Craniofacial malformations are the most common birth defects that occur in humans, with facial clefting representing the majority of these defects. Facial clefts can arise at any stage of development due to perturbations that alter the extracellular matrix as well as affect the patterning, migration, proliferation, and differentiation of cells. In this review, we focus on recent advances in the understanding of the developmental basis for facial clefting through the analysis of the effects of gene disruption experiments and treatments with teratogens in both chickens and mice. Specifically, we analyze the results of disruptions to genes such as Sonic hedgehog (Shh), epidermal growth factor receptor ( EGFR), Distal-less (Dlx), and transforming growth factor beta 3 (TGFβ3). We also describe the effects that teratogens such as retinoic acid, jervine, and cyclopamine have on facial clefting and discuss mechanisms for their action. In addition to providing insight into the bases for abnormal craniofacial growth, genetic and teratogenic techniques are powerful tools for understanding the normal developmental processes that generate and pattern the face.
References
1.
Bally-Cuif L., Boncinelli E. (1997). Transcription factors and head formation in vertebrates. Bioessays19:127-135.
2.
Beachy PA, Cooper MK, Young KE, von Kessler DP, Park W.), Hall TM, et al. (1997). Multiple roles of cholesterol in hedgehog protein biogenesis and signaling. Cold Spring Harbor Symp on Quantitat Biol62:191-204.
3.
Bronner-Fraser M. (1995). Origins and developmental potential of the neural crest. Exp Cell Res218:405-417.
4.
Brown JM, Robertson KE, Wedden SE, Tickle C. (1997). Alterations in Msx 1 and Msx 2 expression correlate with inhibition of outgrowth of chick facial primordia induced by retinoic acid. Anat Embryol195:203-207.
5.
Brown MS, Goldstein JL (1997). The SREBP pathway: regulation of cholesterol metabolism by proteolysis of a membrane-bound transcription factor. Cell89:331-340.
6.
Brunet CL, Sharpe PM, Ferguson MW (1995). Inhibition of TGF-beta 3 (but not TGF-beta 1 or TGF-beta 2) activity prevents normal mouse embryonic palate fusion. Int J Dev Biol39:345-355.
7.
Bryden MM, Keeler RF (1973). Proceedings: effects of alkaloids of Veratrum californicum on developing embryos. J Anat116:464.
8.
Bulfone A., Kim HJ, Puelles L., Porteus MH, Grippo JF, Rubenstein JL (1993). The mouse Dlx-2 (Tes-1) gene is expressed in spatially restricted domains of the forebrain, face and limbs in midgestation mouse embryos. Mech Dev40:129-140.
9.
Carette MJ, Ferguson MW (1992). The fate of medial edge epithelial cells during palatal fusion in vitro: an analysis by Dil labelling and confocal microscopy. Development114:379-388.
10.
Carstea ED, Morris JA, Coleman KG, Loftus SK, Zhang D., Cummings C., et al. (1997). Niemann-Pick Cl disease gene: homology to mediators of cholesterol homeostasis. Science277:228-231.
11.
Casci T., Vinos J., Freeman M. (1999). Sprouty, an intracellular inhibitor of Ras signaling. Cell96:655-665.
12.
Chenevix-Trench G., Jones K., Green AC, Duffy DL, Martin NG (1992). Cleft lip with or without cleft palate: associations with transforming growth factor alpha and retinoic acid receptor loci. Am J Hum Genet51:1377-1385.
13.
Chiang C., Litingtung Y., Lee E., Young KE, Corden JL, Westphal H., et al. (1996). Cyclopia and defective axial patterning in mice lacking Sonic hedgehog gene function. Nature383:407-413.
14.
Cooper MK, Porter JA, Young KE, Beachy PA (1998). Teratogen-mediated inhibition of target tissue response to Shh signaling. Science280:1603-1607.
15.
Couly GF, Coltey PM, Le Douarin NM (1993). The triple origin of skull in higher vertebrates: a study in quail-chick chimeras. Development117:409-429.
16.
