Objective: To examine the effectiveness of interventions for incarcerated women. Method: The researchers use a two-model system: the risk-reduction model for studies analyzing interventions to reduce recidivism rates, and the enhancement model for studies that target psychological and physical well-being. Results: Incarcerated women who participate in substance abuse interventions appear less likely to reoffend than those who do not participate. Enhancement model studies report mixed results. Overall, psychological-oriented interventions and substance abuse programs improve mental health symptoms and substance use among participants as compared to control or comparison groups. Results for HIV prevention programs are ambiguous, and parenting skill programs show no significant effect. Conclusion: Results highlight interventions that appear useful with female inmates. More rigorous research is needed to address many of these evidence-based interventions.
References marked with an asterisk indicate studies included in the meta-analysis.
2.
American Psychiatric Association (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed., text revision). Washington, DC: Author.
3.
Andrews, D.A., & Bonta, J. ( 1998). Psychology of criminal conduct. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson Publishing Co.
4.
Ashley, O., Marsden, M.E., & Brady, T.M. ( 2003). Effectiveness of substance abuse treatment programming for women: A review. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 29, 19-53.
5.
Beck, A. ( 2000). Prison and jail inmates at midyear 2000. Bureau of Justice Statistics Bulletin. Washington. DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
6.
Bedard, L.E., Pate, K.N., & Roe-Sepowitz, D.E. (2003). A program analysis of Esuba: Helping turn abuse around for inmates. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 47, 597-607.
7.
Belknap, J., & Holsinger, K. ( 2006). The gendered nature of risk factors for delinquency. Feminist Criminology, 1, 48-71.
8.
Bilchik, S., Seymour, C., & Kreisher, K. ( 2001). Parents in prison. Corrections Today , 63, 108-111.
9.
Bloom, B., & Steinhart, D. ( 1993). Why punish the children? A reappraisal of the children of incarcerated mothers in America. San Francisco, CA: National Council on Crime and Delinquency.
10.
Bonta, J., Pang, B., & Wallace-Capretta, S. (1995). Predictors of recidivism among incarcerated female offenders. The Prison Journal, 75, 277-294.
11.
Borenstein, M., Hedges, L., Higgins, J., & Rothstein, H. ( 2005). Comprehensive meta analysis (computer program). Englewood, NJ: Biostat.
12.
Borrill, J., Snow, L., Medlicott, D., Teers, R., & Paton, J. ( 2005). Learning from ‘near misses’: Interviews with women who survived an incident of severe self-harm in prison. The Howard Journal, 44, 57-69.
13.
*Bradley, R.G., & Follingstad, D.R. (2003). Group therapy for incarcerated women who experienced interpersonal violence: A pilot study. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 16, 337-340.
14.
Byrd, P.M., & David, J.L. ( 2009). Violent behavior in female inmates. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 24, 379-392.
15.
Card, N.A. ( 2009). Meta-analysis: Quantitative synthesis of social science research. New York: Guilford.
16.
Chesney-Lind, M. ( 1998, November). What to do about girls? Promising perspectives and effective programs. Paper presented at the meeting of the annual American Society for Criminology, Washington, DC.
17.
Chung, J., & Magraw, M.M. ( 1992). A group approach to psychosocial issues faced by HIV-positive women. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 43, 891-894.
18.
Cohen, J. ( 1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
19.
*Cole, K.L., Sarlund-Heinrich, P., & Brown, L.S. ( 2007). Developing and assessing effectiveness of a time-limited therapy group for incarcerated women survivors of childhood sexual abuse. Journal of Trauma & Dissociation, 8, 97-121.
20.
Covington, S. ( 1998). Creating gender-specific treatment for substance-abusing women and girls in community corrections settings. The ICCA Journal on Community Corrections, December, 24-29.
21.
Cullen, F.T., & Gendreau, P. ( 2001). From nothing works to what works: Changing professional ideology in the 21st century. The Prison Journal, 71, 313-338.
22.
De Leon, G. ( 1986). The therapeutic community for substance abuse: Perspective and approach. In D. De Leon & J. T. Zeigenfuss (Eds.), Therapeutic communities for addictions: Readings in theory, research and practice (pp. 5-18). Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.
23.
Deschenes, E.P., Owen, B., & Crow, J. ( 2007). Recidivism among female prisoners: Secondary analysis of the 1994 BJS data set. Retrieved June10, 2009, from www.ncjrs.gov/App/Publications/ abstract.aspx?ID=238573.
