Informed consent to treatment (ICT), designed to honor patient autonomy, has been an important subject of inquiry in many disciplines. To foreground the dynamic and dilemmatic tendencies of ICT practice implied by previous inquiries, I advanced relational dialectics theory into the realm of physicians’ experiences with ICT. On performing a dialectical analysis of transcripts from focus group discussions with radiologists, I found them experiencing four primary tensions: (a) between simple and complex ICT; (b) between radiologist and patient control; (c) between standardized and idiosyncratic practice (involving struggles between documentation and conversational process, and between vague and detailed language use); and (d) between withholding and disclosing alternatives. Moreover, I drew on concepts from relational dialectics theory to capture the various ways radiologists negotiate these dialectics. I conclude with practical applications for physician and patient training and interprofessional coordination.
Alfidi, R.J. ( 1971). Informed consent: A study of patient reaction. Journal of the American Medical Association, 216, 1325-1329.
2.
Alfidi, R.J. ( 1975). Controversy, alternatives, and decisions in complying with the legal doctrine of informed consent. Radiology, 114, 232-241.
3.
Bahrick, A.S., & Harris, M.M. ( 2009). Sexual side effects of antidepressant medications: An informed consent accountability gap. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy, 39, 135-143. doi:10.1007/s10879-008-9094-0
4.
Baxter, L. ( 2004). Relationships as dialogues. Personal Relationships, 11, 1-22.
5.
Baxter, L. ( 2007). Problematizing the problem in communication: A dialogic perspective. Communication Monographs, 74, 118-124. doi:10.1080/03637750701196847
6.
Baxter, L.A. ( 1988). A dialectical perspective on communication strategies in relationship development. In S. Duck (Ed.), Handbook of personal relationships (pp. 257-273). New York: Wiley.
7.
Baxter, L.A., & Braithwaite, D.O. (2007). Social dialectics: The contradictions of relating. In B. B. Whaley & W. Samter (Eds.), Explaining communication: Contemporary theories and exemplars (pp. 275-292). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
8.
Baxter, L.A., & Braithwaite, D.O. (2008). Relational dialectics theory: Crafting meanings from competing discourses. In L. A. Baxter & D. O. Braithwaite (Eds.), Engaging theories in interpersonal communication (pp. 349-362). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
9.
Baxter, L.A., & Braithwaite, D.O. (2010). Relational dialectics, applied. In S. W. Smith & S. R. Wilson (Eds.), New directions in interpersonal communication research (pp. 48-66). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
10.
Baxter, L.A., & Montgomery, B.M. (1996). Relating: Dialogues and dialectics. New York: Guilford.
11.
Baxter, L.A., & Montgomery, B.M. (2000). Rethinking communication in personal relationships from a dialectical perspective. In K. Dindia & S. Duck (Eds.), Communication and personal relationships (pp. 31-53). New York: Wiley.
12.
Baxter, L.A., & Simon, E.P. ( 1993). Relationship maintenance strategies and dialectical contradictions in personal relationships. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 10, 225-242.
13.
Beauchamp, T.L., & Childress, J.F. (1994). Principles of biomedical ethics (4th ed.). New York: Oxford University Press.
14.
Berlin, L. ( 2003). Malpractice issues in radiology. American Journal of Roentgenology, 181, 1481-1486.
15.
Borkon, M.J., Cornett, M.B., Pichert, J.W., Yan, G., Hickson, G.B., & Dattilo, J.B. ( 2009). An ex ante analysis of medical malpractice claims risk in vascular surgery. Journal of Vascular Surgery, 49, S21.
16.
Braddock, C.H., Edwards, K., Hasenberg, N., & Levinson, W. ( 1999). Informed decision-making in outpatient practice. Journal of the American Medical Association, 282, 2313-2320.
17.
Bridge, K., & Baxter, L.A., (1992). Blended relationships: Friends as work associates . Western Journal of Communication, 56, 200-225.
18.
Clark, P.A. ( 2007). Intensive care patients’ evaluations of the informed consent process. Dimensions of Critical Care Nursing, 26, 207-226.
19.
Conn, L.G., Lingard, L., Reeves, S., Miller, K.-L., Russell, A., & Zwarenstein, M. (2009). Communication channels in general internal medicine: A description of baseline patterns for improved interprofessional collaboration. Qualitative Health Research , 19, 943-953. doi:10.1177/1049732309338282
20.
