We argue that patient autonomy is a cultural value specific to Western culture and that the autonomy focus in U.S. health care may produce negative patient outcomes for patients from other cultures. To this end, we present a case study of a Mexican physician’s interactions with his patients and apply the method of discourse analysis to argue that (a) this physician’s interactions are highly paternalistic, (b) there is an appreciation for this among his Latino patients and in the broader Latino community, and (c) this physician provides high-quality ethical care precisely because his paternalism communicates important ethical values such as familial intimacy, insistence, and care. We further propose that paternalism may produce better outcomes for Latino patients.
AaronsD. (2005). Doctor-patient communication in government hospitals in Jamaica: Empiric and ethical dimensions of a socio-cultural phenomenon (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses Database. (Order No. NR21610)
2.
AddissieA.TesfayeM. (2014). Ethiopia. In ten HaveH. A. M. J.GordijnG. (Eds.), Handbook of global bioethics (pp. 1121–1139). New York: Springer. doi:10.1007/978-94-007-2512-6_19
3.
AhmaduF. (2000). Rites and wrongs: An insider/outsider reflects on power and excision. In Shell-DuncanB.HernlundY. (Eds.), Female “circumcision” in Africa: Culture, controversy, and change (pp. 283–312). Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
4.
ArundaleR. B. (2006). Face as relational and interactional: A communication framework for research on face, facework, and politeness. Journal of Politeness Research: Language, Behaviour, Culture, 2, 193–216. doi:10.1515/PR.2006.011
5.
BeauchampT. L. (2011). Informed consent: Its history, meaning, and present challenges. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 20, 515–523. doi:10.1017/s0963180111000259
6.
BeauchampT. L.ChildressJ. F. (2013). Principles of biomedical ethics (7th ed.). New York: Oxford University Press.
7.
Ben-ShaharO.SchneiderC. E. (2014). More than you wanted to know: The failure of mandated disclosure. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
8.
BergmarkR.BarrD.GarciaR. (2010). Mexican immigrants in the US living far from the border may return to Mexico for health services. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health, 12, 610–614. doi:10.1007/s10903-008-9213-8
9.
BetancourtJ.GreenA.CarilloJ. E. (2000). The challenges of cross-cultural healthcare—Diversity, ethics, and the medical encounter. Bioethics Forum, 16, 27–32.
10.
BlackhallL. J.MurphyS. T.FrankG.MichelV.AzenS. (1995). Ethnicity and attitudes toward patient autonomy. The Journal of the American Medical Association, 274, 820–825.
11.
BrownP.LevinsonS. C. (1987). Politeness: Some universals in language usage. New York: Cambridge University Press.
12.
CarreseJ. A.RhodesL. A. (1995). Western bioethics on the Navajo reservation: Benefit or harm?The Journal of the American Medical Association, 274, 826–829.
13.
CharlesC.GafniA.WhelanT. (1997). Shared decision-making in the medical encounter: What does it mean? (or it takes at least two to tango). Social Science & Medicine, 44, 681–692. doi:10.1016/S0277-9536(96)00221-3
14.
CharlesC.GafniA.WhelanT. (1999). Decision-making in the physician–patient encounter: Revisiting the shared treatment decision-making model. Social Science & Medicine, 49, 651–661. doi:10.1016/S0277-9536(99)00145-8
15.
CookD. (2001). Patient autonomy versus parentalism. Critical Care Medicine, 29, N24–N25. doi:10.1097/00003246-200102001-00005
16.
CoulterA. (1999). Paternalism or partnership?British Medical Journal, 319, Article 719. doi:10.1136/bmj.319.7212.719
17.
d’Agincourt-CanningL. (2006). Genetic testing for hereditary breast and ovarian cancer: Responsibility and choice. Qualitative Health Research, 16, 97–118. doi:10.1177/1049732305284002
18.
DresserR. (1995). Dworkin on dementia: Elegant theory, questionable policy. Hastings Center Report, 25(6), 32–38.
ElwynG.EdwardsA.KinnersleyP. (1999). Shared decision-making in primary care: The neglected second half of the consultation. British Journal of General Practice, 49, 477–482.
21.
EmanuelE. J.EmanuelL. L. (1992). Four models of the physician-patient relationship. The Journal of the American Medical Association, 267, 2221–2226. doi:10.1001/jama.1992.03480160079038
22.
EpsteinR. M.StreetR. L. (2011). The values and value of patient-centered care: An Editorial. Annals of Family Medicine, 9, 100–103. doi:10.1370/afm.1239
23.
