Accounting scholars investigate the role of academia in the process of knowledge production, highlighting how paradigms may produce negative effects on knowledge innovations, nourish academic elites, and limit fruitful debates. The current article extends this debate by investigating the cultural isolation experienced by Italian accounting scholars during the twentieth century, when accounting academia supported and protected the Italian paradigm of Economia Aziendale. Drawing on a Foucauldian genealogy perspective, this story of Italian accounting studies demonstrates that isolation results from an interplay of broad paradigmatic content and a recruitment policy focused on professors aligned with this paradigm. The Foucauldian perspective helps interpret knowledge innovation, thus enriching the debate about knowledge production, paradigm innovation, and the role of elites in accounting research.
AmaduzziA (1990) Storia della ragioneria. Percorsi di ricerca tra aziende e contabilità, dottrine e professioni. Milano: Giuffrè.
2.
AntonelliV (2012) Ragioneria ed Economia aziendale. Osservazioni in prospettiva storico-dottrinale sulle controversie in tema di posizionamento. Roma: RIREA Historica.
3.
AntonelliVD’AlessioR (2014) Accounting history as a local discipline: The case of the Italian-speaking literature (1869–2008). Accounting Historians Journal41(1): 79–112.
4.
ArringtonECSchweikerW (1992) The rhetoric and rationality of accounting research. Accounting, Organizations and Society17(6): 511–533.
5.
BakerCR (2011) A genealogical history of positivist and critical accounting research. Accounting History16(2): 207–221.
6.
BeattieV (2005) Moving the financial accounting research front forward: The UK contribution. British Accounting Review37(1): 85–114.
7.
BertiniU (1995) Per una costruttiva interazione tra le diverse aree disciplinari dell’economia aziendale. Sinergie13(36–37): 19–26.
8.
BestaF (1880) La ragioneria: Prolusione letta nella solenne apertura degli studii per l’anno scolastico 1880–81 alla R. Scuola superiore di commercio in Venezia. Venezia.
9.
BestaF (1894) La Ragioneria Scientifica e le sue relazioni con le discipline Amministrative e Sociali. Roma: Loescher.
10.
BiondiY (2002) Gino Zappa e la rivoluzione del reddito. Milano: Giuffrè.
11.
BroadbentJUnermanJ (2011) Developing the relevance of accounting academy: The importance of drawing from the diversity of research approaches. Meditari Accounting Research19(1/2): 7–21.
CapalboFDeanGClarkeF (2005) The Italian Economia Aziendale and Chambers’ CoCoA. In: SISR Proceedings of the International Workshop on Accounting History in Italy. Roma: Rirea.
14.
CarnegieGDNapierCJ (1996) Critical and interpretive histories: Understanding accounting’s present and future through its past. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal9(3): 7–39.
15.
CarnegieGDNapierCJ (2002) Exploring comparative international accounting history. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal15(5): 689–718.
16.
CarnegieGDNapierCJ (2012) Accounting’s past, present and future: The unifying power of history. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal9(2): 328–369.
17.
ChatfieldM (1982) Review on “Papers on business administration”. Accounting Review57(1): 208–209.
18.
ChiapelloEBakerCR (2011) The introduction of French theory into English language accounting research. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal24(2): 140–160.
19.
CinquiniLMarelliATenucciA (2008) An analysis of publishing patterns in accounting history research in Italy. Accounting Historians Journal35(1): 1–48.
DavidsonA (1986) Archeology, genealogy and ethics. In: HoyDC (ed.) Foucault: A Critical Reader. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
22.
Ferraris FranceschiR (1978) L’indagine metodologica in economia aziendale. Milano: Giuffrè.
23.
Ferraris FranceschiR (2010) Il percorso scientifico dell’economia aziendale. Saggi di analisi storica e dottrinale. Torino: Giappichelli.
24.
Ferraris FranceschiR (2011) Le discipline ragioneristiche nel sistema formativo dell’Italia unita ed il loro contributo al processo di sviluppo culturale, relazione presentata al XI convegno SISR. Roma.
25.
Figà TalamancaA (2014) Il reclutamento dei docenti universitari negli ultimi 50 anni, Parte I: gli anni ’60, Parte II: gli anni ’70, Parte III: gli anni ’80, Parte IV: gli anni ’90, Parte V: il nuovo millennio, available at http://www.roars.it/online/
26.
