This review examines the question of whether adverse health effects are attributable to amalgam-derived mercury. The issue of absorbed dose of mercury from amalgam is addressed first. The use of intra-oral Hg vapor measurements to estimate daily uptake must take into account the differences between the collection volume and flow rate of the measuring instrument and the inspiratory volume and flow rate of air through the mouth during inhalation of a single breath. Failure to account for these differences will result in substantial overestimation of the absorbed dose. Other factors that must be considered when making estimates of Hg uptake from amalgam include the accurate measurement of baseline (unstimulated) mercury release rates and the greater stimulation of Hg release afforded by chewing gum relative to ordinary food. The measured levels of amalgam-derived mercury in brain, blood, and urine are shown to be consistent with low absorbed doses (1-3 μg/day). Published relationships between the number of amalgam surfaces and urine levels are used to estimate the number of amalgam surfaces that would be required to produce the 30 μg/g creatinine urine mercury level stated by WHO to be associated with the most subtle, pre-clinical effects in the most sensitive individuals. From 450 to 530 amalgam surfaces would be required to produce the 30 μg/g creatinine urine mercury level for people without any excessive gum-chewing habits. The potential for adverse health effects and for improvement in health following amalgam removal is also addressed. Finally, the issue of whether any material can ever be completely exonerated of claims of producing adverse health effects is considered.
References
1.
Abraham JE, Svare CW, Frank CW (1984). The effect of dental amalgam restorations on blood mercury levels. I Dent Res63:71-73.
2.
Acgih (1996). 1996 TLVs® and BEIs®. Cincinnati, OH: American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, pp 26, 63.
3.
Akesson I., Schutz A., Attewell R., Skerfving S., Glantz P.-O (1991). Status of mercury and selenium status in dental personnel: Impact of amalgam work and own fillings. Arch Environ Hlth46(2):102-109.
4.
Albers IW, Kallenbach LR, Fine LJ, Langolf GD, Wolfe RA, Donofrio PD, et al. (1988). Neurological abnormalities associated with remote occupational elemental mercury exposure. Ann Neurol24:651-659.
5.
Aronsson A-M., Lind B., Nylander M., Nordberg M. (1989). Dental amalgam and mercury. Biol Metals2:25-30.
6.
Atsdr (1994). Toxicological profile for mercury (update). Report No. TP-93/10. Springfield, VA: National Technical Information Service, pp. 1-357.
7.
Barregard L. (1991). Occupational exposure to inorganic mercury in chloralkali workers. Studies on metabolism and health effects (thesis). Universities of Gothenburg and Lund, Sweden.
8.
Barregard L. (1993). Biological monitoring of exposure to mercury vapor. Scand J Work Environ Hlth19(Suppl 1):45-49.
9.
Berdouses E., Vaidyanathan TK, Dastane A., Weisel C., Houpt M., Shey Z. ( 1995). Mercury release from dental amalgams: an in vitro study under controlled chewing and brushing in an artificial mouth. J Dent Res74:1185-1193.
10.
Bergdahl J., Anneroth G., Stenman E. (1994). Description of persons with symptoms presumed to be caused by electricity or visual display units-oral aspects. Scand J Dent Res102:41-45.
11.
Berglund A. (1990). Estimation by a 24-hour study of the daily dose of intra-oral mercury vapor inhaled after release from dental amalgam. J Dent Res69:1646-1651.
12.
Berglund A., Molin M. (1996). Mercury vapor release from dental amalgam in patients with symptoms allegedly caused by amalgam fillings. Eur J Oral Sci104:56-63.
13.
Berglund A., Pohl L., Olsson S., Bergman M. (1988). Determination of the rate of release of intra-oral mercury vapor from amalgam. J Dent Res67:1235-1242.
14.
Bernard SR, Purdue P. (1984). Metabolic models for methyl and inorganic mercury. Hlth Phys46:695-699.
15.
Björkman L., Lind B. ( 1992). Factors influencing mercury evaporation rate from dental amalgam fillings. Scand J Dent Res100:354-360.
16.
Björkman L., Pedersen NL, Lichtenstein P. (1996). Physical and mental health related to dental amalgam fillings in Swedish twins. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol24:260-267.
17.
Boyd ND, Benediktsson H., Vimy MJ, Hooper DE, Lorscheider FL (1991). Mercury from dental "silver" tooth fillings impairs sheep kidney function. Am J Physiol261:R1010-R1014.
18.
Brune D., Evje DM ( 1985). Man's mercury loading from dental amalgams. Sci Total Environ44:51-63.
19.
Camner P., Bakke B. (1980). Nose or mouth breathing? Environ Res21:394-398.
20.
