As the rationale for representative employee participation has become more compelling in recent years, the European works council model has become internationally influential. The 1994 European Works Council Directive gave further momentum to the internationalisation of this model within an expanding European Union, and potentially beyond the EU. This article surveys the existing structures for representative employee participation in the four countries of the Asia Pacific where they are the most substantial: Japan, Korea, the Philippines and Australia. Noting the limitations of representative employee participation in these countries, and more generally in the Asia Pacific, the article explores a major opportunity for developing multinational representative employee participation by exerting pressure on firms operating in the Asia Pacific which are subject already to the European Works Council Directive. It identifies the main firms in this category, and suggests a major role for global unions – the international trade union secretariats – in instigating the momentum for multinational works councils in the Asia Pacific.
ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) . 2004. Employee earnings, benefits and trade union membership, cat. no. 6310.0. Canberra: ABS .
2.
Aoki, M.1990. Toward an economic model of the Japanese firm . Journal of Economic Literature28: 1–27 .
3.
Araki, T.2005. Corporate governance reforms, labour law developments, and the future of Japan's practice-dependent stakeholder model . Japan Labour Review2(1): 26–58 .
4.
Arthur, J.B.1994. Effects of human resource systems on manufacturing performance and turnover . Academy of Management Journal37(3): 670–687 .
5.
Bertone, S. , M. Brown , P. Cressey , J. Frizzell , C. Keating , A. Morris and D. Worland . 1998. Developing effective consultative practices: Case studies of consultation at work. Melbourne: South Pacific .
6.
Binghay, V.C.2003. The role of labor–management councils in the changing world of work . Philippine Journal of Labor and Industrial Relations23/1 & 2: 1–12 .
7.
Bullock, Lord Alan . 1977. Report of the Committee of Inquiry on Industrial Democracy. London: HMSO .
8.
Campbell, D.1996. How have OECD unions fared in an interdependent world economy? Some evidence and some speculation. Mimeo. Cited in G. Bamber , R. Lansbury and N. Wailes , eds. 2004. International and comparative employment relations, 30. Sydney: Allen & Unwin .
9.
Cole, R.1982. Diffusion of participatory work structures in Japan, Sweden and the United States. In Change in organisations, ed. P. Goodman , 159–176. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass .
10.
Cressey, R.1997. Transnational works councils and macro European developments. In Innovation and employee participation through works councils: International case studies, eds R. Markey and J. Monat , 29–48. Aldershot: Avebury .
11.
CSR Asia Weekly. 2005. vol. 1, week 21.
12.
Cully, M. , S. Wodland , A. O'Reilly and G. Dix . 1999. Britain at work: As depicted by the 1998 Workplace Employee Relations Survey. London: Routledge .
13.
Delaney, J.T. and M.A. Huselid . 1996. The impact of human resource management practices on perceptions of organisational performance . Academy of Management Journal39(4): 949–969 .
14.
Dunlop Commission . 1994. Report and recommendations of the Commission on the Future of Worker–Management Relations. Section II. Washington DC: US Department of Labor and Department of Commerce .
eironline. 1998. Report assesses co-determination and recommends modernisation. (website of the European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions) http://www.eiro.eurofound.ie/1998/06.
17.
eironline. 2001a. Reform of Works Constitution Act proposed. http://www.eiro.eurofound.ie/2001/02.
18.
eironline. 2001b. Government adopts draft bill on reform of Works Constitution Act. http://www.eiro.eurofound.ie/2001/03.
19.
eironline. 2001c. Works Constitution Act reform adopted. http://www.eiro.eurofound.ie/2001/07.
20.
eironline. 2002a. Final approval given to consultation directive. http://www.eiro.eurofound.ie/2002/04.
21.
eironline. 2002b. Commission makes new proposal for takeovers directive. http://www.eiro.eurofound.ie/2002/011.
22.
Erickson, C.L. , S. Kuruvilla , R.E. Ofreneo and M.A. Oritz . 2003. From core to periphery? Recent Developments in Employment Relations in the Philippines . Industrial Relations42/3: 368–395 .
23.
europa. 2001a. The European company – frequently asked questions. (website of the European Commission) http://europa.eu.int/comm/internal/en/company/company/news/01-314.
24.
europa. 2001b. New Worker Information and Consultation Directive a ‘modern business tool’, says Commission. http://europa.eu.int/comm/employment_social/news/2002/jan/011_en.
