Supervision contracts for mental health professionals: a systematic review and exploration of the potential relevance to psychiatry training in Australia and New Zealand

Abstract

Objective:

The use of formal supervision contracts has been strongly advocated across non-medical mental health professions. However, the use of such agreements is not a feature of the RANZCP Competency-Based Fellowship Program. This paper critically examines the evidence to support the use of formal supervision contracts.

Method:

A systematic review of empirical studies relating to the outcomes of supervision contracts was completed. Included records were subject to quality appraisal.

Results:

Two studies met the inclusion criteria; both were assessed to be of poor quality. One study found improved supervision effectiveness associated with the use of supervision contracts, and the other found no significant differences associated with formal contracting.

Conclusion:

Despite strong advocacy, limited empirical evidence was found to support the value of formal supervision contracts across mental health professions.

PROSPERO registration - PROSPERO 2018 CRD42018104142

Keywords

supervision contract post-graduate medical education competency-based fellowship program RANZCP clinical supervision

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Cheung

Stephan

Supervision: ‘a random bag of arrangements’? Perspectives from psychiatrists on how to improve clinical teaching. Australas Psychiatry 2017; 25: 510–513.

Parker

Suetani

Motamarri

On being supervised: getting value from a clinical supervisor and making the relationship work when it is not. Australas Psychiatry 2017; 25: 625–629.

Stephan

Cheung

Clinical teaching and supervision in postgraduate psychiatry training: the trainee perspective. Australas Psychiatry 2017; 25: 191–197.

RANZCP. 2012 Fellowship Program: supervisor resources Melbourne, Australia: RANZCP, https://www.ranzcp.org/pre-fellowship/assessors-and-supervisors/2012-fellowship-program-supervisor-resources (2019, accessed 11 March 2019).

Kim

Suetani

Power, Paranoia and Partnerships. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2018; 52: 3–156.

Martin

Copley

Tyack

Twelve tips for effective clinical supervision based on a narrative literature review and expert opinion. Med Teach 2014; 36: 201–207.

Barnett

Molzon

CH.

Clinical supervision of psychotherapy: essential ethics issues for supervisors and supervisees. J Clin Psychol 2014; 70: 1051–1061.

Falender

Shafranske

Ofek

Competent clinical supervision: emerging effective practices. Counselling Psychology Quarterly 2014; 27: 1–16.

RANZCP. Training program regulations, policies and procedures, Melbourne, Australia: RANZCP, https://www.ranzcp.org/Pre-Fellowship/Training-program-documents (2018, accessed 20 September 2018).

10.

Osborn

Davis

TE.

The supervision contract. The Clinical Supervisor. 1996; 14(2): 121–134.

11.

Kilminster

Jolly

BC.

Effective supervision in clinical practice settings: a literature review. Med Educ 2000; 34: 827–840.

12.

Chan

SWC

Chien

. Implementing contract learning in a clinical context: report on a study. J Adv Nurs 2000; 31: 298–305.

13.

Sloan

Clinical supervision: beginning the supervisory relationship. Br J Nurs 2005; 14: 918–923.

14.

Flåm

AM.

Dialogical Research in supervision: practical guidelines from experienced supervisors in family therapy, child protection, and specialty mental health services. Aust N Z J Fam Ther 2016; 37: 282–296.

15.

Spence

Wilson

Kavanagh

, et al. Clinical supervision in four mental health professions: a review of the evidence. Behav Change 2001; 18: 135–155.

16.

Bernard

Goodyear

RK.

Fundamentals of clinical supervision. 4th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill/Pearson, 2009.

17.

Sutter

McPherson

Geeseman

Contracting for supervision. Prof Psychol Res Pr 2002; 33: 495–498.

18.

Holloway

Clinical supervision: a systems approach. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, Inc, 1995.

19.

Corey

Haynes

Moulton

, et al. Clinical supervision in the helping professions: a practical guide. Alexandria, VA: American Counseling Association, 2010.

20.

Cassedy

First steps in clinical supervision: a guide for healthcare professionals. Maidenhead, UK: Open University Press, 2010.

21.

Australian Association of Social Work. Supervision Standards – 2014, https://www.aasw.asn.au/document/item/6027 (2014, accessed 13 October 2018).

22.

Australian College of Mental Health Nurses. Clinical Supervision Position Statement 2011 [updated December 2011], http://www.acmhn.org/career-resources/clinical-supervision (2011, accessed 13 October 2018).

23.

Psychology Board Australia. Guidelines for supervisors 2018, https://www.psychologyboard.gov.au/documents/default.aspx?record=WD18%2f25494&dbid=AP&chksum=h5gIqx6YFDTJqi3ihdaGlw%3d%3d (2018, accessed 13 October 2018).

24.

American Psychological Association. Guidelines for clinical supervision in health service psychology: American Psychological Association, https://www.apa.org/about/policy/guidelines-supervision.pdf (2014, accessed 13 October 2018).

25.

Royal College of Psychiatrists. Specialty training guides, https://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/training/curricula-and-guidance/specialty-guides (2018, accessed 13 April 2019).

26.

Morrell

Supervision contracts revisited – towards a negotiated agreement. Aotearoa N Z Social Work Rev 2008; 20: 22–31.

27.

Martin

Copley

Tyack

Twelve tips for effective clinical supervision based on a narrative literature review and expert opinion. Med Teach 2014; 36: 201–207.

28.

Moher

Liberati

Tetzlaff

, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. The BMJ 2009; 339: 332–336.

29.

DE_IDENTIFIED. The value of supervision contracts in enhancing supervision in the mental health profession: a systematic review. PROSPERO 2018 CRD42018104142 PROSPERO, http://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/display_record.php?ID=CRD42018104142 (2018, accessed 13 October 2018).

30.

Critical Appraisal Skills Programme. CASP checklists Oxford: critical appraisal skills programme, https://casp-uk.net/casp-tools-checklists/ (2018, accessed 13 October 2018).

31.

Saxby

Wilson

Newcombe

Can clinical supervision sustain our workforce in the current healthcare landscape? Findings from a Queensland study of allied health professionals. Aust Health Rev 2015; 39: 476–482.

32.

Bowles

Young

An evaluative study of clinical supervision based on Proctor’s three function interactive model. J Adv Nursing 1999; 30: 958–964.

33.

Kavanagh

Spence

Wilson

, et al. Achieving effective supervision. Drug Alcohol Rev 2002; 21: 247–252.

34.

McNamara

Kangos

Corp

, et al. Narratives of harmful clinical supervision: synthesis and recommendations. Clin Supervisor 2017; 36: 124–144.