24.
Doob, A.N., & Webster, C.M. ( 2006). Countering punitiveness: Understanding stability in Canada’s imprisonment rate. Law and Society Review, 40, 325-368.
25.
Dowden, C., & Andrews, D.A. ( 1999). What works for female offenders: A meta-analytic review . Crime & Delinquency, 45, 438-452.
26.
Dowden, C., & Blanchette, K. (2002). An evaluation of the effectiveness of substance abuse programming for female offenders. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 46, 220-230.
27.
Dowden, C., & Brown, S.L. ( 2002). The role of substance abuse factors in predicting recidivism: A meta-analysis. Canadian Journal of Criminology, 8, 243-264.
28.
Eamon, K.C., Munchua, M.M., & Reddon, J.R. ( 2001). Effectiveness of an anger management program for women inmates. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 34, 45-60.
29.
*El-Bassel, N., Ivanoff, A., Schilling, R.F., Gilbert, L., Borne, D., & Chen, D.R. ( 1995). Preventing HIV/AIDS in drug-abusing incarcerated women through skills building and social support enhancement: Preliminary outcomes . Social Work Research, 19, 131-141.
30.
Gendreau, P. ( 1981). Treatment in corrections: Martinson was wrong. Canadian Psychology/Psychologie Canadienne, 22, 332-338.
31.
*Gonzalez, P., Romero, T., & Cerbana, C.B. ( 2007). Parent education program for incarcerated mothers in Colorado. Journal of Correctional Education, 58, 357-373.
32.
Green, B.L., Miranda, J., Daroowalla, A., & Siddique, J. ( 2005). Trauma exposure, mental health functioning, and program needs of women in jail. Crime and Delinquency, 51, 133-151.
*Hall, E.A., Prendergast, M.L., Wellisch, J., Patten, M., & Cao, Y. ( 2004). Treating drug-abusing women prisoners: An outcomes evaluation of the Forever Free program. The Prison Journal, 84, 81-105.
35.
*Harm, N.J., & Thompson, P.J. (1997). Evaluating the effectiveness of parent education for incarcerated mothers. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 24, 135-152.
36.
Harm, N.J., Thompson, P.J., & Chambers, H. ( 1998). The effectiveness of parent education for substance abusing women offenders. Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly, 16, 63-77.
37.
Heilbrun, K., DeMatteo, D., Fretz, R., Erickson, J., Gerardi, D., & Halper, C. ( 2008). Criminal recidivism of female offenders: The importance of structured, community-based aftercare. Corrections Compendium , 33, 1-32.
38.
Hillman, C.A. ( 2006). Assessing the impact of virtual visitation on familial communication and institutional adjustment for women in prison. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, City University of New York.
39.
Huedo-Medina, T.B., Sanchez-Meca, J., Marin-Martinez, F., & Botella, J. ( 2006). Assessing heterogeneity in meta-analysis: Q statistic or I2 Index? Psychological Methods, 11, 193-206.
40.
James, D.J., & Glaze, L.E. ( 2006). Mental health problems of prison and jail inmates (Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report NCJ 213600). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs .
41.
Johnson, H. ( 2006). Drug use by incarcerated women offenders. Drug and Alcohol Review, 25, 433-437.
42.
*Johnson, J.E., & Zlotnick, C. ( 2008). A pilot study of group interpersonal psychotherapy for depression in substance-abusing female prisoners. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 34, 371-377.
43.
Klein, S.R., & Bahr, S.J. ( 1996). An evaluation of a family-centered cognitive skills program for prison inmates. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 40, 334-346.
44.
Koons, B.A., Burrow, J.D., Morash, M., & Bynum, T. ( 1997). Expert and offender perceptions of program elements linked to successful outcomes for incarcerated women. Crime and Delinquency , 43, 512-532.
45.
Langan, P.A., & Levin, D.J. ( 2002). Recidivism of prisoners released in 1994 (Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report NCJ 193427). Washington DC: U.S. Department of Justice. Retrieved June 30, 2009, from http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/pdf/rpr94.pdf.
46.
Lipsey, M.W., & Wilson, D.B. ( 2001). Practical meta-analysis: Applied social research method series. (Vol. 49). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
47.
Martinson, R.M. ( 1974). What works? Questions and answers about prison reform . The Public Interest, 35, 22-54.
48.
