From marketising to empowering: Evaluating union responses to devolutionary policies in education

Abstract

Major reforms in education, globally, have focused on increased accountability and devolution of responsibility to the local school level to improve the efficiency and quality of education. While emerging research is considering implications of these changed governance arrangements at both a school and system level, little attention has been afforded to teacher union responses to devolutionary reform, despite teaching being a highly union-organised profession and the endurance of decentralising-style reforms in education for over 40 years. Drawing upon a power resources approach, this article examines union responses in cases of devolutionary reform in a populous Australian state. Through analysing evolving policy discourse, from anti-bureaucratic, managerialising rhetoric to a ‘post-bureaucratic, empowerment’ agenda, this article contributes to understandings of union power for resisting decentralising, neoliberal policy agendas by exposing the limits of public sector unions mobilising traditional power resources and arguing for strengthening of discursive and symbolic power.

JEL Code: J5

Keywords

Devolution public education teacher unions Australia new public management governance framing power resources

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (2020) Trade union membership, August 2020. Available at: https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/labour/earnings-and-work-hours/trade-union-membership/latest-release (accessed 21 February 2021).

ABS (2021) Schools, February 2021. Available at: https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/people/education/schools/latest-release#data-download (accessed 3 March 2021).

ARDT Consultants (2011) Independent Review of the School Based Management Pilot: Final Report. Sydney, NSW: Department of Education and Communities.

Bascia

Stevenson

(2017) Organising Teaching: Developing the Power. Brussels, Belgium: Education International.

Benford

Snow

(2000) Framing processes and social movements: an overview and assessment. Annual Review of Sociology 26(1): 611–639.

Boston Consulting Group (2011) Expenditure Review of the Department of Education and Training (DET) – Initial Scan. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Brunetto

Beattie

(2020) Changing role of HRM in the public sector. Public Management Review 22(1): 1–5.

Connell

(2015) Markets all around: defending education in a Neoliberal time. In: Proctor

Brownlee

Freebody

(eds) Controversies in Education: Orthodoxy and Heresy in Policy and Practice. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer, 181–197.

Fitzgerald

Rainnie

(2012) Failing forward: public schools and new public management. Public Policy 7(2): 167–182.

10.

Ford

Gillan

(2021) Power resources and supranational mechanisms: the global unions and the OECD Guidelines. European Journal of Industrial Relations 27: 307–325. DOI: 10.1177/0959680120988238.

11.

Ford

Ward

(2021) Union Renewal in the Education Sector: Prospects for the Asia-Pacific. Malaysia: Education International.

12.

Forster

(1994) The Analysis of Company Documentation. In: Cassell

Symon

(eds) Qualitative Methods in Organizational Research: A Practical Guide. London, UK: Sage, 147–166.

13.

Gahan

Pekarek

(2013) Social movement theory, collective action frames and union theory: a critique and extension. British Journal of Industrial Relations 51(4): 754–776.

14.

Gavin

(2019a) Working industrially or professionally? What strategies should teacher unions use to improve teacher salaries in neoliberal times? Labour & Industry: A Journal of the Social and Economic Relations of Work 29(1): 19–33.

15.

Gavin

(2019b) Changing Conditions of Work in Neoliberal Times: How the NSW Teachers’ Federation has Responded to Changes in Teachers’ Industrial and Professional Working Conditions in NSW Public Education, 1985-2017. Unpublished PhD thesis. Sydney, Australia: The University of Sydney.

16.

Gavin

(2021) Reframing the narrative: renewing power resources and capabilities in union campaigns for public education. Journal of Industrial Relations 63: 753–776. DOI: 10.1177/00221856211000405.

17.

Gavin

McGrath-Champ

(2017) Devolving authority: The impact of giving public schools power to hire staff. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources 55(2): 244–247.

18.

Gerrard

Savage

(2021) The governing parent-citizen: dividing and valorising parent labour through school governance. Journal of Education Policy 1–19. DOI: 10.1080/02680939.2021.1877357.

19.

Glaser

Strauss

(1967) The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. Chicago, IL: Aldine Publishing Company.

20.

Gobby

(2016) Putting ‘The System’ into a school autonomy reform: The case of the Independent Public Schools Program. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 37(1): 16–29.

21.

Hajer

Versteeg

(2006) A decade of discourse analysis of environmental politics: achievements, challenges, perspectives. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning 7(3): 175–184.

22.

Krachler

Auffenberg

Wolf

(2021) The role of organizational factors in mobilizing professionals: evidence from nurse unions in the United States and Germany. British Journal of Industrial Relations 59(3): 643–668.

23.

Lévesque

Murray

(2010) Understanding union power: resources and capabilities for renewing union capacity. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 16(3): 333–350.

24.

Lévesque

Murray

(2013) Renewing union narrative resources: how union capabilities make a difference. British Journal of Industrial Relations 51(4): 777–796.

25.

Lincoln

Guba

(1985) Naturalistic Inquiry. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.

26.

Lingard

Hayes

Mills

(2002) Developments in school-based management. Journal of Educational Administration 40(1): 6–30.

27.

Y-T

(2021) Moral dilemma of striking: a medical worker’s response to job duty, public health protection and the politicization of strikes. Work, Employment and Society. Online First. DOI: 10.1177/0950017020981554.

