Who Cleans up? The Declining Earnings Position of Cleaners in Australia

Abstract

Neoliberal policies of industrial relations decentralisation and privatisation have transformed the economic landscape of Australia in the last 20 years. The primary objective of these policies has been to enhance wealth and prosperity by improving productivity and flexibility of the workforce and competition and accountability in the market. Yet the evidence suggests that precarious workers are not benefiting from this increased prosperity, indeed they suffer by comparison with all other workers. Cleaners are a subset of precarious workers who have been hard hit by the dual impacts of labour market decentralisation and privatisation. This study finds quantitative evidence of an increasing gap in earnings between cleaners and other workers in Australia since the onset of workplace relations decentralisation and the proliferation of privatisation in the mid 1990s. We locate our argument in recent debates about the nature of variegated neoliberalism, the emergence of the networked economy, and the implications of these developments for the nature of work and employment.

Keywords

Cleaners income disparity networked economy outsourcing precarious work privatisation and decentralisation vulnerable low-paid workers

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ABS (1996a) Employee Earnings and Hours, May, Cat. No. 6306.0, ABS, Canberra.

ABS (1996b) Labour Force, Australia, May, Cat. No, 6202.0, ABS, Canberra.

ABS (1998) Employee Earnings and Hours, May. Cat. No. 6306.0, ABS, Canberra.

ABS (2000a) Employee Earnings and Hours, May, Cat. No. 6306.0, ABS, Canberra.

ABS (2000b) Australian Bureau of Statistics, Cleaning Services Industry, Australia, 1998–99 Cat. No. 8672.0, ABS, available: http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/productsbytitle/6F0B7E423A0DC6A6CA2568FD0083C4A8?OpenDocument [accessed 21 December 2009].

ABS (2001) 2001 Census tables: Australia, occupation code 9111-11 by industry division L7866, unpublished data.

ABS (2002) Employee Earnings and Hours, May, Cat. No. 6306.0, ABS, Canberra.

ABS (2004) Employee Earnings and Hours, May, Cat. No. 6306.0, ABS, Canberra.

ABS (2006) Employee Earnings and Hours, Cat. No. 6306.0, ABS, Canberra.

10.

ABS (2008) Employee Earnings and Hours, August, Cat. No. 6306.0, ABS, Canberra.

11.

ABS (2010a) Employee Earnings and Hours, May, Cat. No. 6306.0, ABS, Canberra.

12.

ABS (2010b) Labour Force, Australia, May, Cat. No, 6202.0, ABS, Canberra.

13.

ABS (2010c) Consumer Price Index Australia, Cat. No. 6401.0, ABS, Canberra.

14.

Adams

Hess

(2000) ‘Alternatives to competitive tendering and privatisation: A case study from the Australian health industry’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 59(1), pp. 49–59.

15.

Alcorso

(2002) Improving occupational health and safety information to immigrant workers in NSW, Working Paper No. 78 ACIRRT, University of Sydney.

16.

Atkinson

Leigh

(2007) ‘The distribution of top incomes in Australia’ in Atkinson

Piketty

(eds) Top Incomes over the Twentieth Century: A Contrast Between Continental European and English-Speaking Countries, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 309–332.

17.

Baird

Cooper

Ellem

(2009) ‘Low-paid women: The impact of regulatory change in Australia’, Industrial Relations Journal, 40(5), pp. 393–407.

18.

Boushey

Fremstad

(2008) ‘The wages of exclusion: Low-page work and inequality’, New Labor Forum, 17(2), pp. 9–19.

19.

Bray

Underhill

(2009) ‘Industry differences in the neoliberal transformation of Australian industrial relations', Industrial Relations Journal, 40(5), pp. 372–392.

20.

Brenner

Peck

Theodore

(2010) ‘Variegated neoliberalization: Geographies, modalities, pathways', Global Networks, 10(2), pp. 1–41.

21.

Brosnan

Walsh

(1998) ‘Employment security in Australia and New Zealand’, Labour and Industry, 8(3), pp. 23–42.

22.

