New Zealand Personnel Consultants and the Selection Process

Abstract

This study is based on a survey of 27 selection methods used by New Zealand personnel consultants in managerial selection. The results are consistent with those of other studies in personnel selection, which suggest that personnel con sultants (like many personnel managers) do not always have an accurate perception of the validity of selection methods and frequently use selection methods with low levels of validity.

The results of this study showed a small positive relationship between reported and perceived validities. As expected, the relationship between per ceived validity and frequency of use was much stronger and was statistically significant. Yet on a method-by-method basis, only half were significant.

A quite disturbing result was the strong negative and statistically significant correlation between use and perceived validity for only the most frequently used selection methods. Of the most frequently used selection methods, those with high reported validities are used relatively infrequently, while those methods with lower validities are used more frequently. Thus, when some per sonnel consultants are selecting managers for clients, they are regularly using selection methods which are of little or no value.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahlburg, D.A. (1992) Predicting the job performance of managers: What do the experts know? International Journal of Forecasting , 7(4): 467-72.

Arvey, R.D. , Miller, H.E. , Gould, R. , & Birch, P. (1987) Interview validity for selecting sales clerks. Personnel Psychology, 40(1): 1-12.

Asher, J.J. , & Sciarrino, J.A. (1974) Realistic work samples. A review. Personnel Psychology, 27(4): 519-34.

Ben-Shakhar, G. , Bar-Hillel, M. , Bilu, Y. , Ben-Abba, E. , & Flug, A. (1986). Can graphology predict occupational success? Two empirical studies and some methodological ruminations. Journal of Applied Psychology, 71(4): 645-53.

Campion, M.A. , Purcell, E.D. , & Brown, K. (1988) Structured interviewing: raising the psychometric properties of the employment interview. Personnel Psychology , 41(1): 25-42.

Currer-Briggs, N. , Kennett, B. , & Paterson, J. (1971) Handwriting analysis in business. The use of graphology in personnel selection. London: Associated Business Programmes.

Dakin, S. , & Armstrong, J.S. (1989) Predicting job performance: A comparison of expert opinion and research findings. International Journal of Forecasting, 5(2): 187- 94.

Dowling, P.J. (1988) Psychological testing in Australia: An Overview and Assessment. In Gill Palmer (ed), Australian Personnel Management—A Reader. Melbourne: Macmillan.

Gaugler, B.B. , Rosenthal, D.B. , Thomton, G.C. , & Benston, C. (1987) Meta-analysis of assessment centre validity. Journal of Applied Psychology, 72(3): 493-511.

10.

Gauquelin, M. (1983) The truth about astrology. London: Hutchinson.

11.

Guion, R.M. , & Gibson W.M. (1988) Personnel selection and placement. Annual Review of Psychology, 39(1): 349-74.

12.

Harris, M.M. , & Dworkin, J.B. (1990) Preemployment screening procedures: How human resource managers perceive them. Journal of Business and Psychology , 4(3): 279-92.

13.

Harris, N. (1991) The perceived validity and the reported use of management selection methods in New Zealand organisations. Unpublished Master's project, Massey University, New Zealand.

14.

Human Rights Commission Amendment Act 1992 No. 16. Reprinted Statutes of New Zealand, 18. Wellington: V.R. Ward, Government Printer.

15.

Hunter, J.E. , & Hunter, R.F. (1984) Validity and utility of alternative predictors of job performance. Psychological Bulletin, 96(1): 72-98.

16.

Hough, L.M. (1984) Development and evaluation of the 'accomplishment record' method of selecting and promoting professionals. Journal of Applied Psychology, 69(1): 135-46.

17.

Lai, M.Y. (1981) Management selection. Unpublished thesis, Massey University, New Zealand.

18.

Lewis, C. (1985) Employee selection. London: Hutchinson & Co. Ltd.

19.

Lim, T.E. (1981) A study of management selection practices in New Zealand. Unpublished Masters thesis, Massey University , New Zealand.

20.

Mills, A.J. (1991) Personnel consulting firms managerial selection methods. Unpublished Masters thesis, Waikato University , New Zealand.

21.

Olian, J.D. (1984) Genetic screening for employment purposes. Personnel Psychology, 37(3): 423-38.

22.

Reilly, R.R. , & Chao, G.T. (1982) Validity and fairness of some alternative employee selection procedures. Personnel Psychology, 35(1): 1-62.

23.

Robertson, I.T. , & Makin, P.J. (1986) Management selection in Britain: A survey and critique . Journal of Occupational Psychology, 59(1): 45-57.

24.

Robertson, I.T. , Gratton, L. , & Rout, U. (1990) The validity of situational interviews for administrative jobs. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 11(1): 69-76.

25.

Shackleton, S. , & Newell, S. (1991) Management selection: A comparative survey of methods used in top British and French companies. Journal of Occupational Psychology, 64(1): 23-36.

26.

Smith, M. , & George, D. (1992) Selection methods. In C.L. Cooper & I.T. Robertson (eds), International Review of Industrial and Organisational Psychology (pp. 55-97). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.

27.

Smith, M. , Gregg, M. , & Andrews, D. (1989) Selection and assessment—a new appraisal . London: Pitman Publishing.

28.

Smith, M. , & Robertson, I.T. (1989) Advances in selection and assessment. Bury St Edmunds: John Wiley and Son Ltd.

29.

Stone, R. (1985) Personality tests in executive selection. Human Resources Management in Australia, 23(4): 10-14.

30.

Taylor, P. , Mills, A. , & O' Driscoll, M. (1991) Personnel selection methods used by New Zealand organisations and personnel consulting firms. Paper presented at the New Zealand Psychological Society Conference , Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand, August.

31.

Vaughan, E. , & McLean, J. (1989) A survey and critiques of management selection practices in Australian business firms. Asia Pacific Human Resource Management, 27(4): 20-33.

32.

Waugh, A. (1991) Investigation into staff selection practices throughout New Zealand. Unpublished Honours project, Massey University , Palmerston North.

33.

Weekly, J.A. , & Gier, J.A. (1987) Reliability and validity of the situational interview for a sales position. Journal of Applied Psychology, 72(3): 484-7.