This paper examines the emergence of the legislation relating to auditor resignation
which now forms part of the United Kingdom's Companies Act 1985. It is
argued that the legislation is best understood as part of the complex relationship
between the profession and the state and the state's attempts to promote
public confidence in a capitalist economy. Two case studies are provided to show
that the legislation was conditioned by the state's concern to promote
London as an international financial centre and strengthen perceptions of auditor independence.
Armstrong, P.
,
Glyn, P.
and
Harrison, J.
, (1984), Capitalism Since World War II,
London: Fontana
.
3.
Bingham, The Honourable Lord Justice
, (1992), Inquiry Into the Supervision of the Bank of Credit
and Commerce International,
London: HMSO
.
4.
Clarke, M.
, (1986), Regulating the City,
Milton Keynes: Open University
.
5.
Coakley, J.
and
Harris, L.
, (1983), The City of Capital,
Oxford: Basil Blackwell
.
6.
Cooper, D.
,
Puxty, T.
,
Robson, K.
and
Willmott, H.
, (1996),
“Changes in the International Regulation of Auditors: (In)
Stalling the Eighth Directive in the UK”
, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol.7,
No.6, pp.
589-613
.
7.
De Paula, F.C.
, (1970), The Principles of Auditing, fourteenth
edition,
London: Pitman
.
8.
Department of Trade
, (1971), Pinnock Finance (Great Britain) Limited and
Associated Companies,
London: HMSO
.
9.
Edwards, J. R.
, (1986), Legal Regulation of British Company Accounts
1836-1900,
New York: Garland
.
10.
Edwards, J.R.
and
Chandler, R.A.
, (1994), British Audit Practice: A Case Law
Perspective,
New York: Garland
.
11.
Gilmore, C.
and
Willmott, H.
, (1992), “Company Law and Financial Reporting: A
Sociological History of the UK Experience”, in
Bromwich, M.
and
Hopwood, A.G.
(eds.), Accounting and the Law,
Hemel Hempstead: Prentice-Hall/ICAEW
, pp.159-190.
12.
Gwilliam, D.
, (1987), A Survey of Auditing Research,
London: Prentice-Hall/ICAEW
.
13.
Habermas, J.
, (1976), Legitimation Crisis,
London: Heinemann
.
14.
Hansard's Parliamentary Debates, various issues.
15.
Harris, L.
, (1988), “The UK Economy at
Crossroads”, in
Allen, J.
and
Massey, D.
(eds.), The Economy in Question,
London: Sage/Open University
.
16.
Hopwood, A.G.
, (1988), “Accounting and the Domain of the
Public: Some Observations on Current Developments”, Price
Waterhouse Public Lecture on Accounting, University of Leeds, 1985, reprinted in
Hopwood, A.G.
(ed.), Accounting from the Outside,
London: Garland
.
17.
Lee, T.
, (1972), Company Auditing,
London: Gee & Co.
18.
Miller, P.
, (1990),
“On the Interrelationship Between Accounting and the State”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.15,
No.4, pp.
315-338
.
19.
Napier, C.
and
Noke, C.
, (1992a), “Accounting and Law: An Historical
Overview of an Uneasy Relationship”, in
Bromwich, M.
and
Hopwood, A.G.
(eds.), Accounting and the Law,
Hemel Hempstead: Prentice-Hall/ICAEW
, pp.30-54.
20.
Napier, C.
and
Noke, C.
, (1992b), “Premiums and Pre-Acquisition Profits:
The Legal and Accountancy Professions and Business
Combinations”, in
Freedman, J.
and
Power, M.
(eds.), Law and Accountancy – Conflict and Co-operation in the
1990s,
London: Paul Chapman
, pp.42-61.
21.
Offe, C.
and
Ronge, V.
, (1984), “Theses on the Theory of the
State”, in
Offe, C.
(ed.), Contradictions of the Welfare State,
London: Hutchinson
.
22.
Pierson, C.
, (1991), Beyond the Welfare State,
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
23.
Power, M.
, (1993), “Auditing and the Politics of
Regulatory Control in the UK Financial Sector”, in
McCahery, J.
,
Picciotto, S.
and
Scott, C.
(eds.), Corporate Control and Accountability,
Oxford: Clarendon Press
, pp.187-202.
24.
Radcliffe, V.
,
Cooper, D.J.
and
Robson, K.
, (1994),
“The Management of Professional Enterprises and Regulatory
Change: British Accountancy and the Financial Services Act 1986”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.19,
No.7, pp.
601-628
.
25.
Reid, M.
, (1982), The Secondary Banking Crisis 1973-1975: Its Causes
and Courses,
Basingstoke: Macmillan
.
26.
Robson, K.
, (1991),
“On the Arenas of Accounting Change: The Process of Translation”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.16,
No.5/6, pp.
547-570
.
27.
Sikka, P.
and
Willmott, H.
, (1995a),
“Illuminating the State-Profession Relationship: Accountants
Acting as Department of Trade and Industry Investigators”
, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol.6,
No.4, pp.
341-369
.
28.
Sikka, P.
and
Willmott, H.
, (1995b),
“The Power of ‘Independence’: Defending and
Extending the Jurisdiction of Accounting in the UK”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.20,
No.6, pp.
547-581
.
29.
Sikka, P.
,
Willmott, H.
and
Lowe, T.
, (1989),
“Guardians of Knowledge and Public Interest: Evidence and Issues
of Accountability in the UK Accountancy Profession”
, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability, Vol.2,
No.2, pp.
47-71
.
30.
The Accountant.
31.
The Times.
32.
Therborn, G.
, (1989), “State, Populations and Productivity:
Towards a Political Theory of Welfare States”, in
Lassman, P.
(ed.), Politics and Social Theory,
London: Routledge
.
33.
Waldron, R.S.
, (1963), “C.L.R.P. in
Retrospect”, The Accountant, 12 October, pp.442-443.
34.
Willmott, H.C.
, (1986),
“Organizing the Profession: A Theoretical and Historical
Examination of the Development of Major Accountancy Bodies in the UK
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.11,
No.6, pp.
555-580
.
35.
Woolf, E.
, (1979), Auditing Today, second edition,
London: Prentice-Hall
.
