Setting Reactions in Dental Amalgam Part 1. Phases and Microstructures Between One Hour and One Week

Abstract

The literature on the setting mechanisms of dental amalgams made from powders of silver-rich alloys of tin and/or copper has been critically reviewed. In Part 1 of the review, the microstructure and phase content of recently set amalgams are described. The composition, morphology, and location of product phases are emphasized, since these features are clues to the setting reaction. Thus, Part I provides the background needed to understand the kinetics of the setting reactions, which is the topic of Part 2 of the review.

References

Abbott JR, Makinson OF (1979). Removal of gamma-2 phase in amalgam. J Biomed Mater Res 13:857-863.

Abbott JR, Miller DR (1980). The structure, hardening reaction of silver-tin dental amalgam. Metals Forum 3:211-221.

Abbott JR, Miller DR, Netherway DJ (1982). Reaction of mercury with silver-tin dental amalgam alloy. J Biomed Mater Res 16:535-547.

Abbott JR, Miller DR, Netherway DJ (1984). Plastic deformation of β, -y phase silver-tin alloys. J Mater Sci 19:3255-3265.

Abbott JR, Miller DR, Netherway DJ (1986). Influence of alloy composition on the hardening of silver-tin dental amalgam. J Biomed Mater Res 20:1391-1400.

Aldinger F., Kraft W. (1977). Über den aufbau des vierstoffsystems Silber-Kupfer-Quecksilber bei 37°C. Z Metallkde 67:541-545.

Andersen P., Jensen SJ (1971). Chemical composition, crystal structure of the γ-phase in the silver-mercury system. Scand J Dent Res 79:466-471.

Asgar K. (1971). Behavior of copper in dispersed amalgam alloy (abstract). J Dent Res 51 (Spec Iss):56.

Asgar K. (1974). Amalgam alloy with a single composition behavior similar to Dispersalloy (abstract). J Dent Res 53 (Spec Iss):60.

10.

Asgar K., Reichman S. (1975). Special Metals Corporation assignee. Dental Amalgam. US patent 3,871,875. Mar 18.

11.

Asgar K., Reichman S. (1976). Special Metals Corporation assignee. Dental Amalgam. US patent 3,980,472. Sept.

12.

Black GV (1896). The physical properties of the silver-tin amalgams. Dent Cosmos 38:965-992.

13.

Blanc-Benon J. (1972). Etude metallographique de la prise des amalgames dentaires au stade initial: Importance des phenomenes de diffusion (thesis). Lyon I, France: Universite Claude-Bernard.

14.

Boswell PG (1979). Transmission electron metallography of non-γ2 silver dental amalgam. Scripta Metallur 13:383-388.

15.

Boyer DB, Edie JW ( 1990). Composition of clinically aged amalgam restorations. Dent Mater 6:146-150.

16.

Bryant RW (1984). γ2 phase in conventional dental amalgams-discrete clumps or continuous network? A review. Aust Dent J 29:163-167.

17.

Bryant RW (1985a). The reaction zone around experimental amalgam alloy particles of Ag-Cu eutectic composition. J Oral Rehabil 12:27-36.

18.

Bryant RW (1985b). The reaction zone around commercially available amalgam alloy particles of Ag-Cu eutectic composition. J Oral Rehabil 12:37-48.

19.

Bryant RW, Wing G. ( 1984). Electron microprobe analysis of the γ2 phase in dental amalgam. Aust Dent J 29:116-122.

20.

Cruickshanks-Boyd DW (1982). Physical metallurgy of dental amalgams. 1. Particle-size analysis and phase-content of amalgam alloys. I Dent 10:207-216.

21.

Cruickshanks-Boyd DW (1983). Physical metallurgy of dental amalgams. 2. Microstructure. J Dent 11:41-55.

22.

de Freitas JF (1979). A survey of the elemental composition of alloy for dental amalgam. Aust Dent J 24:17-25.

23.

Durandet YC, Finch RJ, Miller DR (1993). The structure of a spherical particle dental amalgam alloy. Mater Forum 17:51-56.

24.

Espevik S. (1977). Creep, phase transformation in dental amalgam. I Dent Res 56:36-38.

25.