FoucaultM (1977) Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. London: Penguin Books.
27.
FoucaultM (1979) The History of Sexuality. London: Allen Lane.
28.
FoucaultM (1980) Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews & Other Writings 1972–1977. New York: Pantheon Books.
29.
GaffikinMJR (1988) Legacy of the golden age: Recent developments in the methodology of accounting. Abacus24(1): 16–36.
30.
GalassiG (1984) Accounting research in Italy: past, present and future. In: HopwoodAGShreuderH (eds) European Contribution to Accounting Research: The Achievement of the Last Decades. Amsterdam: VU/Uitgeverij/Free University Press.
31.
GalassiGMattessichR (2004) Italian accounting research in the first half of the twentieth century. Review of Accounting and Finance3(2): 62–83.
32.
GendronYBakerCR (2005) On interdisciplinary movements: The development of a network of support around Foucaultian perspectives in accounting research. European Accounting Review14(3): 525–569.
HopwoodAG (2008) Changing pressures on the research process: On trying to research in an age when curiosity in not enough. European Accounting Review17(1): 87–96.
35.
HoskinKWMacveRH (1986), Accounting and the examination: A genealogy of disciplinary power. Accounting, Organizations and Society11(2): 105–136.
KhalifaRQuattroneP (2008) The governance of accounting academia: Issues for a debate. European Accounting Review17(1): 65–86.
38.
KuhnT (1962) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
39.
KuhnT (1977) The Essential Tension: Selected Studies in Scientific Tradition and Change. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.
40.
LaiA (2004) Paradigmi interpretativi dell’impresa contemporanea. Teorie istituzionali e logiche contrattuali. Milano: Franco Angeli.
41.
LaughlinR (2011) Accounting research, policy and practice: Worlds together or worlds apart? In: EvansEBurrittRGuthrieJ (eds) Bridging the Gap between Academic Accounting Research and Professional Practice. Sydney: The Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia.
42.
LeoniGFlorioC (2015) A comparative history of earnings management literature from Italy and the US. Accounting History: forthcoming.
43.
LionzoA (2012) Gli studi di financial accounting di matrice nordamericana. Fondamenti epistemologici e percorsi scientifici. Milano: Franco Angeli.
44.
LockeJLoweA (2008) Evidence and implications of multiple paradigms in accounting knowledge production. European Accounting Review17(1): 161–191.
45.
LoftA (1986) Towards a critical understanding of accounting: The case of cost accounting in the U.K., 1914–1925. Accounting, Organizations and Society11(2): 137–169.
46.
LukkaK (2010) The roles and effects of paradigms in accounting research. Management Accounting Research21(2): 110–115.
47.
LukkaKGranlundM (2002) The fragmented communication structure within the accounting academia: The case of activity-based costing research genres. Accounting, Organizations and Society27(1–2): 165–190.
48.
LukkaKKasanenE (1996) Is accounting a global or a local discipline? Evidence from major research journals. Accounting, Organizations and Society21(7/8): 755–773.
49.
MalmiT (2010) Reflections on paradigms in action in accounting research. Management Accounting Research21(2): 121–123.
50.
ManninenA (1996) The production of knowledge in accounting. Accounting, Organizations and Society21(7–8): 655–674.
51.
MattessichR (2008) Two Hundred Years of Accounting Research: An International Survey of Personalities, Ideas and Publications. Abingdon: Routledge.
52.
MazzaG (1971) La ricerca scientifica e gli studi di Ragioneria. Milano: Giuffrè.
53.
MerchantKA (2008) Why interdisciplinary accounting research tends not to impact most North American academic accountants. Critical Perspective on Accounting19(6): 901–908.
54.
MessnerMBeckerASchäfferUBinderC (2008) Legitimacy and identity in Germanic management accounting research. European Accounting Review17(1): 129–159.
55.
MillerPO’LearyT (1987) Accounting and the construction of the governable person. Accounting, Organizations and Society12(3): 235–265.
56.
MillerPHopperTLaughlinR (1991) The new accounting history: An introduction. Accounting, Organizations and Society16(5–6): 395–403.
57.
NapierCJ (1996) Accounting and the absence of a business economics tradition in the United Kingdom. European Accounting Review5(3): 449-481.