McLeod, B.D., & Weisz, J.R. ( 2004). Using dissertations to examine potential bias in child and adolescent clinical trials. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 72, 235-251.
49.
Messina, N., Burdon, W., Hagopian, G., & Prendergast, M. (2006). Predictors of prison-based treatment outcomes: A comparison of men and women participants. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 32, 7-28.
50.
*Messina, N., Burdon, W., & Prendergast, M. (2006). Prison-based treatment for drug-dependent women offenders: Treatment versus no treatment. Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 3, 333-343.
51.
Messina, N., & Grella, C. ( 2006). Childhood trauma and women’s health outcomes in a California prison population. American Journal of Public Health, 96, 1842-1848.
52.
Milligan, R., & Andrews, B. ( 2005). Suicidal and other self-harming behavior in offender women: The role of shame, anger, and childhood abuse. Legal and Criminological Psychology, 10, 13-25.
53.
*Moore, A.R., & Clement, M.J. ( 1998). Effects of parenting training for incarcerated mothers . Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 27, 57-72.
54.
*Mosher, C., & Phillips, D. ( 2006). The dynamics of a prison-based therapeutic for women offenders: Retention, completion, and outcomes. The Prison Journal, 86, 6-31.
55.
Nugent, W.R. ( 2006). The comparability of the standardized mean difference effect size across different measures of the same construct: Measurement considerations . Educational and Psychological Measurement, 66, 612-623.
56.
Nugent, W.R. ( 2009). Construct validity invariance and discrepancies in meta-analytic effect sizes based on different measures: A simulation study. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 69, 62-78.
57.
Palusci, V., Crum, P., Bliss, R., & Bavolek, S. ( 2008). Changes in parenting attitudes and knowledge among inmates and other at-risk population after a family nurturing program. Children and Youth Services, 30, 79-89.
58.
Pelissier, B.M.M., Camp, S.D., Gaes, G.G., Saylor, W.G., & Rhodes, W. ( 2003). Gender differences in outcomes from prison-based residential treatment. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 24, 149-160.
59.
Pelissier, B.M.M., Motivans, M., & Rounds-Bryant, J.L. (2005). Substance abuse treatment outcomes: A multi-site study of male and female prison programs. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 41, 57-80.
60.
*Perkins, R. ( 1998). The efficacy of mindfulness-based techniques in the reduction of stress in a sample if incarcerated women. Unpublished doctoral dissertation , Florida State University.
61.
Peugh, J., & Belenko, S. ( 1999). Substance-involved women inmates: Challenges to providing effective treatment. The Prison Journal, 79, 23-44.
62.
Pew Center on the States. (2008). One in 100: Behind Bars in America 2008. Washington, DC : Author. Retrieved June 30, 2009 , from http://www.pewcenteronthestates.org/report_detail.aspx?id=35904 .
63.
*Peyrot, M., Yen, S., & Baldassano, C. (1994). Short-term substance abuse prevention in jail: A cognitive-behavioral approach. Journal of Drug Education, 24, 33-47.
64.
*Pomeroy, E.C., Green, D.L., & Kiam, R. ( 2001). Female juvenile offenders incarcerated as adults: A psychoeducational group intervention. Journal of Social Work, 1, 101-115.
65.
*Pomeroy, E.C., Kiam, R., & Abel, E.M. ( 1999). The effectiveness of a psychoeducational group for HIV-infected/affected incarcerated women. Research on Social Work Practice, 9, 171-187.
66.
*Prendergast, M.L., Wellisch, J., & Wong, M.M. ( 1996). Residential treatment for women parolees following prison-based drug treatment: Treatment experiences, needs and services, and outcomes. The Prison Journal, 76, 253-274.
67.
Prothrow-Stith, D., & Spivak, H. ( 2005). Sugar and spice and no longer nice: Preventing violence among girls. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass .
*Sacks, J.Y., Sacks, S., McKendrick, K., Banks, S., Schoenberger, M., Hamilton, Z., et al. (2008). Prison therapeutic community treatment for female offenders: Profiles and preliminary findings for mental health and other variables (crime, substance use, and HIV risk). Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 46, 233-261.
70.
Salisbury, E., & Van Voorhis, P. (2009). Gendered pathways: A quantitative investigation of women probationers’ paths to incarceration. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 36, 541-566.
71.
*Samuelson, M., Carmody, J., Kabat-Zinn, J., & Bratt, M.A. ( 2007). Mindfulness-based stress reduction in Massachusetts correctional facilities. The Prison Journal, 87, 254-268.