25.
ETUI (European Trade Union Institute). 2005. European works council database. www.etui_rehs.org/workers_participation/projects/european_works_councils_database__1. 19 April.
26.
Ferner, A. , R. Hyman and J. Quintanilla . 2002. Between globalisation and capitalist variety: Multinationals and the international diffusion of employment relations . European Journal of Industrial Relations8(3) (November): 243–250 .
27.
Fernie, S. and D. Metcalf . 1995. Participation, contingent pay, representation and workplace performance: Evidence from Great Britain . British Journal of Industrial Relations33(3) (September): 379–416 .
28.
Freeman, R.B. and E.P. Lazear . 1995. An economic analysis of works councils. In Works councils: Consultation, representation, and cooperation in industrial relations, eds J. Rogers and W. Streeck , 27–52. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
29.
Gatchalian, J.C.2000. Employee representation and workplace participation (focus on Philippine labor management councils). In Asia in the twenty-first century: Challenges and opportunities in work and labour. Track 5, 12th World Congress International Industrial Relations Association, 173–85. Tokyo .
30.
Gatchalian, J.C.2004a. The LMC: Prospects and retrospect . Philippine Journal of Labor and Industrial Relations24/1 & 2: 59–78 .
31.
Gatchalian, J.C. 2004b. Bipartite institutions and workplace cooperation: initiatives and advances in Southeast Asia . Paper presented at the 5th Regional Asian Congress of International Industrial Relations Association, Seoul.
32.
Gatchalian, J.C. 2005. Where quality leads, profitability follows. In TQM & 6-Sigma For Competitiveness . Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on ISO 9000 & TQM (IO-ICIT), eds S.K. Ho and X. Tang, 17–19 . Shanghai.
33.
Goodijk, R.2001. Corporate governance and workers' participation in the Netherlands. In Models of employee participation in a changing global environment: Diversity and interaction, eds R. Markey , P.J. Gollan , A. Hodgkinson , A. Chouraqui and U. Veersma , 179–192. Aldershot: Ashgate .
34.
Hazama, H.1996. Keizai taikoku wo tsukuriageta shiso [Ideology that built an economic power]. Tokyo: Bunshin do .
35.
Heller, F.1998. Playing the devil's advocate: Limits to influence sharing in theory and practice. In Organizational Participation. Myth and Reality, eds F. Heller , E. Pusic , G. Strauss , and B. Wilpert , 144–189. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
36.
Hill, J.2003. Corporate governance and the role of the employee. In Partnership at work: The challenge of employee democracy. Labor essays 2003, eds P.J. Gollan and G. Patmore , 110–121. Sydney: Pluto Press .
37.
Hince, K. and J. Lynch1997. Labour relations and tripartism: the relevance of the Philippines model to the micro-states of the South Pacific. In Current research in industrial relations: Proceedings of the 11th AIRAANZ Conference, eds T. Bramble , B. Harley , R. Hall and E. Whitehouse , 153–163. Brisbane: AIRAANZ .
38.
ICFTU (International Confederation of Free Trade Unions). 2004. ICFTU Online: 072/030605.
39.
Itami, H.2005. Revision of the commercial code and reform of the Japanese corporate governance . Japan Labour Review2(1): 4–25 .
40.
JMHLW (Japanese Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare) . 2005. Basic survey on labor unions. In Japan Labour Flash 35. Email journal 1 April. Japan Institute for Labour Policy and Training .
41.
JML (Japanese Ministry of Labour) . 1999. Heisei 12 nen roshi komyunikoshon chosa [Survey of communication between labour and management in 1999]. Tokyo: Japanese Ministry of Labour [Rodosho].
42.
Kavcic, B.1997. Slovenia: From self-management to co-determination. In Innovation and employee participation through works councils: International case studies, eds R. Markey and J. Monat , 210–230. Aldershot: Avebury .
43.
Kerckhofs, P.2002. European works councils facts and figures. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute .
44.
Kerckhofs, P. and I. Pas . 2004. European works council database. Brussels: ETUI . www.etui_rehs.org/workers_participation/projects/european_works_councils_database__1.
45.
Kim, D. and S. Kim . 2003. Globalization, financial crisis, and industrial relations: The case of South Korea . Industrial Relations42(3): 341–367 .