Espevik S. (1980). Properties of amalgams made from lathe-cut, high Cu amalgam alloys. Acta Odontol Scand 38:145-150.

26.

Fairhurst CW (1966). Crystallography of dental amalgam (dissertation). Evanston, IL: Northwestern University.

27.

Fairhurst CW, Cohen JB (1972). The crystal structures of two compounds found in dental amalgam: Ag2Hg3, Ag3Sn. Acta Cryst 28(B):371-378.

28.

Fairhurst CW, Ryge G. ( 1961). X-ray diffraction investigation of the Sn-Hg phase in dental amalgam. In: Advances in x-ray analysis. Vol. 5. Muller W, editor. New York: Plenum Press, pp. 64-70.

29.

Gayler M. (1937a). The constitution of the alloys of silver, tin, mercury. J Inst Metals 60:376-406.

30.

Gayler M. (1937b). Dental amalgams. J Inst Metals 60:407424.

31.

Greener EH (1979). Amalgam-yesterday, today, tomorrow. Oper Dent 4:24-35.

32.

Gruber RG, Skinner EW, Greener EH (1967). Some physical properties of silver-tin amalgams. J Dent Res 46:497-502.

33.

Hansen M., Anderko K. (1958). Constitution of binary alloys. New York: McGraw-Hill.

34.

Herzog M., Stachniss V., Hoppe W. (1982a). Rontgenstrahllinienanalyse der Asgar-Mahler-reaktionszone eines HCD-amalgams (X-ray line analysis of the Asgar-Mahler reaction zone of a HCD amalgam). Dtsch Zahnärztl Z 37:526-530.

35.

Herzog M., Hoppe W., Stachniss V. (1982b). Feinstrukturuntersuchungen an HCD-amalgamen (Ultrastructural studies on HCD amalgams). Dtsch Zalinärztl Z 37:659-662.

36.

Innes DBK, Youdelis WV (1963). Dispersion strengthened amalgams. J Can Dent Assoc 29:587-593.

37.

Jensen SJ (1972). Copper-tin phases in dental silver amalgam alloy. Scand J Dent Res 80:158-161.

38.

Jensen SJ (1977). Phase content of a high-copper dental silver amalgam. Scand J Dent Res 85:297-301.

39.

Jensen SJ (1984). Maximum contents of mercury in dental amalgams. Scand J Dent Res 93:84-88.

40.

Jensen SJ (1989). Decrease of γ1 lattice constant with time in dental silver amalgam. Scand J Dent Res 97:465-469.

41.

Jensen SJ, Jorgensen KD (1978). Creep, β1 formation in dental amalgam. Scand J Dent Res 86:408-411.

42.

Jensen SJ, Jørgensen KD (1981). Stoichiometric, x-ray diffraction analysis on the γ2 → η' transformation in a dispersant phase silver amalgam. Scand J Dent Res 89:108-112.

43.

Johnson LB (1971). The amount of tin in the γ1 phase of dental amalgam. J Biomed Mater Res 5:239-244.

44.

Johnson LN, Asgar K., Peyton FA (1969). Microanalysis of copper-tin phases in dental amalgam. J Dent Res 48:872-882.

45.

Johnson RE (1973). Cu-Sn (Copper-Tin). In: Metals handbook-metallography, structures, phase diagrams. 8th ed. Lyman T, Boyer HE, Carnes WJ, Durand EA, Unterweiser PM, Baker H, et al., editors. Metals Park, OH: American Society for Metals, pp. 299, 358.

46.

Mahler DB (1971). Microprobe analysis of a dispersant amalgam (abstract). J Dent Res 51 (Spec lss):56.

47.

Mahler DB (1988). Research on dental amalgam: 1982-1986. Adv Dent Res 2:71-82.

48.

Mahler DB, Adey ID ( 1977). Microprobe analysis of a high-Cu amalgam alloy. J Dent Res 56:379-384.

49.

Mahler DB, Adey ID ( 1979). The influence of final mercury content on the characteristics of a high-copper amalgam. J Biomed Mater Res 13:467-476.

50.

Mahler DB, Adey ID ( 1984). Microprobe analysis of three high-copper amalgams. J Dent Res 63:921-925.

