rockwell Bomb Plant Is Repeatedly Accused of Poor Safety Record.”The Wall Street Journal 30 Aug. 1989: A-1, A-12.
41.
Wartzman, Rick
. “New Rocky Flats Nuclear Probe Finds Problems, Faults Rockwell and the U.S.”The Wall Street Journal 9 Oct. 1989: B-3.
42.
Winsor, Dorothy A.“Communication Failures Contributing to the Challenger Accident: An Example for Technical Communicators.”IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication31.3 (1988): 101-107.