Ccehrp (1993). Dental amalgam: A scientific review and recommended Public Health Service strategy for research, education and regulation. Final report of the Subcommittee on Risk Management of the Committee to Coordinate Environmental Health and Related Programs. US Public Health Service, Department of Health and Human Services, pp. 3, 4.
21.
Clarkson TW (1972). The pharmacology of mercury compounds. Ann Rev Pharmacol12:375-406.
22.
Clarkson TW, Cranmer J., Sivulka D.), Smith R. (1984). Mercury health effects update. Health issue assessment. Research Triangle Park, NC: US Environmental Protection Agency, pp. 1-1-7-22.
23.
Clarkson TW, Friberg L., Hursh JB, Nylander M. (1988). The prediction of intake of mercury vapor from amalgams. In: Biological monitoring of toxic metals. Clarkson TW, Friberg L, Nordberg GF, Sager PR, editors. New York: Plenum Press, pp. 247-264.
24.
Echeverria D., Heyer NJ, Martin MD, Naleway CA, Woods JS, Bittner AC Jr (1995). Behavioral effects of low-level exposure to HgO among dentists. Neurotoxicol Teratol17:161-168.
25.
Eggleston DW, Nylander M. (1987). Correlation of dental amalgam with mercury in brain tissue. J Prosthet Dent58:704-707.
26.
Fawer RF, De Ribaupierre Y., Guillemin MP, Berode M., Lob M. (1983). Measurement of hand tremor induced by industrial exposure to metallic mercury. Br J Ind Med40:204-208.
27.
Forzi M., Cassitto MG, Bulgheroni C., Foa V. (1976). Psychological measures in workers occupationally exposed to mercury vapours. A validation study. In: Adverse effects of environmental chemicals and psychotoxic drugs. Vol. 2. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers, pp. 165-172.
Gleeson K., Zwillich CW, Braier K., White DP (1986). Breathing route during sleep. Am Rev Resp Dis134:115-120.
30.
Gross MJ, MacGregor IDM (1991). Corrosion wear and mercury loss from dental amalgam in vivo (abstract). J Dent Res70(Spec Iss):676.
31.
Guyton AC (1971). Basic human physiology: normal function and mechanisms of disease. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders Co., p. 330.
32.
Halbach S. (1995). Combined estimation of mercury species released from amalgam. J Dent Res74:1103-1109.
33.
Herrstrom P., Hogstedt B. (1993). Clinical study of oral galvanism: no evidence of toxic mercury exposure but anxiety disorder an important background factor. Scand J Dent Res101:232-237.
34.
Herrstrom P., Hogstedt B. (1994). Dental restorative materials and the prevalence of eczema, allergic rhino-conjunctivitis, and asthma in schoolchildren. Dental amalgam and allergy in schoolchildren. Scand J Prim Hlth Care12:3-8.
35.
Herrstrom P., Schutz A., Raihle G., Holthuis N., Hogstedt B., Rastam L. (1995). Dental amalgam, low-dose exposure to mercury, and urinary proteins in young Swedish men. Arch Environ Hlth50:103-107.
36.
Holland RI (1980). Galvanic currents between gold and amalgam. Scand J Dent Res88:269-272.
37.
Holland RI, Hogstedt P., Ortendahl TW (1993). Mercury release from dental amalgams in vitro. Sec lnt Congr Dental Mater, Nov 1-4, 1993, Hawaii.
38.
Hursh JB, Clarkson TW, Cherian MG, Vostal JJ, Vander Mallie R. (1976). Clearance of mercury (Hg-197, Hg-203) vapor inhaled by human subjects. Arch Environ Hlth31:302-309.
39.
Kraus BS, Jordan RE, Abrams L. (1969). Dental anatomy and occlusion. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins Company, p. 226.
40.
Lambrechts P., Vuylsteke M., Vanherle G., Davidson CL (1985). Quantitative in vivo wear of posterior dental restorations (abstract). J Dent Res64(Spec Iss):370.
41.
Lambrechts P., Braem M., Vuylsteke-Wauters M., Vanherle G. (1989). Quantitative in vivo wear of human enamel. J Dent Res68:1752-1754.
42.
Langolf GD, Chaffin DB, Henderson R., Whittle HP (1978). Evaluation of workers exposed to elemental mercury using quantitative tests of tremor and neuromuscular functions. Am Ind Hyg Assoc J39:976-984.
43.
Langolf GD, Smith PJ, Henderson R., Whittle H. (1981). Measurements of neurological functions in the evaluations of exposure to neurotoxic agents. Ann Occup Hyg24:293-296.
44.
Langworth S. (1992). Early effects of occupational and environmental exposure to inorganic mercury (thesis). Huddinge, Sweden: Huddinge University Hospital and the Karolinska Institutet.
45.
Langworth S., Elinder C-G., Akesson A. (1988a). Mercury exposure from dental fillings. I. Mercury concentrations in blood and urine. Swed Dent J12:69-70.
