Earlier reviews have asserted the superiority of structure versus ambiguity in the prac tice of group therapy. This review attempts to specify the dimensions that lead to this asserted superiority. The pregroup training literature is reviewed in terms of method and timing of presentation and content of training. A model is proposed that links con tent and timing with issues in group development Implications for practice and re search are noted.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bednar, R.L. and C.P. Battersby (1976) "The effects of specific cognitive structure on early group development."J. of Applied Behavioral Sci.12: 513-522
2.
. Bednar, R.L., J. Melnick, and T. Kaul (1974) "Risk, responsibility and structure : a conceptual framework for initiating group counseling and psychotherapy."J. of Counseling Psychology21: 21-37
3.
. BELLACK, A. and M. HERSON [eds.] (1979) Research and Practice in Social Skills Training.New York: Plenum Press.
4.
Bennis, W.F. and H.A. Shepard (1956) "A theory of group development."Human Relations9: 415-437
5.
. Berger, S.N. (1978) "The effects of different sets of disclosure instructions on subject productivity and rated satisfaction."J. of Counseling Psychology25: 506-513
6.
. Conger, J.C. and A.D. Farrell (1981) "Behavioral components of heterosocial skills."Behavior Therapy12: 41-55.
7.
Corazzini, J.G. and P.P. Heppner (1980) "The effects of cognitive information on termination from group therapy."J. of College Student Personnel21: 553-557
8.
. Curran, J.P. (1979a) "Pandora's box re-opened? The assessment of social skills."J. of Behavioral Assessment1, 1: 55-71
9.
. ———( 1979b) "Social skills: methodological issues and future directions," in A. S. Bellack and M. Hersen (eds.) Research and Practice in Social Skills Training.New York: Free Press.
10.
———( 1977) "Skills training as an approach to the treatment of heterosexual-social anxiety: a review."Psych. Bull.84: 140-157.
11.
D'Augelli, A.R. and J.M. Chinsky (1974) "Interpersonal skills and pretraining: implications for the use of group procedures for interpersonal learning and for the selection of nonprofessional mental health workers."J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology42: 65-72
12.
. DeJulio, S., J. Bentley, and T. Cockayne (1979) "Pregroup norm setting effects on encounter group interaction."Small Group Behavior10: 368-388
13.
. Evensen, E.P. and R.L. Bednar (1978) "Effects of specific cognitive and behavioral structure on early group behavior and atmosphere."J. of Counseling Psychology25: 66-75
14.
. Ford, J. (1979) "Research on training counselors and clinicians."Rev. of Educ. Research49: 87-130
15.
. Galassi, J.P. and M.D. Galassi (1979) "Modification of heterosocial skills deficits," in A. S. Bellack and M. Hersen (eds.) Research and Practice in Social Skills Training.New York: Plenum Press.
16.
Garrison, J.E. (1978) "Written vs. verbal preparation of patients for group psychotherapy."Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice15: 130-134
17.
. Hare, A.P. (1976) Handbook of Small Group ResearchNew York: Free Press.
18.
Hersen, M. and A.J. Bellack (1976) "Assessment of social skills," in A. R. Ciminero et al. (eds.) Handbook of Behavioral Assessment.New York: John Wiley.
19.
Hill, W.F. (1965) HIM: Hill Interaction MatrixLos Angeles: University of Southern California, Youth Study Center.
20.
Ilgen, D.R., C.D. Fisher, and M.S. Taylor (1979) "Consequences of individual feedback on behavior in organization."J. of Applied Psychology64: 349-371
21.
. Ivey, A.E. and J. Authier (1978) Microcounseling: Innovations in Interviewing, Counseling, Psychotherapy, and PsychoeducationSpringfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
22.
Kasdorf, J. and K. Gustafson (1978) "Research related to microtraining," in A. Ivey and J. Authier (eds.) Microcounseling: Innovations in Interviewing, Counseling, Psychotherapy, and Psychoeducation.Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
23.
Kiesler, D.J. (1979) Manual for the Impact Message InventoryRichmond: Virginia Commonwealth University.
24.
———( 1966) "Some myths of psychotherapy research and the search for a paradigm."Psych. Bull. 65: 110-136.
