This paper identifies publicly available data about the use of involuntary treatment orders within Australia and considers whether this reporting is sufficient given the gravity of the intervention.
Method:
A search of mental health tribunal, health department and justice department annual reports was conducted to determine the use of involuntary treatment orders in Australia.
Results:
Reporting of involuntary treatment orders varied significantly across jurisdictions; for example, South Australia reported 11,570 distinct orders made during a 12-month period while the Australian Capital Territory reported 627 for the same period.
Conclusion:
The publicly available data for involuntary treatment orders in Australia is inadequate for jurisdictional comparisons. This concern should be addressed to enable transparent public reporting and facilitate benchmarking.
McSherryBWilsonK.The concept of capacity in Australian mental health law reform: going in the wrong direction?Int J Law Psychiatry2015; 40: 60–69.
2.
National Mental Health Commission (NMHC). A contributing life: the 2012 National Report Card on Mental Health and Suicide Prevention. Sydney: NMHC, 2012.
3.
FreckeltonI.Legal liability for psychiatrists’ decisions about involuntary inpatient status for mental health patients. J Law Med2014; 22: 280–289.
4.
LightEKerridgeIRyanCet al. Community treatment orders in Australia: rates and patterns of use. Australas Psychiatry2012; 20: 478–482.
5.
Lawton-SmithS.A question of numbers: the potential impact of community-based treatment orders in England and Wales. London: King’s Fund, 2005.
National Multifamily Housing Council (NMHC). A contributing life: the 2014 report back on the 2012 and 2013 National Report Cards on Mental Health and Suicide Prevention. Sydney: NMHC, 2014.
9.
Australian Capital Territory Government Health Directorate. Chief Psychiatrist annual report 2016–17. Canberra: Health Directorate, Government and Communications Branch, 2017.
10.
Chief Pychiatrist of South Australia, Government of South Australia. 2016–17 annual report. Adelaide: Government of SA, 2017.
11.
Queensland Health. 2016–2017 annual report of the Chief Psychiatrist. Queensland: State of Queensland, 2017.
12.
New South Wales Mental Health Review Tribunal. Mental Health Review Tribunal annual report. New South Wales: NSW Government, 2017.
13.
Northern Territory Mental Health Review Tribunal. Northern Territory Mental Health Review Tribunal annual report. Northern Territory: Northern Territory Government, 2017.
14.
Tasmanian Mental Health Tribunal. The Mental Health Tribunal annual report 2016/17: safeguarding & protecting the rights and dignity of people being involuntarily treated for mental illness. Hobart: MHT, 2017.
15.
Mental Health Tribunal. Mental Health Tribunal 2016–2017 annual report. Victoria: MHT, 2017.
16.
Mental Health Tribunal. Mental Health Tribunal 2017 annual report. Perth, WA: MHT, 2017.
17.
Chief Psychiatrist of Western Australia. ‘Ensuring Safe and High Quality Mental Health Care’ Annual report of the Chief Psychiatrist of Western Australia. Perth: Chief Psychiatrist of WA, 2017.