Dolle P., Ruberte E., Leroy P., Morriss-Kay G., Chambon P. (1990). Retinoic acid receptors and cellular retinoid binding proteins. I. A systematic study of their differential pattern of transcription during mouse organo-genesis. Development110:1133-1151.
17.
Dolle P., Price M., Duboule D. (1992). Expression of the murine Dlx-1 homeobox gene during facial, ocular and limb development. Differentiation49:93-99.
18.
Duboule D. (1994). Guidebook to the homeobox genes. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
19.
Ellerbroek SM, Hudson LG, Stack MS (1998). Proteinase requirements of epidermal growth factor-induced ovarian cancer cell invasion. Int J Cancer78:331-337.
20.
Ericson JM, Kawakami A., Roelink H., lessell TM (1996). Two critical periods of Sonic Hedgehog signaling required for the specification of motor neuron identity. Cell87:661-673.
Ferguson MW, Honig LS (1985). Experimental fusion of the naturally cleft, embryonic chick palate. J Craniofac Genet Dev Biol1(Suppl):323-337.
23.
Fitchett JE, Hay ED (1989). Medial edge epithelium transforms to mesenchyme after embryonic palatal shelves fuse. Dev Biol131:455-474.
24.
Fitzpatrick DR, Denhez F., Kondaiah P., Akhurst RJ (1990). Differential expression of TGF beta isoforms in murine palatogenesis. Development109:585-595.
25.
Foerst-Potts L., Sadler TW (1997). Disruption of Msx-1 and Msx-2 reveals roles for these genes in craniofacial, eye, and axial development. Dev Dyn209:70-84.
26.
Gaunt SJ, Blum M., DeRobertis EM (1993). Expression of the mouse goosecoid gene during mid-embryogenesis may mark mesenchymal cell lineages in the developing head, limbs and body wall. Development117:769-778.
27.
Glucksmann A. (1951). Cell death in normal vetebrate ontogeny. Biol Rev26:59-86.
28.
Gorlin RJ, Cohen MM, Levin LS (1990). Syndromes of the head and neck. New York: Oxford University Press.
29.
Graham A., Koentges G., Lumsden A. (1996). Neural crest apoptosis and the establishment of craniofacial pattern: an honorable death. Molec Cell Neurosci8:76-83.
30.
Grant JH, Maggio-Price L., Reutebuch J., Cunningham ML (1997). Retinoic acid exposure of the mouse on embryonic day 9 selectively spares derivatives of the frontonasal neural crest. J Craniofac Genet Dev Biol17:1-8.
31.
Greene RM, Pratt RM (1978). Inhibition of epithelial cell death in the secondary palate in vitro by alteration of lysosome function. J Histochem Cytochem26:1109-1114.
32.
Griffith CM, Hay ED (1992). Epithelial-mesenchymal transformation during palatal fusion: carboxyfluorescein traces cells at light and electron microscopic levels. Development116:1087-1099.
33.
Hamburger V., Hamilton HL (1951). A series of normal stages in the development of the chick embryo. J Morphol88:49-92.
34.
Hecht JT, Wang YP, Blanton SH, Michels W., Daiger SP (1991). Cleft lip and palate: no evidence of linkage to transforming growth factor alpha. Am J Hum Genet49:682-686.
35.
Helms JA, Kim CH, Eichele G., Thaller C. (1996). Retinoic acid signaling is required during early chick limb development. Development122:1385-1394.
36.
Helms JA, Kim CH, Hu D., Minkoff R., Thaller C., Eichele G. (1997). Sonic hedgehog participates in craniofacial morphogenesis and is down-regulated by teratogenic doses of retinoic acid. Dev Biol187:25-35.
37.
Hoover F., Glover JC (1998). Regional pattern of retinoid X receptor-alpha gene expression in the central nervous system of the chicken embryo and its up-regulation by exposure to 9-cis retinoic acid. J Comp Neurol398575-586.
38.
Hu D., Helms IA (1999). The role of Sonic hedgehog in normal and abnormal craniofacial morphogenesis. Development126:4873-4884.
39.
Hunt P. Krumlauf R. (1991). Deciphering the Hox code: clues to patterning branchial regions of the head. Cell66:1075-1078.
40.
