This research explores the accounting regulations imposed on sea officers, particularly the purser, on board Royal Navy ships between 1731 and 1808. This was a period in which the Royal Navy grew to become one of the largest enterprises in Europe with operations throughout the world. The governance, control and accountability practices imposed upon pursers are analysed. The Regulations for accounting records to be kept by pursers indicate that accounting changed very little in the analysis period, until 1808, when it became substantially more detailed. Drawing on institutional theory, it is argued that this was due to external pressures for increased governance following the impeachment of Melville (First Lord of the Admiralty), public spending administrative and accounting reforms and political disapproval of ‘offices of profit’. The article provides important insights to the development of accounting, governance, audit and accountability within the Royal Navy, and enhances understanding of the historically unique role of pursers.
ADM 7/827 The National Archives–Duke of York’s Orders and Instructions (1660).
2.
ADM 2/1733 Duke of York Orders and Instructions and letters 1662-1666.
3.
ADM 7/639 Instructions for Admiralty Navy Board Officials 1660-1735.
4.
ADM 7/971 Regulations and Instructions relating to his Majesty’s Service at Sea (1808) London: Privy Council.
5.
ADM 30/44 Navy Board: Navy Pay Office Various Registers Precedents and Exceptions for Purser Accounts 1752-1800.
6.
ADM 7/216 Instructions and Regulations for the Guidance of the Officers of the Victualling Establishments at Home1807.
7.
ADM C/722 16 May, 1809, Correspondence Navy Board to Victualling Board.
8.
AND 28 Greenwich–Duke of York’s Orders and Instructions (1660).
9.
Commissioners for Executing the Office of Lord High Admiral of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland (CEO) (1759) Regulations and Instructions for Pursers of HM Vessels. London: W.Winchester and Son.
10.
Commissioners for Executing the Office of Lord High Admiral of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland (CEO) (1813) Additional Instructions to the Flag Officers, Captains, Commanders, Commanding Officers and Pursers of His Majesty’s Navy, Relative to Books and Accounts. London: Royal Navy.
11.
Commissioners for Executing the Office of Lord High Admiral of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland (CEO) (1825) Regulations and Instructions for Pursers of HM Vessels. London: W.Winchester and Son.
12.
HC Deb 4th July 1805, vol. 5 cc737-8, Impeachment of Lord Melville.
13.
HC Deb 27th March 1806, vol. 6 cc557-9, Lords Sitting, Impeachment of Lord Melville.
14.
House of Commons Parliamentary Papers (1806) Report from Committee Appointed to Draw Up Articles of Impeachment Against Henry Lord Viscount Melville, 4th March. London: Reports of Committees.
15.
Instructions to Pursers, volume of printed pursers’ instructions issued to Oliver King, Purser of HMS Savage in 1759, accessed at Portsmouth Naval Dockyard Library.
16.
Longman (1806) The Trial by Impeachment of Henry Lord Viscount Melville for High Crime and Misdemeanors Before the House of Peers in Westminster Hall, Between the 29th April and the 17th May 1806. London: Longman, Hurst Rees and Orme.
17.
MountaineW (1690) The Seaman’s Vade Mecum. London: W. & J. Mount.
18.
MountaineW (1756) The Seaman’s Vade–Mecum and defensive war by sea. London: W. & J. Mount.
19.
MountaineW (1761) The Seaman’s Vade Mecum. London: W. & J. Mount.
20.
MountaineW (1778) The Seaman’s Vade Mecum. London: J. Mount, T. Page and W. Mount.
21.
Regulations and Instructions relating to his Majesty’s Service at Sea (1731) London: Privy Council.
22.
Regulations and Instructions relating to his Majesty’s Service at Sea (1734) London: Privy Council.
23.
Regulations and Instructions relating to his Majesty’s Service at Sea (1757) London: Privy Council.
24.
Regulations and Instructions relating to his Majesty’s Service at Sea (1790) London: Privy Council.
25.
Regulations and Instructions relating to his Majesty’s Service at Sea (1808) London: Privy Council.