72.
Schram, P.J., & Morash, M. ( 2002). Evaluation of a life skills program for women inmates in Michigan. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 34, 47-70.
73.
Shadish, W.R., & Haddock, C.K. ( 1994). Combining estimates of effect size. In C. Harris & H. Larry (Eds.), The handbook of research synthesis (pp. 97-109). New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
74.
Siegal, H.A., Wang, J., Carlson, R.G., Falck, R.S., Rahman, A.M., & Fine, R.L. ( 1999). Ohio’s prison-based therapeutic community treatment programs for substance abusers: Preliminary analysis of re-arrest data. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 28, 33-48.
75.
Sorbello, L., Eccleston, L., Ward, T., & Jones, R. ( 2002). Treatment needs of female offenders: A review. Australian Psychologist, 37, 198-205.
76.
*Spiropoulos, G.V., Spruance, L., Van Voorhis, P., & Schmitt, M.M. ( 2005). Pathfinders and problem solving: Comparing effects of two cognitive-behavioral programs among men and women offenders in community and in prison. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 42, 69-94.
77.
Spohn, R.E. ( 2000). Gender differences in the effect of child maltreatment on criminal activity over the life course. In G. L. Fox & M. L. Benson (Eds.), Families, crime and criminal justice (Vol. 2, pp. 207-231). Amsterdam: JAI.
78.
St Lawrence, . J.S., Eldridge, G.D., Shelby, M.C., Little, C.E., Brasfield, T.L., & O’Bannon, R.E. III. (1997). HIV risk reduction for incarcerated women: A comparison of brief interventions based on two theoretical models. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 65, 504-509.
79.
Steurer, S.J., & Smith, L.G. ( 2003). Education reduces crime: Three-state recidivism study executive summary. Correctional Education Association. Retrieved June 30, 2009, from http://www.ceanational.org/PDFs/EdReducesCrime.
80.
*Sultan, F.E., & Long, G.T. ( 1988). Treatment of the sexually/ physically abused female inmate: Evaluation of an intensive short-term intervention program. Journal of Offender Counseling, Services & Rehabilitation, 12, 131-143.
81.
*Thompson, P.J., & Harm, N.J. ( 2000). Parenting from prison: Helping children and mothers. Issues in Comprehensive Pediatric Nursing, 23, 61-81.
82.
Travis, J. ( 2005). But they all come back: Facing the challenges of prisoner reentry. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.
83.
*Valentine, P.V., & Smith, T.E. ( 2001). Evaluating traumatic incident reduction therapy with female inmates: A randomized controlled clinical trial. Research on Social Work Practice, 11, 40-52.
84.
Wallace, A.J. ( 2007). A program evaluation of the Kentucky Correctional Institution for women’s psychiatric care unit. Unpublished doctoral dissertation , Spalding University.
85.
Ward, T., & Stewart, C. ( 2003). Criminogenic needs and human needs: A theoretical model . Psychology, Crime, and Law, 9, 125-143.
86.
Wells, K., & Littrell, J. ( 2005, January). Assessment of study quality. Paper presented at the Ninth Annual Conference of the Society for Social Work and Research, Miami, FL.
87.
West, H.S., & Sabol, W.J. ( 2009). Prison inmates at Midyear 2008- Statistical tables. Bureau of Justice Statistics, U. S. Department of Justice .
88.
Wexler, H.K., Falkin, G.P., & Lipton, D.S. ( 1990). Outcome evaluation of a prison therapeutic community for substance abuse treatment. Criminal Justice and Behavior , 17, 71-92.
89.
Wolff, N., Blitz, C.L., & Shi, J. ( 2007). Rates of sexual victimization in prison for inmates with and without mental disorders. Psychiatric Services, 58, 1087-1094.
90.
Young, D.S., & Mattucci, R.F. (2006). Enhancing the vocational skills of incarcerated women through a plumbing maintenance program. Journal of Correctional Education, 57, 126-140.
91.
Young, M.C., Gartner, J., O’Connor, T., Larson, D., & Wright, K. ( 1995). Long-term recidivism among federal inmates trained as volunteer prison ministers. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation , 22, 97-118.
92.
*Zlotnick, C., Najavits, L.M., Rohsenow, D.J., & Johnson, D.M. ( 2003). A cognitive-behavioral treatment for incarcerated women with substance abuse disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder: Findings from a pilot study. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 25, 99-105.
