Task shifting from trained clinicians to community health workers (CHWs) is a central, primary health care strategy advocated by global health policy planners in resource-poor settings where trained health professionals are scarce. The evidence base for the efficacy of these programs, however, is limited—in particular, research that identifies their potential unintended consequences. Based on sustained ethnographic study of CHWs working for AIDS projects in South Africa at the height of the country’s AIDS epidemic, this article identifies how structural and local factors produced unintended consequences for CHW programs. These consequences were (a) CHWs moonlighting for multiple organizations, (b) CHWs freelancing in communities without regulation, and (c) adverse patient outcomes resulting from uncoordinated care. These consequences stemmed from structural elements of a bureaucratically weak health system and from local grassroots dynamics that jeopardized long-term CHW program sustainability and eroded national health goals.
AdamsV.BurkeN. J.WhitmarshI. (2014). Slow research: Thoughts for a movement in global health. Medical Anthropology, 33, 179–197. doi:10.1080/01459740.2013.858335
2.
AkintolaO.GweloN. B.LabontéR.AppaduT. (2016). The global financial crisis: Experiences of and implications for community-based organizations providing health and social services in South Africa. Critical Public Health, 26, 307–321. doi:10.1080/09581596.2015.1085959
3.
AronsonJ.NeysmithS. M. (1996). “You’re not just in there to do the work”: Depersonalizing policies and the exploitation of home care workers’ labor. Gender and Society, 10, 59–77. doi:10.1177/089124396010001005
4.
AuldA. F.ShiraishiR. W.CoutoA.MbofanaF.ColbornK.AlfredoC.. . . JobartehK. (2016). A decade of antiretroviral therapy scale-up in Mozambique: Evaluation of outcome trends and new models of service delivery among more than 300,000 patients enrolled during 2004–2013. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 73(2), e11–e22. doi:10.1097/QAI.0000000000001137
5.
BabbS.ChorevN. (2016). International organizations: Loose and tight coupling in the development regime. Studies in Comparative International Development, 51, 81–102. doi:10.1007/s12116-016-9217-7
6.
BaynesC.SemuH.BarakaJ.MushiH.RamseyK.KanteA. M.PhillipsJ. F. (2017). An exploration of the feasibility, acceptability, and effectiveness of professional, multitasked community health workers in Tanzania. Global Public Health, 12, 1018–1032. doi:10.1080/17441692.2015.1080750
7.
BellK. (2012). Cochrane reviews and the behavioral turn in evidence-based medicine. Health Sociology Review, 21, 313–321. doi:10.5172/hesr.2012.21.3.313
8.
BiehlJ. G.PetrynaA. (2013). Critical global health. In BiehlJ. G.PetrynaA. (Eds.), When people come first: Critical studies in global health (pp. 1–20). Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
9.
BiesmaR. G.BrughaR.HarmerA.WalshA.SpicerN.WaltG. (2009). The effects of global health initiatives on country health systems: A review of the evidence from HIV/AIDS control. Health Policy and Planning, 24, 239–252. doi:10.1093/heapol/czp025
10.
BlumerH. (1986). Symbolic interactionism: Perspective and method. Berkeley: University of California Press.
11.
BoermaT.SiyamA. (2013). Health workforce indicators: Let’s get real. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 91, Article 886. doi:10.2471/BLT.13.126656
12.
Bureau-PointE.PhanS. (2016). The structural violence of patient participation in Cambodian HIV services. Qualitative Health Research, 26, 1263–1274. doi:10.1177/1049732315583269
13.
CampbellC. (2003). Letting them die: Why HIV/AIDS prevention programmes fail. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
14.
CampbellC.ScottK. (2011). Retreat from Alma Ata? The WHO’s report on task shifting to community health workers for AIDS care in poor countries. Global Public Health, 6, 125–138. doi:10.1080/17441690903334232
15.
CharmazK. (2006). Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative research. London: Sage.
CohnS.ClinchM.BunnC.StrongeP. (2013). Entangled complexity: Why complex interventions are just not complicated enough. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy, 18, 40–43. doi:10.1258/jhsrp.2012.012036
19.
ColvinC. J. (2015). Anthropologies in and of evidence making in global health research and policy. Medical Anthropology, 34, 99–105. doi:10.1080/01459740.2014.963196
20.
ComettoG.WitterS. (2013). Tackling health workforce challenges to universal health coverage: Setting targets and measuring progress. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 91, 881–885. doi:10.2471/BLT.13.118810
21.
