Although much research has examined the occupational health and safety (OHS) and workers’ compensation (WC) implications of precarious employment and temporary international labor migration, little is known about the implications of diverse types of employment-related geographic mobility for regulatory effectiveness of OHS and WC. This article examines different types of extended mobility to determine regulatory effectiveness of OHS and WC protections. Based on classic legal analysis in seven Canadian jurisdictions, and interviews with key informants, we found that the invisibility of the internally mobile workforce, as well as the alternating visibility and invisibility of temporary foreign workers, contribute to reduced effectiveness of the OHS and WC regulation. Results point to the need for better protections to address working conditions, but also the hazards and challenges associated with mobility itself including getting to and from work, living at work, and maintaining work–life balance while living at the worksite.
NeisBLippelK.Occupational health and safety and the mobile workforce: insights from a Canadian research program. New Solut2019;
29: 297–316. Epub ahead of print. doi:10.1177/1048291119876681.
2.
QuinlanM.The effects of non-standard forms of employment on worker health and safety. Report, International Labour Office, Geneva, Switzerland, 2015.
3.
QuinlanMMayhewCBohleP.The global expansion of precarious employment, work disorganization, and consequences for occupational health: a review of recent research. Int J Health Serv2001;
31: 335–414.
4.
CedilloLLippelKNakacheD.Factors influencing the health and safety of temporary foreign workers in skilled and low-skilled occupations in Canada. New Solut2019;
29: 422–458. Epub ahead of print 7 August 2019. doi:10.1177/1048291119867757.
5.
HillNDorowSBarnetsonB, et al.
Occupational health and safety for domestic workers in Canada: dimensions of (im)mobility. New Solut2019;
29: 397–421. Epub ahead of print 9 August 2019. doi:10.1177/1048291119867740.
6.
SargeantMTuckerE.Layers of vulnerability in occupational safety and health for migrant workers: case studies from Canada and the UK. Policy Pract Heal Saf2009;
7: 51–73.
7.
ShanDLippelK.Occupational health and safety challenges from employment-related geographical mobility among Canadian seafarers on the Great Lakes and St. Lawrence Seaway. New Solut2019;
29: 371–396. Epub ahead of print 22 August 2019. doi:10.1177/1048291119870762.
8.
WaltersDJohnstoneRFrickK, et al.Regulating workplace risks: A comparative study of inspection regimes in times of change. Cheltenham, England: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2011.
9.
JohnstoneR. Labour law: a regulatory perspective. In: Stewart A, Forsyth A, Irving M, et al. (eds) Creighton & Stewart’s labour law. Alexandria: The Federation Press, 2016, pp. 19–44.
10.
JohnstoneRStewartA.Swimming against the tide? Australian labor regulation and the fissured workplace. Comp Labour Law Policy J2015;
37: 55–90.
LippelK.L’avenir du droit de la santé et de la sécurité du travail dans le contexte de la mondialisation. Ottawa Law Rev/Droit D’Ottawa2016;
47: 535–556.
13.
LippelK.Law, public policy and mental health in the workplace. Healthc Pap2011;
11: 20–37.
14.
LippelKCoxR. Regulation as intervention: how regulatory design can affect practices and behaviours in the workplace. In: D’Cruz P, Noronha E and Caponecchia C, Jordi Escartin, Denise Salin, and Michelle R. Tuckey (eds) Dignity and inclusion at work: Handbooks of workplace bullying, emotional abuse and harassment. Singapore: Springer Nature, forthcoming.
15.
LippelKSikkaA.Access to workers’ compensation benefits and other legal protections for work-related mental health problems: a Canadian overview. Can J Public Health2010;
101Suppl 1: S16–S22.
16.
KeefeABornsteinSNeisB.An environmental scan of presumptive coverage for work-related psychological injury (including post-traumatic stress disorder) in Canada and selected international jurisdictions. Report prepared for Workplace NL, St. John’s, NL, 2018.
