How exactly is the child welfare system failing children? Abolitionist perspectives have centered the failures and harms inherent to and reproduced by the system. Despite voicing disagreement with abolition as a path forward, advocates/proponents of reform have not done the painstaking work of analyzing failures of the system itself. We begin to address this gap by examining the persistent phenomenon of critical thinking errors in child welfare, putting into context how and why the child welfare universe not only fails to ameliorate them but actively creates environments conducive to faulty thinking. We conclude that improving outcomes for families can only be accomplished through honest reckonings with current system dynamics and a radical recalibration in child welfare tolerance for child harm.
Ahsani-EstahbanatiE.Sergeevich GordeevV.DoshmangirL. (2022). Interventions to reduce the incidence of medical error and its financial burden in health care systems: A systematic review of systematic reviews. Frontiers in Medicine, 9, 875426.
2.
AinsworthF.HansenP. (2012). Doing harm while doing good: The child protection paradox. Child & Youth Services, 33(2), 146–157.
3.
AlterS. (2014). Theory of workarounds. Communications of the Association for Information Systems, 34, 55.
4.
AntonsenS. (2009). Safety culture and the issue of power. Safety Science, 47(2), 183–191.
5.
BarachP.SmallS. D. (2000). Reporting and preventing medical mishaps: Lessons from non-medical near miss reporting systems. BMJ, 320(7237), 759–763.
6.
BaumannD. J.FlukeJ. D.DalgleishL.KernH. (2014). The decision-making ecology. In ShlonskyA.BenbenishtyR. (Eds.), From evidence to outcomes in child welfare: An international reader (pp. 24–40). Oxford University Press.
7.
BoskE. A. (2018). What counts? Quantification, worker judgment, and divergence in child welfare decision making. Human Service Organizations: Management, Leadership & Governance, 42(2), 205–224.
8.
BoskE. A. (2020). Iron cage or paper cage? The interplay of worker characteristics and organizational policy in shaping unequal responses to a standardized decision-making tool. Social Problems, 67(4), 654–676.
9.
BriggsL. (2021). Twentieth century black and native activism against the child taking system: Lessons for the present. Columbia Journal of Race and Law, 11(3), 611–638.
10.
BroadhurstK.WastellD.WhiteS.HallC.PeckoverS.ThompsonK.PithouseA.DaveyD. (2009). Performing “initial assessment”: Identifying the latent conditions for error at the front-door of local authority children’s services. The British Journal of Social Work, 40(2), 352–370.
California Social Work Education Center. (2022). Safety organized practice.
13.
ChibS.KanetkarM. (2014). Safety culture: The buzzword to ensure occupational safety and health. Procedia Economics and Finance, 11, 130–136.
14.
Child Welfare Information Gateway, & US Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families. (2020). Supervising for quality child welfare practice.
15.
CourtneyM. E.DworskyA. L.CusickG. R.HavlicekJ.PerezA.KellerT. E. (2007). Midwest evaluation of the adult functioning of former foster youth: Outcomes at age 21. Chapin Hall Center for Children.
16.
CullM. J.RzepnickiT. L.O’DayK.EpsteinR. A. (2013). Applying principles from safety science to improve child protection. Child Welfare, 92(2), 179–196.
17.
DarleyJ. M.BatsonC. D. (1973). “From Jerusalem to Jericho”: A study of situational and dispositional variables in helping behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 27(1), 100–108.
18.
DebonoD. S.GreenfieldD.TravagliaJ. F.LongJ. C.BlackD.JohnsonJ.BraithwaiteJ. (2013). Nurses’ workarounds in acute healthcare settings: A scoping review. BMC Health Services Research, 13, 1–16.
19.
DettlaffA. J.BoydR. (2020). Racial disproportionality and disparities in the child welfare system: Why do they exist, and what can be done to address them?The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 692(1), 253–274.
20.
DettlaffA. J.BoydR. (2022). The causes and consequences of racial disproportionality and disparities. In KrugmanR. D.KorbinJ. E. (Eds.), Child maltreatment: Handbook of child maltreatment (pp. 221–237). Springer.
21.
DettlaffA. J.GrahamJ. C.HolzmanJ.BaumannD. J.FlukeJ. D. (2015). Development of an instrument to understand the child protective services decision-making process, with a focus on placement decisions. Child Abuse & Neglect, 49, 24–34.
22.
DettlaffA. J.RivauxS. L.BaumannD. J.FlukeJ. D.RycraftJ. R.JamesJ. (2011). Disentangling substantiation: The influence of race, income, and risk on the substantiation decision in child welfare. Children and Youth Services Review, 33(9), 1630–1637.