DanielsK.ClarkeM.RingsbergK. C. (2012). Developing lay health worker policy in South Africa: A qualitative study. Health Research Policy and Systems, 10, Article 8. doi:10.1186/1478-4505-10-8
22.
DelVecchio GoodM.GoodB.GraymanJ. (2010). Complex engagements: Responding to violence in postconflict Aceh. In FassinD.PandolfiM. (Eds.), Contemporary states of emergency: The politics of military and humanitarian interventions (pp. 241–266). New York: Zone Books.
23.
Department of Health. (2008). Concept paper for the community health worker policy framework review: Deepening access to quality primary health care services in homes and communities. Pretoria: Department of Health.
24.
Department of Public Works. (2009). Expanded public works programme: Five-year report 2004/2005–2008/2009. Pretoria: Government Printers.
25.
De WetK. (2011). Redefining volunteerism: The rhetoric of community home-based care in (the not so new) South Africa. Community Development Journal, 47, 111–125. doi:10.1093/cdj/bsq066
26.
DjellouliN.Quevedo-GómezM. C. (2015). Challenges to successful implementation of HIV and AIDS-related health policies in Cartagena, Colombia. Social Science & Medicine, 133, 36–44. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2015.03.048
27.
DrauckerC. B.MartsolfD. S.RossR.RuskT. B. (2007). Theoretical sampling and category development in grounded theory. Qualitative Health Research, 17, 1137–1148. doi:10.1177/1049732307308450
28.
FarmerP. (2003). Pathologies of power: Health, human rights, and the new war on the poor. Berkeley: University of California Press.
29.
FattiG.GrimwoodA.MothibiE.SheaJ. (2011). The effect of patient load on antiretroviral treatment programmatic outcomes at primary health care facilities in South Africa: A multicohort study. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 58(1), e17–e19. doi:10.1097/QAI.0b013e318229baab
30.
FrascaT.FauréY.Atlani-DuaultL. (2018). Decentralisation of Brazil’s HIV/AIDS programme: Intended and unintended consequences. Global Public Health, 13, 1725–1736. doi:10.1080/17441692.2018.1455888
31.
FriedJ.HarrisB.EylesJ.MoshabelaM. (2015). Acceptable care? Illness constructions, healthworlds, and accessible chronic treatment in South Africa. Qualitative Health Research, 25, 622–635. doi:10.1177/1049732315575315
32.
FunnellS. C.RogersP. J. (2011). Purposeful program theory: Effective use of theories of change and logic models. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
33.
GaltungJ. (1969). Violence, peace, and peace research. Journal of Peace Research, 6, 167–191. doi:10.1177/002234336900600301
34.
GlaserB. G.StraussA. L. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. New Brunswick, NJ: Aldine Transaction.
35.
GreenJ. (2014). What kind of research does public health need?Critical Public Health, 24, 249–252. doi:10.1080/09581596.2014.917813
36.
HafnerT.ShiffmanJ. (2013). The emergence of global attention to health systems strengthening. Health Policy and Planning, 28, 41–50. doi:10.1093/heapol/czs023
37.
HallgrimsdottirH. K.TeghtsoonianK.BrownD. (2008). Public policy, caring practices and gender in health care work. Revue Canadienne de Santé Publique/Canadian Journal of Public Health, 99(Suppl. 2), S43–S47. Retrieved from https://www.jstor.org/stable/41995018
38.
HarrisJ. (2017). Achieving access: Professional movements and the politics of health universalism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
39.
JabeenS. (2016). Do we really care about unintended outcomes? An analysis of evaluation theory and practice. Evaluation and Program Planning, 55, 144–154. doi:10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2015.12.010
40.
JanS.BianY.JumpaM.MengQ.NyazemaN.PrakongsaiP.MillsA. (2005). Dual job holding by public sector health professionals in highly resource-constrained settings: Problem or solution?Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 83, 771–776. doi:10.1590/S0042-96862005001000014
41.
JohnsonL. F.DorringtonR. E.MoollaH. (2017). Progress towards the 2020 targets for HIV diagnosis and antiretroviral treatment in South Africa. Southern African Journal of HIV Medicine, 18(1). Retrieved from https://www.ajol.info/index.php/sajhivm/article/view/161463
42.
Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS. (2015). Progress report on the global plan towards the elimination of new HIV infections among children and keeping their mothers alive. Geneva: Author.
43.
JusticeJ. (1987). The bureaucratic context of international health: A social scientist’s view. Social Science & Medicine, 25, 1303–1306. doi:10.1016/0277-9536(87)90128-6
44.
