This article analyses all articles published in Accounting History using a topic modeling technique. Previous studies focus on the content of accounting history, but not how the field has evolved. The article complements prior assessments of the research published in Accounting History by providing measures of the relative prevalence of research areas and their evolution over time. The analysis offers insights into accounting history by refining previous categorisations, uncovering overlooked topic areas and substantiating trends, such as the demise of interest in the technical core of accounting in favour of more variegated and fragmented approaches. The findings are discussed in light of the claimed pluralisation of methodological and theoretical approaches in this field.
AbdelrehimNMaltbyJTomsS (2015) Narrative reporting and crises: British Petroleum and Shell, 1950–1958. Accounting History20(2): 138–157.
2.
AndersonRH (2002) Leslie Arthur Schumer: Australian cost accounting crusader and historian. Accounting History7(1): 59–78.
3.
BaldwinTJBerryRH (1999) The measurement of nineteenth century accounting error: Cases from the British coal industry 1864–1900. Accounting History4(1): 79–98.
4.
BismanJE (2011) Cite and seek: Exploring accounting history through citation analysis of the specialist accounting history journals, 1996–2008. Accounting History16(2): 161–183.
5.
BismanJE (2012) Surveying the landscape: The first 15 years of Accounting History as an international journal. Accounting History17(1): 5–34.
6.
BleiDMLaffertyJD (2007) A correlated topic model of Science. The Annals of Applied Statistics1(1): 17–35.
BloomRSolotkoJ (2008) Elucidating needs, lifestyles, and community: Researching a late eighteenth-century account book from Lexington, Virginia. Accounting History13(3): 333–352.
9.
BoxGEP (1979) Robustness in the strategy of scientific model building. In: LaunerRLWilkinsonGN (eds) Robustness in Statistics. New York: Academic Press, pp. 201–236.
BuhrN (2012) Accrual accounting by Anglo-American governments: Motivations, developments, and some tensions over the last 30 years. Accounting History17(3–4): 287–309.
12.
CarmonaSGutierrezICamaraM (1999) A profile of European accounting research: Evidence from leading research journals. European Accounting Review8(3): 463–480.
13.
CarnegieGDNapierCJ (1996) Critical and interpretive histories: Insights into accounting’s present and future through its past. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal9(3): 7–39.
14.
CarnegieGDNapierCJ (2012) Accounting’s past, present and future: The unifying power of history. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal25(2): 328–369.
15.
CarnegieGDPotterBN (2000) Publishing patterns in specialist accounting history journals in the English language, 1996–1999. The Academy of Accounting Historians27(2): 177–198.
16.
CarnegieGDRodriguesLL (2007) Exploring the dimensions of the international accounting history community. Accounting History12(4): 441–464.
17.
ClarkeP (2005) The story of Bernard F. Shields: The first professor of accountancy in the UK. Accounting History10(2): 103–123.
18.
CorderyCJ (2012) Funding social services: An historical analysis of responsibility for citizens’ welfare in New Zealand. Accounting History17(3–4): 463–480.
19.
De Serra FariaARS (2008) An analysis of accounting history research in Portugal: 1990–2004. Accounting History13(3): 353–382.
20.
DiMaggioPNagMBleiD (2013) Exploiting affinities between topic modeling and the sociological perspective on culture: Application to newspaper coverage of U.S. government arts funding. Poetics41(6): 570–606.
21.
EdwardsJPWalkerSP (2009) Introduction: Synthesis and engagement. In: EdwardsJPWalkerSP (eds) The Routledge Companion to Accounting History. New York: Routledge, pp. 1–8.
22.
FeredayJMuir-CochraneE (2006) Demonstrating rigor using thematic analysis: A hybrid approach of inductive and deductive coding and theme development. International Journal of Qualitative Methods5(1): 80–92.
23.
FleischmanRKRadcliffeVS (2005) The roaring nineties: Accounting history comes of age. The Accounting Historians Journal32(1): 61–109.
24.