26.
WheatleyH (ed.) (1893–1899) The Diary of Samuel Pepys, vols. 10. London: George Bell.
27.
WheatleyH (1896) The Diary of Samuel Pepys. London: George Bell.
28.
AntonelliVD’AlessioRRossiR (2014) Budgetary practices in the Ministry of War and the Ministry of Munitions in Italy, 1915-1918. Accounting History Review24(2–3): 139–160.
29.
ArnoldA (2014) A paradise for profiteers? The importance of profits during the first World War. Accounting History Review24(2–3): 61–81.
30.
BakerN (1973) Changing attitudes towards government in eighteenth century Britain. In: WhitemanABromleyJDicksonP (eds) Statesmen, Scholars and Merchants; Essays in Eighteenth Century History. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 203–219.
31.
BaughD (1965) British Naval Administration in the Age of Walpole. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
32.
BaughD (1977) Naval Administration 1715-1750. London: Navy Records Society.
33.
BealingW (1994) Actions speak louder than words: An institutional perspective on the securities and exchange commission. Accounting, Organizations and Society19(7): 555–567.
34.
BealingWDirsmithMFogartyT (1996) Early regulatory actions by the SEC: An institutional theory perspective on the dramaturgy of political exchange. Accounting Organisations and Society21(4): 317–338.
35.
BillingsMOatsL (2014) Innovation and pragmatism in tax design: Excess profit duty in the UK during the first World War. Accounting History Review24(2–3): 83–101.
36.
BismanJ (2012) Surveying the landscape: The first 15 years of accounting history as an international journal. Accounting History17(1): 5–34.
37.
BlackJ (2001) Full circle: The cost accounting experiment in the British Army 1917-25 and the Corps of Military Accountants. Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research79(318): 145–162.
38.
BlackJ (2006a) Supermen and superwomen: The Army pay services and the first World War, 1914-1920. Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research84: 268–280.
39.
BlackJ (2006b) War, women and accounting: The pioneering role played by women in the Army Pay Department during the first World War. Accounting, Business & Financial History16(2): 195–218.
40.
BlackJ (2015) ‘The pen is mightier than the sword’: Linking educational history and accounting history in shaping historical thought. Accounting History20(1): 63–84.
41.
BlackJEdwardsJR (2016) Accounting careers traversing the separate spheres of business and government in Victorian Britain. Accounting History21(2–3): 306–328.
42.
BlakeNLawrenceR (2005) The Illustrated Companion to Nelson’s Navy. Mechanicsburg, PA: Stackpole Books.
43.
BlakeR (2014) Religion in the British Navy 1815–1879: Piety and Professionalism. Woodbridge: Boydell Press.
44.
BowlinWHerdaD (2015) Regulatory, accounting and business practices concerning the Sutler at Fort Abercrombie, Dakota Territory. Accounting Historians Journal42(1): 37–60.
45.
BrammerSJacksonGMattenD (2012) Corporate social responsibility and institutional theory: New Perspectives on private governance. Socio-Economic Review10: 3–28.
46.
BrockRE (1986) John Copland – A Purser in Nelson’s Navy From Wembley. London: Brock.
47.
BryerRA (1993) Double-entry bookkeeping and the birth of capitalism: Accounting for the commercial revolution in medieval northern Italy. Critical Perspectives on Accounting4(2): 113–140.
48.
BujakiM (2010) Cost-benefit analysis in correspondence related to building the Rideau Canal. Accounting History15(2): 229–251.
49.
BujakiM (2015) Visualizing the Rideau Canal through early budget estimates, 1823-1824. Accounting History20(1): 43–62.
50.
CardoniF (2014) The ‘science’ of French public finances in the first World War. Accounting History Review24(2–3): 119–138.
51.
CarnegieG (2004) Re-examining the determinants of barter accounting in isolated communities in colonial societies. Accounting History9(3): 73–87.
52.
CarnegieGNapierC (1996) Critical and interpretive histories: Understanding accounting’s present and future through its past. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal9(3): 7–39.