23.
DouglasJ. A. (2015). A checklist manifesto for election day: How to prevent mistakes at the polls. Florida State University Law Review, 43, 353–398.
24.
EvansJ. S. B. (2003). In two minds: Dual-process accounts of reasoning. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 7(10), 454–459.
FlukeJ. D.BaumanD. J.DalgleishL. I.KernH. D. (2022). Decisions to protect children: A decision-making ecology. In KorbinJ. E.KrugmanR. D. (Eds.), Handbook of child maltreatment (pp. 611–626). Springer.
28.
FlukeJ. D.McDonaldW. R. (2005). Rereporting and recurrence of child maltreatment: Findings from NCANDS. US Department of Health and Human Services, Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation.
29.
FlukeJ. D.TonmyrL.GrayJ.RodriguesL. B.BolterF.CashS.JudA.MeinckF.MuñozA. C.O’DonnellM. (2021). Child maltreatment data: A summary of progress, prospects and challenges. Child Abuse & Neglect, 119, 104650.
30.
FosterC. H. (2012). Race and child welfare policy: State-level variations in disproportionality. Race and Social Problems, 4, 93–101.
31.
GarciaA. R.BerrickJ. D.Jonson-ReidM.BarthR. P.GyourkoJ. R.KohlP.GreesonJ. K.DrakeB.CookV. (2024). The stark implications of abolishing child welfare: An alternative path towards support and safety. Child & Family Social Work, 29(4), 896–908.
32.
GawandeA. (2010). The checklist manifesto: How to get things right. Profile Books.
33.
GoldenO. (2009). Reforming child welfare. The. Urban Institute Press.
34.
GruningerM.KohlerM. (2010, April). Too much plane for one man to fly. Safety Sense.
35.
HalesB.TerblancheM.FowlerR.SibbaldW. (2008). Development of medical checklists for improved quality of patient care. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 20(1), 22–30.
36.
HannaM. D. (2021). Child welfare system issues as explanatory factors for racial disproportionality and disparities. In DettlaffA. J. (Ed.), Racial disproportionality and disparities in the child welfare system (pp. 177–197). Springer.
37.
HarrisM. S.HackettW. (2008). Decision points in child welfare: An action research model to address disproportionality. Children and Youth Services Review, 30(2), 199–215.
38.
HarrisonT.PardoT.Gasco-HernandezM.CanestraroD. (2018, January3–6). The salience and urgency of enterprise data management in the public sector [Conference session]. 51st Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Hilton Waikoloa Village, HI, United States, pp. 2246–2255.
39.
Hatton-BowersH.PecoraP. J.JohnsonK.BrooksS.SchindellM. (2015). Evaluating training to promote critical thinking skills for determining children’s safety. Journal of Social Work Education, 51(2), 298–314.
40.
HettemaJ.SteeleJ.MillerW. R. (2005). Motivational interviewing. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 1, 91–111.
41.
KahnemanD.SibonyO.SunsteinC. R. (2021). Noise: A flaw in human judgment. Little, Brown.
42.
KelloggK. M.HettingerZ.ShahM.WearsR. L.SellersC. R.SquiresM.FairbanksR. J. (2017). Our current approach to root cause analysis: Is it contributing to our failure to improve patient safety?BMJ Quality & Safety, 26(5), 381–387.
43.
KohnL. T.CorriganJ. M.DonaldsonM. S. (2000). To err is human: Building a safer health system (Vol. 6). National Academies Press.
44.
KokaliariE. D.RoyA. W.TaylorJ. (2019). African American perspectives on racial disparities in child removals. Child Abuse & Neglect, 90, 139–148.
45.
MitchellM. B.KuczynskiL. (2010). Does anyone know what is going on? Examining children’s lived experience of the transition into foster care. Children and Youth Services Review, 32(3), 437–444.
46.
MunroE. (1996). Avoidable and unavoidable mistakes in child protection work. British Journal of Social Work, 26(6), 793–808.
47.
MunroE. (1999). Common errors of reasoning in child protection work. Child Abuse & Neglect, 23(8), 745–758.
48.
MunroE. (2005). Improving practice: Child protection as a systems problem. Children and Youth Services Review, 27(4), 375–391.
49.
MunroE. (2019). Effective Child Protection.
50.
MunroE. (2019). Decision-making under uncertainty in child protection: Creating a just and learning culture. Child & Family Social Work, 24(1), 123–130.
51.