28.

McAlevey

(2016) No Shortcuts: Organising for Power in the New Gilded Age. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

29.

Murray

(2017) Union renewal: what can we learn from three decades of research? Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research 23(1): 9–29.

30.

Nation

(2001) Selective growth: An examination of the expansion of academically-selective schooling during the metherell era of education in New South Wales 1988-1990. Masters Thesis. Sydney, Australia: The University of Sydney.

31.

NSW Department of School Education (1992) Your School’s Right to Choose: A Discussion Paper on Decision-Making within the NSW Public School System. Sydney, NSW: NSW Department of School Education.

32.

NSW Department of Education and Communities (NSW DEC) (2011) Local Schools, Local Decisions. Sydney, Australia: NSW Department of Education and Communities.

33.

NSW Public Service Commission (2017) Workforce Profile Report 2017. Sydney, Australia: NSW Public Service Commission.

34.

NSWTF (1989a) Global Budgeting. Sydney, Australia: Executive Minutes.

35.

NSWTF (1989b) The President Writes…The Scott Review. Sydney, Australia: Education, 2.

36.

NSWTF (1989c) The Restructuring of Public Education. Sydney, Australia: Annual Conference decisions.

37.

NSWTF (1990a) Global Budgeting. Sydney, NSW: Annual Conference decisions.

38.

NSWTF (1990b) Flexible Staffing. Sydney, Australia: Executive Minutes.

39.

NSWTF (1991a) School Staffing Crisis. Sydney, Australia: Education, p. 5.

40.

NSWTF (1991b) Recommendation to Sky Channel Mass Meeting – 27/8/1991 – Staffing of Schools. Sydney, Australia: Executive Minutes.

41.

NSWTF (1992a) 1992 New South Wales Teachers Federation Annual Report. Sydney, Australia: Executive Minutes.

42.

NSWTF (1992b) Staffing Strike – June 3, 1992. Sydney, Australia: Education, 2.

43.

NSWTF (1992c) Support Federation Staffing Campaign. Sydney, Australia: Education, 3.

44.

NSWTF (2009) Back to the Past with Pilot Program. Sydney, Australia: Education, 6.

45.

NSWTF (2012a) Local Cuts, Local Blame. Sydney, Australia: Education, 1.

46.

NSWTF (2012b) Put Students First. Sydney, Australia: Education, 4.

47.

NSWTF (2012c) NSW Government’s Cost-Cutting Devolution Agenda. Sydney, Australia: Executive Decisions.

48.

NSWTF (2012d) Teachers Vote to Intensify Campaign. Sydney, Australia: Education, 1.

49.

NSWTF (2012e) Transfers Protected until Term 2, 2016. Sydney, Australia: Education, 5.

50.

NSWTF (2013) Putting Students First – Schools. Sydney, Australia: Executive Decisions.

51.

NSWTF (2015) Negotiations Begin for New Staffing Agreement. Sydney, Australia: Education, 1.

52.

NSWTF (2017) The 2017 Annual Report of the NSW Teachers Federation. Surry Hills, Australia: Education.

53.

NSWTF (2020) Negotiating a Crisis of Pandemic Proportions. Sydney, Australia: Education.

54.

Osborne

(2006) The New Public Governance? Public Management Review 8(3): 377–387.

55.

Peck

(2001) Neoliberalizing states: thin policies/hard outcomes. Progress in Human Geography 25(3): 445–455.

56.

Phillips

Smith

(eds) (2009). Governance and Regulation in the Third Sector: International Perspectives. London, UK: Routledge.

57.

Piccoli

(2011) Empowering Local Schools to Enable Better Teaching and Learning. Surry Hills, Australia: Media Release, New South Wales Teachers Federation. Available at: https://www.nswtf.org.au/files/110811_empowering_local_schools_media_release.pdf (accessed 22 February 2021).

58.

Schmalz

Ludwig

Webster

(2018) The power resources approach: developments and challenges. Global Labour Journal 9(2): 113–134.

59.

Scott

(1989) Schools Renewal: A Strategy to Revitalise Schools within the New South Wales State Education System. Milsons Point, Australia: Management Review, New South Wales Education Portfolio.

60.

Scott

(1990) School-Centred Education: Building a More Responsive State System. Milsons Point, Australia: Management Review, New South Wales Education Portfolio.

61.

Silver

(2003) Forces of Labor. Workers’ Movements and Globalization since 1870. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

62.

Stacey

(2017) The teacher ‘problem’: an analysis of the NSW education policy great teaching, inspired learning. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education 38(5): 782–793.

63.

Wilkins

Collet-Sabé

Gobby

, et al. (2019) Translations of new public management: a decentred approach to school governance in four OECD countries. Globalisation, Societies and Education 17(2): 147–160.

64.

Wilson

Stacey

McGrath-Champ

(2020) Teachers’ Work During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Shifts, Challenges and Opportunities. East Melbourne, Australia: Centre for Strategic Education. Occasional Paper 169.

65.

Wright

(2000) Working-class power, capitalist-class interests, and class compromise. American Journal of Sociology 105(4): 957–1002.

66.

Wright

(2012) Fantasies of empowerment: mapping neoliberal discourse in the coalition government’s schools policy. Journal of Education Policy 27(3): 279–294.