Harm Reduction for Women in Treatment for Alcohol Use Problems: Exploring the Impact of Dominant Addiction Discourse

Abstract

The objectives of this study were to profile the landscape of women’s alcohol use programs in Canada. We explored service users’ and providers’ beliefs about alcohol use problems and how this affected treatment choices for alcohol use problems. Data were collected through standardized measures alongside in-depth semi-structured narrative interviews in six women’s alcohol treatment sites in Canada. Findings demonstrated that service users and service providers often supported an abstinence choice and were ambivalent about the viability of controlled or managed use in both abstinence- and harm reduction–based programs. Findings showed that women service users in this study had significant rates of trauma and depression which were associated with their alcohol use; the majority still adopted dominant alcohol addiction discourse which emphasizes the need for abstinence. We offer a number of recommendations to improve the viability of harm reduction for alcohol use in women’s treatment programs.

Keywords

gender feminism women’s health policy policy analysis health users’ experiences health care alcohol alcoholism addiction community-based programs community and public health qualitative methods Canada

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aalto

Saksanen

Laine

Forsström

Raikaa

Kiviluoto

Seppä

Sillanaukee

(2000). Brief intervention for female heavy drinkers in routine general practice: A 3-year randomized, controlled study. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 24(11), 1680–1686.

Adamson

S. J.

Heather

Morton

et al. (2010). Initial preference for drinking goal in the treatment of alcohol problems: II. Treatment outcomes. Alcohol and Alcoholism, 45, 136–142. https://doi.org/10.1093/alcalc/agq005

Ambrogne

J. A.

(2002). Reduced-risk drinking as a treatment goal: What clinicians need to know. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 22, 45–53.

American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). American Psychiatric Publishing.

Annis

H. M.

Graham

J. M.

Davis

C. S.

(1987). Inventory of Drinking Situations (IDS) user’s guide. Addiction Research Foundation.

Braun

Clarke

(2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa

Braun

Clarke

(2013). Successful qualitative research. Sage.

Brochu

(1990). Abstinence versus nonabstinence: The objectives of alcoholism rehabilitation programs in Quebec. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 22, 15–21. https://doi.org/10.1080/02791072.1990.10472193

Brown

(2007). Dethroning the suppressed voice: Unpacking experience as story. In Brown

Augusta-Scott

(Eds.), Narrative therapy: Making meaning, making lives (pp. 177–196). Sage.

10.

Brown

(2020). Critical clinical social work: Theoretical and practical considerations. In Brown McDonald (Eds.), Critical clinical social work: Counterstorying for social justice (pp.16–58). Canadian Scholars’ Press.

11.

Brown

Johnstone

Ross

(2020). Repositioning social work practice in mental health and health equity in Nova Scotia [Report]. Nova Scotia College of Social Workers.

12.

Brown

Stewart

S. H.

(2007). Making harm reduction work: Exploring women’s treatment for alcohol use problems. In Poole

Greaves

(Eds.), Highs and lows: Canadian perspectives on women and substance use (pp. 431–440). Centre for Addiction and Mental Health and the British Columbia Centre of Excellence for Women’s Health.

13.

Brown

Stewart

S. H.

Larsen

(2005). Experiences of harm reduction among women with alcohol use problems. Canadian Journal of Community Mental Health, 24(1), 95–113.

14.

Brown

Strega

(2015). Research as resistance: Revisiting critical, Indigenous, and anti-oppressive approaches (2nd ed.). Canadian Scholars’ Press.

15.

Burstow

(1992). Radical feminist therapy: Working in the context of violence. Sage.

16.

Canadian Women’s Health Network. (2008). Women, mental health and mental: Illness and addiction in Canada: An overview. Ad Hoc Working Group on Women, Mental Health, Mental Illness and Addictions.

17.

Centre for Addiction and Mental Health. (2013). Making the case: Tools for supporting local alcohol policy in Ontario. CAMH Health Promotion Resource Centre and Public Health Ontario. https://www.publichealthontario.ca/-/media/documents/M/2013/making-the-case-alcohol-policy.pdf?la=en

18.

Charmaz

(2006). Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis. Sage.

19.

Clandinin

D. J.

Connelly

M. F.

(2000). Narrative inquiry: Experience and story in qualitative research. Jossey-Bass.

20.

Collin

(2006). Substance abuse and public policies in Canada: I. Canada’s federal drug strategy (PRB 06-15E). Parliamentary Information and Research Service, Library of Parliament, Ottawa. https://lop.parl.ca/staticfiles/PublicWebsite/Home/ResearchPublications/LegislativeSummaries/PDF/40-2/c15-e.pdf

21.

Davis

I. K.

Rosenberg

(2013). Acceptance of non-abstinence goals by addiction professionals in the United States. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 27(4), 1102–1109. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0030563

22.