53.
CarnegieGNapierC (2002) Exploring comparative international accounting history. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal15(5): 689–718.
54.
CarnegieGNapierC (2012) Accounting’s past, present and future: The unifying power of history. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal25(2): 325–369.
55.
ChwastiakMFunnellW (2010) Accounting and the military: Editorial. Accounting History15(2): 147–152.
56.
CinquiniLGiannettiRTenucciA (2016) The making of uniform cost in a war economy: The case of the Uniconti Commission in fascist Italy. Accounting History21(4): 445–471.
57.
ClaxtonAB (1837) Foreign miscellany. Army and Navy Chronicle, 28September, Washington, p. 177.
58.
CobbinP (2009) ‘The best brains of the public accounting world’: The restricted membership of the Army Accountancy Advisory Panel, 1942-1945. The Accounting Historian’s Journal36(2): 1–29.
59.
CobbinPBurrowsG (2010) The British navy’s 1888 budgetary reforms. Accounting History15(2): 153–172.
60.
CobbinPBurrowsG (2018) The profession of arms and the profession of accounting numbers–Accounting, the military and war: A review. Accounting History23(4): 487–520.
61.
DickinsonH (2007) Educating the Royal Navy, 18th and 19th Century Education for Officers, Naval Policy and History. London: Routledge.
62.
DiMaggioP (1988) Interest and agency in institutional theory. In: ZuckerL (ed.) Institutional Patterns and Culture. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger, pp. 3–32.
63.
DiMaggioPPowellW (1983) The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. American Sociological Review48: 147–160.
64.
DjatejASarikasR (2009) The second World War and soviet accounting. Accounting History14(1–2): 35–54.
65.
FleischmanRMarquetteR (2003) The impact of World War II on cost accounting at Sperry Corporation. Accounting Historians Journal30(2): 67–104.
66.
FlescherDPrevittsG (2014) Haskins & sells during the first World War and its aftermath. Accounting History Review24(2–3): 211–225.
67.
FogartyT (1992) Financial accounting standard setting as an institutionalized action field: Constraints, opportunities and dilemmas. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy11: 331–355.
68.
FogartyT (1996) The imagery and reality of peer review in the US: Insights from institutional theory. Accounting Organizations and Society21(2/3): 243–267.
69.
FogartyTZuccaLMeonskeNKirchD (1997) Proactive practice review: A critical case study of accounting regulation that never was. Critical Perspectives on Accounting8: 167–187.
70.
FunnellW (1997) Military influences on the evolution of public sector audit and accounting 1830-1880. Accounting History2(2): 9–29.
71.
FunnellW (2003) Accounting for War: Financial Control of the British Army 1846-1899. Sydney, NSW, Australia: Accounting and Finance Academic Press.
72.
FunnellW (2005) Accounting on the frontline: Cost Accounting, military efficiency and the South African War. Accounting and Business Research35(4): 307–326.
73.
FunnellW (2006) National efficiency, military accounting and the business of war. Critical Perspectives on Accounting17: 719–751.
74.
FunnellW (2009) Military. In: EdwardsJWalkerS (eds) Routledge Companion to Accounting History. London: Taylor & Francis, pp. 561–578.
75.
FunnellW (2010) On his majesty’s secret service: Accounting for the secret service in a time of national peril 1782-1806. Accounting Historians Journal37(1): 29–52.
76.
FunnellW (2011) Social reform, military accounting and the pursuit of economy during the liberal apotheosis, 1906-1912. Accounting, Business & Financial History21(1): 69–93.
77.
FunnellWChwastiakM (2015) Accounting at War: The Politics of Military Finance. London: Routledge.
78.
GeorgiouOJackL (2011) In pursuit of legitimacy: A history behind fair value accounting. British Accounting Review43: 311–323.
79.
GomesD (2008) The interplay of conceptions of accounting and schools of thought in accounting history. Accounting History13(4): 479–509.
80.