FogartyTJDirsmithMW (2005) Saving Chrysler: The use and non-use of accounting information by the US Congress. Accounting History10(3): 89–115.
25.
FowlerC (2010) Financing, accounting and accountability in colonial New Zealand: The case of the Nelson School Society (1842–52). Accounting History15(3): 337–369.
26.
FowlerCKeeperT (2016) Twenty years of Accounting History (1996–2015): Evidence of the changing faces of accounting history research. Accounting History21(4): 389–418.
27.
FunnellW (1997) Military influences on the evolution of public sector audit and accounting 1830–1880. Accounting History2(2): 9–29.
28.
FunnellW (2004) Victorian parsimony and the early champions of modern public sector audit. Accounting History9(1): 25–60.
29.
FunnellW (2008) The ‘Proper Trust of Liberty’: Economical reform, the English constitution and the protections of accounting during the American War of Independence. Accounting History13(1): 7–32.
30.
GaffikinM (2011) What is (accounting) history?Accounting History16(3): 235–251.
31.
GeorgeGHaasMRPentlandA (2014) Big data and management. Academy of Management Journal57(2): 321–326.
32.
GirouxG (2012) Financing the American Civil War: Developing new tax sources. Accounting History17(1): 83–104.
33.
GomesD (2008) The interplay of conceptions of accounting and schools of thought in accounting history. Accounting History13(4): 479–509.
34.
GomesDCarnegieGDNapierCJParkerLDWestB. (2011) Does accounting history matter?Accounting History16(4): 389–402.
35.
GutierrezFRomeroD (2007) The 1770s, a lively decade for quality control: The case of the Royal Tobacco Factory of Seville. Accounting History12(4): 393–415.
36.
HalabiAKFrostLLightbodyMG (2012) Football history off the field: Utilising archived accounting reports to challenge ‘myths’ about the history of an Australian football club. Accounting History17(1): 63–81.
37.
Hernandez-EsteveEH (2008) Some reflections on the orientations and volume of accounting history research in the 21st century. Revista Española De Historia De La Contabilidad9: 97–135.
38.
HollisterJSchultzSM (2007) The Elting and Hasbrouck store accounts: A window into eighteenth-century commerce. Accounting History12(4): 417–440.
39.
LlewelynS (2003) What counts as ‘theory’ in qualitative management and accounting research? Introducing five levels of theorizing. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal16(4): 662–708.
40.
McDonaldJ (2005) Using William the Conqueror’s accounting record to assess manorial efficiency. Accounting History10(2): 125–145.
41.
McFarlandDARamageDChuangJHeerJManningCDJurafskyD (2013) Differentiating language usage through topic models. Poetics41(6): 607–625.
42.
MadonnaSLMaranLCestariG (2014) The 1771 and 1824 reforms of the University of Ferrara: A Foucauldian analysis of Papal interests. Accounting History19(4): 507–532.
43.
MileyFReadA (2013) After the quake: The complex dance of local government, national government and accounting. Accounting History18(4): 447–471.
44.
MillerPHopperTLaughlinR (1991) The new accounting history: An introduction. Accounting, Organizations and Society16(5–6): 395–403.
45.
MohrJWBogdanovP (2013) Introduction – Topic models: What they are and why they matter. Poetics41(6): 545–569.
46.
MussariRMussariB (2006) Bookkeeping in the sixteenth-century building yard of the Castello of Crotone: An accountancy and architectural analysis. Accounting History11(3): 319–355.
47.
NapierCJ (2001) Accounting history and accounting progress. Accounting History6(2): 7–31.
48.
NapierCJ (2006) Accounts of change: 30 years of historical accounting research. Accounting, Organizations and Society31(4–5): 445–507.
49.
NapierCJ (2015) Making documents speak. In: 8th colloquium on qualitative research methods in business and accounting, Melbourne, VIC, Australia, 27–28 August.
50.
NarayanAK (2012) The role of government and accounting in the development of academic research commercialization: The New Zealand experience. Accounting History17(3–4): 311–329.
51.