46.
Kleiner, M.M. and Y. Lee . 1997. Works councils and unionisation: Lessons from South Korea . Industrial Relations36 (1): 1–16 .
47.
KMOL (Korean Ministry of Labour) . 2004. Labour administration. Seoul: www.molab.go.kr (accessed 20 May 2005).
48.
Knudsen, H.1995. Employee participation in Europe. Sage: London .
49.
Kohl, H. and H. Platzer . 2003. Labour relations in central and eastern Europe and the European social model . Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research9(1) (Spring): 11–30 .
50.
KOILAF (Korean International Labour Foundation) . 2004. Current labour situation in Korea. Seoul: www.koilaf.org (accessed 20 May 2005).
51.
Kollonay-Lehoczky, C.1997. The emergence of new forms of workers' participation in central and eastern European countries. In Innovation and employee participation through works councils: International case studies, eds R. Markey and J. Monat , 169–189. Aldershot: Avebury .
52.
Konecki, K. and J. Kulpiñska . 1997. Employee participation in privatised and private firms: The Polish experience. In Innovation and employee participation through works councils: International case studies, eds R. Markey and J. Monat , 231–242. Aldershot: Avebury .
53.
Kuwahara, Y.2004. Employment relations in Japan. In International and comparative employment relations: Globalisation and the developed market economies, 4th edn, eds G. Bamber , R. Lansbury and N. Wailes , 277–305. Sydney: Allen & Unwin .
54.
Lee, C-H.1998. New unionism and the transformation of the Korean industrial relations system . Economic and Industrial Democracy19(2): 347–374 .
55.
Markey, R.2001. Introduction: Global patterns of participation. In Models of employee participation in a changing global environment: Diversity and interaction, eds R. Markey , P.J. Gollan , A. Hodgkinson , A. Chouraqui and U. Veersma , 3–22. Aldershot: Ashgate .
56.
Markey, R. and J. Monat , eds. 1997. Innovation and employee participation through works councils: International case studies. Aldershot: Avebury .
57.
Markey, R. and R. Reglar . 1997. Consultative committees in the Australian steel industry. In Innovation and employee participation through works councils: International case studies, eds R. Markey , and J. Monat , 358–388. Aldershot: Avebury .
58.
Maruo, N.1982. The Japanese model of labour–management relations and workers participation. In Employment and participation: Industrial democracy in crisis, eds V. Rus , A. Ishikawa and T. Woodhouse , 135–148. Tokyo: Chuo University Press .
59.
Mathieu, J.E. and D. Zazac . 1990. A review and meta-analysis of the antecedents, correlates and consequences of organizational commitment . Psychological Bulletin108: 171–194 .
60.
Meyer, J. and L. Topolnytsky . 2000. Building and maintaining employee commitment: implications for HRM policy and practice. In Human resource strategies: An applied approach, eds A. Travaglione and V. Marshall , 335–366. Sydney: McGraw-Hill .
61.
Miller, K.I. and P.R. Monge . 1986. Participation, satisfaction, and productivity: A metaanalytical review . Academy of Management Journal29/4: 727–753 .
62.
Millward, N. , A. Bryson , and J. Forth . 2000. All change at work? British employment relations 1980–1998, as portrayed by the Workplace Industrial Relations Survey series. London: Routledge .
63.
Morehead, A. , M. Steele , M., Alexander , K. Stephen and L. Duffin . 1997. Changes at work: The 1995 Australian Workplace Industrial Relations Survey. Melbourne: Longman .
64.
National Statistics Office , Philippines . 2005. Labour force survey. In LABSTAT update April 9/18. Manila: DOLE .
65.
O'Kelly, K. 2001. The European company statute . Paper presented to Workers' Participation Study Group, International Industrial Relations Association European Congress, Oslo.
66.
Osani, H. and M. Kobayashi . 2005. Reforming corporate governance and employment relations . Japan Labour Review2(1): 58–80 .
67.
Palmer, I. and P. McGraw . 1996. A new era for joint consultation? Human resource managers' perceptions of JCCs and enterprise bargaining. In Workplace reform and enterprise bargaining, eds D. Mortimer , P. Leece and R. Morris , 173–186. Sydney: Harcourt Brace .
68.
