This paper reviews the empirical evidence of rigidity in the New Zealand labour market over the period 1984–1990, with particular reference to collective bargaining. It demonstrates that labour market institutions displayed an important degree of flexibility over this period. Despite this, labour markets were stigmatized as ‘inflexible’ in public debate and labour market policy has been driven by the assumption that more flexibility was required.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AkerlofG.YellenJ., (eds) (1986) Efficiency Wage Models of the Labour Market, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
2.
AndersonG.BrosnanP.ReaD.WalshP. (1992) Labour Market Flexibility and the Firm: A Preliminary Analysis of the Workplace Survey. Paper presented to the Conference of the Association of Australian and New Zealand Industrial Relations Academics, Brisbane, Australia.
3.
AnsellJ.BrosnanP.HarbridgeR. (1990) ‘When is 3 Plus 1 Equal to 3.1? Suggested Methods of Examining Wage Settlements to Determine their Annual Rate of Adjustment’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations. 15(8), pp. 4960.
4.
BairdM.SavageJ.PetherickA. (1990) Responding to Change: What Firms Say About Structural Adjustment, New Zealand Institute of Economic Research, Research Monograph 54, Wellington.
5.
BarkerG.ChapmanR. (1989) ‘Evaluating Labor Market Contracting and Regulation: A Transaction Cost Perspective with Particular Reference to New Zealand, Journal of Institunonal and Theorencal Economics. 145(2) pp. 31742.
6.
BeckermanW., (ed) (1986) Wage Rigidity and Unemployment, The John Hopkins Press, Baltimore.
7.
BlandyR.RichardsonS., (eds) (1982) How Labour Markets Work: Case Studies in Adjustment, Longman Cheshire, Melbourne.
8.
BoxallP. (1990) ‘Towards the Wagner Framework: Change in New Zealand Industrial Relations', The Journal of Industrial Relations. 32(4), pp. 523543.
9.
BoxallP. (1991) ‘New Zealand's Employment Contracts Act 1991: An Analysis of Background, Provisions and Implications', Australian Bulletin of Labour, 17, 4, 284309.
10.
BoyerR. (1987) ‘Labour Flexibilities: Many Forms, Unertain Effects', Labour and Society. 12(1), pp. 107129.
11.
BoyerR., (ed) (1988) The Search for Labour Market Flexibility, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
12.
BradfordM. (1982) Real Wages, Inflation, Unemployment and the New Zealand Wage Determination System. Paper presented to the New Zealand Association of Economists Conference, February.
13.
BradfordM. (1983) ‘Issues of Concern to Employers', in HarbridgeR. (ed) Industrial Relations: Issues of Concern, Industrial Relations Centre, Victoria University, Wellington.
14.
BrookP. (1990) Freedom at Work, Oxford University Press, Auckland.
15.
BrosnanP.ReaD. (1991) ‘An Adequate Minimum Code: A Basis for Freedom, Justice and Efficiency in the Labour Market’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations. 16(2), pp.143–158.
16.
BrosnanP.SmithD.WalshP. (1990) The Dynamics of New Zealand Industrial Relations, Jacaranda, Auckland.
17.
BrunhesB.RojotJ.WassermannW. (1989) Labour Market Flexibility: Trends in Enterprises, OECD, Paris.
18.
CambellC.BollardA.SavageJ. (1989) Productivity and Quality in New Zealand Firms: Effects of Deregulation, New Zealand Institute of Economic Research, Research Monograph 46, Wellington.
19.
ClarkM (1990) Non Wage flexibility Changes in Work Practices and Conditions in Recent Awards. Paper presented to the New Zealand Planning Council Labour Market Adaptability Seminar, Wellington.
20.
CrocombeG.EnrightM.PorterM. (1991) Upgrading New Zealand's Competitive Advantage, Oxford University Press, Auckland.
21.
Department of Labour (1985) Industrial Relations: A Framework for Review, Government Print, Wellington, Volume 1 & 2.
22.
Department of Labour (1986) Government Policy Statement on Labour Relations, Government Print, Wellington.
23.
Department of Labour (1990) Ministerial Brief, Wellington.
24.
Department of Statistics (1989) Key Statistics: July, Government Print, Wellington.
25.
Department of Statistics (1992) Infos, Wellington.
26.
DicksonI. (1989) ‘Taxation’, in WalkerSimon (ed) Rogernomics: Reshaping New Zealand's Economy, GP Books, Auckland, Second Edition, pp. 137153.
27.
DoeringerP.PioreM. (1971) Internal Labour Markets and Manpower Analysis, Lexington Books, Lexington Massachusetts.
28.
EastonB. (1986) Wages and the Poor, Allen, and Unwin, Wellington.
29.
EastonB. (1987) ‘The Labour Market and Economic Liberalisation’, in BollardA.BuckleR. (eds) Economic Liberalisation in New Zealand, Allen and Unwin, Wellington.
30.
EastonB. (1990) The Real Wage Debate: 1978 1990, Project on Economic Planning, Victoria University of Wellington.
31.
Economic Monitoring Group (1986) Labour Market Flexibility, New Zealand Planning Council, Wellington.
32.
