This paper examines a number of aspects of the economic impact of unions with particular emphasis on the exit/voice model proposed by Freeman and Medoff. It examines the reported effects of unions in quit rates and job tenure; productivity; wage dispersion and merit pay; employment; fringe benefits; technological change and profits.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BeanC.SymonsJ. (1990) Ten Years of Mrs T LSE Centre for Labour Economics, Discussion Paper 370.
2.
BelmanD. (1989), Unions, the Quality of Labor Relations and Firm Performance, mimeo, Economic Policy Institute, Washington D.C.
3.
BetchermanG. (1988), Technological Change and Its Impacts: Do Unions Make a Difference?’, Proceedings of 1987 Annual Meeting of the Canadian Industrial Relations Association.
4.
BlanchflowerD.G.FreemanR. B. (1990) Going Different Ways: Unionism in the US and Other Advanced OECD Countries Discussion Paper No. 5, Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics.
5.
BlanchflowerD.G.OswaldA.J., (1988a) ‘Internal and External Influences Upon Pay Settlements', British Journal of Industrial Relations, November, 26(3), pp. 363–370.
BlanchflowerD.G.OswaldA.J., (1989), ‘Working Internationally’, in British Social Attitudes: the International Report, by JowellR.WitherspoonS.BrookL. (ed.), Gower.
8.
BlanchflowerD.G.MillwardN. (1988) ‘Trade Unions and Employment Change: An Analysis of British Establishment Data’European Economic Review, 32 pp.717–726.
9.
BlanchflowerD.G.MillwardN.OswaldA.J. (1988), Unionisation and Employment Behaviour, Discussion Paper No. 339, Centre for Labour Economics, LSE.
10.
BrownC.MedoffJ. (1978) ‘Trade Unions in the Production Process'Journal of Political Economy, 86:3 pp 355–78.
11.
CavesR. (1980) Productivity Differences Among Industries' in CavesR.KrauseL. (eds) Britain's Economic Performance, Washington D.C., Brookings Institution.
12.
ClarkK. (1980) ‘The Impact of Unionization on Productivity: A Case Study’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 33:4 pp 451–69.
13.
ClarkK. (1984) ‘Unionisation and Firm Performance: The Impact on Profit, Growth and Productivity’American Economic Review, 74:5 pp 893–919.
14.
CrockettG.DawkinsP.MillerP.W.MulveyC., (1992) ‘The Impact of Unions on Workplace Productivity and Profitability in Australia’. Australian Bulletin of Labour, forthcoming.
15.
DanielW.W. (1987), Workplace Industrial Relations and Technical Change, Francis Pinter.
DragoR.WoodenM. (1989) ‘Trade Unions and Workplace Efficiency in Australia: Some Preliminary Results' in BrayM.KellyD. (eds) Issues and Trends in Australasian Industrial Relations: Proceedings of the 4th Biennial AIRAANZ Conference, University of Sydney.
18.
DragoR.WoodenM., (1992) 1 The Links Between Workplace Performance and Industrial Relations: Evidence from the AWIRS'. Australian Bulletin of Labour, forthcoming.
19.
EdwardsP. (1987) Managing the Factory, Oxford, Basil Blackwell.
20.
EliasP.BlanchflowerD. (1990), Occupations, Earnings and Work Histories of Young Adults: Who Gets the Good Jobs?Department of Employment Research Paper, London, forthcoming.
21.
FreemanR. (1982), ‘Union Wage Practices and Wage Dispersion Within Establishments', Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 36(1), pp. 3–39.
22.
FreemanR. (1983) Unionism, Price-Cost margins and the Return to capital NBER Working Paper No. 1164.
23.
FreemanR.MedoffJ. (1984), What Do Unions Do?Basic Books, New York.
24.
GreenF.HadjimatheouG.SmailR. (1985), ‘Fringe Benefit Distribution in Britain’, British Journal of Industrial Relations, vol. 23, pp. 261–280.
25.
HirschB.T.AddisonJ.T. (1986) The Economic Analysis of Unions, Boston, Allen and Unwin.
26.
HirschB.LinkA.N. (1987), Labor Union Effects on Innovative Activity, Journal of Labor Research, 8, pp. 323–332.
27.
HirschmanA. O. (1970) Exit, Voice and Loyalty, Cambridge, Mass, Harvard U. P.
28.
KeefeJ. (1989), Do Unions Hinder Technological Change?, mimeo, Economic Policy Institute, Washington D.C.
29.
KnightK. G. (1989) ‘Labour Productivity and Strike Activity in British manufacturing Industries: Some Quantitative Evidence’British Journal of Industrial Relations, 27 pp 365–74.
30.
