Reforming Miners’ Lung Disease Compensation in South Africa—Long Overdue but What Are the Options?

Abstract

A number of countries have workers’ compensation systems which reserve specific arrangements for workers in certain sectors, notably mining. This article describes the current impetus to reform of the century-old South African mining compensation system. It is intended as a case study of the implications of harmonization of two disparate compensation systems for occupational lung disease, specifically in relation to equity in financial benefits, equity in coverage, linkage of compensation to disease prevention, and efficient administration. After decades of neglect, it is clear that while inferior financial benefits for miners are no longer tenable, the costs of equalization are not supportable by the current actuarial status of the miners’ Compensation Fund. There is also an argument for two miner-specific entitlements to be retained—free medical examinations for ex-miners and autopsy-based posthumous compensation. A new dispensation to support the casualties of a declining industry will require sustained political will.

Keywords

mining compensation silicosis coverage prevention efficiency South Africa

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Pecillo M. International comparison of occupational accident insurance system. European Agency for Safety and Health Work, http://oshwiki.eu/wiki/International_comparison_of_occupational_accident_insurance_system (2013, accessed 2015 May 15).

Chamber of Mines of South Africa. The South African mining sector in 2013: facts and figures 2013/2014, https://commondatastorage.googleapis.com/comsa/f_f_2014_final.pdf (undated, accessed 15 May 2015).

Harington

McGlashan

Chelkowska

. A century of migrant labour in the gold mines of South Africa. J S Afr Inst Min Metall 2004; 104: 65–71.

McCulloch

. South Africa’s gold mines and the politics of silicosis, New York, NY: James Currey, 2012.

Ehrlich

. A century of miner’s compensation in South Africa. Am J Ind Med 2012; 55: 560–569. DOI: 10.1002/ajim.22030.

van Wyngaardt M. SA mining health compensation seen as complex, overlapping, www.miningweekly.com/article/sa-statutory-mining-health-compensation-seen-as-complex-in-need-of-reform-2010-07-30 (2010, accessed 30 April 2015).

Constitutional Court of South Africa (Khmpepe J). Themekile Mankai v Anglogold Ashanti Limited, 2011. Case CCT 40/10. ZACC3.

Case studies: legacy of silicosis. Report to Society, Anglogold Ashanti, 119–129, http://www.anglogoldashanti.com/en/Media/Reports/Sustainability%20Reports/AGA-sustainable-gold-2006.pdf (2006, accessed 30 April 2015).

Medical Bureau for Occupational Diseases: management report, http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/140827management.pdf (2014, accessed 30 April 2015).

10.

Compensation commission for occupational diseases on its 2015/16 strategic and annual performance plan, http://www.samed.org.za/Filemanager/userfiles/Compensation%20Commission%20for%20Occupational%20Diseases%20on%20its%202015%20and%202016.pdf (2015, accessed 16 May 2015).

11.

Rees

Murray

Nelson

. Oscillating migration and the epidemics of silicosis, tuberculosis and HIV infection in South African gold miners. Am J Ind Med 2009; 53: 398–404.

12.

Creamer M. Ex-miners taking steps to access R6bn unpaid benefits, http://www.miningweekly.com/article/ex-mineworkers-taking-steps-to-access-r6bn-in-undisbursed-benefits-2014-02-26 (2014, accessed 23 May 2015).

13.

Trapido

Goode

White

. Costs of occupational lung disease in South Africa gold mining. J Miner Policy Bus Environ Raw Mater Rep 1998; 13: 26–33.

14.

High Court of South Africa (North Gauteng Division) (Zondo J). Chamber of mines v the compensation commissioner for occupational diseases and other respondents. Case 38488/08.

15.

White N. Is the ODMW Act fair? A comparison of the Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Amendment Act 1993 and the compensation of Occupational Injuries and Disease Act 1993 with respect to compensation of pneumoconiosis. Cape Town: University of Cape Town, http://www.publichealth.uct.ac.za/sites/default/files/image_tool/images/8/A%20Comparison%20of%20the%20Occupational%20Diseases%20in%20Mines%20and%20Works%20Amendment%20Act,%201993.pdf (2004, accessed 2 August 2015).

16.

Peacock D, Yawa A and Keehn EN. Comment: workers seek justice over killer dust. Mail and Guardian, http://mg.co.za/article/2015-03-05-comment-miners-seek-justice-over-killer-dust (2015, accessed 30 April 2015).

17.

Lewis P. The scandal of South Africa’s sick miners. Groundup, http://groundup.org.za/article/scandal-south-africa%E2%80%99s-sick-miners_3017 (2015, accessed 30 July 2015).

18.

Boyko R. Fulfilling broken promises. Global health justice partnership, Yale Law School and Yale School of Public Health, http://www.law.yale.edu/documents/pdf/News_&_Events/GHJP_Report_on_Compensation_for_Miners_in_Southern_Africa.pdf (2013, accessed 23 May 2015).

19.

Budlender D. Labour legislation in South Africa 1924-1945. Master’s Dissertation, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, 1979.

20.

Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Act No. 78 of 1973. Republic of South Africa: Government Gazette 3970. 1973: 1–112.

21.

Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Amendment Act No. 208 of 1993. Republic of South Africa: Government Gazette 15449. 1993: 1–34.

22.

Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Disease Act No. 130 of 1993. Republic of South Africa: Government Gazette 15159. 1993: 1–90.

23.

Katz

. The White death: silicosis on the Witwatersrand gold mines, 1886–1910, Johannesburg: Witwatersrand University Press, 1994.