EnderwickP. (1990) Managerial Strategies and Labour Flexibility, Paper presented to the Industrial Relations Centre Seminar on Labour Market Flexibility, James Cook Hotel, Wellington.
33.
GrillsW. (1988) ‘Labour Market Flexibility: Wage Relativities Under the Labour Relations Act 1987’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relanons. 13(3), pp. 157166.
34.
HainesL (1990) Labour Market Flexibility, Paper presented to New Zealand Planning Council Labour Market Adaptability Seminar, Wellington.
35.
HarbridgeR. (1986) ‘Collective Second tier Bargaining in New Zealand’, New Zealand Journal of Business8 pp. 4055.
36.
HarbridgeR. (1988) ‘The Way We Were A Survey of the Last Wage Round Negotiated Under the Industrial Relations Act 1973’, New Zealand Journal of Business. 10, pp. 4865.
37.
HarbridgeR. (1992) ‘Recent Redundancy Agreements: A Contents Analysis', New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations. 17(I), forthcoming.
38.
HarbridgeR.DreaverM. (1989) ‘Changing Patterns of Working Time Arrangements in Registered Collective Agreements in New Zealand’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations. 14(3), pp. 251266.
39.
HarbridgeR.McCawS. (1989) ‘The First Wage Round under the Labour Relations Act 1987: Changing Relative Power’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations. 14(2), pp. 149167.
40.
HarbridgeR.McCawS. (1990) Registered Settlements and Wage Flexibility in the New Zealand Private Sector’, The Journal of Industrial Relations. 32(2), pp. 224237.
41.
HarbridgeR.McCawS. (1992) ‘Award, Agreement or Nothing? A Review of the Impact of S132a of the Labour Relations Act 1987 on Collective Bargaining’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations. 17(1), forthcoming.
42.
HerbertP. (1989) ‘Industrial Relations: Softly, Softly Players Temper Compact Strings', National Business Review. 24 February W8.
43.
HughesJ. (1990) Labour Law in New Zealand, The Law Book Company, Sydney.
44.
JessonP. (1989) Fragments of Labour The Story Behind the Labour Government, Penguin, Auckland.
45.
JollC.McKennaC.McNabbR.ShoreyJ., (eds) (1983) Developments in Labour Market Analysis, George Allen and Unwin, London.
46.
KielyT. (1988) How Have Composite, Enterprise and Industry Bargaining Been Doing? Paper presented to the New Zealand Institute for International Research's Second Annual Conference on Industrial Relations, September 56, Auckland.
47.
McAndrewIHursthouseP. (1990) ‘Southern Employers on Enterprise Bargaining’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations. 15(2), pp. 117128.
48.
McAndrewIHursthouseP. (1991) ‘Reforming Labour Relations: What Southern Employers Say’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations. 16(1), pp. 538555.
49.
MeuldersD.WilkinL. (1987) ‘Labour Market Flexibility: Critical Introduction to the Analysis of a Concept’, Labour and Society. 12(1), pp. 317.
50.
New Zealand Business Roundtable (1987) Freedom and Employment: Why New Zealand Needs a Flexible Decentralised Labour Market, NZBR, Wellington.
51.
New Zealand Business Roundtable (1988) Labour Markets and EmploymentNZBR, Wellington.
52.
New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations (1991) Symposium: The Employment Contracts Act 1991. 16, 2, 105–175.
53.
OECD (1985) Economic Surveys: New Zealand, OECD, Paris.
54.
OECD (1989) Economic Surveys: New Zealand, OECD, Paris.
55.
OiW. (1962) ‘Labour as a QuasiFixed Factor of Production’, Journal of Political Economy. 70(6), pp. 338355.
56.
Pierce DuranceE. (1988) ‘Brash call for flexible hours', National Business Review. 22 November, p. 5.
57.
RodgerS. (1987) ‘Foreword’ in Department of Labour A Guide to the Labour Relations Act, Government Print, Wellington.
58.
RoseD. (1990) Labour Market Flexibility: What Can be Inferred from Census Data. Paper presented to New Zealand Planning Council Labour Market Adaptability Seminar, Wellington.
59.
RuberyJ.TarlingR.WilkinsonF. (1987) ‘Flexibility, Marketing and the Organisation of Production’, Labour and Society. 12(1), pp. 131152.
60.
RyanR. (1992) Flexibility in the Employment Practices of Northern Firms, forthcoming.
61.
SarfatiH.KobrinC., (eds) (1988) Labour Market Flexibility, Gower, Aldershot.
62.
SavageJ. (1989) Internal Labour Markets: Labour Adjustment within Firms, New Zealand Institute of Economic Research, Research Monograph 45, Wellington.
63.
SchultzeC. (1985) ‘Microeconomic Efficiency and Nominal Wage Stickiness', American Economic Review. 75(1), pp. 219.
64.
StandingG. (1986) Unemployment and Labour Market Flexibility: The United Kingdom, ILO, Geneva.
65.
Treasury (1984) Economic Management, Government Print, Wellingtn.
66.
Treasury (1990) Briefing Notes to the Incoming Government, Wellington.
67.
WoodsN. (1963) Industrial Conciliation and Arbitration in New Zealand, Government Print, Wellington.