KalofonosI. (2014). “All they do is pray”: Community labour and the narrowing of “care” during Mozambique’s HIV scale-up. Global Public Health, 9(1–2), 7–24. doi:10.1080/17441692.2014.881527
45.
KangoviS.GrandeD.Trinh-ShevrinC. (2015). From rhetoric to reality—Community health workers in post-reform U.S. health care. New England Journal of Medicine, 372, 2277–2279. doi:10.1056/NEJMp1502569
46.
KarimS. S. A.ChurchyardG. J.KarimQ. A.LawnS. D. (2009). HIV infection and tuberculosis in South Africa: An urgent need to escalate the public health response. The Lancet, 374, 921–933. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60916-8
47.
KokM. C.OrmelH.BroerseJ. E. W.KaneS.NamakhomaI.OtisoL.. . . DielemanM. (2017). Optimising the benefits of community health workers’ unique position between communities and the health sector: A comparative analysis of factors shaping relationships in four countries. Global Public Health, 12, 1404–1432. doi:10.1080/17441692.2016.1174722
48.
LeibbrandtM.WoolardI.McEwenH.KoepC. (2010). Trends in South African Income Distribution and Poverty since the Fall of Apartheid. OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers, no. 101. Paris: OECD Publishing. doi: 10.1787/5kmms0t7p1ms-en
49.
LewinS.Munabi-BabigumiraS.GlentonC.DanielsK.Bosch-CapblanchX.van WykB. E.. . . ZwarensteinM. (2010). Lay health workers in primary and community health care for maternal and child health and the management of infectious diseases. Cochrane Database of Systematic Review, 2010(3), 1–211. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD004015.pub3
50.
LiebermanE. S. (2011). The perils of polycentric governance of infectious disease in South Africa. Social Science & Medicine, 73, 676–684. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.06.012
51.
LincolnY. S.GubaE. G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry. London: Sage.
52.
LinkB. G.PhelanJ. (1995). Social conditions as fundamental causes of disease. Journal of Health & Social Behavior, 35, 80–94. doi:10.2307/2626958
53.
LundF. (2010). Hierarchies of care work in South Africa: Nurses, social workers and home-based care workers. International Labour Review, 149, 495–509. doi:10.1111/j.1564-913X.2010.00100.x
54.
MaesK. (2015). “Volunteers are not paid because they are priceless”: Community health worker capacities and values in an AIDS treatment intervention in urban Ethiopia. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 29, 97–115. doi:10.1111/maq.12136
55.
MaesK.ClosserS.VorelE.TesfayeY. (2015). Using community health workers: Discipline and hierarchy in Ethiopia’s women’s development army. Annals of Anthropological Practice, 39(1), 42–57. doi:10.1111/napa.12064
56.
MaesK.KalofonosI. (2013). Becoming and remaining community health workers: Perspectives from Ethiopia and Mozambique. Social Science & Medicine, 87, 52–59. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2013.03.026
57.
MaesK. C.KohrtB. A.ClosserS. (2010). Culture, status and context in community health worker pay: Pitfalls and opportunities for policy research. A commentary on Glenton et al. (2010). Social Science & Medicine, 71, 1375–1380. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2010.06.020
58.
MalkkiL. H. (2015). The need to help: The domestic arts of international humanitarianism. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
59.
MartenR.McIntyreD.TravassosC.ShishkinS.LongdeW.ReddyS.VegaJ. (2014). An assessment of progress towards universal health coverage in Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa (BRICS). The Lancet, 384, 2164–2171. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60075-1
60.
MayosiB. M.BenatarS. R. (2014). Health and health care in South Africa—20 years after Mandela. New England Journal of Medicine, 371, 1344–1353. doi:10.1056/NEJMsr1405012
61.
MayosiB. M.LawnJ. E.van NiekerkA.BradshawD.Abdool KarimS. S.CoovadiaH. M. (2012). Health in South Africa: Changes and challenges since 2009. The Lancet, 380, 2029–2043. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(12)61814-5
62.
McKayR. (2017). Medicine in the meantime: The work of care in Mozambique. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
63.
MertonR. K. (1936). The unanticipated consequences of purposive social action. American Sociological Review, 1, 894–904. doi:10.2307/2084615
64.
Meyer-RathG.JohnsonL. F.PillayY.BlecherM.BrennanA. T.LongL.. . . RosenS. (2017). Changing the South African national antiretroviral therapy guidelines: The role of cost modelling. PLoS ONE, 12(10), e0186557. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0186557
65.