46.
Langworth S., Kölbeck K-G., Akesson A. (1988b). Mercury exposure from dental fillings. II. Release and absorption. Swed Dent J12:71-72.
47.
Langworth S., Almkvist O., Soderman E., Wikstrom BO (1992). Effects of occupational exposure to mercury vapour on the central nervous system. Br J Ind Med49:545-555.
48.
Lorscheider FL, Vimy MJ ( 1993). Evaluation of the safety issue of mercury release from dental fillings. FASEB J7:1432-1433.
49.
Lorscheider FL, Vimy MJ, Summers AO (1995). Mercury exposure from "silver" tooth fillings: emerging evidence questions a traditional dental paradigm. FASEB J9:504-508.
50.
Lutz F., Phillips RW, Roulet JF, Setcos JC (1984). In vivo and in vitro wear of potential posterior composites. J Dent Res63:914-920.
51.
Mackert JR Jr ( 1987). Factors affecting estimation of dental amalgam mercury exposure from measurements of mercury vapor levels in intra-oral and expired air. J Dent Res66:1775-1780.
52.
Mahler D., Simms L. (1996). Influence of liquid films on Hg loss from dental amalgams (abstract). J Dent Res75(Spec lss):38.
53.
Malvin RL, Schnermann JB, Churchill PC, Bidani AK (1992). Mercury from dental "silver" tooth fillings (letter). Am J Physiol262:R716-717.
54.
McHugh WD (1992). Statement: Effects and side-effects of dental restorative materials. Adv Dent Res6:139-144.
55.
McNerney JJ, Buseck PR, Hanson RC (1972). Mercury detection by means of thin gold films. Science178:611-612.
56.
Meurman JH, Porko C., Murtomaa H. (1990). Patients complaining about amalgam-related symptoms suffer more often from illnesses and chronic craniofacial pain than their controls. Scand J Dent Res98:167-172.
57.
Michel 1, Norback D., Edling C (1989). An epidemiologic study of the relation between symptoms of fatigue, dental amalgam and other factors. Swed Dent J13:33-38.
58.
Molin M., Bergman B., Marklund SL, Schutz A., Skerfving S. (1990). Mercury, selenium, and glutathione peroxidase before and after amalgam removal in man. Acta Odontol Scand48:189-202.
59.
Newman SM (1987). Mercury detection in the oral environment from amalgams and interferences (abstract). J Dent Res66(Spec Iss):112.
60.
Ngim C.-H, Foo SC, Boey KW, Jeyaratnam J. (1992). Chronic neurobehavioural effects of elemental mercury in dentists. Br J Ind Med49:782-790.
61.
Nielsen-Kudsk F. (1965). Absorption of mercury vapour from the respiratory tract in man. Acta Pharmacol Toxicol23:250-262.
62.
Nilsson B., Nilsson B. (1986). Mercury in dental practice. II. Urinary mercury excretion in dental personnel. Swed Dent J10:221-232.
63.
Ninimaa V., Cole P., Mintz S., Shephard RJ (1981). Oronasal distribution of respiratory airflow. Respir Physiol43:69-75.
64.
Nylander M., Friberg L., Lind B. ( 1987). Mercury concentrations in the human brain and kidneys in relation to exposure from dental amalgam fillings. Swed Dent J11:179-187.
65.
Olea N., Pulgar R., Pérez P., Olea-Serrano F., Rivas A., Novillo-Fertrell A., et al. (1996). Estrogenicity of resin-based composites and sealants used in dentistry. Environ Hlth Perspect104:298-305.
66.
Olsson S., Bergman M. (1987). Letter to the editor J Dent Res66:1288-1289.
67.
Olsson S., Bergman M. (1992). Daily dose calculations from measurements of intra-oral mercury vapor. J Dent Res71:414-423.
68.
Ott KH, Kraftt T., Kroncke A., Schaller KH, Valentin H., Weltle D. (1986). Untersuchungen zum zeitlichen Verlauf der Quecksilberfreisetzung aus Amalgamfüllungen nach dem Kauen. Dtsch Zahnärztl Z41:968-972.
69.
Patterson JE, Weissberg BG, Dennison P.) (1985). Mercury in human breath from dental amalgams. Bull Envir Contam Toxicol34:459-468.
70.
Richardson GM (1995). Assessment of mercury exposure and risks from dental amalgam. Ottawa: Environmental Health Directorate, Health Canada, pp. 1-109.
71.
Richardson M., Mitchell M., Coad S., Raphael R. (1995). Exposure to mercury in Canada: A multimedia analysis. Water Air Soil Pollut80:21-30.
72.