ErzingerS. L. (1989). Consultas médicas: A study of communication between Spanish-speaking patients and their doctors (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of California, Berkeley.
24.
FadimanA. (2012). The spirit catches you and you fall down: A Hmong child, her American doctors, and the collision of two cultures. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
25.
FinklerK. (2001). Physicians at work, patients in pain: Biomedical practice and patient response in Mexico (2nd ed.). Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.
26.
FraenkelL.McGrawS. (2007). What are the essential elements to enable patient participation in medical decision making?Journal of General Internal Medicine, 22, 614–619. doi:10.1007/s11606-007-0149-9
27.
FrankG.BlackhallL. J.MichelV.MurphyS. T.AzenS. P.ParkK. (1998). A discourse of relationships in bioethics: Patient autonomy and end-of-life decision making among elderly Korean Americans. Medical Anthropology Quarterly, 12, 403–423. doi:10.1525/maq.1998.12.4.403
28.
FroschD. L.KaplanR. M. (1999). Shared decision making in clinical medicine: Past research and future directions. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 17, 285–294. doi:10.1016/S0749-3797(99)00097-5
29.
Garcia-GonzalezA.Gonzalez-LopezL.Gamez-NavaJ. I.Rodriguez-ArreolaB. E.CoxV.Suarez-AlmazorM. E. (2009). Doctor-patient interactions in Mexican patients with rheumatic disease. Journal of Clinical Rheumatology, 15, 120–123. doi:10.1097/RHU.0b013e31819d89bf
30.
GoffmanE. (1967). On face-work: An analysis of ritual elements in social interaction. New York: Doubleday.
31.
GraciaD. (1993). The intellectual basis of bioethics in Southern European countries. Bioethics, 7, 97–107. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8519.1993.tb00276.x
32.
GustafsonD. L.BrungerF. (2014). Ethics, “vulnerability,” and feminist participatory action research with a disability community. Qualitative Health Research, 24, 997–1005. doi:10.1177/1049732314538122
33.
HahnJ. W.HatfieldH. (2011). Group face in Korea and the United States: Taking responsibility for the individual and the group. Multilingua: Journal of Cross-Cultural and Interlanguage Communication, 30, 25–70. doi:10.1515/mult.2011.003
34.
HalgunsethL. C.IspaJ. M.RudyD. (2006). Parental control in Latino families: An integrated review of the literature. Child Development, 77, 1282–1297. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8624.2006.00934.x
35.
HenrichJ.HeineS. J.NorenzayanA. (2010). The weirdest people in the world?Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 33, 61–83. doi:10.1017/S0140525X0999152X
36.
HoA. (2008). Relational autonomy or undue pressure? Family’s role in medical decision-making. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences, 22, 128–135. doi:10.1111/j.1471-6712.2007.00561.x
37.
HortonS.ColeS. (2011). Medical returns: Seeking health care in Mexico. Social Science & Medicine, 72, 1846–1852. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.03.035
38.
IshiwataR.SakaiA. (1994). The physician–patient relationship and medical ethics in Japan. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 3, 60–66. doi:10.1017/S0963180100004722
39.
JenningsB. (2009). Autonomy. In SteinbockB. (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of bioethics (pp. 72-89). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
40.
KleinmanA.van der GeestS. (2009). “Care” in health care: Remaking the moral world of medicine. Medische Antropologie, 21, 159–168.
41.
KuhseH.SchüklenkU.SingerP. (Eds.). (2015). Bioethics: An anthology (3rd ed.). Oxford, UK: John Wiley.
42.
Lazcano-PonceE.Angeles-LlerenasA.RíoA. A.Salazar-MartínezE.AllenB.Hernández-AvilaM.KrausA. (2004). Ethics and communication between physicians and their patients with cancer, HIV/AIDS, and rheumatoid arthritis in Mexico. Archives of Medical Research, 35, 66–75. doi:10.1016/j.arcmed.2003.06.007
43.
LeechG. (2005). Politeness: Is there an East-West divide?Journal of Foreign Languages, 160, 1–30. doi:10.1515/PR.2007.009
44.
LevinsonW.KaoA.KubyA.ThistedR. A. (2005). Not all patients want to participate in decision making. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 20, 531–535. doi:10.1111/j.1525-1497.2005.04101.x
45.
MacklinR. (1999). Against relativism: Cultural diversity and the search for ethical universals in medicine. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
46.