Hunt P. Ferretti P., Krumlauf R., Thorogood P. (1995). Restoration of normal Hox code and branchial arch morphogenesis after extensive deletion of hindbrain neural crest Dev Biol168:584-597.
41.
Jones EA (1997) Introduction: retinoic acid and its receptors in development. Semin Cell Dev Biol8:401-402.
42.
Jones FS, Kioussi C., Copertino DW, Kallunki P., Hoist BD, Edelman GM (1997). Barx2 a new homeobox gene of the Bar class, is expressed in neural and craniofacial structures during development. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA94:2632-2637.
43.
Kaartinen V. Voncken JW, Shuler C., Warburton D., Bu D., Heisterkamp N., et al. (1995). Abnormal lung development and cleft palate in mice lacking TGF-β3 indicates defects of epithelial-mesenchymal interaction. Nat Genet11: 415-421.
44.
Kaartinen V. Cui XM, Heisterkamp N., Groffen J., Shuler CF (1997). Transforming growth factor-beta3 regulates transdifferentiation of medial edge epithelium during palatal fusion and associated degradation of the basement membrane. Dev Dyn209:255-260.
45.
Kaufman MH (1992). The atlas of mouse development. San Diego CA: Academic Press.
46.
Keeler RF Binns W. (1968). Teratogenic compounds of Veratrum californicum (Durand). V. Comparison of cyclopian effects of steroidal alkaloids from the plant and structurally related compounds from other sources. Teratology1:5-10.
47.
Kelley RL, Roessler E., Hennekam RC, Feldman GL, Kosaki K. Jones MC, et al. (1996). Holoprosencephaly in RSH/Smith-Lemli-Opitz syndrome: does abnormal cholesterol metabolism affect the function of Sonic Hedgehog? Am J Med Genet66:478-484.
48.
Kingsley DM (1994). The TGF-beta superfamily: new members, new receptors, and new genetic tests of function in different organisms. Genes Dev8:133-146.
49.
Köntges G., Lumsden A. (1996), Rhombencephalic neural crest segmentation is preserved throughout craniofacial ontogeny Development122:3229-3242.
50.
Krumlauf R. Marshall H. Studer M., Nonchev S., Sham MH, Lumsden A. (1993). Hox homeobcx genes and regionalisation of the nervous system. J Neurobiol24:1328-1340.
51.
Kuratani S., Matsuo I., Aizawa S. (1997). Developmental patterning and evolution of the mammalian viscerocranium: genetic insights into comparative morphology. Dev Dyn209:139-155.
52.
Loftus SK, Morris JA, Carstea ED, Gu JZ Cummings C., Brown A., et al. (1997). Murine model of Niemann-Pick C disease: mutation in a cholesterol homeostasis gene. Science277:232-235.
53.
Lohnes D., Mark M., Mendelsohn C., Dolle P., Dierich D., Gorry P., et al. (1994). Function of the retinoic acid receptors (RARs) during development (l). Craniofacial and skeletal abnormalities in RAR double mutants. Development120:2723-2748.
54.
Mansouri A., Stoykova A., Torres M., Gruss P. (1996). Dysgenesis of cephalic neural crest derivatives in Pax7-/- mutant mice. Development122:831-838.
55.
Matsuo I., Kuratani S., Kimura C., Takeda N., Aizawa S. (1995). Mouse Otx2 functions in the formation and patterning of rostral head. Genes Dev9:2646-2658.
56.
McGonnell IM, Clarke JD, Tickle C. (1998). Fate map of the developing chick face: analysis of expansion of facial primordia and establishment of the primary palate. Dev Dyn212:102-118.
57.
Miettinen PJ, Chin JR, Shum L., Slavkin HC, Shuler CF, Derynck R., et al. ( 1999). Epidermal growth factor receptor function is necessary for normal craniofacial development and palate closure. Nat Genet22:69-73.
58.
Mitchell PJ, Timmons PM, Hebert JM, Rigby PWJ, Tjian R. (1991). Transcription factor AP-2 is expressed in neural crest cell lineages during mouse embryogenesis. Genes Dev5:105-119.