24.

Budget 2015: estimates of national expenditure, vote 16: health. National Treasury, Republic of South Africa, http://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/national%20budget/2015/enebooklets/Vote%2016%20Health.pdf (2015, accessed 15 May 2015).

25.

The National Occupational Health and Safety policy revised version 3. Republic of South Africa, http://www.kznhealth.gov.za/occhealth/policy2.pdf (2003, accessed 23 April 2015).

26.

Ison

. Worker’s compensation systems. ILO encyclopaedia of occupational health and safety, Geneva: International Labour Organisation, 2011.

27.

Garzarelli G, Keeton-Stolk L and Schoer V. Worker’s compensation in the Republic of South Africa. Johannesburg: University of Witwatersrand School of Economic and Business Sciences, http://us-cdn.creamermedia.co.za/assets/articles/attachments/17662_compensationreport.pdf (2008, accessed 27 March 2015).

28.

International Labour Office (ILO). Guidelines for the use of the ILO classification of radiographs of pneumoconiosis, rev ed. Occupational Safety and Health Series No. 22, Geneva, Switzerland: International Labour Office, 2002.

29.

Risk management and internal controls. Anglogold Ashanti annual financial statements, 174 http://www.anglogoldashanti.com/en/Media/Reports/Annual%20Reports/AGA_Annual-Financial-Statements_2008.pdf (2008, accessed 30 April 2015).

30.

van Assen L. The need for amendments to legislation. Workmen’s Compensation Assistance, http://wcawca.co.za/blogs/louis/2012/05/need-amendments-legislation (2010, accessed 4 May 2015).

31.

Stewart P. Great expectations: expenditure patterns and assessment of asbestos relief trust compensation awards. Johannesburg: Wits enterprise, http://www.asbestostrust.co.za/documents/Great_Expectations_Final_Report%2818Jun2007%29.pdf (2007, accessed 15 May 2015).

32.

Coverage against employment injuries and diseases. Committee reports of the Taylor committee into a social security system for South Africa, No. 11, http://www.sarpn.org/CountryPovertyPapers/SouthAfrica/taylor/report11.pdf (undated, accessed 15 May 2015).

33.

International Labour Office. C121-employment injury benefits convention No 121. Geneva: International Labour Office, http://www.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_ILO_CODE:C121 (1964, accessed 15 May 2015).

34.

Banyini

Rees

Gilbert

. Even if I were to consent: my family will never agree: exploring autopsy services for posthumous occupational lung disease compensation among mineworkers in South Africa. Global Health Action 2013; 6: 19518.

35.

Molautsi S. Scientific workshop on risk assessment in mines and works, quantification of exposure and disease: presentation on assessment of levies in controlled mines and works, http://www.nioh.ac.za/assets/files/RA_in_mining/S_Molautsi_Assessment_of_Levies.pdf (2013, accessed 18 May 2015).

36.

Ndlovu

teWater

Murray

. Compensation for environmental asbestos-related diseases in South Africa: a neglected issue. Global Health Action 2013; 6: 19410.

37.

Benjamin

. Occupational health and safety prevention and compensation laws: piece of the same puzzle. Occup Health S Afr: ICOH Special Issue 2009, pp. 1–5.

38.

Tompa

Trevithick

McLeod

. Systematic review of the prevention incentives of insurance and regulatory mechanisms for occupational health and safety. Scand J Work Environ Health 2007; 33: 85–95.

39.

Du Toit

RSJ

. Mine ventilation officials and the quality of mine air. J Mine Vent Soc S Afr 1962; December: 225–237.

40.

Benjamin P and Greef J. Report of the committee of inquiry into a National Health and Safety Council in South Africa. Pretoria: Department of Labour, http://www.commerciallaw.uct.ac.za/usr/commercial/downloads/13.pdf (2003, accessed 15 May 2015).

41.

Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Act of 2011. Republic of South Africa: Government Gazette 34462. 2011: 16–17.

42.

Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Act 1973: regulations relating to the basis on which owners of controlled mines and controlled works shall pay amounts in respect of risk shifts worked. Republic of South Africa: Government Gazette 18992. 1998: 89.

43.

Acturial and Insurance Solutions, Deloitte and Touche. Compensation commissioner for occupational diseases in mines and works. Report on the actuarial valuation as at Dec 2003, Johannesburg, 2004 September 21.

44.

Ehrlich

. Failure of the compensation system for occupational disease in South Africa. S Afr Med J 2012; 102: 95–97.

45.

South African Society of Occupational Medicine. Report on workman’s compensation in crisis summit. Occup Health S Afr 2013; 19: 28–29.

46.

Parliamentary Monitoring Group. Compensation fund turnaround: department of labour briefings. Republic of South Africa, Committee National Council of Provinces Communications and Public Enterprises, https://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/15468/ (2013, accessed 15 May 2015).

47.

Nelson

Girdler-Brown

Ndlovu

. Three decades of silicosis: disease trends at autopsy in South African gold mines. Environ Health Perspect 2010; 118: 421–426.

48.

Roberts J. They hide things like that from us. The hidden epidemic amongst former miners: silicosis, tuberculosis and the Occupational Diseases in Mines and Works Act in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. South Africa: Health systems trust, http://www.hst.org.za/publications/855 (2009, accessed 30 April 2015).

49.

South African Development Community. Declaration on tuberculosis in the mining industry, http://www.stoptb.org/assets/documents/news/Declaration%20on%20Tuberculosis%20in%20the%20Mining%20Sector2012English.pdf (2012, accessed 21 May 2014).