51.

Mahler DB, Adey JD ( 1988). Sn in the Ag-Hg phase of dental amalgam. J Dent Res 67:1275-1277.

52.

Mahler DB, Adey ID ( 1991) Factors influencing the creep of dental amalgam. J Dent Res 70:1384-1400.

53.

Mahler DB, Terkla LG, Van Eysden J., Reisbick M. (1970). Marginal fracture vs mechanical properties of amalgam. J Dent Res 49:1452-1457.

54.

Mahler DB, Adey JD, Van Eysden J. (1973). Transformation of γ1 in clinical amalgam restorations (abstract). I Dent Res 52 (Spec Iss):106.

55.

Mahler DB, Adey JD, Van Eysden J. (1975). Quantitative microprobe analysis of amalgam. J Dent Res 54:218-226.

56.

Mahler DB, Adey JD, Marshall SJ (1987). Effect of time at 37°C on the creep, metallurgical characteristics of amalgam. J Dent Res 66:1146-1148.

57.

Malhotra ML, Asgar K. (1981). X-ray diffraction analysis of γ2 (Sn-Hg) phase in high-copper amalgams of varying mercury content. J Dent Res 60:149-153.

58.

Marek M. (1990). The effect of tin on the corrosion behavior of the Ag-Hg phase of dental amalgam, dissolution of mercury. J Dent Res 69:1786-1790.

59.

Marshall GW, Marshall SJ (1980). Characteristics of the reaction zones of some Cu-rich amalgams. In: Biomaterials 1980. Winter GD, Gibbons DF, Flenk H Jr, editors. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons Ltd., pp. 335-340.

60.

Marshall GW, Marshall SJ, Greener EH (1977). SEM/EDX analysis of new dental amalgams. Scanning Electr Microsc 1:129-136.

61.

Marshall GW, McCoy DD, Kinney JH, Letzel H., Marshall SJ (1992). Microstructural changes in retrieved amalgam restorations. Cells, Materials 2:29-36.

62.

Marshall SJ, Marshall GW (1979). Time-dependent phase changes in Cu-rich amalgams. J Biomed Mater Res 13:395-406.

63.

Matsuda K., Ohno H., Hanawa T., Ferracane JL, Spears R., Okabe T. (1987). Thermal analysis of component phases in amalgams (abstract). J Dent Res 66 (Spec Iss):290.

64.

Mitchell RJ, Okabe T., Butts MB (1981). The size of η'crystals in high-copper amalgams (abstract). J Dent Res 60(A):290.

65.

Moffett JC, Ryge G., Barkow AG (1952). Phase changes in silver-tin amalgams. J Appl Phys 23:1188-1189.

66.

Murphy AJ (1926). The constitution of alloys of silver and tin. J Inst Metals 35:107-124.

67.

Nagai K., Ohashi M., Habu H., Nemoto K., Yamaki F., Meguro E., et al. (1970). Study on the initial hardening of dental amalgam. Part I: Microstructural observations. J Nihon Univ Sch Dent 12:62-77.

68.

O'Brien WJ, Greener E., Mahler DB (1985). Dental amalgam. In: Restorative dental materials: An overview. Reese JM, Valega TM, eds. London, England: Quintessence Publishing Co., Ltd., pp. 17-23.

69.

Okabe T., Hochman RF, Sims LO ( 1975). Amalgamation reaction on mercury-plated dental alloy (Ag3Sn). I Biomed Mater Res 9:221-236.

70.

Okabe T., Mitchell RJ, Butts MB, Bosley JR Fairhurst CW (1977). Analysis of Asgar-Mahler reaction zone in Dispersalloy amalgam by electron diffraction. J Dent Res 56:1037-1043.

71.

Okabe T., Mitchell RJ, Butts MB, Wright AH, Fairhurst CW (1978a). A study of high-copper amalgams. I. A comparison of amalgamation on high-copper alloy tablets. J Dent Res 57:759-767.

72.

Okabe T., Mitchell RJ, Butts MB, Fairhurst CW (1978b). A study of high-copper amalgams, III. SEM observation of amalgamation of high-copper powders. J Dent Res 57:975-982.

73.