59.
Morriss-Kay G. (1993). Retinoic acid and craniofacial development: molecules and morphogenesis. Bioessays15:9-15.
60.
Naski MC, Ornitz DM (1998). FGF signaling in skeletal development. Front Biosci3:781-794.
61.
Noden DM (1978). The control of avian cephalic neural crest cytodifferentiation: 1. Skeletal and connective tissues. Dev Biol67:296-312.
62.
Noden DM (1983). The role of the neural crest in patterning of avian cranial skeletal, connective, and muscle tissues. Dev Biol96:144-165.
63.
Noden DM (1986). Origins and patterning of craniofacial mesenchymal tissues. Craniofac Genet Dev Biol2:15-31.
64.
Osumi-Yamashita N., Noji S., Nohno T. Koyama E., Doi H., Eto K., et al. ( 1990). Expression of retinoic acid receptor genes in neural crest-derived cells during mouse facial development. FEBS Lett264:71-74.
65.
Osumi-Yamashita N., Ninomiya Y., Doi H. Eto K. (1994). The contribution of both forebrain and midbrain crest cells to the mesenchyme in the frontonasal mass of mouse embryos. Dev Biol164:409-419.
66.
Pelton RW, Hogan BL, Miller DA, Moses HL (1990). Differential expression of genes encoding TGFs beta 1, beta 2, and beta 3 during murine palate formation. Dev Biol141:456-460.
67.
Pelton RW, Saxena B., Jones M., Moses HL, Gold L.l (1991). Immunohistochemical localization of TGF beta 1, TGF beta 2, and TGF beta 3 in the mouse embryo: expression patterns suggest multiple roles during embryonic development. J Cell Biol115:1091-1105.
68.
Peters H., Neubuser A., Kratochwil K., Balling R. (1998). Pax9-deficient mice lack pharyngeal pouch derivatives and teeth and exhibit craniofacial and limb abnormalities. Genes Dev12:2735-2747.
69.
Price M. (1993). Members of the Dlx- and Nkx2-gene families are regionally expressed in the developing forebrain. J Neurobiol24:1385-1399.
70.
Proetzel G., Pawlowski SA, Wiles MV, Yin M., Boivin GP, Howles PN, et al. (1995). Transforming growth factor-beta 3 is required for secondary palate fusion. Nat Genet11:409-414.
71.
Oiu M., Bulfone A., Martinez S., Meneses JJ, Shimamura K., Pedersen RA, et al. (1995). Null mutation of Dlx-2 results in abnormal morphogenesis of proximal first and second branchial arch derivatives and abnormal differentiation in the forebrain. Genes Dev9:2523-2538.
72.
Qiu M., Bulfone A., Ghattas I., Meneses JJ, Christensen L., Sharpe PT, et al. (1997). Role of the Dlx homeobox genes in proximodistal patterning of the branchial arches: mutations of Dlx-1, Dlx-2, and Dlx-1 and -2 alter morphogenesis of proximal skeletal and soft tissue structures derived from the first and second arches. Dev Biol185:165-184.
73.
Richman JM (1992). The role of retinoids in normal and abnormal embryonic craniofacial morphogenesis. Crit Rev Oral Biol Med4:93-109.
74.
Richman JM, Tickle C. (1989). Epithelia are interchangeable between facial primordia of chick embryos and morphogenesis is controlled by the mesenchyme. Dev Biol136:201-210.
75.
Rivera-Perez JA, Mallo M., Gendron-Maguire M., Gridley T., Behringer RR (1995). Goosecoid is not an essential component of the mouse gastrula organizer but is required for craniofacial and rib development. Development121:3005-3012.
76.
Robinson GW, Mahon KA (1994). Differential and overlapping expression domains of Dlx-2 and Dlx-3 suggest distinct roles for Distal-less homeobox genes in craniofacial development. Mech Dev48:199-215.
77.
Roessler E., Belloni E., Gaudenz K., Jay P., Berta P., Scherer SW, et al. (1996). Mutations in the human Sonic Hedgehog gene cause holoprosencephaly. Nat Genet14:357-360.
78.
