This article illustrates that certain relatively well-known results from feedback control theory can be used to determine the maximum-attainable power generation for a vibratory energy harvester excited by a stationary broadband stochastic disturbance. For such applications, control techniques based on impedance matching theory cannot be used to optimize power generation, because the dynamic controller they prescribe is always anticausal. However, an optimal causal controller does exist, and can be derived using H2/LQG theory. Levels of power generation with this controller are compared to those of the anticausal optimal performance, as well as to traditional 'tuning' techniques which match the anticausal impedance only at the resonant frequency. It is demonstrated that tuning techniques can be significantly sub-optimal in broadband applications, especially when electronic conversion is relatively efficient. In addition to being useful in the design of controllers for energy harvesting applications, these results may also be used to ascertain the insurpassable power generation limits associated with a given combination of transducer and electronic hardware.
Braslavsky, J.H., Seron, M.M., Mayne, D.Q. and Kokotovic, P.V.1999. "Limiting Performance of Optimal Linear Filters," Automatica, 35:189-199.
6.
Brogliato, B., Lozano, R., Maschke, B. and Egeland, O.2007. Dissipative Systems Analysis and Control, 2nd edn, Springer-Verlag, London.
7.
Bryson, A.E. and Johansen, D.E.1965. "Linear Filtering for Time-Varying Systems using Measurements Containing Colored Noise," IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 10:4-10.
8.
Clements, D.J. and Anderson, B.D.O.1973. "Singular Optimal Control: The Linear Quadratic Problem," In: Balakrishnan, A.V. and Thorma, M. (eds), Lecture Notes in Control and Information Sciences, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg , New York.
9.
Elliott, S.J., Joseph, P., Nelson, P.A. and Johnson, M.E.1991. "Power Output Minimization and Power Absorption in the Active Control of Sound," Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 90:2501-2512.
10.
Glaese, R.M. and Miller, D.W.1999. "A Generalized Impedance Matching Method for Determining Structural-Acoustic Power Flow Control Laws," Journal of Sound & Vibration, 224:283-808.
11.
Guyomar, D., Magnet, C., Lefeuvre, E. and Richard, C.2006. "Nonlinear Processing of the Output Voltage of a Piezoelectric Transformer," IEEE Transactions On Ultrasonics Ferroelectrics And Frequency Control, 53:1362-1375.
12.
Haddad, W.M., Bernstein, D.S. and Wang, Y.W.1994. "Dissipative H2/H∞ Controller Synthesis,"IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 39:827-831.
13.
Hirami, N.1999. "Optimal Energy Absorption as an Active Noise and Vibration Control Strategy," Journal of Sound and Vibration, 200:243-259.
14.
Kasyap, A., Lim, J., Johnson, D., Horowitz, S., Nishida, T., Ngo, K., Sheplak, M. and Cattafesta, L.2002. "Energy reclamation from a vibrating piezoceramic composite beam," In: Ninth Interational Congress on Sound and Vibration , 8-11 July, Orlando, FL.
15.
Kishimoto, Y., Bernstein, D.S. and Hall, S.R.1995a. "Energy Flow Control of Interconnected Structures: I. Modal Subsystems,"Control-Theory and Advanced Technology , 10:1563-1590.
16.
Kishimoto, Y., Bernstein, D.S. and Hall, S.R.1995b. "Energy Flow Control of Interconnected Structures: II. Structural Subsystems,"Control-Theory and Advanced Technology , 10:1591-1618.
17.
Kishimoto, Y., Bernstein, D.S. and Hall, S.R.1995c. "Energy Flow Modelling of Structures: A Deterministic Foundation for Statistical Energy Analysis," Journal of Sound and Vibration, 186:407-445.
18.
Kwakernaak, H. and Sivan, R.1972. "The maximally Achievable Accuracy of Linear Optimal Regulators and Linear Optimal Filters," IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 17:79-85.
19.
Liu, Y., Tian, G., Wang, Y., Lin, J., Zhang, Q. and Hofmann, H.F. 2009. "Active Piezoelectric Energy Harvesting: General Principle and Experimental Demonstration,"Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures, 20:575-585.
20.
Lozano-Leal, R. and Joshi, S.M.1988. "On the Design of Dissipative LQG Type Controller," In: IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, Austin, TX, pp. 1645-1646.
21.
Lozano-Leal, R. and Joshi, S.M.1990. "Strictly Postiive Real Transfer Functions Revisited," IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 35:1243-1245.
22.
Luenberger, D.1971. "An Introduction to Observers,"IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 16:596-602.
23.
MacMartin, D.G. and Hall, S.R.1991a. "Control of Uncertain Structures Using an H∞ Power Flow Approach," Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics , 14:521-530.
24.
MacMartin, D.G. and Hall, S.R.1991b. "Structural Control Experiments Using an H∞ Power Flow Approach," Journal of Sound and Vibration, 148:223-241.
25.
MacMartin, D.G., Miller, D.W. and Hall, S.R.1991. "Structural Control Using Active Broadband Impedance Matching," In: Rogers, C.A. and Fuller, C.A. (eds), Recent Advances in Active Control of Sound & Vibration, pp. 604-617.
26.
Makihara, K., Onoda, J. and Miyakawa, T.2006. "Low Energy Dissipation Electric Circuit for Energy Harvesting ," Smart Materials & Structures, 15:1493-1498.
27.
Miller, D.W., Hall, S.R. and von Flotow, A.H.1990. "Optimal Control of Power Flow at Structural Junctions ," Journal of Sound and Vibration, 140:475-497.
28.
Ottman, G.K., Hofmann, H.F. and Lesieutre, G.A.2003. "Optimized Piezoelectric Energy Harvesting Circuit Using Step-down Converter in Discontinuous Conduction Mode," IEEE Transactions On Power Electronics, 18:696-703.
29.
Scherer, C., Gahinet, P. and Chilali, M.1997. "Multiobjective Output-Feedback Control Via LMI Optimization ," IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 42:896-911.
30.
Schumacher, J.M.1985. "A geometric Approach to the Singular Filtering Problem ," IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 30:1075-1082.
31.
Scruggs, J.T.2008. "Multi-objective Optimal Control of Vibratory Energy Harvesting Systems," In: SPIE Smart Structures and Materials Conference, San Diego, CA.
32.
Scruggs, J.T.2009. "An Optimal Stochastic Control Theory for Distributed Energy Harvesting Networks,"Journal of Sound and Vibration , 320:707-725.
33.
Sharp, S.J., Nelson, P.A. and Koopmann, G.H.2002. "A Theoretical Investigation of Optimal Power Absorption as a Noise Control Technique," Journal of Sound and Vibration , 251:927-935.
34.
Sodano, H.A., Park, G. and Inman, D.J.2004. "Estimation of Electric Charge Output for Piezoelectric Energy Harvesting," Strain, 40:49-58.
35.
Taylor, J.H.1974. "Strictly Positive Real Functions and Lefschetz-Kalman-Yakubovich (LKY) Lemma," IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems, 3:310-311.
36.
Ward, J.K. and Behrens, S.2008. "Adaptive Learning Algorithms for Vibration Energy Harvesting,"Smart Materials & Structures, 17:035025.
37.
Willems, J.C.1971. "Least Squares Stationary Optimal Control and the Algebraic Riccati Equation," IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control , 16:621-634.