HamiltonC (2011) The Making of the Modern Admiralty: British Naval Policy Making, 1805-1927. Cambridge: Military Histories.
81.
HeierI (2010) Accounting for the ravages of war: Corporate reporting at a troubled American railroad during the Civil War. Accounting History15(2): 199–228.
82.
HinesAMcBrideKFearnleySBrandtR (2001) We’re off to see the wizard: An evaluation of directors’ and auditors’ experiences with the Financial Reporting Review Panel. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal14(1): 53–84.
83.
HoskinKMacveR (1988) The genesis of accountability: The West Point connection. Accounting Organizations and Society13(1): 37–73.
84.
HoskinKMacveR (1994) Re-appraising the genesis of managerialism: A re-examination of the role of accounting at the Springfield Armory 1815-45. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal6(2): 4–29.
85.
IkinCJohnsLHayesC (2012) Field, capital and habitus: An oral history of women in accounting in Australia during World War II. Accounting History17(2): 175–192.
86.
KingDPremoKCaseC (2009) Historical influences on modern cost accounting practices. Academy of Accounting and Financial Studies Journal13(4): 21–39.
87.
KnightR (2008) Politics and trust in victualling the Navy, 1793-1815. The Mariners Mirror94(2): 133–149.
88.
KnightRWilcoxM (2010) Sustaining the Fleet, 1793–1815, War, the British Navy and the Contractor State. Woodbridge, UK: Boydell Press.
89.
LaiALeoniGStacchezziniR (2012) Governmentality rationales and calculative devices: The rejection of a seventeenth-century territorial barter proposed by the King of Spain. Accounting History17(3–4): 369–392.
90.
LaveryB (1998) Shipboard Life and Organisation 1731-1815. Aldershot: Ashgate.
91.
LewisM (1960) A Social History of the Navy 1793-1815. London: Allen & Unwin.
92.
LippmanEWilsonP (2007) The culpability of accounting in perpetuating the holocaust. Accounting History12(3): 283–303.
93.
McBrideK (2018) And one man in his time plays many parts’–Samuel Pepys the accomptant. In: XIV Convegno Nazionale della Societa Italiana di Storia della Ragioneria Conference: Accounting History and Arts, Turin. Available at: http://www.symposium.it/eventi/2018/xiv-convegno-nazionale-sisr
94.
McBrideKHinesA (2018) What shall we do with the drunken sailor? Accounting and controls for alcohol in the Royal Navy in the time of Nelson. In: QuinnMOliveiraJ (eds) Accounting for Alcohol: An Accounting History of Brewing, Distilling and Viniculture. London: Routledge, chapter5, 85-101.
95.
McBrideKHinesACraigR (2016) A rum deal: The purser’s measure and accounting control of materials in the Royal Navy, 1665-1832. Business History58(6): 925–946.
96.
MacDonaldJ (2004) Feeding Nelson’s Navy: The True Story of Food at Sea in the Georgian Era. London: Chatham Publishing.
97.
MacDonaldJ (2010) The British Navy’s Victualling Board, 1793-1815, Management Competence and Incompetence. Woodbridge: Boydell Press.
98.
MacDougallP (2013) London and the Georgian Navy. Stroud: The History Press.
99.
MasonCKirkbrideJBrydeD (2007) From stakeholders to institutions: The changing face of social enterprise governance theory. Management Decision45(2): 284–301.
100.
Mayer-SommerAP (2010) So many controls; So little control: The case of Isaac Henderson, Navy agent at New York, 1861-4. Accounting History15(2): 173–198.
101.
MeyerJ (1986) Social environments and organizational accounting. Accounting, Organizations and Society11: 345–356.
102.
MeyerJRowanB (1977) Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology83(2): 340–363.
103.
MeyerJRowanB (1991) Institutionalised organisations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. In: PowellWDiMaggioP (eds) The New Institutionalism in Organisational Analysis. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press, pp. 41–62.
104.
MeyerJScottW (1983) Centralization and the legitimacy problems of local government. In: MeyerJScottW (eds) Organisational Environments: Ritual and Rationality. Beverly Hills: SAGE, pp. 199–215.