KornfeldR. (1990) Effects of Unions on Young Workers in Australia mimeo, Harvard University.
31.
KupferschmitdM.SwidinskyR. (1989) Longitudinal Estimates of the Union Effect on Wages, Wage Dispersion and Pension Fringe Benefits mimeo, University of Guelph.
32.
LeonardJ. (1986), Employment Variability and Wage Rigidity — a Comparison of Union and Non-union Plants, mimeo, University of California at Berkeley.
33.
LinkA.N. (1981) ‘Basic Research and productivity Increase in Manufacturing: Additional Evidence’American Economic Review, 71:5 pp 1111–2.
34.
MachinS. (1987) Union Productivity Effects in British Engineering mimeo, University of Warwick.
35.
MachinS. (1988), Unions and the Capture of Economic Rents: an Investigation Using British Firm Level Data, mimeo, Dept. of Economics, University College, London.
36.
MachinS.StewartM. (1988) Unions and the Financial Performance of British Private Sector EstablishmentsUniversity College London, Dept. of Economics Working Paper No. 88–23.
37.
MachinS.WadhwaniS. (1989) The Effects of Unions on Organisational Change, Investment and Employment: Evidence from WIRSLSE Centre for labour Economics, Discussion Paper No. 355.
38.
MansfieldE. (1980) Basic Research and Productivity Increase in Manufacturing’American Economic Review, 70:5 pp 863–73.
39.
MetcalfD. (1990) ‘Union Presence and Labour Productivity in British Manufacturing Industry: A Reply to Nolan and Marginson’British Journal of Industrial Relations, 28:2 pp 228–49.
40.
MillerP. W.MulveyC. (1989a) ‘Union Density and the Union/Non-Union Wage Differential in Australia’, Discussion Paper in Industrial Relations No. 17, University of Western Australia.
41.
MillerP. W.MulveyC. (1991) ‘Australian Evidence on the Exit/Voice Model of the Labor Market’Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 45.1 pp 44–57.
MillwardN.StevensM. (1986) British Workplace Industrial Relations 1980–84, Aldershot, Gower.
44.
MuramatsuK. (1984), Chapter in Economic Analysis of the Japanese Firm edited by AokiM., North-Holland.
45.
NakamuraK.SatoH.KamiyaT. (1988), Do Labor Unions Really Have a Useful Role?, Tokyo: Sogo Rodo Kenkyujo.
46.
NickellS.R.WadhwaniS.WallM. (1989) Unions and Productivity Growth In Britain 1974–86: Evidence from UK Company Accounts DataLSE Centre for Labour Economics, Discussion Paper 353.
47.
NolanP.MarginsonP. (1990), ‘Skating on Thin Ice?: David Metcalf on Trade Unions and Productivity’, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 28:2 pp 216–248.
48.
OsawaM. (1989), ‘The Service Economy and Industrial Relations in Small and Medium Size Firms in Japan’, Japan Labor Bulletin, July 1st.
49.
OultonN. (1989) Shock and Shakeout: Searching for an Explanation of the Productivity Improvement of the 1980s, mimeo, NIESR.
50.
PencavelJ. (1970) An Analysis of the Quit Rate in American Manufacturing, Princeton, Industrial Relations Section, Princeton University.
51.
PencavelJ. (1977‘The Distributional and Efficiency Effects of Trade Unions in Britain’. British Journal of Industrial Relations15.2 pp 137–156.
52.
PencavelJ.HartsogC.E. (1984) ‘A Reconsideration of the Effects of Unionism on Relative Wages and Employment in the United States, 1920–1980[’Journal of Labor Economics, 2:2 pp 193–232.
53.
RobinsonC. (1989) ‘The Joint Determination of Union Status and Union Wage Effects', Journal of Political Economy, 97 pp 639–67.
StoikovV.RaimonR. (1968) ‘Determinants of the Differences in Quit Rates Among Industries'American Economic Review, 63:5 pp 1283–98.
56.
TerleckyjN. E. (1980) ‘What Do R&D Numbers Tell Us About Technological Change ?’American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings, 70:2 pp 55–61.
57.
WilsonN. (1989) Unionisation, Wages and Productivity: Some British Evidence, University of Bradford, Occasional Paper 8901.
58.
WilsonN.CableJ.R.PeelM.J. (1990) ‘Quit Rates and the Impact of Participation, Profit Sharing and Unionisation: Empirical Evidence from UK Engineering Firms'British Journal of Industrial Relations, 28:2 pp 197–214.
59.
WraggR.RobertsonJ. (1978) Post-War Trends in Employment, Productivity, Output, Labour Costs and Prices by Industry in the United Kingdom, Research Paper 3, Department of Employment.