NoguchiMNakajimaM (2008) ‘Working rules for financial statements’ and pre-Second World War financial reporting of Japanese industrial firms: The case of chemical firms. Accounting History13(3): 281–311.
52.
NormandCJWoottonCW (2010) Use of financial statements to legitimize a new non-profit organization during the US Civil War: The case of the Northwestern Sanitary Commission. Accounting History15(1): 93–119.
53.
ParkerLD (1999) Historiography for the new millennium: Adventures in accounting and management. Accounting History4(2): 11–42.
54.
ParkerRH (2005) Naming and branding: Accountants and accountancy bodies in the British Empire and Commonwealth, 1853–2003. Accounting History10(1): 7–46.
55.
ParkerRH (2014) The first 32 importers of an English professional accountancy qualification: Opportunities, incentives, impact. Accounting History19(1–2): 171–192.
56.
PittsMV (1998) Did dividends dictate depreciation in British coal companies 1864–1914?Accounting History3(2): 37–67.
57.
PrevitsGJParkerLDCoffmanEN (1990) An accounting historiography: Subject matter and methodology. Abacus26(2): 136–158.
58.
Prieto-MorenoMBLarrinaga-GonzalezC (2001) Cost accounting in eighteenth century Spain: The Royal Textile factory of Ezcaray. Accounting History6(2): 59–90.
59.
RodriguesLLCraigRGomesD (2007) State intervention in commercial education: The case of the Portuguese School of Commerce, 1759. Accounting History12(1): 55–85.
60.
Romero FúnezD (2005) The interface of disciplinary practices and accounting: The case of the Royal Tobacco Factory of Seville, 1761–1790. Accounting History10(1): 71–97.
61.
RosenzweigR (2003) Scarcity or abundance? Preserving the past in the digital era. The American Historical Review108(3): 735–762.
62.
RoySPSpraakmanG (1996) Transaction cost economics and nineteenth century fur trade accounting: Relevance of a contemporary theory. Accounting History1(2): 55–78.
63.
Sánchez-MatamorosJBGutierrez HidalgoF (2010) Patterns of accounting history literature: Movements beginning history at the beginning of the 21st century. The Accounting Historians Journal37(2): 123–144.
64.
Sánchez-MatamorosJBGutierrez HidalgoF (2011) Publishing patterns of accounting history research. Accounting History16(3): 331–342.
65.
Sánchez-MatamorosJBGutierrez HidalgoF (2012) Accounting for the production of coins: The enactment and implementation of the Spanish Ordinances of the Mints, 1730. Accounting History17(3–4): 351–367.
66.
SheltonWJacobsK (2015) Allan Douglas Barton: A scholar who spanned theory and practice. Accounting History20(1): 20–42.
67.
SpraakmanGDavidsonR (1998) Transaction cost economics as a predictor of management accounting practices at the Hudson’s Bay Company, 1860–1914. Accounting History3(2): 69–101.
68.
SpraakmanGWilkieA (2000) The development of management accounting at the Hudson’s Bay Company, 1670–1820. Accounting History5(1): 59–84.
69.
VasarhelyiMAKoganATuttleBM (2015) Big data in accounting: An overview. Accounting Horizons29(2): 381–396.
70.
VerhoefG (2014) Globalisation of knowledge but not opportunity: Closure strategies in the making of the South African accounting market, 1890s to 1958. Accounting History19(1–2): 193–226.
71.
WalkerSP (2008) Innovation, convergence and argument without end in accounting history. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal21(2): 296–322.
72.
WilliamsBWinesG (2006) The first 10 years of Accounting History as an international refereed journal: 1996–2005. Accounting History11(4): 419–445.
73.
WilliamsRB (1999) Lifting stones: A place for microhistory in accounting history research?Accounting History4(1): 59–78.
74.
YamamotoKNoguchiM (2013) Different scenarios for accounting reform in non-Anglophone contexts: The case of Japanese local governments since the 1990s. Accounting History18(4): 529–549.
75.
ZanL (1994) Toward a history of accounting histories. European Accounting Review3(2): 255–310.