25.
Marcy, M.R. and D.K. Fromme (1979) "Group modification of affective verbalizations: 'here and now' and valence effects."Small Group Behavior10: 547-556
26.
. Martin, H. and K. Shewmaker (1962) "Written instructions in group psychotherapy."Group Psychotherapy15: 24-29
27.
. Morrison, R.L. and A.S. Bellack (1981) "The role of social perception in social skills."Behavior Therapy12: 69-79
28.
. Nadler, D.A. (1979) "The effects of feedback on task group behavior: a review of experimental research."Organizational Behavior and Human Performance23: 309-338
29.
. Parloff, M. (1979) "Can psychotherapy research guide the policy maker?"Amer. Psychologist34: 296-306
30.
. Paul, G. (1967) "Strategy of outcome research in psychotherapy."J. of Consulting Psychology31: 109-119
31.
. Piper, W.E., E.G. Debbane, J. Garant, and J. Bienvenu (1979) "Pretrammg for group psychotherapy."Archives of General Psychiatry36: 1250-1256
32.
Rabin, H.M. (1969) "Preparing patients for group psychotherapy."Int. J. of Group Psychotherapy12:135-145
33.
. Roark, A.E. and A.B. Roark (1979) "Group structure: components and effects."J. for Specialists in Group Work4: 187-192
34.
. Rose, G.S. and R.L. Bednar (1980) "Effects of positive and negative self-disclosure and feedback on early group development."J. of Counseling Psychology27: 63-70
35.
. Sauber, S.R. (1974) "Approaches to pretherapy training."J. of Contemporary Psychotherapy6: 190-197
36.
. Stone, G.L. and L.W. Steppins (1975) "Effect of differential pretraining on client self-disclosure."J. of Counseling Psychology22: 17-20
37.
. Stone, G.L. and A. Vance (1976) "Instructions, modeling, and rehearsal: implications for training."J. of Counseling Psychology23: 272-279
38.
. Strupp, H.H. and A.L. Bloxom (1973) "Preparing lower-class patients for group psychotherapy: development and evaluation of a role-induction film."J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology41: 373-384
39.
. Trotzer, J.P. (1979) "Developmental tasks in group counseling: the basis for structure."J. of Specialists in Group Work4: 177-185
40.
. Trower, P. (1979) "Fundamentals of interpersonal behavior: a social-psychological perspective," in A. S. Bellack and N. Hersen (eds.) Research and Practice in Social Skills Training.New York: Plenum Press.
41.
Truax, C.B. and R.R. Carkhuff (1965) "Personality change in hospitalized mental patients during group psychotherapy as a function of alternate sessions and vicarious therapy pretraining."J. of Clinical Psychology21: 190-201
42.
. Truax, C.B., J.G. Shapiro, and D.G. Wargo (1968) "The effects of alternate sessions and vicarious therapy pretraining on group psychotherapy."Int. J. of Group Psychotherapy18: 186-198
43.
. Tuckman, B.W. and M.A. Jensen (1977) "Stages of small-group development revisited."Group and Organizational Studies2: 419-427.
44.
Twentyman, C.T. and R.T. Zimering (1979) "Behavioral training of social skills: a critical review."Progress in Behavior Modification7: 319-400.
45.
West, B.L., K.E. Goethe, and W.M. Kallman (1980) "Heterosocial skills training: a behavioral-cognitive approach," in D. Upper and S. M. Ross (eds.) Behavioral Group Therapy, 1980: An Annual Review.Champaign, IL: Research Press.
46.
Whalen, C. (1969) "Effects of a model and instructions on group verbal behaviors."J. of Consulting and Counseling Psychology33: 509-521
47.
. Wogan, M., H. Getter, M.F. Nichols, and G. Okman (1979) "Influencing interaction and outcomes m group psychotherapy."Small Group Behavior8: 25-46
48.
. Yalom, I.D., P.S. Houts, G. Newells, and K.H. Rand (1967) "Preparation of patients for group therapy."Archives of General Psychiatry17: 416-427.
49.
Zarle, T.H. and S. Willis (1975) "A pregroup training technique for encounter group stress."J. of Counseling Psychology22: 49-53.