DeBeck

Wood

Montaner

Kerr

(2009). Canada’s new federal “national anti-drug strategy”: An informed audit of reported funding allocation. International Journal of Drug Policy, 20(2), 188–191. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2008.04.004

23.

Department of Justice. (2010). National anti-drug strategy implementation evaluation: Final report. Government of Canada. https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/cp-pm/eval/rep-rap/10/nasie-snaef/nasie.pdf

24.

Dupuis

MacKay

(2008). Legislative summary: Bill C-26: An Act to amend the controlled drugs and substances act and to make consequential amendments to other acts, LS-595E. Parliamentary Information and Research Service, Library of Parliament, Ottawa. https://lop.parl.ca/sites/PublicWebsite/default/en_CA/ResearchPublications/LegislativeSummaries/392LS595E

25.

Echo: Improving women’s health in Ontario. (2011). Women and alcohol expert panel report: Alcohol treatment services for Ontario women. Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care. https://www.womenscollegehospital.ca/assets/pdf/echo_improving_womens_health_in_ontario.pdf

26.

Federal framework on posttraumatic stress disorder: Recognition, collaboration and support. (2020). Government of Canada. https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/publications/healthy-living/federal-framework-post-traumatic-stress-disorder.html

27.

Foucault

(1980). The history of sexuality: An introduction (Vol. 1). Vintage Books.

28.

Fricker

(2003). Epistemic injustice and a role for virtue in the politics of knowing. Metaphilosophy, 34, 154–173. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9973.00266

29.

Gates Consulting (2006). Final report: Review of the women’s substance abuse treatment system in Ontario. The Jean Tweed Center.

30.

Government of Canada (2016). Canadian drugs and substances strategy report. Ottawa.

31.

Greaves

Poole

(2012). Becoming trauma informed. Centre for Addiction and Mental Health.

32.

Green

(2006). Gender and use of substance abuse treatment services. Alcohol Research & Health, 29(1), 55–62.

33.

Health Canada. (2018). Background document: Public consultation on strengthening Canada’s approach to substance use issues. https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/hc-sc/documents/services/substance-use/canadian-drugs-substances-strategy/strengthening-canada-approach-substance-use-issue/strengthening-canada-approach-substance-use-issue.pdf

34.

Heather

(2006). Controlled drinking, harm reduction and their roles in the response to alcohol-related problems. Addiction Research & Theory, 14(1), 7–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/16066350500489170

35.

Herman

(2015). Trauma and recovery: The aftermath of violence—From domestic abuse to political terror (2nd ed.). Basic Books.

36.

Hobden

Cunningham

(2006). Barriers to the dissemination of four harm reduction strategies: A survey of addiction treatment providers in Ontario. Harm Reduction Journal, 3, Article 35. https://doi.org/10.1186/1477-7517-3-35

37.

Holmila

(1993). Heavy drinking women: Drinking patterns and resources for controlled drinking. Addiction Research, 1, 119–130. https://doi.org/10.3109/16066359309035329

38.

Koerkle

(2002). Controlled drinking as a treatment goal in Germany. Journal of Drug Issues, 32(2), 667–688. https://doi.org/10.1177/002204260203200221

39.

Kosok

(2006). The Moderation Management programme in 2004: What type of drinker seeks controlled drinking? International Journal of Drug Policy, 17(4), 295–303. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2006.03.003

40.

Lafrance

(2014). Depression as oppression: Disrupting the biomedical discourse in women’s stories of sadness. In McKenzie-Mohr

Lafrance

(Eds.), Creating counterstories: Women resisting dominant discourses in speaking their lives (pp. 141–158). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203094365-9

41.

Lafrance

McKenzie-Mohr

(2013). The DSM and its lure of legitimacy. Feminism & Psychology, 23(1), 119–140. https://doi.org/10.1177/0959353512467974

42.

Madigan

(2003). Counterviewing injurious speech acts: Destabilising eight conversational habits of highly effective problems. International Journal of Narrative Therapy and Community Work, 1, 43–59.

43.

Mann

(2003). Beyond convictions, toward science and hope of a broader literature base. Comment on chapter 2: Alcohol: No ordinary commodity. Addiction, 98, 1352–1353. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1360-0443.2003.00507.x

44.

Marlatt

G. A.

(1998). Basic principles and strategies of harm reduction. In Marlatt

G. A.

(Ed.), Harm reduction: Pragmatic strategies for managing high risk behaviors (pp. 49–66). Guilford Press.

45.

Marlatt

G. A.

Larimer

M. E.

Baer

J. S.

Quigley

L. A.

(1993). Harm reduction for alcohol problems: Moving beyond the controlled drinking controversy. Behavior Therapy, 24, 461–504.

46.

