Home-based Telework and Telecommuting in Australia: More Myth than Modern Work Form

Abstract

Many articles have promoted teleworking and telecommuting from home, and have suggested that large numbers of employees are working in this way. However, there has been little academic research on either the productivity of home-based teleworkers, or the psychosocial effects on employees of such programs. One explanation for the absence of such research is that home-based telework is rare, and that reports of its incidence are based on overestimates. This paper reports the results of a survey of 157 Australian companies, including 98 of the 1998 BRW ‘Top 100’ companies. It found few employees teleworking from home. It is suggested the absence of academic research may be due to difficulties in getting adequate samples.

Keywords

telework telecommuting home-based work

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barnes

(1994) Tips for managing telecommuters. HR Focus, 71 (11): 9–10

Baruch

Nicholson

(1997) Home, sweet work: Requirements for effective home working. Journal of General Management, 23: 15–30

Bright

(1994) Teleworking: The strategic benefits. Telecommunications, 28 (11): 81–82, 91

BRW Top 1000 (1998) Business Review Weekly, November 16

Crossan

Burton

P. F.

(1993) Teleworking stereotypes: A case study. Journal of Information Science, 19: 349–62

cyberDialogue (1998) Telecommuting boosted in 1998 by internet & economy. http://www.cyberdialogue.com/press/releases

Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) (1996) APS Home Based Work Interim Award: A resource document. Canberra: AGPS

DuBrin

A. J.

(1991) Comparison of the job satisfaction and productivity of telecommuters versus in-house employees: A research note on work in progress. Psychological Reports, 68: 1223–34

European Commission (White Paper) (1993) Growth, competitiveness, employment: Challenges and ways forward into the 21st century. COM (93) 700

10.

Feldman

D. C.

Gainey

T. W.

(1997) Patterns of telecommuting and their consequences. Human Resource Management Review, 7: 369–88

11.

Felstead

(1996) Homeworking in Britain: The national picture in the mid-1990's. Industrial Relations Journal, 27: 225–38

12.

Frazee

(1996) Support for telecommuting is on the rise. Personnel Journal, 75 (10): 22

13.

Gbezo

B. E.

(1995) Working differently: The telework revolution. World of Work, 14: 4–7

14.

Grantham

C. E.

Paul

E. D.

(1995) The ‘greening’ of organizational change: A case study. Innovation: The European Journal of Social Sciences, 8: 221–33

15.

Gray

Hodson

Gordon

(1993) Teleworking explained. New York: Wiley

16.

Green

D. L.

(1997) Telecommuting in the tax department. Tax Executive, 49: 387–96

17.

Hartman

R. I.

Stoner

C. R.

Arora

(1991) An investigation of selected variables affecting telecommuting productivity and satisfaction. Journal of Business and Psychology, 6: 207–24

18.

Holti

(1994) Telematics, workplaces and homes: The evolving picture of teleworking. In Andriessen

J. H. E.

Roe

R. A.

(eds), Telematics and Work (pp. 261–88). London: Lawrence Erlbaum & Assoc

19.

Holti

(1994) Telematics, workplaces and homes: The evolving picture of teleworking. In Andriessen

J. H. E.

Roe

R. A.

(eds), Telematics and Work (pp. 261–88). London: Lawrence Erlbaum & Assoc

20.

Jackson

P. J.

van der Wielen

J. M.

(1998) Actors, approaches, and agendas: From telecommuting to the virtual organisation. In Jackson

P. J.

Wielen

J. M.van der

(eds), Teleworking: International perspectives (pp. 1–18). London: Routledge

21.

Johnston

Botterman

(1998) Status report on European telework. http://www.eto.org.uk/

22.

Johnston

Botterman

(1999) Status report on European telework: New methods of work. http://www.eto.org.uk/

23.

Jones

(1996) Telecommuting honks own horn: Few hop aboard. USA Today, 25 (November): 1–2b

24.

Kramar

(1999) Policies for managing people in Australia: What has changed in the 1990s? Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 37 (2): 24–32

25.

Laabs

(1998) Global tempts fill the workforce void. Workforce, 77 (10): 60–8

26.

Lamond

Standen

Daniels

(1998) Contexts, cultures and forms of teleworking. In Griffin

(ed.), Management Theory and Practice (pp. 145–57). Melbourne: Macmillan

27.

Mahlon

(1998) The alternative workplace: Changing where and how people work. Harvard Business Review, 76 (3): 121–30

28.

McLennan

(1996) Persons employed at home. Canberra: ABS, AGPS

29.

McLennan

(2000a) Household use of information technology. Canberra: ABS, AGPS

30.

McLennan

(2000b) Use of the Internet by householders. Canberra: ABS, AGPS

31.

Miller

T. E.

(1995) Telecommuting fact sheet. http://etrg.findsvp.com/telework/teleindx.htm

32.

Pliskin

(1997) The telecommuting paradox. Information Technology & People, 10 (2): 164–72

33.

Reilly

E. H.

(1997) Telecommuting: Putting policy into practice. HR Focus, 74 (9): 5–6

34.

Russell

(1996) How many home workers? American Demographics, (May): 6

35.

Schilling

S. L.

(1999) The basics of a successful telework network. HR Focus, (June): 9–10

36.

Silver

(1993) Homework and domestic work. Sociological Forum, 8 (2): 181–204

37.

Smith

(1994) Welcome to the virtual office. HR Focus (November): 16

38.

Soares

A. S.

(1992) Telework and communication in data processing centres in Brazil. In Gattiker

U. E.

Stollenmaier

R. S.

(eds), Technology-mediated communication (pp. 117–45). Berlin: SAGE Publications

39.

Standen

(1997) Home, work and management in the Information age. Journal of the Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management, 3: 1–14

40.

Stanworth

(1996) Working at home: A study of homeworking and teleworking. London: Institute of Employment Rights

41.

Stanworth

(1995) The self-employed without employees—autonomous or atypical? Industrial Relations Journal, 26: 221–30

42.

Telecommute America sets goal for 1.2 million more telecommuters (1997) The CPA Journal, 67 (11): 9

43.

There's no place like home (1998) Wall Street & Technology, 16 (10): 82

44.

Ward

(1996) Westpac cracks the myths of home-based work. HR Monthly (November): 4–5

45.

Weiss

J. M.

(1994) Telecommuting boosts employee output. HR Magazine (February): 51–3