Government procurement contracts and minimum labour standards enforcement: Rhetoric,duplication and distraction?

Abstract

Government contracts for services typically include terms requiring contractors to comply with minimum labour standards laws. Procurement contract clauses specify reporting procedures and sanctions for non-compliance, implying that government contracting agencies will monitor and enforce minimum labour standards within contract performance management. In this article, the case of school cleaners employed under New South Wales government contracts between 2010 and 2011 is the vehicle for exploring the effectiveness of these protective clauses. We find that the inclusion of these protective clauses in procurement contracts is unnecessary in the Australian context, and any expectations that government contracting agencies will monitor and enforce labour standards are misleading. At best, the clauses are rhetoric, and at worst, they are a distraction for parties with enforcement powers.

Keywords

Cleaners enforcement government procurement contracts minimum labour standards

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ABS (2000) Cleaning Services Industry, Australia 1998–99. Cat. no. 8672.0. Canberra, ACT, Australia: ABS. Available at: http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/productsbytitle/6F0B7E423A0DC6A6CA2568FD0083C4A8?OpenDocument (accessed 21 February 2011).

Alcorso

(2002) Improving occupational health and safety information to immigrant workers in NSW. Working paper no. 78 ACIRRT, 4 September. Sydney, NSW, Australia: University of Sydney.

Arrowsmith

Kunzlik

(eds) (2009) Social and Environmental Policies in EC Procurement Law: New Directives and New Directions. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Arrowsmith

Linarelli

Wallace

(2000) Regulating Public Procurement: National and International Perspectives. The Hague: Kluwer Law International.

Australian Government (2009) Australian government procurement statement. Minister for Finance and Deregulation, Australian Government, Canberra, ACT, Australia, July.

Australian Government (2010) Fair work principles user guide. Australian Government, Canberra, ACT, Australia, January.

Bercusson

(1978) Fair Wages Resolution. London: Mansell Information Publishing.

Bolton

(2006) Government procurement as a policy tool in South Africa. Journal of Public Procurement 6(3): 193–217.

Campbell

Peeters

(2008) Low pay, compressed schedules and high work intensity: a study of contract cleaners in Australia. Australian Journal of Labour Economics 11(1): 27–46.

10.

Collins

(1999) Regulating Contracts. Oxford; Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Oxford University Press.

11.

Collins

(2000) Justifications and techniques of legal regulation of the employment relation. In: Collins

Davies

Rideout

(eds) Legal Regulation of the Employment Relation. The Hague: Kluwer Law International, pp. 3–27.

12.

Cooper

Ellem

(2011) The neoliberal state, trade unions and collective bargaining in Australia. British Journal of Industrial Relations 46(3): 532–554.

13.

Daintith

(1994) The Techniques of Government. 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

14.

Dickens

(2012) Fairer workplaces: making employment rights effective. In: Dickens

(ed.) Making Employment Rights Effective: Issues of Enforcement and Compliance. Oxford: Hart Publishing, pp. 205–228.

15.

Fair Work Act (2009) Fair Work Act (Cth). Available at: http://comlaw.gov.au/Series/C2009A00028 (accessed 10 March 2014).

16.

Fair Work Ombudsman (2010) NSW – Sydney metropolitan cleaning contractors campaign. Final report, Fair Work Ombudsman, Canberra, ACT, Australia, June.

17.

Fair Work Ombudsman (2011) National cleaning services campaign 2010–11. Fair Work Ombudsman, Canberra, ACT, Australia, June.

18.

Fraser

(1997) Impact of Contracting-Out on Female NESB Workers: Case Study of the NSW Government Cleaning Service. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Research and Statistics Branch, Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs.

19.

Freiberg

(2010) The Tools of Regulation. Sydney, NSW, Australia: The Federation Press.

20.

Goodwin

Maconachie

(2011) Minimum labour standards enforcement in Australia: caught in the crossfire? Economic and Labour Relations Review 22(2): 55–80.

21.

Hardy

(2009) A changing of the guard: enforcement of workplace relations laws since work choices and beyond. In: Stewart

Forsyth

(eds) Fair Work: The New Workplace Laws and the Work Choices Legacy. Sydney, NSW, Australia: The Federation Press, pp. 84–107.

22.

Hardy

(2012) Enrolling non-state actors to improve compliance with minimum employment standards. Economic and Labour Relations Review 22(3): 117–140.

23.

Hardy

Howe

(2009) Partners in enforcement? The new balance between government and trade union enforcement of employment standards in Australia. Australian Journal of Labour Law 22: 306–336.

24.

Hardy

Howe

Cooney

(2013) Less energetic but more enlightened? exploring the Fair Work Ombudsman’s use of litigation in regulatory enforcement. Sydney Law Review 35: 565–597.