58.
OnidaP (1951) Le discipine economico-aziendali. Milano: Giuffrè.
59.
OnidaP (1965) Economia d’azienda. Torino: UTET.
60.
PalumboR (ed.) (2011) La valutazione periodica della ricerca nelle discipline economico-aziendali. Una comparazione internazionale. Milano: Franco Angeli.
61.
PalumboRSantiniF (2011) La valutazione della ricerca in Italia. In: PalumboR (ed.) La valutazione periodica della ricerca nelle discipline economico-aziendali. Una comparazione internazionale. Milano: Franco Angeli, pp.133–158.
62.
ParkerL (2007) Developing research journals and qualitative inquiry: The role of the editorial board. Qualitative Research in Accounting and Management4(3): 35–56.
63.
RabinowP (ed.) (1984) The Foucault Reader. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
64.
SchmalenbachE (1919) Dynamische Bilanz. Cologne and Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlay.
65.
SembouE (2011) Foucault’s genealogy. Paper presented at the 10th Annual Meeting of the International Social Theory Consortium held at University College Cork, Ireland, 16–17 June 2011.
66.
SIDREA (2006a) Appunti per un dibattito sulla cultura aziendale, October2006, available at www.sidrea.it
67.
SIDREA (2006b) Correlazioni e interdipendenze ambiente/comunità scientifica degli aziendalisti e criteri di selezione dei docenti. Firenze, November18, available at www.sidrea.it
68.
SIDREA (2009) La Ragioneria e l’Economia Aziendale: dinamiche evolutive e prospettive di cambiamento. Milano: Franco Angeli.
69.
StacchezziniR (2012) Accounting e potere. Il contributo interpretativo del governmentality framework. Milano: Franco Angeli.
70.
TessitoreA (1997) Una riconsiderazione del concetto di azienda. In AA.VV. (eds.) Economia e Finanza Aziendale. Scritti in onore di Edoardo Ardemani. Milano: Giuffrè.
71.
ViganòE (1991) La teoria economico aziendale di fronte alla crescente specializzazione degli studi. In: Continuità e rinnovamento negli studi economico-aziendali. Bologna: Cleub.
72.
ViganòE (1997) L’economia aziendale e la ragioneria. Evoluzione – Prospettive internazionali. Padova: CEDAM.
73.
ViganòE (ed.) (2000) Azienda. Contributi per un rinnovato concetto generale. Padova: CEDAM.
74.
ViganòEMattessichR (2007) Accounting research in Italy: Second half of the 20th century. Review of Accounting and Finance6(1): 24–41.
75.
WattsRLZimmermanJL (1978) Towards a positive theory of the determination of accounting standards. Accounting Review53(1): 112–134.
76.
WattsRLZimmermanJL (1990) Positive accounting theory: A ten year perspective. Accounting Review65(1): 131–156.
77.
WilliamsPFJenkinsJGIngrahamL (2006) The winnowing away of behavioural accounting research in the US: The process for anointing academic elites. Accounting, Organizations and Society31(3): 783–818.
78.
ZambonSSacconC (1993) Accounting change in Italy: Fresh start or Gattopardo’s revolution?European Accounting Review2(2): 245–284.
79.
ZambonSZanL (2000) Accounting relativism: The unstable relationship between income measurement and theories of the firm. Accounting, Organization and Society25(8): 799–822.
80.
ZanL (1994) Towards a history of accounting histories: Perspectives from the Italian tradition. European Accounting Review3(3): 255–307.
81.
ZaninottoE (ed.) (2006) Presente e futuro negli studi di economia aziendale e management in Italia. Atti del Convegno Nazionale dell’Accademia Italiana di Economia Aziendale – Trento, 14–15 ottobre 2005. Bologna: Il Mulino.
82.
ZappaG (1927) Tendenze nuove negli studi di ragioneria, discorso inaugurale dell’a.a. 1926–27 nel R. Istituto Superiore di Scienze economiche e commerciali di Venezia. Milano: Istituto Editoriale Scientifico.
83.
ZappaG (1950) Il reddito d’impresa. Scritture doppie conti e bilanci delle aziende commerciali. Milano: Giuffrè.
84.
ZappaG (1956) Le produzioni nell’economia delle imprese. Milano: Giuffrè.
