The existence of cooperation in the face of temptation to free ride requires
explanation. We discuss two psychological phenomena, ‘symmetry’
and ‘the illusion of control,’ which we believe underlie the
‘what if everyone acted that way’ type of reasoning used in some
types of cooperation. We provide a simple model of how these lead to cooperation. We
also show how some bizarre causal beliefs, such as effect preceding cause, can
follow from these phenomena. We look at some existing evidence for these phenomena
and report on our studies which support the model.
Axelrod, Robert
. 1984. The Evolution of Cooperation.
New York: Basic Books
.
2.
Binmore, Ken
. 1993. ‘Bargaining and
Morality.’ In Rationality, Justice and the Social Contract:
Themes from ‘Morals by Agreement’, eds
David Gauthier
and
Robert Sugden
, pp. 131-156.
Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press
.
3.
Binmore, Ken
. 1994. Game Theory and the Social Contract. Volume I: Playing
Fair.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
4.
Blau, Peter
. 1964. Exchange and Power in Social Life.
New York: Wiley
.
5.
Brams, Steven J.1975.
‘Newcomb’s Problem and the Prisoners’ Dilemma.’Journal of Conflict Resolution19:
596-612
.
6.
Brown, Donald E.1991. Human Universals.
New York: McGraw Hill
.
7.
Carruthers, Peter
. 1996. ‘Simulation and Self-Knowledge: A Defence
of Theory-Theory.’ In Theories of Theories of
Mind., eds
Peter Carruthers
and
Peter K. Smith
, pp. 22-38.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
8.
Davis, Lawrence H.1985a. ‘Is the Symmetry Argument
Valid?’ In Paradoxes of Rationality and Cooperation:
Prisoner’s Dilemma and Newcomb’s Problem, eds
Richmond Campbell
and
Lanning Sowden
, pp. 255-263.
Vancouver: University of Vancouver Press
.
9.
(Originally published in American Philosophical Quarterly,
14(4), 1977.)
10.
Dawes, Robyn M.
,
Jeanne McTavish
and
Harriet Shaklee
. 1977.
‘Behavior, Communication, Assumptions about Other
People’s Behavior in a Common Dilemma Situation.’Journal of Personality and Social Psychology35:
1-11
.
11.
Dennett, Daniel C.1984. Elbow Room: The Varieties of Free Will Worth Wanting.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
12.
Elster, Jon
. 1989. The Cement of Society: A Study of Social Order.
Studies in Rationality and Social Change.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
13.
Elster, Jon
. 1996.
‘Rationality and the Emotions.’The Economic Journal106:
1386-1397
.
14.
Frank, Robert H.1988. Passions within Reason.
New York: Norton
.
15.
Gauthier, David
. 1986. Morals by Agreements.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
16.
(Originally published in
Hooker, Leach
, and
McClennen
(eds.) Foundations and Applications of Decision Theory, Volume I,
1978,
D. Reidel, Dordrecht
.)
17.
Gilovich, Thomas
. 1990.
‘Differential Construal and False Consensus Effect.’Journal of Personality and Social Psychology59:
623-634
.
18.
Hayashi, Nahoko
,
Elinor Ostrom
,
James Walker
and
Toshio Yamagishi
. 1999.
‘Reciprocity, Trust, and the Sense of Control: A Cross-Societal Study.’Rationality and Society, 11:
27-46
.
19.
Hirshleifer, Jack
. 1985.
‘The Expanding Domain of Economics.’American Economic Review75:
53-79
.
20.
Hirshleifer, Jack
. 1987. ‘On the Emotions as Guarantors of Threats
and Promises.’ In The Latest on the Best, ed.
John Dupre.Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
21.
Hirshleifer, Jack
and
Juan Carlos Martínez Coll
. 1988.
‘What Strategies can Support the Evolutionary Emergence of Cooperation.’Journal of Conflict Resolution32:
367-398
.
22.
Hofstadter, Douglas
. 1983.
‘Metamagical Themas: The Calculus of Cooperation Tested through a Lottery.’Scientific American248:
14-18
.
23.
Jankowski, Richard
. 2002.
‘Buying a Lottery Ticket to Help the Poor: Altruism, Civic Duty,
and Self-Interest in the Decision to Vote.’Rationality and Society14:
55-77
.
24.
Langer, Ellen J.1975.
‘The Illusion of Control.’Journal of Personality and Social Psychology32:
311-328
.
25.
(Originally published in Philosophy and Public Affairs, Volume
8, no 3, 1979.)
26.
Markoczy, Lívia
. 2004.
‘Multiple Motives for Cooperation.’International Journal of Human Resource Management15:
1018-1039
.
27.
Markoczky, Lívia
and
Jeff Goldberg
. 1997.
‘The Virtue of Cooperation: A Review of Ridley’s
Origins of Virtue ’
. Managerial and Decision Economics18:
399-411
.
28.
Morris, Michael W.
,
Damien L. H. Sims
and
Vittorio Girotto
. 1995.
‘Sources of Cooperation in the One-Shot Prisoner’s
Dilemma: Distinguishing between Causal Illusion and Ethical Obligation.’Journal of Experimental Social Psychology34:
494-512
.
29.
Murnighan, J. Keith
,
Jae Wook Kim
and
Richard Metzger
. 1983.
‘The Volunteer Dilemma.’Administrative Science Quarterly38:
515-538
.
30.
Nozick, Robert
. 1985. ‘Newcomb’s Problem and Two
Principles of Choice.’ In Paradoxes of Rationality and
Cooperation: Prisoner’s Dilemma and Newcomb’s Problem,
eds
Richmond Campbell
and
Lanning Sowden
, pp. 107-133.
Vancouver: University of Vancouver Press
. (Originally published in Essays in Honor of Carl G. Hempel, 1969, D.
Reidel, Dordrecht.)
31.
Premack, David
and
G. Woodruff
. 1978.
‘Does the Chimpanzee Have a Theory of Mind?’Behavioral and Brain Sciences1:
515-526
.
32.
Quattrone, Georg A.
and
Amos Tversky
. 1984.
‘Causal Versus Diagnostic Contingencies: On Self-Deception and on
the Voter’s Illusion.’Journal of Personality and Social Psychology46:
237-248
.
33.
Rapoport, Anatol
. 1966. Two-Person Game Theory: The Essential Ideas.
Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press
.
34.
Schuessler, Alexander A.2000.
‘Expressive Voting.’Rationality and Society12:
87-119
.
35.
Shafir, Eldar
and
Amos Tversky
. 1992.
‘Thinking Through Uncertainty: Non-consequential Reasoning and Choice.’Cognitive Psychology24:
449-474
.
36.
Tooby, John
and
Leda Cosmides
. 1992. ‘The Psychological Foundations of
Culture.’ In The Adapted Mind, eds
Jerome H. Barkow
,
Leda Cosmides
and
John Tooby
, pp. 19-136.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
37.
Trivers, Robert L.1971.
‘The Evolution of Reciprocal Altruism.’Quarterly Review of Biology46:
35-57
.
38.
Watabe, M.
,
S. Terai
,
N. Hayashi
and
T. Yamagishi
. 1996.
‘Cooperation in One-Shot Prisoner’s Dilemma Based on
Expectations of Reciprocity.’Japanese Journal of Experimental Social Psychology36:
183-196
. (In Japanese.)
39.
Zahn, G. Lawrence
and
Gerrit Wolf
. 1998.
‘Cooperation and Coordination in Superior-Subordinate Relations.’Computational & Mathematical Organization Theory3:
249-265
.