Roels H., Abdeladim S., Ceulemans E., Lauwerys R. (1987). Relationships between the concentrations of mercury in air and in blood or urine in workers exposed to mercury vapour. Ann Occup Hyg31:135-145.
73.
Sällsten G., Thoren J., Barregård L., Schütz A., Skarping G. (1996). Long-term use of nicotine chewing gum and mercury exposure from dental amalgam fillings. J Dent Res75:594-598.
74.
Sandborgh-Englund G., Dahlqvist R., Lindelöf B., Söderman EW, Jonzon B., Vesterberg O., et al. (1994). DMSA administration to patients with alleged mercury poisoning from dental amalgam: a placebo-controlled study. J Dent Res73:620-628.
75.
Sandborgh-Englund G., Ekstrand J., Elinder CG, Johanson G., Skare I. (1996a). Studies on mercury kinetics in man (abstract). ) J Dent Res75(Spec Iss):38.
76.
Sandborgh-Englund G., Nygren AT, Ekstrand J., Elinder C-G. (1996b). No evidence of renal toxicity from amalgam fillings. Am J Physiol271:R941-R945.
77.
Saxe SR, Snowdon DA, Wekstein MW, Henry RG, Grant FT, Donegan SJ, et al. (1995). Dental amalgam and cognitive function in older women: findings from the nun study. J Am Dent Assoc126:1495-1511.
78.
Shibko SI, Shapiro RE, Kolbye AC Jr (1976). Exposure to toxic metals via food: Relationship to other exposures, critical organ concentration and toxic effect. In: Effects and dose-response relationships of toxic metals. Nordberg GF, editor. Amsterdam: Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co., pp. 199-206.
79.
Skare I., Engqvist A. (1994). Human exposure to mercury and silver released from dental amalgam restorations. Arch Environ Hlth49:384-394.
80.
Skare I., Johansson R. (1991). Reaktioner mellan kvicksilverånga och klor vid arbetshygieniska haltnivåer. Undersökningsrapport nr 3. Solna, Sweden: Arbetsmiljöinstitutet.
81.
Snapp KR, Boyer DB, Peterson LC, Svare CW (1989). The contribution of dental amalgam to mercury in blood. J Dent Res68:780-785.
82.
Socialstyrelsen (1987). Kvicksilver/amalgam halsorisker (in Swedish, English summary). SoS-rapport 1987:10.
83.
Socialstyrelsen (1994). Blir man sjuk av amalgam? (in Swedish, English summary). SoS-rapport 1994:21.
84.
Sugita M. (1978). The biological half-time of heavy metals. The existence of a third, "slowest" component. Int Arch Occup Environ Hlth41:25-40.
85.
Svare CW, Peterson LC, Reinhardt JW, Boyer DB, Frank CW, Gay DD, et al. (1981). The effect of dental amalgams on mercury levels in expired air. J Dent Res60:1668-1671.
86.
Teisinger J., Fiserova-Bergerova V. (1965). Pulmonary retention and excretion of mercury vapors in man. Ind Med Surg34:580-584.
87.
Tsalev DL, Zaprianov ZK (1983). Atomic absorption spectroscopy in occupational and environmental health practice. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, pp. 158-169.
88.
Uddströmer M. (1940). Nasal respiration. A critical survey of some current physiological and clinical aspects on the respiratory mechanism with a description of a new method of diagnosis (thesis). Uppsala, Sweden: Akademiska sjukhuset.
89.
Vimy MJ, Lorscheider FL (1985a). lntra-oral air mercury released from dental amalgam. J Dent Res64:1069-1071.
90.
Vimy MJ, Lorscheider FL (1985b). Serial measurements of intra-oral air mercury: Estimation of daily dose from dental amalgam. ) J Dent Res64:1072-1075.
91.
Vimy MJ, Lorscheider FL (1990). Dental amalgam mercury daily dose estimated from intra-oral vapor measurements: A predictor of mercury accumulation in human tissues. J Trace Elem Exper Med3:111-123.
92.
Viola PL, Cassano GB (1968). The effect of chlorine on mercury vapor intoxication. Med Lav59:437-444.
93.
Weiner JA, Nylander M., Berglund F. (1990). Does mercury from amalgam restorations constitute a health hazard? Sci Total Environ99:1-22.
94.
WHO (1976). Environmental health criteria 1. Mercury. Geneva: World Health Organization.
95.
WHO (1991). Environmental health criteria 118. Inorganic mercury. Geneva: World Health Organization.
96.
Williams DF, editor (1981). Mercury. In: Systemic aspects of biocompatibility. Vol. 1. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, pp. 237-249.
97.
Woods JS, Martin MD, Naleway C., Echeverria D. (1993). Urinary porphyrin profiles as a biomarker of mercury exposure: Studies on dentists with occupational exposure to mercury vapor. J Toxicol Environ Hlth40:235-246.
