Industrial relations theory has produced two conflicting hypotheses on the effects of multi-unionism on the incidence of industrial conflict. International comparative research proposes that unions organizing the same worker domains are prone to competition, for which industrial conflict is used as a means of propaganda. British economic research claims that unions organizing substitutable workers cooperate and act as one union. This study argues that apparent cooperation is not always voluntary action but is sometimes the result of a loss of autonomy caused by competition and a lack of mobilization power. Micro-level data on industrial action are used to test hypotheses of the conditions for such involuntary participation in labor disputes.
AchterkampMAkkermanA (2003) Identifying latent conflict in collective bargaining. Rationality and Society15: 15–43.
2.
AkkermanA (2000) Verdeelde vakbeweging en stakingen: concurrentie om leden (Divided labor movement and strikes: competition for members). Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, dissertation.
3.
AkkermanA (2008) Union competition and strikes: the need for analysis at the sector level. Industrial and Labor Relations Review61: 445–459.
4.
AkkermanAWielersRVan KootenG (1995) Vakbondscoalities en stakingen [Union coalitions and strikes]. Tijdschrift voor arbeidsvraagstukken11: 163–172.
5.
AshenfelterOCJohnsonGE (1969) Bargaining theory, trade unions, and industrial strike activity. American Economic Review59: 35–49.
6.
AxelrodRM (1970) Conflict of Interest: A Theory of Divergent Goals with Applications to Politics. Chicago, IL: Markham Publishing Company.
7.
BattistaA (1991) Political division in organized labor, 1968–1988. Polity14: 173–197.
8.
BrittDWGalleOR (1972) Industrial conflict and unionization. American Sociological Review37: 46–57.
9.
BrysonA (2005) Union effects on employee relations in Britain. Human Relations58: 1111–1139.
10.
Bueno de MesquitaBStokmanFN (eds) (1994) European Community Decision Making: Models, Applications, and Comparisons. New Haven, CT and London: Yale University Press.
11.
Bueno de MesquitaBNewmanDRabushkaA (1985) Forecasting Political Events: The Future of Hong Kong. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
12.
ChaisonGN (1996) Union Mergers in Hard Times: The View from Five Countries (issue no. 31). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
13.
ClarkPF (2013) Building More Effective Unions. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
14.
CohnS (1993) When Strikes Make Sense—And Why: Lessons from Third Republic French Coal Miners. New York and London: Plenum Press.
15.
ColemanJS (1994) Foundations of Social Theory. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
16.
De SwaanA (1973) Coalition theories and government formation. Amsterdam: Elsevier. American Political Science Review92: 611–621.
17.
DobsonJR (1997) The effects of multi-unionism: a survey of large manufacturing establishments. British Journal of Industrial Relations35: 547–566.
FrancisH (1985) Law, oral tradition and the mining community. The Journal of Law and Society12: 267–271.
20.
GalensonW (1940) Rival Unionism in the United States. New York: Russell & Russell.
21.
GallG (1994) The rise of single table bargaining in Britain. Employment Relations16: 62–71.
22.
GetmanJ (1999) The betrayal of Local14. Cornell University Press.
23.
GitlowAL (1952) Union rivalries. Southern Economic Journal18: 338–349.
24.
GrammCL (1986) The determinants of strike incidence and severity: a micro-level study. Industrial and Labor Relations Review39: 361–376.
25.
Gumbrell-McCormickRHymanR (2013) Trade Unions in Western Europe: Hard Times, Hard Choices. New York: Oxford University Press.
26.
HornHWolinskyA (1988) Workers substitutability and patterns of unionisation. The Economic Journal98: 484–497.
27.
IngramPMetcalfDWadsworthJ (1993) Strike incidence in British manufacturing in the 1980s. Industrial and Labor Relations Review46: 704–717.
28.
JenkinsJCKlandermansB (eds) (1995) The Politics of Social Protest: Comparative Perspectives on States and Social Movements, vol. 3. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
29.
JunBH (1989) Non-cooperative bargaining and union formation. The Review of Economic Studies56: 59–76.
30.
KlandermansB (1984) Mobilization and participation: social-psychological expansions of resource mobilization theory. American Sociological Review47: 583–600.
31.
KochanTA (1980) Collective Bargaining and Industrial Relations: From Theory to Policy and Practice. Homewood, IL: Irwin.
32.
KrislovJ (1960) Organizational rivalry among American unions. Industrial and Labor Relations Review13: 216–226.
33.
LesterRA (1958) As Unions Mature: An Analysis of the Evolution of American Trade Unionism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
34.
MachinSStewartMVan ReenenJ (1993) The economic effects of multiple unionism: evidence from the 1984 workplace industrial relations survey. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics95: 279–296.
OswaldAJ (1979) Wage determination in an economy with many trade unions. Oxford Economic Papers31: 369–385.
37.
PohjolaM (1984) Union rivalry and economic growth: a different game approach. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics86: 365–370.
38.
RojerM (1999) Collective decision-making models applied to labour negotiations in the Netherlands: a comparison between an exchange model and a conflict model. Rationality and Society11: 207–235.
39.
RossAHIrwinD (1951) Strike experience in five countries, 1927–1947: an interpretation. Industrial and Labor Relations Review4: 323–342.
40.
StoutSK (1998) Union Competition to Organize Healthcare Workers, 1972 to 1991. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University.
41.
ThommesKAkkermanA (2013) Clean up your network—how a strike changed the social networks of a working team. In: Sunbelt XXXIII international network for social network analysis annual conference, Universitat Hamburg, Hamburg, 21–26 May.
42.
ThommesKAkkermanATorenvliedR. (2014) The dark side of solidarity: social norms and social relations in the aftermath of strikes. Industrial Relations Journal45(4): 348–367.
43.
TracyJS (1987) An empirical test of an asymmetric information model of strikes. Journal of Labor Economics5: 149–173.
44.
VisserJ (1992) The strength of union movements in advanced capital democracies: social and organizational variations. In: ReginiM (ed.) The Future of Labour Movements. London: SAGE, pp. 17–52.
45.
WalshDJ (1994) On Different Planes: An Organizational Analysis of Cooperation and Conflict among Airline Unions. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
46.
WebbSWebbB (1897) Industrial Democracy. London: Longmans, Green and Co.
47.
WheelerHN (1984) Determinants of strikes: comment. Industrial and Labor Relations Review37: 263–269.