Connelly, J.E. ( 1988). Informed consent: An improved perspective. Archives of Internal Medicine, 148, 1266-1268.
21.
Creswell, J.W. ( 1998). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five traditions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
22.
Delany, C. ( 2008). Making a difference: Incorporating theories of autonomy into models of informed consent. Journal of Medical Ethics , 34, 1-5. doi:10.1136/jme.2007.023804
23.
Ehrenkranz, P.D., Pagan, J.A., Begier, E.M., Linas, B.P., Madison, K., & Armstrong, K. ( 2009). Written informed consent statutes and HIV testing. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 37, 57-63. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2009.03.011
Garrud, P., Wood, M., & Stainsby, L. ( 2001). Impact of risk information in a patient education leaflet . Patient Education and Counseling, 43, 301-304.
26.
Gikonyo, C., Bejon, P., Marsh, V., & Molyneux, S. ( 2008). Taking social relationships seriously: Lessons learned from the informed consent practices of a vaccine trial on the Kenyan coast . Social Science & Medicine, 67, 708-720. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2008.02.003
27.
Glaser, B.G. ( 1978). Theoretical sensitivity: Advances in the methodology of grounded theory. Mill Valley, CA: Sociology Press.
28.
Glaser, B.G., & Strauss, A.L. ( 1967). The discovery of grounded theory. Chicago: Aldine
29.
Goddard, A., Murray, C.D., & Simpson, J. ( 2008). Informed consent and psychotherapy: An interpretative phenomenological analysis of therapists’ views. Psychology and Psychotherapy, 81, 177-191. doi:10.1348/147608307X266587
30.
Hickson, G.B., Federspiel, C.F., Pichert, J.W., Miller, C.S., Gauld-Jaeger, J., & Bost, P. ( 2002). Patient complaints and malpractice risk. Journal of the American Medical Association, 287, 2951-2957. doi:10.1001/jama.287.22.2951
31.
Holquist, M. ( 2002). Dialogism (2nd ed.). New York: Routledge.
32.
Irabor, D.O., & Omonzejele, P. (2009). Local attitudes, moral obligation, customary obedience and other cultural practices. Developing World Bioethics, 9, 34-42. doi:10.1111/ j.1471-8847.2007.00198.x
33.
King, J.S., & Moulton, B.W. ( 2006). Rethinking informed consent: The case for shared decision making. American Journal of Law & Medicine, 32, 429-502.
34.
Kramer, M.W. ( 2004). Toward a communication theory of group dialectics: An ethnographic study of a community theater group. Communication Monographs, 71, 311-332. doi:10.1080/0363452042000288292
35.
Krueger, R.A., & Casey, M.A. ( 2000). Focus groups: A practical guide for applied research (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage
36.
LaPook, J. ( 2009, June 8). Is angioplasty worth the risk? CBS Evening News With Katie Couric. Retrieved from http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2009/06/08/eveningnews/main5072841.shtml?tag=mncol;lst;1
37.
Lidz, C.W. ( 2006). The therapeutic misconception and our models of competency and informed consent. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 24, 535-546. doi:10.1002/bsl.700
38.
Lidz, C.W., Appelbaum, P.S., & Meisel, A. ( 1988). Two models of implementing informed consent. Archives of Internal Medicine, 148, 1385-1389.
39.
Lidz, C.W., & Roth, L.H. ( 1983). The signed form-Informed consent? In R. F. Boruch & J. S. Cecil (Eds.), Solutions to ethical and legal problems in social research (pp. 145-157). New York: Academic Press.
40.
Mavroforou, A., Giannoukas, A., Katsamouris, A., & Michalodimitrakis, E. (2002). The importance of communication between physicians and patients: Special considerations in the era of endovascular therapy. International Angiology, 21, 99-102.
41.
Mello, M.M., Studdert, D.M., & Brennan, T.A. ( 2003). The new medical malpractice crisis. New England Journal of Medicine, 348, 2281-2284.
42.
Merckaert, I., Libert, Y., Bron, D., Jaivenois, M., Martiat, P., Slachmuylder, J., & Razavi, D. ( 2009). Impact of life-threatening risk information on the evolution of patients’ anxiety and risk recall. Patient Education and Counseling, 75, 192-198. doi:10.1016/j.pec.2008.09.013
43.
