This paper revisits state intervention in families on behalf of children rather than on behalf of parents. Drawing upon the theory of comparative advantage, the study argues that the reported rise in child abuse and neglect results from parents' lacking the absolute minimum levels of skills needed to sustain a family, not from parents' lacking altruism for children. The analysis has implications for child welfare policies and the sorts of welfare programs families should receive, and questions the efficacy of costly child protection programs. Interestingly, applying the theory of comparative advantage to this unfortunate aspect of family life yields similar conclusions to those reached by others. Most significantly, akin to past studies, this study concludes that the state faces an `agency problem' when it intervenes on behalf of maltreated children, because it cannot fully monitor parents judged as incompetent at raising their children.
Atkinson, A.
and J. Stiglitz. 1980. Lectures in Public Economics. New York: McGraw-Hill.
2.
Bandura, A.1977. `Self-Efficacy: Toward a Unifying Theory of Behavioral Change.'Psychological Review84: 191-215.
3.
Barnett, W.
1995. `Long-Term Effects of Early Children Programs on Cognitive and School Outcomes.' In The Future of Children, ed. R. Behrman, pp. 25-50. Los Altos, CA: Center for the Future of Children, The David and Lucile Packard Foundation.
4.
Becker, G.1974. `A Theory of Social Interactions.'Journal of Political Economy82: 1063-1091.
5.
Becker, G.
1981. A Treatise on the Family. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
6.
Becker, G.
and Murphy, K.1988. `The Family and the State.'Journal of Law and Economics31: 1-18.
7.
Becker, G.
and Tomes, N.1986. `Human Capital and the Rise and Fall of Families.'Journal of Labor Economics4 (3), Part 2: S1-S39.
8.
Besharov, D.1996. `The Children of Crack: A Status Report.'Public Welfare (Winter): 33-37.
9.
Brandon, P.1999. `The State, the Child, and Imperfect Parenting.'Rationality and Society11: 399-418.
10.
Bronas, S.
and J. Grogger. 1994. `The Economic Consequences of Unwed Motherhood: Using Twin Births as a Natural Experiment.'American Economic Review84: 1141-1156.
11.
Bronfenbrenner, U.
1979. The Ecology of Human Development: Experiments by Nature and Design. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
12.
Chase-Lansdale, L.
and M. Vinovskis. 1989. `Whose Responsibility? An Historical Analysis of the Changing Roles of Mothers and Society in the Assuming of Responsibility for US Children.' Unpublished manuscript presented at the Child Development Forum on the Family Support Act, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC.
13.
Currie, J.
and D. Thomas. 1995. `Does Head Start Make a Difference?'American Economic Review85: 341-364.
14.
Garbarino, J.
1981. `An Ecological Perspective on Child Maltreatment.' In The Social Context of Child Abuse and Neglect, ed. L. Pelson, pp. 228-267. New York: Human Sciences Press.
15.
Gomby, D.
, P. Culnoss and R. Behrman. 1999. `Home Visiting: Recent Program Evaluations—Analysis and Recommendations.' In The Future of Children, ed. R. Behrman, pp. 4-26. Los Altos, CA: Center for the Future of Children, The David and Lucile Packard Foundation.
16.
Grogger, J.
and S. Bronas. 1993. `The Socioeconomic Consequences of Teenage Childbearing: Findings from a Natural Experiment.'Family Panning Perspectives25: 156-161.
17.
Hicks, J.
1946. Value and Capital, 2nd edn.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
18.
Institute for Research on Poverty
. 1997. `Two-Generation Programs: A Roadmap to National Evaluations.'Focus19 (Summer/Fall): 28-33.
19.
Moffitt, R.1994. `Welfare Effects on Female Headship with Area Effects.'Journal of Human Resources29: 621-636.
20.
National Institutes of Health
. 1999. `Career Development Awards: Child Abuse and Neglect Research.' NIH Guide: http://www.nih.gov/grants/pa-files/PA-99-133.html: 1-12.
21.
Olds, D.
, C. Henderson, Jr., R. Tatelbaum and R. Chamberlin. 1988. `Improving the Life-Course Development of Socially Disadvantaged Mothers: A Randomized Trail of Nurse Home Visitation.'American Journal of Public Health78: 1436-1445.
22.
Olds, D.
, H. Kitzman, R. Cole and J. Robinson. 1997. `Theoretical Foundations of a Program of Home Visitation for Pregnant Women and Parents of Young Children.'Journal of Community Psychology78: 1436-1445.
23.
Ramey, S.
and C. Ramey. 1992. `Early Education Intervention with Disadvantaged Children—To What Effect?'Applied and Preventive Psychology1: 131-140.
24.
Ricardo, D.
1817. The Principles of Political Economy and Taxation (1965: Reprint edn). London: J. M. Dent and Son.
25.
Silverberg, E.
1990. The Structure of Economics: A Mathematical Analysis, 2nd edn.New York: McGraw-Hill.
26.
St. Pierre, R.
, and J. Layzer. 1999. `Using Home Visits for Multiple Purposes: The Comprehensive Child Development Program.' In The Future of Children, ed. R. Behrman, pp. 134-151. Los Altos, CA: Center for the Future of Children, The David and Lucile Packard Foundation.
27.
St. Pierre, R.
, J. Layzer, B. Goodson and L. Bernstein. 1999. `The Effectiveness of Comprehensive Case Management Interventions: Evidence from the National Evaluation of the Comprehensive Child Development Program.'American Journal of Evaluation20(1): 15-34.
28.
United States General Accounting Office
. 1997. `Welfare Reform: Implications of Increased Work Participation for Child Care.' GAO/HEHS 97-75. US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.
29.
Wagner, M.
and S. Clayton. 1999. `The Parents as Teachers Program: Results from Two Demonstrations.' In The Future of Children, ed. R. Behrman, pp. 91-115. Los Altos, CA: Center for the Future of Children, The David and Lucile Packard Foundation.
30.
Wasik, B.
, C. Ramey, D. Bryant and J. Sparling. 1990. `A Longitudinal Study of Two Early Intervention Strategies: Project CARE.'Child Development61: 1682-1696.
31.
Willis, R.
1986. `Wage Determinants: A Survey and Reinterpretation of Human Capital Earnings Functions.' In The Handbook of Labor Economics, ed. Orley Ahenfelter and Richard Layard, pp. 525-602. Amsterdam: North Holland-Elsevier Science Publishers.