MunroE.HubbardA. (2011). A systems approach to evaluating organisational change in children’s social care. British Journal of Social Work, 41(4), 726–743.
52.
OkesD. (2009). Root cause analysis: The core of problem solving and corrective action. ASQ Quality Press.
53.
Parliament by the Chief Secretary. (2003). Every child matters.
54.
Pickard-CambridgeW. A. (2014). Sophistical refutations. In BarnesJ. (Ed.), Complete works of Aristotle (Vol. 1, pp. 278–314). Princeton University Press.
55.
PietrowiakD.SchibanoffS. L. (2003). Child welfare: Most states are developing statewide information systems, but reliability of child welfare data could be improved. U.S. Government Accountability Office.
56.
PugachM. C. (2017). The edTPA as an occasion for structuring faculty dialogue across the divide? A “Checklist Manifesto” for a more inclusive teacher education. Teacher Education and Special Education, 40(4), 314–321.
57.
ReasonJ. (1993). The identification of latent organizational failures in complex systems. In WiseJ. A.HopkinV. D.StagerP. (Eds.), Verification and validation of complex systems: Human factors issues (pp. 223–237). Springer.
58.
RöderN.WiescheM.SchermannM.KrcmarH. (2014, August7–9). Why managers tolerate workarounds–the role of information systems [Conference session]. Twentieth Americas Conference on Information Systems, Savannah, GA, United States.
59.
RzepnickiT. L.JohnsonP. R. (2005). Examining decision errors in child protection: A new application of root cause analysis. Children and Youth Services Review, 27(4), 393–407.
60.
SavageI. (2013). Comparing the fatality risks in United States transportation across modes and over time. Research in Transportation Economics, 43(1), 9–22.
61.
SaxenaD.RepaciC.SageM. D.GuhaS. (2022, April28). How to train a (bad) algorithmic caseworker: A quantitative deconstruction of risk assessments in child welfare [Conference session]. Extended Abstracts of the 2022 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI EA’22), Association for Computing Machinery, New York, NY, United States, pp. 1–7.
62.
SmithA. J. (2010). The Checklist Manifesto: Examples from the hotel industry. Journal of Organizational Behavior Management, 30(3), 280–282.
63.
SorensenJ. (2002). Safety culture: A survey of the state-of-the-art. Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 76(2), 189–204.
64.
StanovichK. E.ToplakM. E.WestR. F. (2008). The development of rational thought: A taxonomy of heuristics and biases. Advances in Child Development and Behavior, 36, 251–285.
65.
TearM. J.ReaderT. W.ShorrockS.KirwanB. (2020). Safety culture and power: Interactions between perceptions of safety culture, organisational hierarchy, and national culture. Safety Science, 121, 550–561.
66.
ThurstonH.BellJ. F.InduniM. (2018). Community-level adverse experiences and emotional regulation in children and adolescents. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 42, 25–33.
67.
ThurstonH.BoydR.WolfJ. P.FreisthlerB. (2023). Is my work racist? Critical thinking and critical discourse in social work research. Children and Youth Services Review, 153, 107106.
68.
TjahjonoB.BallP.VitanovV. I.ScorzafaveC.NogueiraJ.CallejaJ.MinguetM.NarasimhaL.RivasA.SrivastavaA. (2010). Six Sigma: A literature review. International Journal of Lean Six Sigma, 1(3), 216–233.
69.
TurnellA.EdwardsS. (1999). Signs of safety. A solution oriented approach to child protection. W. W. Norton & Company.
70.
TverskyA.KahnemanD. (1973). Availability: A heuristic for judging frequency and probability. Cognitive Psychology, 5(2), 207–232.
71.
US Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families. (2010). The Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act.
72.
US Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families, Children’s Bureau. (2016). Root cause analysis: Keep the questions coming.
73.
VaughnD. (1996). The challenger launch decision: Risky technology, culture, and deviance at NASA. The University of Chicago Press.
74.
VogusT. J.CullM. J.HengelbrokN. E.ModellS. J.EpsteinR. A. (2016). Assessing safety culture in child welfare: Evidence from Tennessee. Children and Youth Services Review, 65, 94–103.
75.
WarnerJ. (2014). “Heads must roll”? Emotional politics, the press and the death of Baby P. British Journal of Social Work, 44(6), 1637–1653.
76.
WilliamsP. M. (2001). Techniques for root cause analysis. Proceedings (Baylor University Medical Center), 14(2), 154–157.
77.
ZwartzM. (2018). Report writing in the forensic context: Recurring problems and the use of a checklist to address them. Psychiatry, Psychology and Law, 25(4), 578–588.