Romer AS (1956). Osteology of the reptiles. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
79.
Rowe A., Brickell PM (1995). Expression of the chicken retinoid X receptor-gamma gene in migrating cranial neural crest cells. Anat Embryol192:1-8.
80.
Rowe A., Eager NS, Brickell PM (1991a). A member of the RXR nuclear receptor family is expressed in neural-crest-derived cells of the developing chick peripheral nervous system. Development111:771-778.
81.
Rowe A., Richman JM, Brickell PM (1991b). Retinoic acid treatment alters the distribution of retinoic acid receptor-beta transcripts in the embryonic chick face. Development111:1007-1016.
82.
Rowe A., Richman JM, Brickell PM (1992). Development of the spatial pattern of retinoic acid receptor-beta transcripts in embryonic chick facial primordia. Development114:805-813.
83.
Rubenstein JL, Beachy PA (1998). Patterning of the embryonic forebrain. Curr Opin Neurobiol8:18-26.
84.
Ruberte E., Dolle P., Chambon P., Morriss-Kay G. (1991). Retinoic acid receptors and cellular retinoid binding proteins. II. Their differential pattern of transcription during early morphogenesis in mouse embryos. Development111:45-60.
85.
Ruberte E., Friederich V., Chambon P., Morriss-Kay G. (1993). Retinoic acid receptors and cellular retinoid binding proteins. III. Their differential transcript distribution during mouse nervous system development. Development118:267-282.
86.
Satokata I., Maas R. ( 1994). Msx1 deficient mice exhibit cleft palate and abnormalities of craniofacial and tooth development. Nat Genet6:348-356.
87.
Saunders JW Jr (1966). Death in embryonic systems. Science154:604-612.
88.
Schilling TF (1997). Genetic analysis of craniofacial development in the vertebrate embryo. Bioessays19:459-468.
89.
Schmid P., Cox D., Bilbe G., Maier R., McMaster GK (1991). Differential expression of TGF beta 1, beta 2 and beta 3 genes during mouse embryogenesis. Development111:117-130.
90.
Schneider RA (1999). Neural crest can form cartilages normally derived from mesoderm during development of the avian head skeleton. Dev Biol208:441-455.
91.
Schneider RA, Helms JA (1998). Development and regeneration of the musculoskeletal system. Curr Opin Orthop9:20-24.
92.
Schneider RA, Hu D., Helms JA (1999). From head to toe: conservation of molecular signals regulating limb and craniofacial morphogenesis. Cell Tissue Res296:103-109.
93.
Schorle H., Meier P., Buchert M., Jaenisch R., Mitchell PJ (1996). Transcription factor AP-2 essential for cranial closure and craniofacial development. Nature381:235-238.
94.
Serbedzija GN, Bronner-Fraser M., Fraser SE (1992). Vital dye analysis of cranial neural crest cell migration in the mouse embryo. Development116:297-307.
95.
Shah RM, Crawford BJ (1980). Development of the secondary palate in chick embryo: a light and electron microscopic and histochemical study. Invest Cell Pathol3:319-328.
96.
Shah RM, Cheng KM, MacKay RA, Wong A. ( 1987). Secondary palate development in the domestic duck (Khaki Campbell). An electron microscopic, histochemical, autoradiographic and biochemical study. J Anat154245-258.
97.
Shapiro BL, Sweney L. (1969). Electron microscopic and histochemical examination of oral epithelial-mesenchymal interaction (programmed cell death). J Dent Res48:652-660.
98.
Shen H., Wilke T. Ashique AM, Narvey M., Zerucha T., Savino E., et al. (1997). Chicken transcription factor AP-2: cloning, expression and its role in outgrowth of facial prominences and limb buds. Dev Biol188:248-266.
99.
Shepard TH (1995). Catalog of teratogenic agents. Baltimore lohns Hopkins University Press.
100.
Shiang R., Lidral AC, Ardinger HH Buetow KH, Romitti PA, Munger RG, et al. (1993). Association of transforming growth-factor alpha gene polymorphisms with nonsyndromic cleft palate only (CPO). Am J Hum Genet53:836-843
101.
