A new type of lawsuit, wrongful adoption, is a growing concern in adoption practice. Social workers and agencies face legal action for failure to disclose medical and other health-related information about children to the parents who adopt them. The author examines the potential impact of nondisclosure of health and background information, the legal theories on which wrongful-adoption cases are brought, and suggests actions agencies and social workers can take to minimize liability in this area.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndrewsL. B. (1991). Legal aspects of genetic information. Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine, 64, 29–40.
2.
BarthR., & BerryM. (1988). Adoption and disruptions: Rates, risks and responses.New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
3.
BebenseeP. (1993). In the best interests of children and adoptive parents: The need for disclosure. Iowa Law Review, 78, 397–426.
4.
BennisonK. (1992). No deposit no return: The adoption dilemma. Nova Law Review, 16, 909–934.
5.
BlairD. M. (1992a). Getting the whole truth and nothing but the truth: The limits of liability for wrongful adoption. Notre Dame Law Review, 67, 850–969.
6.
BlairD. M. (1992b). Lifting the genealogical veil: A blueprint for legislative reform of the disclosure of health-related information in adoption. North Carolina Law Review, 70, 683–779.
7.
BlankM. (1994). Adoption nightmares prompt judicial recognition of the tort of wrongful adoption: Will New York follow suit?Cardoza Law Review, 15, 1687–1743.
8.
Burr v. Board of Commissioners of Stark County. (1986). 491 N.E. 2d 1101.
9.
Child Welfare League of America. (1988). Standards for adoption service (rev. ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
10.
ConnellyS. (1991). The need for disclosure laws: A survey of the wrongful-adoption cause of action and statutory remedies for fraud. Review of Litigation, 10, 793–821.
11.
DeWoodyM. (1993). Adoption and disclosure of medical and social history: A review of the law. Child Welfare, 72, 195–218.
12.
FestingerT. (1986). Necessary risk. A study of adoptions and disrupted placements.Washington, DC: Child Welfare League of America.
13.
Foster v. Bass. (1990). 575 So. 2d 967 (Miss. 1990).
14.
Gibbs v. Ernst. (1992). 615 A. 2d 851; 150 Pa. Commw. 154.
15.
HowardA. (1984). Annulment of adoption decrees on petition of adoptive parents. Journal of Family Law, 22, 549–572.
16.
KleinD. (1988, May 29). Dark past can haunt adoptions. Los Angeles Times, pp. 1, 31–34.
17.
Juman v. Louise Wise Servs. (1994). 159 Misc. 2d 314; 608 N.Y.S. 2d 612.
18.
Meracle v. Children's Service Society of Wisconsin. (1989). 437 N.W. 2d 532 (Wis. 1989).
19.
M.H. and J.L.H. v. Caritas Family Services. (1992). 488 N.W. 2d 282 (Minn. 1992).
20.
Michael J. v. L.A. Cty. D. of Adoptions. (1988). 247 Cal. Rptr. 504 (Cal. App. 1988).
21.
Mohr v. Massachusetts. (1991). Bristol County Superior Court, No. 87–0152 (November 4, 1991).
22.
National Committee for Adoption. (1989). Adoption factbook.Washington, DC: Author.
23.
NelsonK. A. (1985). On the frontier of adoption: A study of special-needs adoptive families.Washington, DC: Child Welfare League of America.
24.
President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medical and Biomedical Behavioral Research. (1983). Screening and counseling for genetic conditions: The ethical, social and legal implications of genetic screening, counseling and educational programs.Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
25.
RauchJ. B. (1990). Genetic services for foster children: A unmet need?Child Welfare, 69, 341–355.
26.
Richard P. v. Vista Del Mar Child Care Service. (1980). 106 Cal. App. 3d 860 (1980).