17.
Gesualdi-FecteauD,
Nakache D and Matte Guilmain L. Travel time as working time? Nature and scope of labor law’s protections for mobile workers. New Solut2019;
29: 349–370. Epub ahead of print 12 August 2019. doi:10.1177/1048291119867750.
18.
BittleSChenAHébertJ.Work-related deaths in Canada. Labour/Le Trav2018;
82: 159–187.
19.
KangS-KKwonO-J.Occupational injury statistics in Korea. Saf Health Work2011;
2: 52–56.
20.
Rusli BinN.Rising trend of work-related commuting accidents, deaths, injuries and disabilities in developing countries: a case study of Malaysia. Ind Health2014;
52: 275–277.
21.
Camino LópezMAGonzález GonzálezDRitzelDO, et al.
Accidents in working hours & accidents while commuting: Spain. J Saf Health Environ Res2015;
11: 242–252.
22.
MerciecaPChappertFTherryP.Photographie statistique des accidents de travail, des accidents de trajet et des maladies professionnelles en France selon le sexe entre 2001 et 2016. Report, Anact (L’agence nationale pour l’amélioration des conditions de travail), Paris, France, 2018.
23.
ParidonHMParidonCMBindziusFA.The German Berufsgenossenschaften (institutions for statutory accident insurance and prevention): organisation, mandate and activities in the area of mental health. Int J Law Psychiatry2007;
30: 400–415.
24.
European Agency for Safety and Health at Work. New risks and trends in the safety and health of women at work. Report, European Agency for Safety and Health at Work, Luxembourg, 2013.
25.
FitzpatrickKNeisB.On the move and working alone: policy implications of the experiences of unionised Newfoundland and Labrador homecare workers. Policy Pract Heal Saf2015;
13: 47–67.
26.
QuinlanMBohlePRawlings-WayO.Health and safety of homecare workers engaged by temporary employment agencies. J Ind Relat2015;
57: 94–114.
PreibischKOteroG.Does citizenship status matter in Canadian agriculture? Workplace health and safety for migrant and immigrant laborers. Rural Sociol2014;
79: 174–199.
29.
Construction camp rules and regulations for construction camp accommodations, approved by the Building Trades of Alberta and Construction Labour Relations—An Alberta Association, 2010-2018, s. 3.01., http://www.ualocal179.com/pdfs/agreements/CampAgreement2010-2018.pdf (accessed 10 February 2018).
30.
GailliéMOlivier-GobeilJBrodeurC.La Néo-féodalisation du droit du travail agricole: étude de cas sur les conditions de travail et de vie des travailleurs agricoles migrants à Saint-Rémi (Québec), Cahiers du GIREPS, Québec, No. 8. Montréal, Canada, http://www.archipel.uqam.ca/10722/1/Rapport_DroitTravail_Online.pdf (2017, accessed 28 July 2019).
IsonTG.A historical perspective on contemporary challenges in workers’ compensation. Osgoode Hall Law J1996;
34: 807–833.
36.
CoxR. From sexual to psychological harassment: one step forward, twenty-five years back for women’s equality at work? In: Day S, Lamarche L and Norman K (eds) 14 Arguments in favour of human rights institutions. Toronto: The Federation Press, Irwin Law Inc., pp. 237–276.
37.
LippelK.Workers’ compensation for asbestos related disease in five Canadian provinces. Report, Canadian Partnership Against Cancer and the Occupational Health Clinics for Ontario Workers (OHCOW), Toronto, Canada, 2010.
LippelKEakinJMHolnessDL, et al.
The structure and process of workers’ compensation systems and the role of doctors: a comparison of Ontario and Québec. Am J Ind Med2016;
59: 1070–1086.
40.
LippelK.Strengths and weaknesses of regulatory systems designed to prevent work disability after injury or illness: an overview of mechanisms in a selection of Canadian compensation systems. In: MacEachenE (ed) The science and politics of work disability prevention.