Burgess

Campbell

(1998) ‘The nature and dimensions of precarious employment in Australia’, Labour and Industry, 8(3), pp. 5–22.

23.

Castells

(1996) The Rise of the Network Society, Blackwell, Oxford.

24.

Creswell

J. W.

(2009) Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative and Mixed Methods Approaches, Sage, Thousand Oaks.

25.

de Man

A-P.

(2004) The Network Economy: Strategy, Structure and Management, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

26.

DiMaggio

(2001) ‘Introduction’ in DiMaggio

(ed.) The Twenty First Century Firm: Changing Economic Organization in International Perspective, Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp. 3–30.

27.

Elton

Pocock

(2008) ‘The effects of WorkChoices on vulnerable South Australian workers and their households', Labour and Industry, 18(3), pp. 93–114.

28.

Flecker

(2009) ‘Outsourcing spatial relocation and the fragmentation of employment’, Competition and Change, 13(3), pp. 251–266.

29.

Flecker

(2010) ‘Organisational restructuring, employment relations and the dynamics of national regulatory frameworks', Work Organisation, Labour and Globalisation, 4(1), pp. 8–23.

30.

Flecker

Holtgrewe

Schönauer

Dunkel

Meil

(2007) Restructuring Across Value Chains and Changes in Work and Employment: Case Study Evidence from the Clothing, Food, IT and Public Sector, WORKS Project WP 10, CIT3-CT-2005-006193.

31.

Flecker

Meil

(2010) ‘Organisational restructuring and emerging service value chains', Work, Employment and Society, 24(4), pp. 680–698.

32.

Fraser

(1997) Impact of contracting out on female NESB workers: Case study of the NSW Government cleaning service, Research and Statistics Branch, Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, Canberra.

33.

FWO (2011) Fair Work Ombudsman, National Cleaning Services Campaign 201–11, Australian Government, Canberra, available: http://www.fairwork.gov.au/campaignresults/National/National-Cleaning-Services-Campaign-Final-Report.pdf [accessed 11 November 2011].

34.

Grimshaw

Marchington

Rubery

Willmott

(2005) ‘Introduction: Fragmenting work across organizational boundaries' in Marchington

Grimshaw

Rubery

Willmott

(eds) Fragmenting Work: Blurring Organizational Boundaries and Disordering Hierarchies, Oxford University Press, New York, pp. 1–38.

35.

Grugulis

Vincent

Hebson

(2003) ‘The rise of the “network organisation” and the decline of discretion’, Human Resource Management Journal, 13(2), pp. 45–59.

36.

Herod

Aguiar

(2006) ‘Introduction: Cleaners and the dirty work of neoliberalism’, Antipode, 38(3), pp. 425–434.

37.

HILDA (2006) ‘The Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (HILDA) Survey’, The Melbourne Institute.

38.

Hyman

(2008) ‘The state in industrial relations' in Blyton

Bacon

Fiorito

Heery

(eds) The Sage Handbook of Industrial Relations, SAGE Publications, Thousand Oaks, pp. 12–37.

39.

IBISworld (2004) Industry Report for Cleaning Services in Australia, December, IBIS World, Melbourne.

40.

IBISworld (2010) Cleaning Services in Australia, April, IBIS World, Melbourne.

41.

Johnstone

Mayhew

Quinlan

(2001) ‘Outsourcing risk? The regulation of occupational health and safety where subcontractors are employed’, Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal, 22 (2–3), pp. 351–394.

42.

Kelly

(1995) ‘Privatising public health: Private profit at public expense?’, Just Policy, 3, pp. 25–32.

43.

Marchington

Grimshaw

Rubery

Willmott

(2005) Fragmenting Work: Blurring Organizational Boundaries and Disordering Hierarchies, Oxford University Press, New York.

44.

Marchington

Rubery

Grimshaw

(2011) ‘Alignment, integration and consistency in HRM across multiemployer networks', Human Resource Management, 50(3), pp. 313–339.

45.

