There has been growing concern over the role of industrial relations arrangements in the workplace in Australia. In response more industrial relations research has focused on the workplace over the recent past. Although this work has centred on a range of themes, it has however relied on essentially the same theoretical framework or industrial relations paradigm. The basis of which is the analysis of bargained rules — the result of the joint-regulation of employment and workplace practice. In other words, the bargaining paradigm focuses overwhelmingly on one type of labour-management relation — viz. bargaining. This paper proposes a typology based on a number of types of social relations in order to broaden the basis of industrial relations analysis. It is used to analyse the characteristics and dynamics of a number of industrial relations systems currently under debate in Australia over the reshaping of industrial relations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlexanderMichaelGreenRoy (1992), “Workplace productivity and joint consultation”, Australian Bulletin of Labour, June.
2.
AngwinMichael (1991) “Myths and Realities: A Review of the Australian Workplace Industrial Relations Survey”Economic and Labour Relations Review, 2:1, 57–71.
3.
BallotMichael (1992), Labor-Management Relations in a Changing Environment, Wiley, New York.
4.
BlauPeter (1964), Exchange and Power in Social Life, Wiley, New York.
5.
BlockRichard (1987), “Industrial Relations and the Performance of the Firm: An Overview”, in KleinM. (eds), Human Resources and the Performance of the Firm, IIRC, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 319–343.
6.
BoyleElizabethLawlerEdward (1991), “Resolving Conflict Through Explicit Bargaining”, Social Forces, 69:4, 1183–1204.
7.
BoxallPeterHaynesPeter (1992), “Unions and Non-union Bargaining Agents under the Employment Contracts Act 1991: An Assessment After 12 Months”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, 17:2, 223–232.
8.
BrownWilliam (1972), “A Consideration of Custom and Practice”, British Journal of industrial Relations, 10:1, 42–61.
9.
BrownWillieWadhwaniSushil (1990), “The economic effects of industrial relations legislation since 1979”National Institute Economic Review, No. 131 Feb, 57–70.
10.
BurawoyMichael (1985), The Politics of Production, Verso, London.
11.
Business Council of Australia, Industrial Relations Study Commission (1989), Vol 1, Enterprise-Based Bargaining Units: A Better Way of Working, BCA, Melbourne.
12.
Business Council of Australia, Industrial Relations Study Commission (1991), Vol 2, Avoiding Industrial Action, Allen and Unwin & BCA, Melbourne.
13.
CAI-ACTU (1988), Joint Statement on Participative Principles, CAI-ACTU, Melbourne.
14.
CallusRon (1991), “The Australian Workplace Industrial relations Survey and the Prospects for Enterprise Bargaining”, The Economic and Labour Relations Review, 2:1, 42–56.
15.
CallusRonMoreheadAlisonCulleyMarkBuchananJohn (1991), Industrial Relations at Work, AGPS, Canberra.
16.
CastlesF. (1985), The Working Class and Welfare, Sydney.
17.
CleggStewart (1989), Frameworks of Power, Sage, London.
18.
CookeWilliam (1989), “Improving Productivity and Quality Through Collaboration”, Industrial Relations, 28:2, 299–319.
19.
Cutcher-GershenfeldJoelMcKersieRobert (1989), “Negotiating Transformation: Bargaining Lessons From the Transformation of Employment Relations”, Acadamy of Management, Best Papers Proceedings, ed. HayFrank, Acadamy of Management, Washington, 366–370.
20.
DeakinSimon (1991), “Legal change and labour market restructuring in Western Europe and the US”, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, 16:2, 109–125.
21.
DeutschmannChristoph (1987), “Economic Restructuring and Company Unionism-the Japanese Model”, Economic and Industrial Democracy, 8, 463–488.
22.
DoreRonald (1990), “Two Kinds of Rigidity: Corporate Communities and Collectivism”, in BrunettaR.Dell'AringaC. (eds), Labour Relations and Economic Performance, University of New York Press, New York, 92–113.
23.
DragoRobertWoodenMarkSloanJudith (1992), Productive Relations? Australian Industrial Relations and Workplace Performance, Allen and Unwin, Sydney.
