Evaluating Social Work Practice in a Medical Setting: How Do We Meet the Challenges of a Rapidly Changing System?

Abstract

Social work's response to a rapidly changing health care system requires an empirical approach to practice. However, most empirical studies that evaluate social work services emphasize productivity and efficiency instead of effectiveness. This article examines the following ques tions : (a) What is the nature of contemporary social work practice in a medical setting? (b) What accounts for the effectiveness of social work interventions? (c) Does the currentpractice ofsocial workers meet the demands of a changing health care system? Social workers in a large metropolitan hospital collected data on 60 cases. Descriptive data regarding the types of presenting problems, nsk factors that complicate these problems, interventions, and obstacles to service delivery are presented. Regression analyses showed that the obstacles were the strongest predictors of the overall outcome of the cases. The authors discuss the implications of the rapidly changing medical system on social workers' activities.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Berkman, B. , Bedell, D. , Parker, E. , McCarthy, L. , & Rosenbaum, C. (1988). Preadmission screening: An efficacy study Social Work in Health Care, 13(3), 35-50.

Coulton, C.J. , Keller, S.M. , & Boone, C.R. (1985). Predicting social workers' expenditure of time with hospital patients Health and Social Work , 10(1), 35-44.

Craft, J.L. (1990). Statistics and data analysis for social workers Itasca, IL: F. E. Peacock.

Evans, R. , Hendricks, D. , Lawrence-Umlauf, K. , & Bishop, D. (1989). Timing of social work intervention and medical patients' length of hospital stay Health and Social Work , 14, 277-282.

Holden, M. (1989). Meeting diagnostic related group goals for elderly patients Health and Social Work, 14, 13-21.

Mayer, J. , Kapust, L. , Mulcahey, A. , Helfand, L. , Heinlein, A. , Seltzer, M. , Litchfield, L. , & Levin, R. (1990). Empowering families of the chronically ill: A partnership experience in a hospital setting Social Work in Health Care, 14, 73-90.

Oktay, J. , Steinwachs, D. , Mamon, J. , Bone, L. , & Fahey, M. (1992). Evaluating social work discharge planning services for elderly people: Access, complexity and outcome Health and Social Work, 17, 290-298.

Polinsky, M. , Fred, C. , & Ganz, P. (1991). Quantitative and qualitative assessment of a case management program for cancer patients Health and Social Work, 16, 176-183.

Price, R.H. (1986). Foreword In E. J. Thomas (Ed.), Designing interventions for the helping professions (pp. 7-8). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

10.

Reardon, G. , Blumenfield, S. , Weissman, A. , & Rosenberg, G. (1988). Findings and implications from preadmission screening of elderly patients waiting for elective surgery Social Work in Health Care, 13, 51-63.

11.

Soskolne, V. , & Auslander, G. (1993). Follow-up evaluation of discharge planning by social workers in an acute-care medical center in Israel Social Work in Health Care, 18 , 23-48.

12.

Subramanian, K. , & Rose, S. (1988). Social work and the treatment of chronic pain Health and Social Work, 13(1), 49-60.

13.

Thomas, E.J. (1984). Designing interventions for the helping professions Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

14.

Turnbull, J.E. , Saltz, C.C. , & Gwyther, L.P. (1988). A prescription for promoting social work research in a university hospital Health and Social Work , 13, 97-105.

15.

Wimberly, E.T. (1988). Using productivity measures to avoid reductions in force Social Work, 33(1), 60-61.