The WorkChoices legislation was controversial at the time of its introduction. The controversy has continued as to what its outcomes have been, and in whose interests it has operated. One outcome of the legislation has been a proliferation of extremely comprehensive analyses of its effects to date. This review article on those reports concludes that the overwhelming weight of evidence is that the legislation has benefited employers at the expense of employees. However, this article provides a materialist analysis of WorkChoices and the wider employer offensive which contrasts with the dominant interpretations amongst the critics of WorkChoices. The paper situates WorkChoices as part of a longer-term employer offensive designed to maintain profitability by increasing the rate of labour exploitation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) (2007) Australian System of National Accounts, 2006–07, Catalogue No. 5204.0, Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
BairdM.CooperR.OliverD. (2007) Down and out with WorkChoices: The impact of WorkChoices on the work and lives of women in low paid employment. A Report to the Office of Industrial Relations, Department of Commerce, New South Wales. Prepared by the Women and Work Research Group, University of Sydney, June, available: http://wwrg.econ.usyd.edu.au/Events/2007/Women_and_Work_Choices_Report_2007.pdf [accessed 17 November 2007].
4.
BrambleT. (2004) ‘Contradictions in Australia's “Miracle Economy“’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, 54, pp. 5–31.
5.
BravermanH. (1974) Labor and Monopoly Capital. The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century, Monthly Review Press, New York.
6.
CallinicosA. (2004) The Revolutionary Ideas of Karl Marx, Bookmarks, London.
7.
CharlesworthS.MacdonaldF. (2007) Going too far: WorkChoices and the experience of 30 Victorian workers in minimum wage sectors. A Report to Industrial Relations Victoria, prepared by the Centre for Applied Social Research, RMIT University, available: http://www.nfaw.org/social/www/2007/Going_too_far.pdf [accessed 17 November 2007].
8.
EllemB. and Women and Work Research Group (2007) More work, less choice: the impact of national labour re-regulation on low-paid women workers in the Australian Capital Territory, A Report to the Department of Disability, Housing and Community Services, prepared by Work and Organisational Studies and Women and Work Research Group, University of Sydney.
9.
EltonJ. BaileyBairdJ.CharlesworthM.CooperS.EllemR.JeffersonB.MacdonaldT.OliverF.PocockD.PrestonB.WhitehouseA.WhitehouseG. (2007) Women and WorkChoices: Impacts on the low pay sector: Summary report. Centre for Work + Life, Adelaide, August.
10.
EltonJ.PocockB. (2007) Not fair, no choice. The impact of WorkChoices on twenty South Australian workers and their households. A Report to SafeWork SA and The Office for Women. Prepared by the Centre for Life + Work, University of South Australia, July, available: http://www.nfaw.org/social/www/2007/WandWC_Summary.pdf [accessed 17 November 2007].
11.
EvessonJ. BuchananBamberryJ.FrinoL.OliverD. (2007) Lowering the standards: From awards to WorkChoices in retail and hospitality collective agreements: Synthesis report. Report prepared for the Queensland, New South Wales, and Victorian Governments. Workplace Research Centre, Sydney, September.
12.
ForsythA. (2007) Freedom to fire: Economic dismissals under WorkChoices. Report for the Victorian Office of the Workplace Rights Advocate, August.
13.
GahanP. (2007) Employer Greenfields agreements under WorkChoices: Interim report. Office of the Workplace Rights Advocate, Melbourne, August.
14.
HarmanC. (1999) Explaining the Crisis. A Marxist Re-appraisal, Bookmarks, London.
Industrial Relations Commission (SA) (2007) Inquiry into the impact of WorkChoices in South Australia, Interim report, Industrial Relations Commission of SA, Adelaide.
18.
KnoxA. (2007) Fear and loathing in Australia: Gauging employee responses to the WorkChoices act, paper presented to 21st conference of Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand, Auckland, 7–9 February.
19.
JeffersonT. PrestonChapple-FahlessonA.MitchellS. (2007) A study of low paid work and low paid workers in Western Australia. Prepared by WiSER (Women in Social and Economic Research), Curtin University of Technology, August.
20.
MacdonaldF.WhitehouseG.BaileyJ. (2007) Tipping the scales: A qualitative study of the impact of WorkChoices on women in low-paid employment in Queensland, A Report to the Queensland Department of Employment and Industrial Relations, prepared by the School of Political science and International Studies, University of Queensland and Department of Industrial Relations, Griffith University, June.
21.
MarxKEngelsF. (1986) Manifesto of the Communist Party, Progress Publishers, Moscow.
22.
MohunS. (2003) ‘The Australian rate of profit 1965–2001’, Journal of Australian Political Economy, 52, December, pp. 83–112.
23.
National Foundation for Australian Women [NFAW] (2007) What Women Want: Consultations on Welfare to Work and Work Choices, 1 June 2007.
24.
OakleyC. (2007) ‘Nurses show the way to fight’, Socialist Alternative, 122, November.
25.
PeetzD. (1998) Unions in a Contrary World. The Future of the Australian Trade Union Movement, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
26.
PeetzD. (2007a) Brave new WorkChoices: What is the story so far?, paper presented to 21st conference of Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand, Auckland, 7–9 February.
27.
PeetzD. (2007b) Collateral damage: Women and the WorkChoices battlefield, Diverging employment relations patterns in Australia and New Zealand? Paper presented to 21st conference of Association of Industrial Relations Academics of Australia and New Zealand, Auckland, 7–9 February.
28.
PeetzD. (2007c) Assessing the impact of WorkChoices — One year on. Report to the Department of Innovation, Industry and Regional Development Victoria. Industrial Relations Victoria, Melbourne, March.
Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (2007) Final report — Inquiry into the impact of WorkChoices on Queensland workplaces, employees and employers, January.
32.
van WanrooyB. OxenbridgeBuchananS.JakubauskasM. (2007) Australia@Work. The Benchmark Report, Workplace Research Centre, Sydney, September.