Marlatt

G. A.

Witkiewitz

(2010). Update on harm-reduction policy and intervention research. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 6, 591–606. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.clinpsy.121208.131438

47.

McMullen

L. M.

(2011). A discursive analysis of Teresa’s protocol: Enhancing oneself, diminishing others. In Wertz

F. J.

Charmza

McMullen

L. M.

Josselson

Anderson

McSpadden

(Eds.), Five ways of doing qualitative analysis: Phenomenological psychology, grounded theory, discourse analysis, narrative research, and intuitive inquiry (pp. 205–223). Guilford Press.

48.

McMullen

L. M.

(2012). Discourses of influence and autonomy in physicians’ accounts of treatment decision making for depression. Qualitative Health Research, 22, 238–249. https://doi.org/10.1177/1049732311420738

49.

Morrow

Weisser

(2012). Towards a social justice framework of mental health recovery. Studies in Social Justice, 6(1), 27–43.

50.

Morse

Field

(1995). Qualitative research methods for health professionals. Sage.

51.

Muhr

(2004). User’s manual for ATLAS.ti 5.0. ATLAS.ti Scientific Software Development GmbH.

52.

Najavitis

L. M.

(2015). Trauma and substance abuse: A clinician’s guide to treatment. In Schnyder

Cloitre

(Eds.), Evidence based treatments for trauma-related psychological disorders: A practical guide for clinicians (pp. 317–330). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-07109-1_16

53.

National Alcohol Strategy Working Group. (2007). Reducing alcohol-related harm in Canada: Toward a culture of moderation—Recommendations for a national alcohol strategy. Canadian Centre on Substance Use and Addiction. www.ccsa.ca

54.

National Anti-Drug Strategy. (2007). Justice Canada, Government of Canada.

55.

National Treatment Strategy Working Group. (2008). A systems approach to substance use in Canada: Recommendations for a National Treatment Strategy. National Framework for Action to Reduce the Harms Associated with Alcohol and Other Drugs and Substances in Canada. https://www.ccsa.ca/sites/default/files/2019-05/nts-systems-approach-substance-abuse-canada-2008-en.pdf

56.

Neale

Nettleton

Pickering

(2011). What is the role of harm reduction when drug users say they want abstinence? International Journal of Drug Policy, 22(3), 189–193. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2010.09.007

57.

Paradis

(2016). Canada’s national alcohol strategy: It’s time to assess progress. Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation / La Revue canadienne d’évaluation de programme, 31(2), 232–241. https://doi.org/10.3138/cjpe.276

58.

Parker

R. N.

McCaffree

K. J.

(2013). The nature of the relationship and the promise of prevention. Lexington Books.

59.

Pauly

(2008). Harm reduction through a social justice lens. International Journal of Drug Policy, 19, 4–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2007.11.005

60.

Pauly

Vallance

Wettlaufer

Chow

Brown

Evans

Gray

Krysowaty

Ivsins

Schiff

Stockwell

(2018). Community managed alcohol programs in Canada: Overview of key dimensions and implementation. Drug and Alcohol Review, 37(1), S132–S139. https://doi.org/10.1111/dar.12681

61.

Pirisi

(2000). Alcohol’s siege on women’s health. Journal of Addiction & Mental Health, 3(3), 13.

62.

Plant

M. L.

(2008). The role of alcohol in women’s lives: A review of issues and responses. Journal of Substance Use, 13(3), 155–191. https://doi.org/10.1080/14659890802040880

63.

Pokorny

A. D.

Miller

B. A.

Kaplan

H. B.

(1972). The brief MAST: A shortened version of the Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test. The American Journal of Psychiatry, 129, 342–345. https://doi.org/10.1176/ajp.129.3.342

64.

Poole

Greaves

(2007). Making harm reduction work: Exploring women’s treatment for alcohol use problems. In Poole

Greaves

(Eds.), Highs and lows: Canadian perspectives on women and substance use (pp. 431–440). Centre for Addiction and Mental Health and the British Columbia Centre of Excellence for Women’s Health.

65.

Public Health Ontario. (2017). Alcohol screening, brief intervention and referral (SBIR) in health settings. http://www.sbir-diba.ca/

66.

Rosenberg

(1993). Prediction of controlled drinking by alcoholics and problem drinkers. Psychological Bulletin, 113(1), 129–139. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.113.1.129

67.

Rosenberg

Devine

Rothrock

(1996). Acceptance of moderate drinking by alcoholism treatment services in Canada. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 57, 559–562. https://doi.org/10.15288/jsa.1996.57.559

68.

Ross

Gilbert

Torres

Dugas

Jefferies

McDonald

Savage

Ungar

(2020). Adverse childhood experiences: Assessing the impact on physical and psychosocial health in adulthood and the mitigating role of resilience. Child Abuse & Neglect, 103, 104440.

