Investigating the Representation of Merging Behavior at the Floor—Stair Interface in Computer Simulations of Multi-Floor Building Evacuations

Abstract

In this article, the representation of the merging process at the floor— stair interface is examined within a comprehensive evacuation model and trends found in experimental data are compared with model predictions. The analysis suggests that the representation of floor—stair merging within the comprehensive model appears to be consistent with trends observed within several published experiments of the merging process. In particular: (a) The floor flow rate onto the stairs decreases as the stair population density increases. (b) For a given stair population density, the floor population's flow rate onto the stairs can be maximized by connecting the floor to the landing adjacent to the incoming stair. (c) In situations where the floor is connected adjacent to the incoming stair, the merging process appears to be biased in favor of the floor population. It is further conjectured that when the floor is connected opposite the incoming stair, the merging process between the stair and floor streams is almost in balance for high stair population densities, with a slight bias in favor of the floor stream at low population densities. A key practical finding of this analysis is that the speed at which a floor can be emptied onto a stair can be enhanced simply by connecting the floor to the landing at a location adjacent to the incoming stair rather than opposite the stair. Configuring the stair in this way, while reducing the floor emptying time, results in a corresponding decrease in the descent flow rate of those already on the stairs. While this is expected to have a negligible impact on the overall time to evacuate the building, the evacuation time for those higher up in the building is extended while those on the lower flows is reduced. It is thus suggested that in high-rise buildings, floors should be connected to the landing on the opposite side to the incoming stair. Information of this type will allow engineers to better design stair—floor interfaces to meet specific design objectives.

Keywords

evacuation deference behavior evacuation simulation high rise building stair merging behavior.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Pauls, J.L. , ``Movement of People in Building Evacuations'', In: Conway, D.J., ed., Human Response to Tall Buildings, CDS/34, Hutchinson and Ross, Inc., Dowden, 1977, pp. 281-292.

Fruin, J.J. , Pedestrain Planning and Design, Metropolitan Association of Urban Designers and Environmental Planners, Inc., New York, 1971.

Proulx, G. , ``The movement of People: The Evacuation Timing'', In: DiNenno, P.J., Beyler, C.L., Custer, R.L.P., Walton, W.D., Watts, J.M., Drysdale, D., Hall, J.R., eds., SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering, 3rd edn, NFPA International, Quincy, MA USA, 2002, pp. 3-342 to 3-366.

Nelson, H.E. and Mowrer, F.W. , Emergency Movement, ``Emergency Movement'', In: DiNenno, P.J., Beyler, C.L., Custer, R.L.P., Walton, W.D., Watts, J.M., Drysdale, D., Hall, J.R., eds., SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering, 3rd edn, NFPA International, Quincy, MA USA, 2002, pp. 3-367 to 3-380.

Hokugo, A. , Kubo, K. and Murozaki, Y. , ``An Experimental Study on Confluence of Two Foot Traffic Flows in Staircase,'' Journal of Architecture, Planning and Environmental Engineering , No. 358, Architectural Institute of Japan, Dec, 1985, pp. 37-43.

Takeichi, N. , Yoshida, Y. , Sano, T. , Kimura, T. , Watanabe, H. and Ohmiya, Y. , ``Characteristics of Merging Occupants in a Staircase'', In: Gottuk, D.T. and Lattimer, B.Y. eds., Fire Safety Science, Proceedings of the Eighth International Symposium, International Association for Fire Safety Science, London, 2006, pp. 591-598.

Pauls, J.L. , ``Suggestions on Evacuation Models and Research'', Human Behaviour in Fire, 3rd International Symposium, Interscience, London, 2004, pp. 23-33.

Kagawa, M. , Satoshi, K. and Morishita, Y. , ''Movement of People on Stairs during Fire Evacuation Drill - Japanese Experience in a High Rise Office Building'', Fire Safety Science, In: Grant, C.E. and Pagni, P.J. eds., Proceedings of the First International Symposium, Hemisphere Publishing Corp., USA, 1986, pp. 533-540.

Pauls, J. and Jones, B. , `` Building Evacuation : Research Methods and Case Studies'', In: Canter, D. ed., Fires and Human Behaviour, Wiley, London, 1980, pp. 227-249.

10.

Gwynne, S. , Galea, E.R. , Owen M. , Lawrence P.J. and Filippidis L. , ``A Review of the Methodologies Used in Evacuation Modelling'', Fire and Materials, Vol. 23, No. 6, Nov-Dec 1999, pp. 383-389.

11.

Kuligowski, E.D. and Peacock, R.D. , A Review of Building Evacuation Models, NIST Technical Note 1471, Gaithersburg, MD USA, 2005.

12.

Galea, E.R. , Sharp, G. , Lawrence, P.J. and Holden, R. , ``Approximating the Evacuation of the WTC North Tower Using Computer Simulation'' , Journal of Fire Protection Engineering, Vol. 18, No. 2, 2008, pp. 85-115.

13.

Gwynne, S. , Galea, E.R. , Lawrence, L. and Filippidis, L. , ``Modelling Occupant Interaction with Fire Conditions Using the building EXODUS Evacuation Model'', Fire Safety Journal, Vol. 36, 2001, pp. 327-357.

14.

Park, J. , Gwynne, S. , Galea, E.R. and Lawrence, P. , ``Validating the buildingEXODUS Evacuation Model Using Data from an Unannounced Trial Evacuation,'' In: Galea, E.R. ed., Proceedings of the 2nd International Pedestrian and Evacuation Dynamics Conference, ISBN 1904521088, CMS Press , Greenwich, UK, 2003, pp. 295-306.

15.

Galea, E.R. , Finney, K.M. , Dixon, A.J.P. , Siddiqui, A. and Cooney, D.P. , ``Aircraft Accident Statistics and Knowledge Database: Analyzing Passenger Behavior in Aviation Accidents,'' AIAA Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 43, No. 5, 2006, pp. 1272-1281.

16.

Pauls, J. , Private communication 30 May 2007.

17.

Project HEED, www.wtc-evacuation.com

18.

Galea, E.R. , Shields, J. , Canter, D. , Boyce, K. , Day, R. , Hulse, L. , Siddiqui, A. , Summerfield, L. , Marselle, M. , Greenall, P. , The UK WTC 9/11 Evacuation Study: Methodologies used in the elicitation and storage of human factors data, 11th Interflam Conference Proceedings, London, Sept 2007, Vol 1, 2007, pp 169-181.