Miller, S.M., Fleisher, L., Pagona, R., Buzaglo, J.S., Schnoll, R., Slater, E., . . . Popa-Mabe, M. ( 2005). Facilitating informed decision making about breast cancer risk and genetic counseling among women calling the NCI’s cancer information service. Journal of Health Communication, 10, 119-136. doi:10.1080/07366290500265335
44.
Mumby, D.K. ( 2005). Theorizing resistance in organization studies: A dialectical approach. Management Communication Quarterly, 19, 19-44. doi:10.1177/0893318905276558
45.
Munch, S., & deKryger, L. ( 2001). Moral wounds: Complicated complications. Journal of the American Medical Association, 285, 1131-1134. doi:10.1001/jama.285.9.1131
46.
National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1978). The Belmont Report (Report No. OS78-0012). Washington, DC: DHEW Publication .
47.
Olufowote, J.O. ( 2008). A structurational analysis of informed consent to treatment: Societal evolution, contradiction, and reproductions in medical practice. Health Communication, 23, 292-303. doi:10.1080/10410230802056404
48.
Olufowote, J.O. ( 2009). A structurational analysis of informed consent to treatment: (Re)productions of contradictory sociohistorical structures in practitioners’ interpretive schemes. Qualitative Health Research, 19, 802-814. doi:10.1177/1049732309335605
49.
Olufowote, J.O. ( 2010). Informed consent to treatment’s sociohistorical discourse of traditionalism: A structurational analysis of radiology residents’ accounts. Health Communication, 25, 22-31. doi:10.1080/10410230903473508
50.
Ormond, K.E., Banuvar, S., Daly, A., Iris, M., Minogue, J., & Elias, S. ( 2009). Information preferences of high literacy pregnant women regarding informed consent models for genetic carrier screening. Patient Education and Counseling, 75, 244-250. doi:10.1016/j.pec.2008.09.020
51.
Pitts, M.J., Fowler, C., Kaplan, M.S., Nussbaum, J., & Becker, J.C. ( 2009). Dialectical tensions underpinning family farm succession planning. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 37, 59-79. doi:10.1080/00909880802592631
52.
Rawlins, W.K. ( 1989). A dialectical analysis of the tensions, functions, and strategic challenges of communication in young adult friendships. Communication Yearbook, 12, 157-189.
53.
Sand, K., Loge, J.H., Berger, O., Gronberg, B.H., & Kaasa, S. ( 2008). Lung cancer patients’ perceptions of informed consent documents. Patient Education and Counseling, 73, 313-317. doi:10.1016/j.pec.2008.06.011
54.
Studdert, D.M., Mello, M.M., & Brennan, T.A. ( 2004). Medical malpractice. New England Journal of Medicine, 350, 283-292.
55.
Sulmasy, D.P., Lehman, L.S., Levine, D.M., & Faden, R.R. ( 1994). Patients’ perceptions of the quality of informed consent for common medical procedures. Journal of Clinical Ethics, 5, 189-194.
56.
Toller, P.W. ( 2005). Negotiation of dialectical contradictions by parents who have experienced the death of a child. Journal of Applied Communication Research, 33, 46-66. doi:10.1080/0090988042000318512
57.
Vermeulen, E. ( 2004). Dealing with doubt: Making decisions in a neonatal ward in The Netherlands. Social Science & Medicine, 59, 2071-2085. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2004.03.010
58.
Waller, B.N., & Repko, R.A. ( 2008). Informed consent: Good medicine, dangerous side effects . Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 17, 66-74. doi:10.1017/ S0963180108080079
Williamson, C. ( 2005). Withholding policies from patients restricts their autonomy . British Medical Journal, 331, 1078-1080.
61.
Wofford, M.M., Wofford, J.L., Bothra, J., Kendrick, B., Smith, A., & Lichstein, P.R. (2004). Patient complaints about physician behaviors: A qualitative study. Academic Medicine , 79, 134-138.
62.
Wu, W.C., & Pearlman, R.A. (1988). Consent in medical decision-making: The role of communication. Journal of General Internal Medicine , 3, 9-14.
63.
Young, A.J., Kim, L., Li, S., Baker, J.N., Schmidt, M., Camp, J.W., & Barfield, R.C. (2010). Agency and communication challenges in discussions of informed consent in pediatric cancer research . Qualitative Health Research, 20, 628-643. doi:10.1177/1049732310361467
64.
Yu, W. ( 2004). Patient complaints brought to legal counsel. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 30, 415. doi:10.1016/j. jen.2004.07.030