69.

Ross

Morrison

(2020). Safety, belonging and voice: Critical clinical practice with girls and women struggling with substance use In Brown

Macdonald

(Eds.), Critical clinical social work: Counterstorying for social justice (pp. 171–194). Canadian Scholars’ Press.

70.

Rush

Ogborne

(1986). Acceptability of non-abstinence treatment goals among alcoholism treatment programs. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs, 47(2), 146–150. https://doi.org/10.15288/jsa.1986.47.146

71.

Sanchez-Craig

Spivak

Davila

(1991). Superior outcome of females over males after brief treatment for the reduction of heavy drinking: Replication and report of therapist effects. British Journal of Addiction, 86, 867–876. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1360-0443.1991.tb01842.x

72.

Sanders

(2007). A poetics of resistance: Compassionate practice in substance misuse therapy. In Brown

Augusta-Scott

(Eds.), Narrative therapy: Making meaning, making lives (pp. 59–76). Sage.

73.

Sobell

M. B.

Sobell

L. C.

(1995). Controlled drinking after 25 years: How important was the great debate? Addiction, 90, 1149–1153. https://doi.org/10.1080/09652149541392

74.

Stewart

S. H.

Gavric

Collins

(2009). Women, girls and alcohol. In Brady

Back

Greenfield

(Eds.), Women and alcohol: A comprehensive handbook (pp. 341–359). Guilford Press.

75.

Stewart

S. H.

Israeli

(2003). Substance abuse and co-occurring psychiatric disorders in victims of intimate violence. In Wekerle

Wall

A. M.

(Eds.), The violence and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in substance abuse and relationship violence (pp. 98–122). Brunner/Mazel.

76.

Stewart

S. H.

Samoluk

S. B.

Conrod

P. J.

Pihl

R. O.

Dongier

(2000). Psychometric evaluation of the short form Inventory of Drinking Situations (IDS-42) in a community-recruited sample of substance abusing women. Journal of Substance Abuse, 11, 305–321.

77.

Stockwell

Pauly

Chow

Erickson

Krysowaty

Roemer

Vallance

Wettlaufer

Zhao

(2018). Does managing the consumption of people with severe alcohol dependence reduce harm? A comparison of participants in six Canadian managed alcohol programs with locally recruited controls. Drugs and Alcohol Review, 37(Suppl. 1), S159–S166. https://doi.org/10.1111/dar.12618

78.

Stoppard

(2000). Understanding depression: Feminist social constructionist approach. Routledge.

79.

Strauss

A. L.

Corbin

(1990). Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques. Sage.

80.

Strong

(2012). Talking about the DSM-V. International Journal of Narrative Therapy & Community Work, 2, 54–64.

81.

Tatarsky

(1998). An integrative approach to harm reduction psychotherapy: A case of problem drinking secondary to depression. In Session: Psychotherapy in Practice, 4(1), 9–24. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1520-6572(199821)4:1<9::AID-SESS2>3.0.CO;2-I

82.

United Nations. (2004). Substance abuse treatment and care for women. https://www.unodc.org/pdf/report_2004-08-30_1.pdf

83.

Vallance

Stockwell

Pauly

Chow

Gray

Krysowaty

Perkin

Zhao

(2016). Do managed alcohol programs change patterns of alcohol consumption and reduce related harm? A pilot study. Harm Reduction Journal, 13, Article 13. http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12954-016-0103-4

84.

van Amsterdam

van den Brink

(2013). Reduced-risk drinking as a viable treatment goal in problematic alcohol use and alcohol dependence. Journal of Psychopharmacology, 27(11), 987–997. https://doi.org/10.1177/0269881113495320

85.

Vannicelli

(2001). Moderation training for problem drinkers: Treatment techniques and clinical considerations. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, 8(1), 53–61. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1077-7229(01)80044-4

86.

Wells

(2011). Narrative inquiry. Oxford University Press.

87.

White

(2001). Narrative practice and the unpacking of identity conclusions. Journal of Deconstruction and Narrative Ideas in Therapeutic Practice, 1, 28–55.

88.

White

(2007). Maps of narrative practice. W.W. Norton.

89.

White

Epston

(1990). Narrative means to therapeutic ends. W.W. Norton.

90.

Witkiewitz

Marlatt

G. A.

(2006). Overview of harm reduction treatments for alcohol problems. International Journal of Drug Policy, 17(4), 285–294. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2006.03.005

91.

Women’s Service Strategy Work Group. (2005). Best practices in action: Guidelines and criteria for women’s substance abuse treatment services in Ontario. Ministry of Health and Long Term Care. http://jeantweed.com/wp-content/themes/JTC/pdfs/Best%20Practice-English.pdf