Good Faith and the Fair Work Act : Its Potential,in Light of the New Zealand Experience

Abstract

This article addresses the potential of the Fair Work Act's good faith bargaining provision to enhance good faith bargaining and employment relationships, using New Zealand's good faith provisions under the Employment Relations Act 2000 as a comparative frame of reference. It explores the limitations of the Fair Work Act's compliance-based approach to good faith, which consists mainly of the parties presenting a legally defensible appearance of not acting in bad faith. In contrast, the New Zealand legislation aims to suffuse good faith with considerable content and definition, enabling parties to the employment relationship to extend good faith well beyond bargaining. In contrast to the Employment Relations Act, the formalistic, procedural approach promoted by the Fair Work Act is unlikely to encourage a significant cultural change towards meaningful good faith principles and practices.

Keywords

Australian workplace relations Fair Work Act Australia good faith labour law union-management relations New Zealand workplace relations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

(2006) ‘Transplanting and growing good faith in New Zealand labour law’, Australian Journal of Labour Law, 19(1), pp. 1–29.

Attorney-General and Minister for Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs (2010) Discussion paper: Leading practice agreements: maximising outcomes from native title benefits, available: http://www.ag.gov.au/www/agd/agd.nsf/Page/Indigenouslawandnativetitle_Nativetitle_Nativetitlereform#governance [accessed 1August 2010].

Burnside

(2009) ‘Negotiation in good faith under the Native Title Act: A critical analysis', Land, Rights, Laws: Issues in Native Title, 4(3), pp. 1–16.

Cooper

Ellem

(2009) ‘Fair Work and the re-regulation of collective bargaining’, Australian Journal of Labour Law, 22(3), pp. 284–305.

Cox

(1958) ‘The duty to bargain in good faith’, Harvard Law Review, 71(8), pp. 1401–1442.

Department of Labour (2009), The Effect of the Employment Relations Act 2000 on Collective Bargaining, Department of Labour, Wellington.

Duvin

R. P.

(1964) ‘The duty to bargain: Law in search of policy’, Columbia Law Review, 64, pp. 248–292.

Freeman

Boxall

Haynes

(eds) (2007), What Workers Say: Employee Voice in the Anglo-American Workplace, ILR Press, Ithaca and London.

House of Representatives (2008), Explanatory Memorandum, Fair Work Bill, Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.

10.

Knowles

(2003) Reviewing the Employment Relations Act, Business New Zealand, Wellington.

11.

Lafferty

Kiely

(2008), Employment Agreements: Bargaining Trends and Employment Law 15, Industrial Relations Centre, Wellington.

12.

Lee

(2005) ‘Crafting remedies for bad faith bargaining, coercion and duress: “Relative ethical flexibility” in the twenty-first century’, Australian Journal of Labour Law, 18(1), pp. 26–52.

13.

McAndrew

(2006) ‘Employers, unions and workplace partnerships in New Zealand’, New Zealand Journal of Employment Relations, 31(3), pp. 51–65.

14.

McAndrew

Penn

(2003) ‘Collective bargaining under the ERA 2000: Report of a workshop on negotiation’, New Zealand Journal of Industrial Relations, 28(2), pp. 170–182.

15.

McCallum

(2000) ‘Trade union recognition and Australia's neo-liberal voluntary bargaining law’, Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations, 57(2), pp. 225–251.

16.

McClelland, R. (Attorney-General) (2008) Speech at the Negotiating Native Title Forum, Brisbane, available: http://www.attorneygeneral.gov.au/www/ministers/mcclelland.nsf/Page/Speeches_2008_FirstQuarter_29February2008-NegotiatingNativeTitleForum [accessed 1 August 2010].

17.

Ministry of Health, District Health Boards, New Zealand Council of Trade Unions (with health sector unions) (2007), Health Sector Relationship Agreement, Ministry of Health, Wellington.

18.

Rathmell

(2008) ‘Collective bargaining after WorkChoices: Will “good faith” take us forward with fairness?’, Australian Journal of Labour Law, 21(2), pp. 164–199.

19.

Telstra Corporation Limited (Telstra), Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU), Australian Communications. Electrical and Plumbing Union, Community and Public Sector Union, Association of Professional Engineers and Scientists Australia (2009) ‘Telstra and communications industry unions agree on important principles', media release, 1 July.