Shuler CF, Halpern DE, Guo Y., Sank AC ( 1992). Medial edge epithelium fate traced by cell lineage analysis during epithelial-mesenchymal transformation in vivo Dev Biol154:318-330.
102.
Simeone A., Acampora D., Gulisano M., Stornaiuolo A., Boncinelli E. (1992). Nested expression domains of four homeobox genes in developing rostral brain. Nature358:687-690
103.
Smith KK Schneider RA (1998). Have gene knockouts caused evolutionary reversals in the mammalian first arch? BioEssays20:245-255.
104.
Smith SM (1994). Retinoic acid receptor isoform beta 2 is an early marker for alimentary tract and central nervous system positional specification in the chicken. Dev Dyn20014-25.
105.
Smith SM Eichele G. (1991). Temporal and regional differences in the expression pattern of distinct retinoic acid receptor-beta transcripts in the chick embryo. Development111:245-252.
Sucov HM Evans RM (1995). Retinoic acid and retinoic acid receptors in development. Molec Neurobiol10:169-184
108.
Sun D. Vanderburg CR, Odierna GS, Hay ED (1998). TGFbeta3 promotes transformation of chicken palate medial edge epithelium to mesenchyme in vitro. Development125:95-105.
109.
Suzuki M. Raab G., Moses MA, Fernandez CA, Klagsbrun M. (1997). Matrix metalloproteinase-3 releases active heparin-binding EGF-like growth factor by cleavage at a specific juxtamembrane site. J Biol Chem272:31730-31737.
110.
Tamarin A., Crawley A., Lee J., Tickle C. (1984). Analysis of upper beak defects in chicken embryos following with retinoic acid. J Embryol Exp Morphol84:105-123.
111.
Taya Y., O'Kane S., Ferguson M. (1999). Pathogenesis of cleft palate in TGFb3 knockout mice. Development126:3869-3879.
112.
Ten Berge D., Brouwer A., Korving J., Martin JF, Meijlink F. (1998). Prxl and Prx2 in skeletogenesis: roles in the craniofacial region, inner ear and limbs Development125:3831-3842.
113.
van der Wees J., Schilthuis JG, Koster CH, Diesveld-Schipper H., Folkers GE, van der Saag PT, et al. (1998). Inhibition of retinoic acid receptor-mediated signalling alters positional identity in the developing hindbrain. Development125:545-556.
114.
Vintiner GM, Holder SE, Winter RM, Malcolm S. (1992). No evidence of linkage between the transforming growth factor-alpha gene in families with apparently autosomal dominant inheritance of cleft lip and palate. J Med Genet29:393-397.
115.
Wedden SE (1987). Epithelial-mesenchymal interactions in the development of chick facial primordia and the target of retinoid action. Development99:341-351.
116.
Wedden SE (1991). Effects of retinoids on chick face development. J Craniofac Genet Dev Biol11:326-337.
117.
Willnow TE, Hilpert J., Armstrong SA, Rohlmann A., Hammer RE, Burns DK, et al. (1996). Defective forebrain development in mice lacking gp330/megalin. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA93:8460-8464.
118.
Wyszynski DF, Maestri N., Lewanda AF Mcintosh I., Smith EA, García-Delgado C., et al. (1997). No evidence of linkage for cleft lip with or without cleft palate to a marker near the transforming growth factor alpha locus in two populations. Hum Hered47:101-109.
119.
Yamada G., Mansouri A., Torres M., Stuart ET Blum M., Schultz M., et al. (1995). Targeted mutation of the murine goosecoid gene results in craniofacial defects and death. Development121:2917-2922.
120.
Yamagata T., Momoi MY, Yanagisawa M., Kumagai H., Yamakado M., Momoi T. (1994). Changes of the expression and distribution of retinoic acid receptors during neurogenesis in mouse embryos. Dev Brain Res77:163-176.
121.
Zhang J., Hagopian-Donaldson S., Serbedzija G., Elsemore J. Plehn-Dujowich D., McMahon AP, et al. (1996). Neural tube, skeletal and body wall defects in mice lacking transcription factor AP-2. Nature381:238-241.