MolA. (2002). The body multiple: Ontology in medical practice. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
66.
MorellJ. A. (2010). Evaluation in the face of uncertainty: Anticipating surprise and responding to the inevitable. London: Guilford Press.
67.
MutevedziP. C.LessellsR. J.NewellM. (2013). Disengagement from care in a decentralised primary health care antiretroviral treatment programme: Cohort study in rural South Africa. Tropical Medicine & International Health, 18, 934–941. doi:10.1111/tmi.12135
68.
MuulaA. S.MasekoF. C. (2006). How are health professionals earning their living in Malawi?BMC Health Services Research, 6, Article 97. doi:10.1186/1472-6963-6-97
69.
MykhalovskiyE.WeirL. (2004). The problem of evidence-based medicine: Directions for social science. Social Science & Medicine, 59, 1059–1069. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2003.12.002
70.
NadingA. M. (2013). “Love isn’t there in your stomach”: A moral economy of medical citizenship among Nicaraguan community health workers. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 27, 84–102. doi:10.1111/maq.12017
71.
NaidooL.JacobsonJ. S.NeugutA. I.DlovaN. C.MosamA. (2016). HAART in hand: The change in Kaposi’s sarcoma presentation in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. South African Medical Journal, 106, 611–616. doi:10.7196/SAMJ.2016.v106i6.10333
72.
NaimoliJ. F.FrymusD. E.WulijiT.FrancoL. M.NewsomeM. H. (2014). A community health worker “logic model”: Towards a theory of enhanced performance in low- and middle-income countries. Human Resources for Health, 12(1), Article 56. doi:10.1186/1478-4491-12-56
NglaziM. D.LawnS. D.KaplanR.KranzerK.OrrellC.WoodR.BekkerL. G. (2011). Changes in programmatic outcomes during 7 years of scale-up at a community-based antiretroviral treatment service in South Africa. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 56(1), e1–e8. doi:10.1097/QAI.0b013e3181ff0bdc
NugusP.DésalliersJ.MoralesJ.GravesL.EvansA.MacaulayA. C. (2018). Localizing global medicine: Challenges and opportunities in cervical screening in an indigenous community in Ecuador. Qualitative Health Research, 28, 800–812. doi:10.1177/1049732317742129
78.
NxumaloN.GoudgeJ.MandersonL. (2016). Community health workers, recipients’ experiences and constraints to care in South Africa—A pathway to trust. AIDS Care, 28(Suppl. 4), 61–71. doi:10.1080/09540121.2016.1195484
79.
PerryH. B.ZulligerR.RogersM. M. (2014). Community health workers in low-, middle-, and high-income countries: An overview of their history, recent evolution, and current effectiveness. Annual Review of Public Health, 35, 399–421. doi:10.1146/annurev-publhealth-032013-182354
80.
PfeifferJ.NichterM. (2008). What can critical medical anthropology contribute to global health?Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 22, 410–415. doi:10.1111/j.1548-1387.2008.00041.x
81.
PhelanJ. C.LinkB. G.TehranifarP. (2010). Social conditions as fundamental causes of health inequalities: Theory, evidence, and policy implications. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 51, S28–S40. doi:10.1177/0022146510383498
82.
PiersonP. (2005). The study of policy development. Journal of Policy History, 17(1), 34–51. doi:10.1353/jph.2005.0006
83.
PlagersonS.PatelL.HochfeldT.UlriksenM. S. (2019). Social policy in South Africa: Navigating the route to social development. World Development, 113, 1–9. doi:10.1016/j.worlddev.2018.08.019
84.
PrinceR. J.OtienoP. (2014). In the shadowlands of global health: Observations from health workers in Kenya. Global Public Health, 9, 927–945. doi:10.1080/17441692.2014.941897
85.
Republic of South Africa. (2017). White paper 2017: National Health Insurance for South Africa; towards universal health coverage. Pretoria: National Department of Health.
86.
RispelL. (2016). Analysing the progress and fault lines of health sector transformation in South Africa. South African Health Review, 2016(1), 17–23.
87.
RispelL. C.BlaauwD.ChirwaT.de WetK. (2014). Factors influencing agency nursing and moonlighting among nurses in South Africa. Global Health Action, 7, Article 23585. doi:10.3402/gha.v7.23585
88.
RispelL. C.ChirwaT.BlaauwD. (2014). Does moonlighting influence South African nurses’ intention to leave their primary jobs?Global Health Action, 7, 25754. doi:10.3402/gha.v7.25754
89.