Parasuraman, B.2002. Employee involvement in the private sector: A case study from Kota Kinabalu, Sabah . MANU (Journal of Institute for Promotion of Knowledge and Languages) 7: 29–47 .
69.
Parasuraman, B. 2005. Employee involvement in the Malaysian private sector . Paper presented at the International Employment Relations Association 13th Annual Conference, Aalborg.
70.
Park, F. and Y. Park . 2000. Changing approaches to employment relations in South Korea. In Employment relations in the Asia-Pacific: Changing approaches, eds G. Bamber , F. Park , C. Lee , P.K. Ross and K. Broadbent , 80–99. Sydney: Allen & Unwin .
71.
Park, Y.1995. Economic developmental globalization, and practices in industrial relations and human resource management in Korea. In Employment relations in the growing Asian economies, eds A. Verma , T.A. Kochan and R. Lansbury , 27–61. London: Routledge .
72.
Park, Y. and C. Leggett . 2004. Employment relations in the Republic of Korea. In International and comparative employment relations: Globalisation and the developed market economies, 4th edn, eds G. Bamber , R. Lansbury and N. Wailes , 306–329. Sydney: Allen & Unwin .
73.
Poole, M.1986. Towards a new industrial democracy: Workers' participation in industry. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul .
74.
Poole, M. , R. Lansbury and N. Wailes . 2001. Participation and industrial democracy revisited: A theoretical perspective. In Models of employee participation in a changing global environment: Diversity and interaction, eds R. Markey , P. Gollan , A. Hodgkinson , A. Chouraqui and U. Veersma , 23–36. Aldershot: Ashgate .
75.
Rogers, J.1995. United States: Lessons from abroad and home. In Works councils: Consultation, representation, and cooperation in industrial relations, eds J. Rogers and W. Streeck , 375–410. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
76.
Steiert, R.2001. European works councils, world works councils and the liaison role of the trade unions: a test of international union policy . Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research7(1) (Spring): 114–131 .
77.
Strauss, G.1998. An overview. In Organizational participation: Myth and reality, eds F. Heller , E. Pusic , G. Strauss , and B. Wilpert , 8–39. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
78.
Streeck, W.1995. Works councils in Western Europe: From consultation to participation. In Works councils: Consultation, representation, and cooperation in industrial relations, eds J. Rogers and W. Streeck , 313–348. Chicago: University of Chicago Press .
79.
Suzuki, F.2005. Corporate governance reform and industrial democracy in Japan . Japan Labour Review2(1): 81–104 .
80.
Tackney, C.T.2000. Changing approaches to employment relations in Japan. In Employment relations in the Asia-Pacific: Changing approaches, eds G. Bamber , F. Park , C. Lee , P.K. Ross and K. Broadbent , 64–79. Sydney: Allen & Unwin .
81.
Terry, M.1999. Systems of collective employee representation in non-union firms in the UK . Industrial Relations Journal30(1) (March): 16–30 .
82.
Tilly, C.1995. Globalisation threatens labor's rights . International Labour and Working Class History47(1): 1–23 .
83.
UN Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights . 1996. Philippines: Human rights plan 1996–2000. Geneva.
84.
Vanek, J.1971. The general theory of labor–managed market economics. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press .
85.
Veersma, U. and T. Tegelaers1997. Information exchange at the European level: Unilever as a case study for European industrial relations. In Innovation and employee participation through works councils: International case studies, eds R. Markey and J. Monat , 67–86. Aldershot: Avebury .
86.
Waddington, J. and P. Kerckhofs . 2003. European works councils: What is the current state of play?Transfer. European Review of Labour and Research9(2) (Summer): 322–340 .
87.
Wilpert, B.1998. A view from psychology. In Organizational participation: Myth and reality, eds F. Heller , E. Pusic , G. Strauss , and B. Wilpert , 40–64. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
88.
Wilkinson, B.1994. The Korea labour ‘problem’ . British Journal of Industrial Relations32(3): 347–354 .
89.
Worland, D.1995. Consultation in enterprise agreements: The Australian experience. Melbourne: Department of Applied Economics, Victoria University of Technology .
90.
World Bank . 1999. Corporate governance: A framework for implementation. New York: World Bank .
91.
Yamashita, M.2005. Japanese labor–management relations in an era of diversification of employment types: Diversifying workers and the role of labor unions . Japan Labour Review2(1): 105–117 .