Masterman-Smith

May

Pocock

(2008) Living Low Paid: The Dark Side of Prosperous Australia, Allen and Unwin, Sydney.

46.

Mayer-Ahuja

(2004) ‘Three worlds of cleaning: Women's experiences of precarious labor in the public sector, cleaning companies and private households of West Germany’, Journal of Women's History, 16(2), pp. 116–141.

47.

Murray

Owens

(2009) ‘The safety net: Labour standards in the new era’ in Forsyth

Stewart

(eds) Fair Work: The New Workplace Laws and the Work Choices Legacy, The Federation Press, Sydney, pp. 40–74.

48.

Peck

Theodore

(2010) ‘Labour markets from the bottom up’ in Mc-Grath-Champ

Herod

Rainnie

(eds) Handbook of Employment and Society: Working Space, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp. 87–105.

49.

Peetz

Preston

(2009) ‘Individual contracting, collective bargaining and wages in Australia’, Industrial Relations Journal, 40(5), pp. 444–461.

50.

Powell

(2001) ‘The capitalist firm in the twenty first century: Emerging patterns in western enterprise’ in DiMaggio

(ed.) The Twenty First Century Firm: Changing Economic Organization in International Perspective, Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp. 33–69.

51.

Quiggin

(1996) ‘Competitive tendering and contracting in the Australian public sector’, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 55(3), pp. 49–58.

52.

Quinlan

Johnstone

(2009) ‘The implications of de-collectivitist industrial relations laws and associated developments for worker health and safety in Australia 1996–2007’, Industrial Relations Journal, 40(5), pp. 426–443.

53.

Quinlan

Mayhew

Bohle

(2001) ‘The global expansion of precarious employment, work disorganization, and consequences for occupational health: A review of recent research’, International Journal of Health Services, 31(2), pp. 335–414.

54.

Rainnie

Barrett

Burgess

Connell

(2008) ‘Call Centres, the networked economy and the value chain’, Journal of Industrial Relations, 50(2), pp. 195–208.

55.

Rubery

Grimshaw

Marchington

(2010) ‘Blurring boundaries and disordering hierarchies: Challenges for employment and skills in networked organisations', Praxis 6, UK Commission for Employment and Skills, available: http://www.ukces.org.uk/assets/bispartners/ukces/docs/publications/praxis-6-blurring-boundaries-and-disordering-hierarchies.pdf [accessed 1 February 2011].

56.

Ryan

(2007) ‘Dirty deeds done dirt cheap?’ Employment relations and the organisation of work in the NSW commercial cleaning industry, unpublished PhD thesis, School of Work and Organisational Studies, University of Sydney, Sydney.

57.

Ryan

Herod

(2006) ‘Restructuring the architecture of state regulation in the Australian and Aotearoa/New Zealand cleaning industries and the growth of precarious employment’, Antipode, 38(3), pp. 486–507.

58.

Schienstock

(2002) The network as a paradigm of business restructuring, Paper presented at the workshop for Labour Organisation and Competence in National Innovation Systems Project, Paris, April.

59.

Standing

(2009) Work After Globalization: Building Occupational Citizenship, Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham.

60.

Stilwell

(2000) Changing Track: A New Political Economic Direction for Australia, Pluto Press, Annandale.

61.

Svensen

Teicher

(1998) ‘The privatisation of the Australian state and its implications for trade unionism’ in Harbridge

Gadd

Crawford

(eds) Current Research in Industrial Relations, Proceedings of the 12^th AIRAANZ Conference, Wellington, New Zealand, 3–5 February, pp. 361–367.

62.

Underhill

Fernando

(1998) ‘Deregulating precarious employment in Victoria: Trends in employee complaints', Labour and Industry, 8(3), pp. 43–61.

63.

Vosko

L. F.

(2007) ‘Precarious part-time work in Australia in transnational labour regulation: The gendered limits of SER-centrism’, Labour and Industry, 17(3), pp. 45–71.

64.

Walsh

(2004) Dirty schools, forgotten cleaners: The injuries of Victoria's failed experiment in contract school cleaning, Liquor Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union Report, December.