24.
EdwardsPaul K. (1992), “Industrial Conflict: Themes and Issues in Recent Research”, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 30:3, 361–404.
25.
EdwardsPaul (1986), Conflict at Work, Blackwell, Oxford.
26.
EtzioniAmitai (1961), A Comparative Analysis of Complex Organizations: On Power, Involvement and Their Correlates, Free Press, New York.
27.
FoxAlan (1974), Beyond Contract; Work, Power and Trust Relations, Faber and Faber, London.
28.
FoxAlan (1973), “Industrial Relations: A Social Critique of Pluralist Ideology” in ChildJ. (ed), Man and Organisation, Allen and Unwin, London, 185–233.
29.
FreemanRichardMedoffJ. L. (1984), What Do Unions Do?, Basic Books, New York.
30.
FreemanRichardPelletiertJeffrey, (1990), “The Impact of Industrial Legislation on British Union Density”, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 28:2, 141–164.
31.
FrenkelStephen (1986), “Industrial Sociology and Workplace Relations in Advanced Capitalist Societies”, International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 27:1–2, 69–86.
32.
FriedmanAndrew (1986), “Developing the Managerial Strategies Approach to the Labour Process”, Capital and Class, 30, 87–124.
33.
FulcherJ. (1988), “On the explanation of industrial relations diversity: Labour movements, employers and the state in Britain and Sweden”, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 26:2, 246–273.
34.
FulcherJ. (1987), “Labour movement theory versus corporatism: Social democracy in Sweden”, Sociology, 21:2, 231–352.
35.
GodardJohn (1991), “The Progressive HRM Paradigm: A Theoretical and Empirical Re-Examination”, Relations Industrielles, 46:2, 378–399.
GordonDavidEdwardsRichardReichMichael (1982), Segmented Work, Divided Workers, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
38.
GouldnerAlvin (1960), “The norm of reciprocity: A preliminary statement”, American Sociological Review, 25:2, 161–178.
39.
GranovetterMark (1985), “Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness”, American Journal of Sociology, 91, 481–510.
40.
GrenierGuillermoHoglerRaymond (1991), “Labor Law and Managerial Ideology: Employee participation as a social control system”, Work and Occupations, 18:3, 313–333.
41.
GuilleHoward (1989), “A Tale of Two States: The Hanger and Niland Reports”, Labour and Industry, 2:3, 453–469.
42.
HarbridgeRaymondHinceKevin (1992), Decollectivisation of Industrial Relations in New Zealand: Issues of Union Membership and Structure, Working Papers 1/92 Industrial Relations Centre, Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.
43.
Industrial Relations Commission (IRC) (1991), National Wage Case Decision, Print No K0300, October.
44.
IsaacJ. E. (1989), “The Arbitration Commission: Prime Mover of Facilitator?”, The Journal of Industrial Relations, 31:3, 407–427.
45.
KatzHarry (1983), “Industrial relations performance, economic performance, and QWL programs: An interplant analysis”, Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 37:1, 3–17.
46.
KellerBerndt (1990), “The future of labour relations in the Federal Republic of Germany: Flexibility, deregulation and micro-corporatism within a stable system”, Labour and Society, 15:4, 379–399.
47.
KellyDiana (1990), Defining the “Workplace” in Workplace Industrial Relations, ACIRRT Working Paper No 4, July, University of Sydney, Sydney.
48.
KitayJim (1991), “Analyzing Workplace Industrial Relations: The Australian Workplace Industrial Relations Survey Typology”, The Journal of Industrial Relations, 33:4, 547–563.
49.
KochanThomas (1980), “Collective Bargaining and Organizational Behaviour Research”, Research in Organizational Behavior, 2, 129–176.
KochanThomasCapelliPeter (1984), “The transformation of industrial relations and personnel functions”, in OstermanP. (ed.), Internal Labor Markets, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., 133–162.
52.
KochanThomasVermaAnil (1983), “Negotiations in organizations: Blending Industrial Relations and Organizational Behaviour Approaches” in BazermanMaxLewickiRoy (eds), Negotiating in Organizations, Sage, Beverly Hills, 13–32.
