The authors review the literature on the relative competence of recovering and nonrecovering counselors and report the findings of a study on the beliefs, preferences, and practices of administrators regarding these two groups. Most administrators believe that the two groups have no differences in effectiveness. Administrators are equally divided between pre/erring a balance of recovering and nonrecovering counselors and having no preference. Implications for policy, practice, and research are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AikenL. S., & Lo SciutoL. A. (1985). Ex-addict versus nonaddict counselors' knowledge of clients' drug use. International Journal of the Addictions, 20, 417–433.
2.
AikenL. S.Lo SciutoL. A.AusettsM. A., & BrownB. S. (1984). Paraprofessional versus professional drug counselors: The progress of clients in treatment. International Journal of the Addictions, 19, 383–401.
3.
AndersonS. C. (1987). Alcohol use and addiction. In MinahanA. (Ed.), Encyclopedia of social work (pp. 132–142). Silver Spring, MD: National Association of Social Workers.
4.
ArgeriouM., & ManoharV. (1978). Relative effectiveness of nonalcoholics and recovered alcoholics as counselors. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 39, 793–799.
5.
ArmorD. J.PolichJ. M., & StambulH. B. (1976). Alcoholism and treatment.Prepared for the U.S. National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corp.
6.
BallJ. C.GraffH., & SheehanJ. J. (1974). The heroin addict's view of methadone maintenance. British Journal of Additions, 69(1), 89–95.
7.
BissellL. C. (1982). Recovered alcoholic counselors. In PattisonE. M., & KaufmanE. (Eds.), Encyclopedic handbook of alcoholism (pp. 810–817). New York: Gardner Press.
8.
BrownB. S., & ThompsonR. F. (1976). The effectiveness of formerly addicted and nonaddicted counselors on client functioning. Drug Forum, 5, 123–129.
9.
ConnettG. E. (1980). Comparison of progress of patients with professional and paraprofessional counselors in a methadone maintenance program. International Journal of the Addictions, 15, 585–589.
10.
CorriganE. M., & AndersonS. C. (1985). Graduate social work education in alcoholism. In FreemanE. (Ed.), Social work practice with clients who have alcohol problems (pp. 335–350). Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
11.
CovnerB. J. (1969). Screening volunteer alcoholism counselors. Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 30, 420–425.
12.
GerardD. L.SaengerG., & WileR. (1962). The abstinent alcoholic. Archives of General Psychiatry, 6, 99–111.
13.
HoffmannH., & MinerB. B. (1973). Personality of alcoholics who became counselors. Psychological Reports, 33, 878.
14.
JansenD. G., & HoffmanH. (1975). MMPI scores of counselors on alcoholism prior to and after training. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 43, 271.
15.
JohnsonM. E., & PrenticeD. G. (1990). Effects of counselor gender and drinking status on perceptions of the counselor. Journal of Alcohol and Drug Education, 35(3), 38–44.
16.
KalbM., & PropperM. S. (1976). The future of alcohology: Craft or science?American Journal of Psychiatry, 133, 641–645.
17.
KingB. L.BissellL. C., & O'BrienP. (1979). Alcoholics Anonymous, alcoholism counseling, and social work treatment. Health and Social Work, 4, 181–198.
18.
KirkW. G.BestJ. B., & IrwinP. (1986). The perception of empathy in alcoholism counselors, Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 47, 82–84.
19.
LawsonG. (1982). Relation of counselor traits to evaluation of the counseling relationship to alcoholics. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 43, 834–838.
20.
Lo BelloS. G. (1984). Counselor credibility with alcoholics and nonalcoholics: It takes one to help one?Journal of Alcohol and Drug Education, 29(2), 58–66.
21.
Lo SciutoL.AikenL. S.AusettsM. A., & BrownB. S. (1984). Paraprofessional versus professional drug abuse counselors: Attitudes and expectations of the counselors and their clients. International Journal of the Addictions, 19, 233–252.
22.
LongwellB.MillerJ., & NicholsA. W. (1978). Counselor effectiveness in a methadone maintenance program. International Journal of the Addictions, 13, 307–315.
23.
MachellD. F. (in press). Counselor substance abuse history, client fellowship, and alcoholism treatment outcome. Journal of Alcohol and Drug Education.
24.
MannM. (1973). Attitude: Key to successful treatment. In StaubG. E., & KentL. M. (Eds.), The paraprofessional in the treatment of alcoholism.Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
25.
The National Drug and Alcoholism Treatment Utilization Survey of 1980. (1982). In O'BrienR., & ChafetzM. (Eds)., The encyclopedia of alcoholism.New York: Facts on File.
26.
NietzelM. T., & FisherS. G. (1981). Effectiveness of professional and paraprofessional helpers: A comment on Durlak. Psychological Bulletin, 89, 555–565.
27.
OttomanelliG. A. (1978). Patient improvement, measured by the MMPI and Pyp, related to paraprofessional and professional counselor assignment. Inter–national Journal of the Addictions, 13, 503–507.
28.
RosenbergC. M. (1982). The paraprofessionals in alcoholism treatment. In PattisonE. M., & KaufmanE. (Eds.), Encyclopedic Handbook of Alcoholism (pp. 802–809). New York: Gardner Press.
29.
RosenbergC. M.GerreinJ.ManoharV., & LiflikJ. (1976). Evaluation of training of alcoholism counselors. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 37, 1236–1246.
30.
SinnettE. R.HagenK., & HarveyW. M. (1975). Credibility of sources of information about drugs to heroin addicts. Psychological Reports, 37, 1239–1242.
31.
TournierR. E. (1979). Alcoholics Anonymous as treatment and as ideology. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 40, 230–239.
32.
ValleS. K. (1979). Alcoholism counseling.Springfield, IL: Charles C Thomas.
33.
Van WormerK. (1987). Social work and alcoholism counseling. Social Casework, 68, 426–432.
34.
WoodyG. E.LuborskyL.McLellanA. T.O'BrienC.BeckA. T.BlaineJ.HermanI., & HoleA. (1983). Psychotherapy for opiate addicts. Archives of General Psychiatry, 40, 639–645.
35.
WoolfD. S., & BennettG. (1983). Health professionals in substance abuse treatment. In BennettG. (Ed.), Substance abuse: Pharmacologic, developmental, and clinical perspectives (pp. 428–434). New York: John Wiley.
