This work describes damage detection in a foam core composite wing (1320 mm × 152.4 mm × 13.4 mm) following a series of low energy impacts. Thirteen impacts (6—8 J deposited energy) were applied at adjacent locations approximately 1/4 of the way out from the wing center. Following every one or two impacts, the wing was tested using static tip deflection and dynamic vibrational excitation. Static and dynamic strains were measured using eight fiber Bragg grating sensors. Dynamic acceleration was also monitored using three conventional accelerometers. The estimated bicoherence was used to detect the presence of damage-induced non-linearity in time-series data recorded from each sensor. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were constructed for each sensor based on 15 or more dynamic measurements made for each damage case. The ROC curves provide a quantitative, statistical approach to evaluating the damage detection capabilities of the various sensors.
Aktas, E., Seaver, M., Nichols, J.M., Trickey, S.T. and Davis, W.R.2009. ‘‘The Influence of Low Energy Impacts on the Static and Dynamic Response of a Foam Core Composite Wing,’’Journal of Intelligent Materials Systems and Structures, 20:1351-1361.
2.
Asraf, D.E. and Gustafsson, M.G.2003. ‘‘Optimal Detection of Crack Echo Families in Elastic Solids,’’ Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 113:2732-2741.
3.
Azarbayejani, M., El-Osery, A.I., Choi, K.K. and Taha, M.M.R.2008. ‘‘A Probabilistic Approach for Optimal Sensor Allocation in Structural Health Monitoring,’’Smart Materials and Structures, 17, art. # 055019.
4.
Brockett, P.L., Hinich, M.J. and Patterson, D.1988. ‘‘Bispectral-based Tests for the Detection of Gaussianity and Linearity in Time Series,’’Journal of the American Statistical Association, 83(403):657-664.
5.
Farrar, C.R., Worden, K., Todd, M.D., Park, G., Nichols, J., Adams, D.E., Bement, M.T. and Farinholt, K.2007. ‘‘Nonlinear System Identification for Damage Detection,’’Report on a Los Alamos National Laboratory Workshop, #LA-14353. Available at: http://institute.lanl.gov/ei/annual-workshops/
6.
Frangopol, D.M. and Messervey, T.B.2008. ‘‘Quantifying the Benefits of Smart Technologies in a Life-cycle Context,’’ Advances in Science and Technology, 56:179-188.
7.
Goebel, K.F., Yan, W., Eklund, N.H.W. and Hu, X.2006. ‘‘Defect Classification of Highly Noisy NDE Data Using Classifier Ensembles,’’ In: Inaudi, D., Ecke, W., Culshaw, B., Peters, K.J. and Udd, E. (eds), Proceedings of the SPIE, Smart Structures and Materials, Smart Sensor Monitoring Systems and Applications, Vol. 6167, pp. 460-471.
8.
Hickey, D., Worden, K., Platten, M.F., Wright, J.R. and Cooper, J.E.2008. ‘‘Higher-order Spectra for Identification of Nonlinear Modal Coupling,’’Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, doi:10.1016/j.ymssp.2008.10.008.
9.
Hillis, A.J., Nelid, S.A., Drinkwater, B.W. and Wilcox, P.D.2006. ‘‘Global Crack Detection Using Bispectral Analysis,’’Proceedings of the Royal Society A , 462:1515-1530.
10.
Hinich, M.J. and Wilson, G.R.1990. ‘‘Detection of Non-Gaussian Signals in Non-Gaussian Noise Using the Bispectrum,’’ IEEE Transactions on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, 38(7):1126-1131.
11.
Hopley, L. and van Schalkwyk, J.2007. ‘‘The Magnificent ROC,’’ Available at: http://www.anaesthetist.com/mnm/stats/roc/Findex.htm
12.
Kim, Y.C. and Powers, E.J.1979. ‘‘Digital Bispectral Analysis and its Application to Nonlinear Wave Interaction,’’ IEEE Transaction of Plasma Science, PS-7:120-131.
13.