New York:
Routledge, 2019, pp. 50–71.
41.
AllenD.‘For here or to go?’ Migrant workers and the enforcement of workplace rights in Canada: temporary foreign workers in the British Columbia hospitality sector. Master of Laws Thesis. University of Victoria, Victoria, Canada, 2017.
42.
FanZJFoleyMPRauserE, et al.
Effects of residential location and work-commuting on long-term work disability. J Occup Rehabil2013;
23: 610–620.
43.
LavoieCAVoaklanderDBeachJR, et al.
The association between rurality and return to work for workers’ compensation claimants with work-related musculoskeletal injuries: an analysis of workers who failed to return to work within typical healing time frames. Int J Occup Med Environ Health2017;
30: 715–729.
44.
GravelSVillanuevaFBernsteinS, et al.
Les mesures de santé et sécurité au travail auprès des travailleurs étrangers temporaires dans les entreprises saisonnières. Pistes2014; 16. doi:10.4000/pistes.3912.
45.
DubéJGravelS.Les pratiques préventives auprès des travailleurs d’agences de location de personnel temporaire ou permanent: comparaison entre les travailleurs immigrants et non immigrants. Pistes2014; 16. doi:10.4000/pistes.3911.
46.
GrzywaczJGLipscombHJCasanovaV, et al.
Organization of work in the agricultural, forestry, and fishing sector in the US southeast: implications for immigrant workers’ occupational safety and health. Am J Ind Med2013;
56: 925–939.
47.
RathodJ.Beyond the ‘chilling effect’: immigrant worker behavior and the regulation of occupational safety & health. Empl Rights Employ Policy J2010;
14: 267.
JoynerAMGeorgeLHallML, et al.
Federal farmworker housing standards and regulations, their promise and limitations, and implications for farmworker health. New Solut2015;
25: 334–352.
50.
ArcuryTAJacobsIJRuizV.Farmworker housing quality and health. New Solut2015;
25: 256–262.
51.
DécosseF. Maisons de campagne: sociologie du logement des ouvriers agricoles étrangers sous contrats saisonniers OFII. In: Canepari E, Mésini S and Mourlane S (eds) Mobil hom(m)es: formes d’habitats et façon d’habiter la mobilité. La tour d’aigues: les éditions de l’Aube, 2016, pp. 135–143.
52.
WaltersDWadsworthEJohnstoneR, et al.The role and effects of representing miners in arrangements for safety and health in coal mining: a global study. Report, Institution of Occupational Safety and Health (IOSH), Leicester, England, www.iosh.co.uk/coalmining (2018, accessed 8 July 2019).
53.
MacEachenESaundersRLippelK, et al.Understanding the occupational health and safety inspection process in a changing labour market. Research study funded by Ontario Ministry of Labour, Ontario, Canada.
54.
Thébaud-MonyA.Nuclear servitude: subcontracting and health in the French civil nuclear industry.
New York:
Baywood, 2011.
55.
LippelKMacEachenESaundersR, et al.
Legal protections governing the occupational safety and health and workers’ compensation of temporary employment agency workers in Canada: reflections on regulatory effectiveness. Policy Pract Heal Saf2011;
9: 69–90.
56.
NewhookJTNeisBJacksonL, et al.
Employment-related mobility and the health of workers, families, and communities: the Canadian context. Labour/Le Trav2011;
67: 121–156.
57.
PremjiS.Precarious employment and difficult daily commutes. Relat Ind Relat2017;
72: 77–98.
58.
LippelKJohnstoneRBaril-GingrasG.Regulation, change and the work environment. Relat Ind Relat2017;
72: 3–16.
59.
McLaughlinJHennebryJHainesT.Paper versus practice: occupational health and safety protections and realities for temporary foreign agricultural workers in Ontario. Pistes2014; 16. doi:10.4000/pistes.3844.