53.
LeibensteinHarvey (1987), Inside the Firm: The Inefficiencies of Hierarchy, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
54.
LittlerC.QuinlanM.KitayJ. (1989), “Australian Workplace Industrial Relations: Towards a Conceptual Framework”, The Journal of Industrial Relations, 31:4, 500–525.
55.
LorenzEdward H. (1992), “Trust and the Flexible Firm: International Comparisons”, Industrial Relations, 31:3, 455–472.
56.
LuhmannNiklas (1979), Trust and Power, Wiley, Chichester.
57.
MacintyreStuartMitchellRichard (eds), Foundations of Arbitration, Oxford University Press, Melbourne.
MitchellR. (1989), “State Systems of Conciliation and Arbitration: The Legal Origins of the Australasian Model” in MacintyreS.MitchellR. (eds), The Foundations of Arbitration, op. cit.
60.
MorganDavid E. (1992), A Typology of Workplace Relations: Types of Social Relations and Social Action, IROB Working Paper, November, University of New South Wales.
61.
MontgomeryDavid (1979), Workers' Control in America, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
62.
NilandJohn (1978), Collective Bargaining and Compulsory Arbitration in Australia, UNSW Press, Sydney.
63.
NilandJohn (1976), “The Case for More Collective Bargaining in Australia”, The Journal of Industrial Relations, 18:4, 365–390.
64.
O'BrienJ. M. (1990), “Regulating Decentralised Industrial Relations: The Niland Prescription”, The Journal of Industrial Relations, 32:4, 544–559.
65.
PlowmanDavid (1991), “Industrial Relations at Work: A Survey of the Survey”, The Industrial Relations Journal, 33:4, 437–449.
66.
PlowmanDavid (1988), “Employer Associations and Bargaining Structures: An Australian Perspective”, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 26:3, 371–393.
67.
PlowmanDavid (1985), “Industrial Legislation and the Rise of Employer Associations, 1890–1906”, The Journal of Industrial Relations, 27:3, 283–309.
68.
PriceRichard (1980), Masters, Unions and Men, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
69.
PruittDean (1983), “Achieving Integrative Agreements” in BazermanMaxLewickiRoy (eds), Negotiating in Organizations, Sage, Beverly Hills, 35–50.
70.
SahlinsMarshall (1972), Stone Age Economics, Aldine-Atherton, New York.
71.
SchererP. (1985), “State Syndicalism?”, in HydeJ.NurickJ. (eds), Wages Wasteland, Hale and Iremonger, Sydney.
72.
SelznickPhilip (1969), Law, Society and Industrial Justice, Russell Sage, Berkeley.
73.
SimonHerbert A. (1991), “Organizations and Markets”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 5:2, 25–44.
74.
TerryMichael (1977), “The Inevitable Growth of Informality”, British Journal of industrial Relations, 15:1, 76–90.
75.
VoosPaula (1989), “The Influence of Cooperative Programs on Union-Management Relations, Flexibility and Other Labour Relations Outcomes”, Journal of Labour Research, 10:1, 103–117.
76.
WaltonRichard E. (1985), “From Control to Commitment in the Workplace”, Harvard Business Review, 64:2 April, 77–84.
77.
WaltonRichard E.McKersieRobert (1965), Behavioral Theory of Labor Negotiations, McGraw-Hill, New York.
78.
WardellMarkWeisenfeldLeslie (1991), “Management accounting and the workplace in the United States and Great Britain”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 16:7, 655–670.
79.
WedderburnLord (1989), “Freedom of Association and Philosophies of Labour Law”, The Industrial Law Journal, 18:1, 1–38.
80.
WindolfPaul (1989), “Productivity Coalitions and the Future of European Corporatism”, Industrial Relations, 28:1, 1–20.
81.
YerburyDiIsaacJ. E. (1971), “Recent Trends in Collective Bargaining in Australia”, International Labour Review, 103:May, 421–452.
82.
ZuckerLynne (1986), “Production of Trust: Institutional sources of economic structure”, in Research in Organizational Behavior, 8, 53–111.