MacklinR. (2003). Dignity is a useless concept: It means no more than respect for persons or their autonomy. British Medical Journal, 327, Article 1419. doi:10.1136/bmj.327.7429.1419
47.
MacklinR. (2012). Ethics in global health: Research, policy, and practice. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
48.
MacklinR. (2014). Respect for cultural diversity and pluralism. In ten HaveH. A. M. J.GordijnG. (Eds.), Handbook of global bioethics (pp. 153–167). New York: Springer. doi:10.1007/978-94-007-2512-6_75
49.
MacklinR. (2015). The doctor-patient relationship in different cultures. In KuhseH.SchüklenkU.SingerP. (Eds.), Bioethics: An anthology (3rd ed.) (pp. 642-653). Oxford, UK: John Wiley. (Original work published 1999)
50.
McMullenL. M. (2012). Discourses of influence and autonomy in physicians’ accounts of treatment decision making for depression. Qualitative Health Research, 22, 238–249. doi:10.1177/1049732311420738
51.
NormanI. (2015). Blind trust in the care-giver: Is paternalism essential to the health-seeking behavior of patients in sub-Saharan Africa?Advances in Applied Sociology, 5, 94–104. doi:10.4236/aasoci.2015.52008
52.
ParkerJ. (2011). Different names for the same thing: Domestic homicides and dowry deaths in the Western media. University of Colorado Law Review, 83, 1181-1206.
53.
Perez-StableE. (1987). Issues in Latino health care. The Western Journal of Medicine, 146, 213–218.
54.
PintoK. C. (2004). Intersections of gender and age in health care: Adapting autonomy and confidentiality for the adolescent girl. Qualitative Health Research, 14, 78–99. doi:10.1177/1049732303259674
55.
PomaP. A. (1983). Hispanic cultural influences on medical practice. Journal of the National Medical Association, 75, 941–946.
56.
QuesadaG. M. (1976). Language and communication barriers for health delivery to a minority group. Social Science & Medicine, 10, 323–327. doi:10.1016/0037-7856(76)90078-0
57.
SavulescuJ.DahlE. (2000). Sex selection and preimplantation diagnosis: A response to the ethics committee of the American society of reproductive medicine. Human Reproduction, 15, 1879–1880. doi:10.1093/humrep/15.9.1879
58.
SchneiderC. E. (1998). The practice of autonomy: Patients, doctors, and medical decisions. New York: Oxford University Press.
59.
SeijoR.GomezH.FreidenbergJ. (1991). Language as a communication barrier in medical care for Hispanic patients. Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences, 13, 363–376. doi:10.1177/07399863910134001
60.
SneadO. C.Mulder-WestrateK. (2014). Autonomy and individual responsibility. In ten HaveH. A. M. J.GordijnG. (Eds.), Handbook of global bioethics (pp. 75–83). New York: Springer.
61.
SousaA. J. (2011). Pragmatic ethics, sensible care: Psychiatry and schizophrenia in North India (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses Database. (Order No. 3472956)
62.
StirratG. M.GillR. (2005). Autonomy in medical ethics after O’Neill. Journal of Medical Ethics, 31, 127–130. doi:10.1136/jme.2004.008292
63.
StoneL.JamesC. (1995). Dowry, bride-burning, and female power in India. Women’s Studies International Forum, 18, 125–134. doi:10.1016/0277-5395(95)80049-U
64.
TriandisH. C.MarínG.LinsankyJ.BetancourtH. (1984). Simpatía as a cultural script of Hispanics. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 47, 1363–1375. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.47.6.1363
65.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2000). Healthy people 2010: Understanding and improving health (2nd ed.). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
66.
ValdesG. (1996). Con respeto: Bridging the distances between culturally diverse families and schools: An ethnographic portrait. New York: Teachers College Press.
67.
van ServellenG.LombardiE. (2005). Supportive relationships and medication adherence in HIV-infected, low-income Latinos. Western Journal of Nursing Research, 27, 1023–1039. doi:10.1177/0193945905279446
68.
VolppL. (2001). Feminism versus multiculturalism. Columbia Law Review, 101, 1181–1218.
69.
WallaceS. P.Mendez-LuckC.CastañedaX. (2009). Heading South: Why Mexican immigrants in California seek health services in Mexico. Medical Care, 47, 662–669. doi:10.1097/mlr.0b013e318190cc95
70.
WangQ. (2010). Doctor-patient communication and patient satisfaction: A cross-cultural comparative study between China and the U.S. (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses Database. (Order No. 3444876)