RispelL. C.de JagerP.FonnS. (2016). Exploring corruption in the South African health sector. Health Policy and Planning, 31, 239–249. doi:10.1093/heapol/czv047
90.
RogersP.WesthorpG.WalkerB. (2015). Dealing with complexity in a realist synthesis: Community accountability and empowerment initiatives. In BambergerM.VaessenJ.RaimondoE.RogersP.WesthorpG.WalkerB. (Eds.), Dealing with complexity in development evaluation: A practical approach (pp. 385–404). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
91.
RosenthalA. (2016). “Doing the best we can”: Providing care in a Malawian antiretroviral clinic. Medical Anthropology, 35, 132–146. doi:10.1080/01459740.2015.1076409
92.
RossiP. H.LipseyM. W.FreemanH. E. (2003). Evaluation: A systematic approach. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
93.
RossiP. H.WilliamsW. (1972). Evaluating social programs: Theory, practice, and politics. New York: Seminar Press.
94.
SchneiderH.HlopheH.van RensburgD. (2008). Community health workers and the response to HIV/AIDS in South Africa: Tensions and prospects. Health Policy and Planning, 23, 179–187. doi:10.1093/heapol/czn006
95.
SchneiderH.LehmannU. (2010). Lay health workers and HIV programmes: Implications for health systems. AIDS Care, 22, 60–67. doi:10.1080/09540120903483042
96.
SchneiderH.NxumaloN. (2017). Leadership and governance of community health worker programmes at scale: A cross case analysis of provincial implementation in South Africa. International Journal for Equity in Health, 16(1), Article 72. doi:10.1186/s12939-017-0565-3
97.
SchneiderH.OkelloD.LehmannU. (2016). The global pendulum swing towards community health workers in low- and middle-income countries: A scoping review of trends, geographical distribution and programmatic orientations, 2005 to 2014. Human Resources for Health, 14(1), Article 65. doi:10.1186/s12960-016-0163-2
98.
SchneiderH.SchaayN.DudleyL.GoliathC.QukulaT. (2015). The challenges of reshaping disease specific and care oriented community based services towards comprehensive goals: A situation appraisal in the Western Cape Province, South Africa. BMC Health Services Research, 15(1), Article 436. doi:10.1186/s12913-015-1109-4
99.
SinghP.SachsJ. D. (2013). 1 million community health workers in sub-Saharan Africa by 2015. The Lancet, 382, 363–365. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(12)62002-9
100.
StarksH.TrinidadS. B. (2007). Choose your method: A comparison of phenomenology, discourse analysis, and grounded theory. Qualitative Health Research, 17, 1372–1380. doi:10.1177/1049732307307031
StorengK. T. (2014). The GAVI Alliance and the “Gates approach” to health system strengthening. Global Public Health, 9, 865–879. doi:10.1080/17441692.2014.940362
103.
SwartzA.ColvinC. J. (2015). “It’s in our veins”: Caring natures and material motivations of community health workers in contexts of economic marginalisation. Critical Public Health, 25, 139–152. doi:10.1080/09581596.2014.941281
104.
SwidlerA.WatkinsS. C. (2009). “Teach a man to fish”: The sustainability doctrine and its social consequences. World Development, 37, 1182–1196. doi:10.1016/j.worlddev.2008.11.002
105.
TakasugiT.LeeA. C. K. (2012). Why do community health workers volunteer? A qualitative study in Kenya. Public Health, 126, 839–845. doi:10.1016/j.puhe.2012.06.005
106.
TrinitapoliJ.YeatmanS. (2011). Uncertainty and fertility in a generalized AIDS epidemic. American Sociological Review, 76, 935–954. doi:10.1177/0003122411427672
107.
van de RuitC. (2017a). Politics in the making of HIV/AIDS in South Africa. Contemporary Sociology, 46, 587–589. doi:10.1177/0094306117725085gg
108.
van de RuitC. (2017b). Social work professionalism during and after apartheid in South Africa. Sociology of Development, 3, 273–294. doi:10.1525/sod.2017.3.3.273
109.
van RensburgH. C. (2014). South Africa’s protracted struggle for equal distribution and equitable access—Still not there. Human Resources for Health, 12(1), Article 26. doi:10.1186/1478-4491-12-26
110.
World Health Organization. (2007). Task shifting: Rational redistribution of tasks among health workforce teams: Global recommendations and guidelines. Geneva: Author.
111.
World Health Organization. (2012). WHO recommendations: Optimizing health worker roles to improve access to key maternal and newborn health interventions through task shifting. Geneva: Author.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