105.
MeziasS (1990) An institutional model of organisational practice: Financial reporting at the fortune 200. Administrative Science Quarterly35: 431–457.
106.
MileyFReadA (2012) The implications of supply accounting deficiencies in the Australian Army during the Second World War. Accounting History Review22(1): 73–91.
107.
MileyFReadA (2014) Cartoons as alternative accounting: Front-line supply in the First World War. Accounting History Review24(2–3): 161–189.
108.
MileyFReadA (2017) The purgatorial shadows of war: Blame and shellshock pensions, 1914-1923. Accounting History22(1): 5–28.
109.
PowellWDiMaggioP (eds) (1991). The New Institutionalism in Organisational Analysis. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
110.
PrevittsGMerinoB (1998) A History of Accountancy in the United States. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University Press.
111.
QuinnMJacksonW (2014) Accounting for war risk: Management accounting change at Guinness during the First World War. Accounting History Review24(2–3): 191–209.
112.
RodgerN (1986) The Wooden World – An Anatomy of the Georgian Navy. London: W.W. Norton.
113.
RodgerN (2004) The Command of the Ocean – A Naval History of Britain 1649-1815. London: Penguin Books; National Maritime Museum.
114.
RollinsTBremserW (1997) The SEC’s enforcement actions against auditors: An auditor reputation and institutional theory perspective. Critical Perspectives on Accounting8: 191–206.
115.
RosierB (2010) The construction costs of eighteenth-century warships. Mariner’s Mirror96(2): 161–172.
116.
RutterfordJWaltonP (2014) The war, taxation and the Blackpool Tower Company. Accounting History Review24(2–3): 103–117.
117.
Sanchez-MatamorosJ (2014) Management accounting and rationalisation in the Army: The case of Spanish Hospitals in the 18th century. Revista de Contabiladad – Spanish Accounting Review17(1): 71–77.
118.
Sanchez-MatamorosJFunnellW (2015) War or the business of God, sacred mission, accounting and Spanish military hospitals in the 18th century. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal28(3): 434–459.
119.
ScorgieMReissJ (1997) The impact of naval experience on accounting in colonial Australia from 1788 to 1792. Accounting History2(2): 53–76.
120.
ScottW (1987) The adolescence of institutional theory. Administrative Science Quarterly32: 493–511.
121.
ScottW (2008) Institutions and Organisations: Ideas and Interests. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.
122.
SuchmanM (1995) Managing legitimacy; Strategic and institutional approaches. Academy of Management Review20(3): 571–610.
123.
TalbotP (2000) Accounting for local management control in the late Victorian volunteer army. Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research78: 115–123.
124.
TalbotP (2010) Colonel William Henry Sykes: His contribution to statistical accounting. Accounting History15(2): 253–276.
125.
ThelenK (1999) Historical institutionalism in comparative politics. American Review of Political Science2: 369–404.
126.
TorranceJ (1978) Social class and bureaucratic innovation, the commissioners for examining the public accounts 1780-1787. Past and Present78: 56–81.
127.
TurnerM (2003) Pitt the Younger: A Life. London: Hambledon and London.
128.
VollmersGAntonelliVD’AlessioRRossiR. (2016) Cost accounting for war: Contracting procedures and cost-plus pricing in WWI industrial mobilization in Italy. European Accounting Review25(4): 735–769.
129.
WalkerS (2005) Accounting in history. Accounting Historians Journal32(2): 233–259.
130.
WarlowB (1984) The Pusser and His Men: A Short History of the Supply and Secretariat Branch of the Royal Navy. London: B. Warlow.
131.
WilsonB (2013) Empire of the Deep: The Rise and Fall of the British Navy. London: Hachette UK.
132.
ZuckerL (1977) The role of institutionalisation in cultural persistence. American Sociological Review42: 726–743.
133.
ZuckerL (1987) Institutional theories of organization. Annual Review of Sociology13: 443–464.