Lu, Y.H. and Michaels, J.E.2005. ‘‘A Methodology for Structural Health Monitoring with Diffuse Ultrasonic Waves in the Presence of Temperature Variations, ’’ Ultrasonics, 9:717-731.
14.
McDonough, R.N. and Whalen, A.D.1995. Detection of Signals in Noise, Academic Press, New York.
15.
Milanese, A., Marzocca, P., Nichols, J.M., Seaver, M. and Trickey, S.T.2008. ‘‘Modeling and Detection of Joint Loosening Using Output-only Broad-band Vibration Data,’’ Structural Health Monitoring an International Journal, 7:309-328.
16.
Nichols, J.M., Seaver, M., Trickey, S.T., Salvino, L.W. and Pecora, D.L.2005. ‘‘Detecting Impact Damage in Experimental Composite Structures: An Information-theoretic Approach,’’ Smart Materials and Structures, 14:1-11.
17.
Nichols, J.M., Trickey, S.T., Seaver, M., Motley, S.R. and Eisner, E.D.2007. ‘‘Using Ambient Vibrations to Detect Loosening of a Composite-to-metal Bolted Joint in the Presence of Strong Temperature Fluctuations,’’ Journal of Vibrations and Acoustics -transactions of the ASME, 129:710-717.
18.
Nichols, J.M., Trickey, S.T., Seaver, M. and Motley, S.R.2008. ‘‘Using ROC Curves to Assess the Efficacy of Several Detectors of Damage-induced Nonlinearities in a Bolted Composite Structure,’’ Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing , 22:1610-1622.
19.
Okure, M.A.E. and Peshkin, M.A.1995. ‘‘Quantitative Evaluation of Neural Networks for NDE Applications Using the ROC Curve,’’ Review of Progress in Quantitataive Nondestructive Evaluation Parts A&B, 14:2405-2412.
20.
Olin, B.D. and Meeker, W.Q.1996. ‘‘Applications of Statistical Methods to Nondestructive Evaluation,’’ Technometrics, 38:95-112.
21.
Rivola, A. and White, P.R.1998. ‘‘Bispectral Analysis of the Bilinear Oscillator with Application to the Detection of Fatigue Cracks,’’ Journal of Sound and Vibration, 216:899-910.
22.
Richardson, A.M. and Hodgkiss, W.S.1994. ‘‘Bispectral Analysis of Underwater Acoustic Data,’’ Journal of the Acoustical Society of America , 96:828-837.
23.
Peeters, B. and De Roeck, G.2001. ‘‘One-year Monitoring of the Z24Bridge: Environmental Effects Versus Damage Events,’’ Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics, 30:149-171.
24.
Petrunin, I. and Gelman, L.2008. ‘‘Novel Optimization of Bicoherence Estimation for Fatigue Monitoring,’’Insight, doi:10.1784/insi.2008.50.3.133.
25.
Shook, B.D., Millwater, H.R., Enright, M.P., Hudak, S.J. and Francis, W.L.2008. ‘‘Simulation of Recurring Automated Inspections on Probability-of-fracture Estimates,’’ Structural Health Monitoring an International Journal, 7:293-307.
26.
Sohn, H., Dzwonczyk, M., Straser, E.G., Kiremidjian, A.S., Law, K.H. and Meng, T.1999. ‘‘An Experimental Study of Temperature Effect on Modal Parameters of the Alamosa Canyon Bridge,’’ Earthquake Engineering and Structural Dynamics, 28:879-897.
27.
Swets, J.A.1988. ‘‘Measuring the Accuracy of Diagnostic Systems ,’’ Science, 240:1285-1293.
28.
Todd, M.D., Seaver, M., Bucholtz, F., Nichols, J.M. and Trickey, S.T.2006. ‘‘Modeling and Measurement of Accuracy/Distortion in an Operationally-passive FBG Demodulation Technique,’’ In: Marcus, M.A., Culshaw, B. and Dakin, J.P. (eds), Photonic Sensing Technologies, Proceedings of the SPIE, Vol. 6371, pp. U106-U117.