Okabe T., Mitchell RJ, Fairhurst CW (1979). A study of high-copper amalgams, IV. Formation of η' Cu-Sn (Cu6Sn5) crystals in high-copper dispersant amalgam matrix. ) J Dent Res 58:1087-1092.

74.

Okabe T., Mitchell RJ, Butts MB, Ferracane JL (1985). Microstructural changes on the surface of dental amalgam during aging. In: Microstructural science. Vol. 13. Shiels SA, Bagnall C, Witkowski RE, Vander Voort GF, editors. New York: Elsevier North Holland, Inc., pp. 177-195.

75.

Otani H. (1970). The setting reaction of dental amalgam. J Osaka Univ Dent Sch 10:57-68.

76.

Paffenbarger GC, Rupp NW, Waterstrat RM (1982). Metals in solution in mercury expressed from copper-rich dental amalgam. ) J Dent Res 61:30-32.

77.

Pearson WB, Villar P, Calvert LD, editors (1985). Pearson's handbook of crystallographic data for intermetallic phases. Metals Park, OH: American Society for Metals.

78.

Petzow G, Effenberg G, editors (1988). Ternary alloys-a comprehensive compendium of evaluated constitutional data on phase diagrams. Weinheim, Germany: VCH Vergsgesellschaft.

79.

Preston GD (1931). The x-ray examination of the system silver-mercury. J Inst Met 46:522-535.

80.

Ryge G., Fairhurst CW, Fischer CH (1961). The present knowledge of the mechanism of the setting of dental amalgam. Int Dent J 7:181-185.

81.

Sarkar NK (1994). Intergranular structure in dental amalgams. J Mater Res 5:171-175.

82.

Sarkar NK, Eyer CS ( 1986). Solid solubility of tin in silver-mercury γ1 in dental amalgams. J Oral Rehabil 13:559-566.

83.

Sarkar NK, Eyer CS, Koger S. (1985). Detection of new phases in dental amalgams using DSC. Am Lab 17:24-27.

84.

Sarkar NK, Norling BK, Prasad A. (1991). Amalgamation reaction of Dispersalloy-reexamined (abstract). J Dent Res 70 (Spec lss):293.

85.

Soderholm KJM (1987). An x-ray diffractometric investigation of the Sn-Hg binary system within the 0-40% Hg interval. J Dent Res 66:712-715.

86.

Stenbeck S. (1933). Rontgenanalyse der Legierungen von Quecksilber mit Silber, Gold, und Zinn. Z Anorg Chem 214:16-26.

87.

Suprinick H. (1971). Relating reactions in silver-mercury, tin-mercury to properties of amalgam alloys. J Dent Res 50:944-959.

88.

Sutfin LV, Ogilvie RE (1972). Scanning electron microscopy, energy dispersion microanalysis of metallographically polished dental amalgam surfaces. J Dent Res 51:1048-1054.

89.

Taylor DF, Burns CL (1963). An investigation of the constitution of the mercury-tin system. J Res Natl Bur Stand 67(A):55-70.

90.

Treheux D., Guiraldenq P., Blanc-Benon JJ (1975). Diffusion de l'argent, de l'etain, du mercure pendant la preparation des amalgames (Diffusion of silver, tin, mercury during the preparation of amalgams). Odontol Conservatrice 2:47-59.

91.

Troiano AR (1938). An x-ray study of dental amalgams. J Inst Met 63:247-259.

92.

von Simson C. (1924). Rontgenuntersuchungen an amalgamen. Z Physik Chem 109:183-192.

93.

Vrijhoef MA, Driessens FCM (1973). X-ray diffraction analysis of Cu6Sn5 formation during setting of dental amalgam (research annotation). J Dent Res 52:841.

94.

Wing G. ( 1966). Phase identification in dental amalgam. Aust Dent J 11: 105-113.

95.

Wing G., Ryge G. ( 1965a). Reaction of silver-tin alloys and mercury. ) Dent Res 44:701-711.

96.

Wing G., Ryge G. ( 1965b). Setting reactions of spherical-particle amalgams. J Dent Res 44:1325-1333.

97.

Youdelis WV (1967). Dental amalgam. US Patent No. 3,305,356. Feb.