The authors report the findings of a study of ethical decision making using case vignettes that posed ethical dilemmas. Responses among acute-care hospital social workers, child welfare protective service workers, and students in a school of social work are compared with the help of a cost–benefit decision-making framework. Findings indicate that workers are most comfortable when their decisions meet both client wishes and organizational requirements.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbramsonM. (1983). Ethical dilemmas in social work practice. Social Work, 28, 31–35.
2.
BillingsleyA. (1964). Bureaucratic and professional orientation patterns in social casework. Social Service Review, 38, 400–407.
3.
ElliottM. W. (1984). Ethical issues in social work: An annotated bibliography.New York: Council on Social Work Education.
4.
GilbertN., & SpechtH. (1976). Advocacy and professional ethics. Social Work, 21, 288–293.
5.
HayesD., & VarleyB. (1965). The impact of social work education on students' values. Social Work, 10, 40–46.
6.
JanisI. L., & MannL. (1977). Decisionmating. New York: Free Press.
7.
LevyC. S. (1976). Social work ethics.New York: Human Sciences Press.
8.
LevyC. S. (1985). NASW code of ethics. Social Work, 30, 451–452.
9.
LoewenbergF., & DolgoffR. (1982). Ethical decisions for social work practice.Itasca, IL: F. E. Peacock.
10.
McCannC. W., & CutlerJ. P. (1979). Ethics and the alleged unethical. Social Work, 24, 5–8.
11.
PilseckerC. (1978). Values: A problem for everyone. Social Work, 23, 54–57.
12.
Practice Digest. (1984), 6(4), 1–29.
13.
ReamerF. (1979). Fundamental ethical issues in social work: An essay review. Social Service Review, 53, 229–243.
14.
ReamerF. (1983). Ethical dilemmas in social service.New York: Columbia University Press.
15.
RhodesM. L. (1985). Rhodes replies. Social Work, 30, 452–453.
16.
RossJ. (1982). Ethical conflicts in medical social work: Pediatric cancer care as prototype. Health and Social Work, 7, 95–101.
17.
SharwellG. R. (1974). Can values be taught? A study of two variables related to orientation of social work graduate students toward public policy. Journal of Education for Social Work, 10, 99–105.
18.
ShellhaseL. S. (1977). Impediments to the ethical practice of social work. Social Perspectives, 5, 4–9.
19.
VarleyB. K. (1963). Socialization in social work education. Social Work, 8(3), 102–109.
20.
VarleyB. K. (1968). Social work values: Changes in value commitments of students from admission to graduation. Journal of Education for Social Work, 4(2), 67–76.
21.
WassermanH. (1971). The professional social worker in a bureaucracy. Social Work, 16, 88–95.