25.

Holley

Rainnie

(2012) Who cleans up? The declining earnings position of cleaners in Australia. Economic and Labour Relations Review 23(1): 143–160.

26.

Howe

(2006) ‘Money and favours’: government deployment of public wealth as an instrument of labour regulation. In: Arup

Gahan

Howe

. (eds) Labour Law and Labour Market Regulation. Sydney, NSW, Australia: The Federation Press, pp. 167–186.

27.

Howe

(2010) The regulatory impact of using public procurement to promote better labour standards in corporate supply chains. In: Macdonald

Marshall

(eds) Fair Trade, Corporate Accountability and beyond. Surrey: Ashgate, pp. 331–349.

28.

Howe

(2014) Regulatory facilitation of voice. In: Bogg

Novitz

(eds) Voices at Work: Continuity and Change in the Common Law World. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 381–400.

29.

Howe

Landau

(2009) Using public procurement to promote better labour standards in Australia: a case study of responsive regulatory design. Journal of Industrial Relations 51(4): 575–589.

30.

IBISWorld (2010) Cleaning services in Australia. IBISWorld industry report L7866, April 2010. Melbourne, VIC, Australia: IBISWorld.

31.

Industry Commission Australia (1995) The Growth and Revenue Implications of Hilmer and Related Reforms. Industry Commission to the Council of Australian Governments. Canberra, ACT, Australia: Industry Commission Australia.

32.

Johnstone

Mitchell

(2004) Regulating work. In: Parker

Scott

Lacey

. (eds) Regulating Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 101–121.

33.

McCrudden

(1999) International economic law and the pursuit of human rights: a framework for discussion of the legality of ‘selective purchasing’ laws under the WTO Government procurement agreement. Journal of International Economic Law 2(1): 3–48.

34.

McCrudden

(2004) Using public procurement to achieve social outcomes. Natural Resources Forum 28(4): 257–267.

35.

McCrudden

(2007) Buying Social Justice: Equality, Government Procurement, and Legal Change. 1st ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

36.

McCrudden

(2012) Procurement and fairness in the workplace. In: Dickens

(ed.) Making Employment Rights Effective: Issues of enforcement and compliance. Oxford: Hart Publishing, pp. 87–114.

37.

NSW Government (1999) Implementation Guidelines for the NSW Government Procurement Code of Practice and Code of Tendering. Sydney, NSW, Australia: New South Wales Department of Treasury.

38.

NSW Treasury (2004) Policy and guidelines paper. NSW Government Procurement Policy, Office of Financial Management, Sydney, NSW, Australia, July.

39.

Occupational Health and Safety Act (2000) Occupational Health and Safety Act (NSW). Available at: http://www.legislation.nsw.gov.au/fullhtml/inforce/act+40+2000+FIRST+0+N (accessed 20 December 2013).

40.

Public Sector Employment and Management Act (2002) Public Sector Employment and Management Act (NSW). Available at: http://www.legislation.nsw.gov.au/xref/inforce/?xref=Type%3Dact%20AND%20Year%3D2002%20AND%20no%3D43&nohits=y (accessed 15 April 2014).

41.

Ryan

(2007) ‘Dirty Deads Done Dirt Cheap?’ Employment relations and the organisation of work in the NSW commercial cleaning industry. Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.

42.

Ryan

Herod

(2006) Restructuring the architecture of state regulation in the Australian and Aotearoa/New Zealand cleaning industries and the growth of precarious employment. Antipode 38(3): 486–507.

43.

Seddon

(2009) Government Contracts: Federal, State and Local. 4th ed. Sydney, NSW, Australia: The Federation Press.

44.

Sullivan

(1997) Mapping contract. In: Davis

Sullivan

Yeatman

(eds) The New Contractualism. South Melbourne, VIC, Australia: Macmillan Education Australia, pp. 1–13.

45.

Tarrant

(2011) United voice. Paper presented at employment relations in a global context conference, Workplace Research Centre, Sydney, NSW, Australia.

46.

Trepte

(2004) Regulating Procurement: Understanding the Ends and Means of Public Procurement Regulation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

47.

United Nations (2008) Public procurement as a tool for promoting more sustainable consumption and production patterns. August. Available at: http://www.un.org/esa/sustdev/publications/innovationbriefs/no5.pdf (accessed 23 December 2009).

48.

United Voice (2012) Clean Start Guidelines to Responsible Contracting. Sydney, NSW, Australia: United Voice.

49.

Weiss

Thurbon

(2006) The business of buying American: public procurement as trade strategy in the USA. Review of International Political Economy 13(5): 701–724.